Star Sea: Explorer's Notes

Chapter 73 Argument
"The two things you mentioned about 'free will' and 'choice', in my opinion, are not the criteria for judging the legitimacy of mechanical life at all."

"An intelligent body is an intelligent body. It is a mistake to introduce the concept of mechanical life." Dick ignored the discussions in the audience and continued, "Neurology proves that the root of human consciousness is material. It is generated by the synthesis of various stimuli transmitted by synapses."

"Free will is a kind of self-doubt that is acquired by our brains. In the final analysis, it does not conform to logical reality," he said here, spreading his hands. It exists?"

The second half of his sentence was obviously addressed to Frege.

After thinking for a moment, Frege raised his head and responded: "There are differences between humans and animals, and ordinary intelligent bodies. We just name the unique ability of humans to make choices through independent rationality as free will."

"Animals naturally have the ability to make choices, which is the sensibility and talent they inherit in their blood. The same is true for intelligent bodies. Their source is the algorithm and logic preset by humans."

Dick's explanation is obviously a refutation of Frege's words.

He clutched his chest, with a heartbroken look, "Your so-called basis is measured by human standards after all, and each different creature has its own unique way of existence, you have to use human standards to judge If they are qualitative, it is naturally impossible for them to fulfill your request."

"Everyone try to imagine, maybe it's not me standing on this stage tomorrow, but a cat or a dog, they can speak human words, and they can also discuss with you about free will and how mechanical life is possible ..." A smile appeared on Dick's face, "Do you think this is possible?"

Discussions sounded again, and this time Dick's supporters were obviously more than before.

"Take a step back, Mr. Frege, oh of course, and Professor Lano," his eyes wandered back and forth between the two, "you just proposed a proof method, even if mechanical life really exists , there are still [-] steps to go from proof to principle."

"The concept of mechanical life is a lie, a complete scam!"

Dick's emotions suddenly became a little agitated, "I appeal here, don't let this kind of meaningless research continue, don't let our limited funds and resources be spent on meaningless things!"

"Stop research! Stop research!"

"scam!"

In an instant, the scene of the opening ceremony, which was full of elites, turned into a place for large-scale parades and gatherings. Many people were emotionally affected by Dick Bellani's words, and stood up to support the boycott of the so-called mechanical life.

A trace of confusion could not help flashing in Lano's eyes, but Frege's loud declaration brought him back to clarity immediately.

"Free will must exist," Frege's voice was not loud, but everyone in the venue could hear his words at this moment, "Mechanical life must also exist."

"First of all, I admire Mr. Dick," he stood in the center of the stage, "I admire his ability to turn black and white and tell tales."

"I'll just use your example, you said it's impossible for cats and dogs to stand on stage and explain their point of view to everyone, but it's possible for us humans - and that's what we're doing."

"So, what's the reason?" He looked at Dick Bellany. "Why can humans, cats and dogs, and not intelligent agents?"

"Isn't it because we have a difference? What is that difference? Is there anything wrong with calling him 'free will'?"

"You're sophistry!" Dick suddenly gritted his teeth a little bit. "It's people like you who become a monk halfway. When it comes to research issues, you need to use evidence to support your point of view, instead of trying to prevaricate everyone with concepts."

"Do all the questions have corresponding answers and proofs when they are raised?" Frege sneered. "From raising to proving to solving, isn't this a process that takes time to advance?"

"What you are denying is the significance of the study of mechanical life. What I want to prove is just this point. Please stop using that kind of clumsy words to deceive everyone present. I don't think they will be able to tell you apart. distorting the facts."

Sure enough, after hearing his words, the reaction of the people below was obviously not as intense as before.

Although most of them are not professional, the guiding meaning in Dick Bellani's words is too obvious, and their best choice when they don't know the truth of the matter is to remain neutral.

"If you don't want to continue wrangling, then I will share my point of view," Frege said with a smile, and then ignored Dick's livid face, "Let me explain the significance of this study to everyone. .”

"Everyone must have heard the question discussed with this gentleman just now. He thinks that the research on mechanical life is completely meaningless. He thinks that it is impossible for us to create an intelligent body with the same rational thinking ability as human beings."

"The reason I refute is that since there is a difference between humans and ordinary animals, and intelligent bodies, then this difference called free will must be discovered, found, and shaped in our own way."

"What is free will, and what is the ability to make decisions?" He shrugged, "What are you going to eat tonight, where are you going to sleep? These are all decisions that need to be made. It may be due to the arrangement of the meeting or other reasons. You don’t need to consider this aspect, but whether you follow their arrangement or you have other ideas is up to you to decide.”

"Animals only have perceptual choices. If you put a piece of food, they will pass by. Intelligent bodies are more intelligent. They will do what you design the program. This is the difference."

Discussions sounded again from the audience, and this time their discussion was obviously more inclined to Frege's side. His views were completely consistent with what they saw in their daily lives.

"Conversely, why is this not just a way of existence unique to human beings? To put it a bit disrespectful, the chairman of the audience is the best proof."

All eyes were on Jacques Junior, who nodded slowly to indicate that he could continue.

"Thank you, Mr. Chairman," Frege bowed slightly towards him, "Humanity has developed from the era of the parent planet to today. The three branches of mechanical species, psionic species, and improved species belong to humans in name, but we know that the three The differences between the large populations have long been sufficiently high that they can be classified into three distinct races."

"Psionic species have extraordinary brains, mechanical species have powerful bodies, and improved species have the most primitive ecology..." Frege paused again at this point, "But we are still collectively called human beings, and free consciousness is in it. The most critical factor that always comes together.”

"Well said."

While everyone was discussing, a burst of applause suddenly sounded from below.

The source of the applause is the current chairman of the Galactic Federation, Jacques Junior.

(End of this chapter)