The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 136 A human life is only worth 8000?

"I think we should be more cautious in judging no responsibility. The result of the trial must at least conform to the principle of fair responsibility."

"When the principle of fair liability was created, the purpose was to reflect the care of the law for the party whose interests have been harmed. If there is no responsibility, it would be too cruel to the plaintiff."

"I still hold that point of view. In today's society, fairness and indifference may be even more difficult to curb!"

"The principle of fair responsibility has always been controversial. In my opinion, the law is not muddled. Its purpose is to assist the better development of the country and society..."

"..."

For the verdict, the seven are very cautious.

From the case itself...

Gradually, it involves advocating social values, changing the atmosphere, and the "principle of fair responsibility".

In civil compensation, there has always been an important principle.

That is the principle of fair responsibility.

Regardless of whether you are at fault or not, as long as one party suffers a major loss...

On the other hand, corresponding civil compensation must be made to demonstrate the legal protection and care for the weak.

in fact.

At the beginning of the law, it was to ensure fairness, prevent the weak from being exploited, and protect the rights of the weak.

But this rule has always been controversial in the legal profession.

There are different views.

For example, if you drive normally and get into a car accident, the other party hits you and dies...

I was obviously hit, and I didn't have any responsibility.

Also need to bear a lot of civil compensation!

"Everyone, everyone should have seen the changes in society over the past few decades. Do you think... it is important to take into account fairness, or is this urgent matter?"

"Those who hold salaries for everyone should not let them freeze to death in the snow!"

Zhou Quanmin slowly raised his head and glanced at the other six people.

questioned.

in the final presentation.

Qin Mu cited 15 years of precedents.

Very representative.

That case was a sensation.

Countless people made it into a joke. Before helping people, the BMW at home ran wildly, and after helping people...

Only one broken bicycle remained.

Although it was a joke, it was enough to reflect the bad influence of that incident.

Helping others, since you have to worry about whether you will be accused and sentenced to lose money...

Then I simply don't help.

Seeing someone being hit by a car, lying on the side of the road, watching indifferently, and posting photos on Moments abound.

Anyway, it's legal...

As long as it didn't happen to me, it has nothing to do with me.

Even if he watched the person who was hit, he bled to death on the spot, he didn't have to bear any responsibility.

instead……

Saved the person, sent him to the hospital, helped to pay the medical expenses, and was demanded by his family for compensation!
The case that Yuan Cuilian is now prosecuting is also extremely special.

No matter how much compensation is awarded, even if it is a penny...

It is tantamount to telling the world that it is wrong to act bravely for justice!
……

after an hour.

Second Criminal Court.

Zhou Quanmin returned to his seat with the members of the collegial panel.

"All rise!"

The bailiff spoke in a low voice.

Everyone in the plaintiff's seat, the defendant's seat, and the auditorium stood up collectively.

Staring at the collegial panel in front of everyone.

Everyone is looking forward to the result of the judgment.

I felt a little apprehensive in my heart.

Yuan Cuilian hopes that the court can judge Qin Mu and others to bear their due responsibilities and make corresponding civil compensation.

As for Liang Chengbin, Bai Xuelan, and Hua Li, they were a little apprehensive.

I don't know how the court will judge.

Especially Liang Chengbin.

His family situation is not good. These years, he has lived frugally and worked day and night. He has indeed saved 10,000+ money.

But that was for reading to my son.

If you really want to lose money...

That just made things worse.

As for being brave?

When he encounters such a thing in the future, he will never take another look at it!
And in the gallery.

At the most exciting part, all the old people lost their sleepiness.

His old eyes widened.

Excitedly waiting for the verdict to appear.

This court session...

The trial lasted nearly eight hours.

From morning to afternoon, the results are finally coming out.

"Boom-"

Zhou Quanmin took a deep breath and sounded the solemn gavel.

A verdict was produced.

It was announced: "Today, this court formed a collegial panel in accordance with the law in the death case of Qin Mu and others, and held a public hearing. Both the plaintiff and the defendant have attended the court to participate in the lawsuit, and the trial has ended."

"The plaintiff, Yuan Cuilian, sued Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin, Bai Xuelan, and Hua Li for chasing and fleeing to death. The cause was that on the 27th of last month, Bai Xuelan was walking normally, and Xia Yuan snatched a gold necklace in the street."

"After the trial, the facts have been ascertained. Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin heard the shouts and acted bravely. They chased Xia Yuan. There were surveillance and witnesses along the way..."

