tearjerker director

Chapter 759 Polarization
"Dear" has a lot of comments, and the topic is very hot, which shows that the audience has a high degree of participation, or a strong sense of substitution.

This is indeed a good thing, but in terms of film critics and the media, the evaluation of this film is also polarized!

Although there are more positive reviews than negative reviews, it also shows that movies with sensitive subjects are really difficult to make!

There is nothing to say about the biggest controversy in "Dear", it must be Li Hongqin, or the second half of the movie!

Even many movie fans were arguing about it.

Some people questioned: "In the film, Tian Peng can clearly communicate with adults. The child does not know the trafficker Yang Mingfu, and knows the situation of his parents. If such a child is kidnapped, doesn't Li Hongqin, the trafficker's wife, know that she was kidnapped?
In addition, is it possible for this child to completely forget his biological parents in such a short period of time?Therefore, just judging from the setting of the movie, it is very blunt to say that Li Hongqin is ignorant. "

However, some people question it and some people refute it.

"The questioning upstairs seems reasonable, but it is too subjective. First of all, the movie did not tell us clearly that Li Hongqin really didn't know about it. From the back, the conversation between Li Hongqin and lawyer Gao Xia can also be seen. out.

This itself is a plot for the audience to understand for themselves!

Moreover, Tian Peng was only three years old at the time. A child of this age was taken away. A child of this age has limited memory. I am the father myself. The child was only placed with his grandparents for a week. I'm a bit of a stranger, let alone a few years. "

Some people questioned whether Ji Fang was abducted:
"It's outrageous. It seems difficult to prove whether Jifang was kidnapped, right? A worker who has a good relationship with the traffickers saw it? The problem is what the worker saw. No real footage was given. After abducting Jifang, he put it in It is also very possible that the construction site created the false appearance of an abandoned baby. All of Li Hongqin’s moral support is that Ji Fang was abandoned, but this bottom line is very vague given in the movie. Her man is dead, without any strong logical support, nor straight Bai’s statement. If there is a possibility of Ji Fang being abducted, then this movie has failed to keep the basic moral bottom line.

Moreover, can one person's one-sided statement be used as evidence?He still agreed to testify after Li Hongqin exchanged his body. Can such evidence be used? "

However, fans quickly refuted the same.

"I wonder why there are so many people who think that what the movie is about expressing is what the movie is about expressing?

It seems that the movie never explicitly told us whether Jifang was kidnapped or not.

The movie just gave these clues, and one more, Li Hongqin's moral support?This seems to be what you think too, right?Movies never sympathize with this woman, do they?All I saw was all kinds of abuse, making her lose everything.

Does she know or not? In fact, it doesn't matter at all. Just like those families who buy children, are there still few in this society?The only difference between them and Li Hongqin is that they don't have a family of traffickers!

But in fact, there is no harm if there is no sale. If the movie tells you directly, you may say it is preaching again. Just like the ending Li Hongqin is pregnant. Can you say that the movie is to give the audience warmth?But why not start more cruelly?
So, don’t think about everything, you think, the movie just tells such a story, and it doesn’t make us sympathize with Li Hongqin. Even the lawyer, the reason why he is willing to help Li Hongqin may be because he is also a family member of a criminal, so he empathizes with Li Hongqin. ! "

Soon someone else refuted the rebuttal of others.

"As it is said in the movie: child abduction is one of the most inhumane crimes. But please don't set up a whitewashing plot full of loopholes. Chinese filmmakers just like to use vague bureaucratic accents, and it's the same when it comes to right and wrong. Anyway, If I don’t make it clear, I have no responsibility. I’m afraid to take the responsibility to make a socially responsible film? The film’s doing this is tantamount to pushing all the moral burden on the audience, allowing the audience to identify themselves under unclear conditions. Of course, this kind of Recognition is strongly induced by cinema.

The same is true for Tian Peng, as long as the movie takes a few minutes, no matter at what time, explain Tian Peng’s first arrival at Li Hongqin’s house, explain how the traffickers deceived him, and explain why Li Hongqin can trust such a big child , children who don’t know her and his husband at all, and children who have memories of their own family, were born by his husband and other women.Naturally, moral issues can be eliminated, but why not add them?This is deliberate confusion, no responsibility! "

"I laughed. According to what you said, there can't be any hidden scenes when making a movie? As long as there is unknown information, you must explain it clearly? How long is such a movie? The time for a TV series is not enough, right?
What else is there no responsibility if you don't make it clear?There's a word called "understanding," okay?Everything has to be made clear, is that still a movie?Everything is shot according to reality, it is a documentary, not a movie!I really did it according to what you said, I guess you will say again, is this woman stupid?Can you believe such an obvious lie?

Of course, this is also the opinion of my family. Anyway, I think whether Li Hongqin knows or not becomes a topic of discussion, which is the real essence of this movie! "

Dear is certainly not a perfect movie!

It is also impossible that there are no bugs at all, and it is even more impossible that everyone likes such a movie.

Controversy is inevitable.

For example, in the movie, it takes 24 hours to file a case.

Even if it is explained, the timeline in the movie, and the experience of Sun Bin and others were indeed like this at the beginning, but some people still feel that the movie is misleading the audience.

Controversy is not a bad thing, it just shows that the audience is serious about watching movies.

And the score of "Dear" exceeds eight points, which can explain some problems.

There are controversies, but obviously there are more positive reviews than negative reviews.

This is a good thing for the promotion of the movie.

You must know that movies like "Dear" are naturally not the kind of commercial movies purely to please the audience and earn box office.

So if you want to get a higher box office and let more people buy tickets to watch, a certain degree of controversy is a good thing.

Because only when there is controversy can the topic of the movie become popular. If there is really no controversy, then there are only two possibilities, either it is a classic or it is a bad movie.

And "Dear" focuses on the movies with the theme of fighting abduction. It can be said that most of the movies with similar themes are similar to the first half of "Dear", or the routine is similar.

The point is a search process.

On the contrary, the controversial second half of "Dear" is different from other themes of the same type.

(End of this chapter)