After simply stating the facts.

Zhou Quanmin looked at the people in the court, and said in a deep voice: "This court believes that Xia Yuan's behavior of crossing the road during the process of being chased violated the traffic safety law, and her dangerous behavior was created by herself, which is a dangerous self-inflicted crime." Behavior has no necessary causal relationship with others."

"According to Article 230 of the Criminal Law, the crime of negligent death requires serious consequences caused by negligent behavior, which does not exist in this case. Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin, and Bai Xuelan's three pursuers do not bear criminal responsibility."

"Huali was driving normally and encountered a traffic accident. According to the responsibility determined by the traffic police department, Huali does not bear the main responsibility and does not constitute a crime of causing a traffic accident."

"In accordance with the relevant provisions of Articles 183 and 184 of the "Civil Code": the implementation of acts of righteousness and bravery, except for major negligence, the person who acts bravely does not bear civil liability."

"After trial, the facts are clear and the evidence is clear. This court believes that Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin did not intimidate or threaten in the process of carrying out acts of righteousness. Xia Yuan's death is dangerous self-inflicted, and there is no serious negligence. .”

"According to Article 230 of the Criminal Law and Articles 183 and 184 of the Civil Code, the judgment is hereby announced as follows:

All claims of the plaintiff, Yuan Cuilian, were dismissed. The pursuit of Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin, and Bai Xuelan did not constitute a legal causal relationship, and they did not need to bear criminal responsibility; there was no major negligence, and they did not need to bear civil liability for compensation.

In addition, the pursuit of Qin Mu and Liang Chengbin is not illegal, and it is a righteous act, which should be supported and encouraged, and the relevant departments directly under it should reward them materially and spiritually.

In addition, under Article 260 of the Criminal Law, Xia Yuan committed the crime of robbery with clear facts and sufficient evidence. Because of her death, she does not need to bear criminal responsibility. Her family is ordered to compensate Bai Xuelan for mental damage, loss of work, nutrition, etc., totaling 13000 yuan.

Hua Li drove a motor vehicle and caused Xia Yuan's death. He needs to pay 8000 yuan in civil compensation to his family. "

"If you do not obey this judgment, you can file a retrial with this court or appeal to a higher court within ten days from the date of issuance of the judgment."

A full 10 minutes.

Zhou Quanmin just finished announcing the verdict of this case, and let out a long breath.

Just an hour ago.

They discussed for a long time in the collegial panel.

In the end, the judgment was passed by voting.

And after the verdict was pronounced.

The entire court fell into a brief silence.

Everyone is digesting the verdict.

in the dock.

Liang Chengbin and the others swallowed their saliva and did not react for a while.

"we won."

Zhang Wei grinned, showing a relieved expression.

If he remembers correctly...

This should be the first time he won a lawsuit in his career!
before.

The cases he took were all defendants who had been prosecuted for criminal offenses, and they were all engaged in the defense of commutation of sentences.

This time...

For the first time, he helped the defendant successfully defend his innocence!

and.

The defendant in this case is not a criminal who is full of evil.

This made him very happy.

Be brave...

Finally, there is no longer any need to bear compensation.

"What do you mean? I... can still get compensation?"

After digesting the verdict, Bai Xuelan blinked her eyes, not daring to believe it.

"I seem to be able to get some material rewards..."

Liang Chengbin also looked at Qin Mu instinctively, and swallowed.

The court's verdict...

It seems that the relevant departments want to give him material rewards, nothing more than money.

"It seems that I'm the only one who wants to lose money..."

Hua Li smiled wryly, with a complicated expression on his face.

He had already been mentally prepared for losing money.

After all, he was the one who killed someone.

but……

The three of Qin Mu will either be compensated or rewarded, and he alone will lose money!
He always felt that this judgment was bullied by him alone.

However, the compensation of 8000 yuan is already very low.

According to the division of responsibilities, he bears about 4% of the civil compensation liability.

These days.

He also inquired about the compensation for accidental death on the Internet, and the highest compensation was even 10,000+.

"Rejected? I still have to lose money? I don't accept it!"

A sharp cry suddenly sounded.

Plaintiffs.

Yuan Cuilian's eyes were red, and she started to swear.

"This is a human life!"

"My son died, and none of you are responsible, so just pay 8000 yuan?"

"Not only you, but also the court, you are too indifferent to life!"

"Is a life so insignificant in your eyes?"

"That's right, my son robbed something, but just robbed a gold necklace, how much is it worth? Is a life important?!"

"I will pay you ten gold necklaces, can you give me back my son?"

Her voice was hoarse, and she kept cursing at Qin Mu and Bai Xuelan.

The 8000 yuan in the judgment just now deeply hurt her heart.

Let her heart cool down.

Also.

She even had to compensate Bai Xuelan for mental damage, which was as high as 13000.

Comparing the two, her son's compensation is not as high as the mental damage fee of a living person!

She can't accept this result no matter what!

Once in and out, she also lost 5000.

Not even enough to hire a lawyer.

and.

They lost the case, and the other party's lawyer's fees also need to be borne by her.

"Mom, let's continue to appeal. If Jincheng can't win the case, let's go to the Intermediate Court!"

Auditorium.

Xia Qingqing hurried out and supported Yuan Cuilian, also extremely angry.

She thinks the reason why Jincheng didn't win the lawsuit...

It's all about the courts!
And the people of Jincheng...

It seemed that they were all leaning towards Qin Mu.

In the local news commentary, everyone is accusing them, regardless of right and wrong.

Obviously, so many people in the whole network are on their side.

"Mom, let's go, go back and post the video, I want to expose the unfair judgment of the court!"

She didn't read the verdict, she tossed it aside.

Yuan Cuilian, who was mentally stimulated, left the court.

And the rest of the auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan and the others shouted happily, their expressions excited.

They were all satisfied with the result.

To do good deeds should not take risks.

In ancient times...

These are all great benefactors, and if the benefactor loses money, he will be stabbed in the back!
……

Court entrance.

After the case is over.

"This time I really appreciate Brother Qin..."

40-year-old Liang Chengbin looked at Qin Mu "with affection", full of gratitude.

After receiving the subpoena.

He really didn't know what to do.

Fortunately, I met Qin Mu and led him to fight the lawsuit.

"You don't have to thank me, you're not the only one they're suing."

Qin Mu smiled.

Everyone is satisfied with the verdict of this incident.

Bai Xuelan and the others expressed that they wanted to invite him and Zhang Wei to a meal.

but……

They were all declined.

After the three of Liang Chengbin left, Qin Mu looked at Zhang Wei, his teammate of this cooperation.

He argued hard in the presentation of the lawsuit, while Zhang Wei worked hard in the proof and cross-examination links.

In general.

Both sides played well this time to achieve such a verdict.

slightly hesitant.

He revealed: "I'll tell you an insider information, the case filing center has already accepted the defamation case."

Zhang Wei was taken aback for a moment.

Then he reacted suddenly, showing an expression of disbelief.

Defamation case!
Qin Mu mentioned it a few days ago.

This time it is really unprecedented, suing 3000 people in the whole network at once!
The key is……

The filing center really accepted the case!
"That is to say... a large number of defendants are about to rush to Jincheng?"

Zhang Wei swallowed.

Breathing gradually became faster.

In the last case, Qin Mu sued sixty trolls.

Just give him a lot of money!

The down payment for the new house has been collected.

Generally speaking.

The agency fee for a criminal case is about 4000 to 10000.

For the [-] defendants this time, if he can take over the representation of all of them...

How much is that?

The procedural law stipulates that a defendant can hire up to two lawyers.

But it does not prohibit multiple defendants from retaining the same attorney.

So in theory, he could act as the lawyer for these three thousand defendants at once!

The premise is...

He can seek the consent of all parties to represent these cases.

but……

He felt that those colleagues in Jincheng would never let this opportunity go!

Before long, Jincheng's lawyer circle will probably usher in a fierce battle!
"The reply from the case-filing court is that the case will be heard in ten days."

At last.

Looking at the relationship between friends, Qin Mu revealed the time.

Because there are too many defendants...

The trial date was postponed to ten days later.

……

Shanshui Garden District.

After the trial is over.

Qin Mu returned home.

Lying comfortably on the bed, he breathed a sigh of relief.

in fact.

Before the trial, he was mentally prepared.

As long as civil compensation needs to be paid in the judgment, he intends to appeal!

Because of various limitations and loopholes, the law cannot represent justice, but the law must constantly move closer to justice.

For such an act of righteousness...

Should not have paid for those perpetrators!
"Up, you guys are amazing, congratulations, I didn't go out all day today, I was watching the live broadcast of the trial!"

Sudden.

Qing Lan sent him a message with a very excited tone.

It seems that she is more excited than she won the lawsuit.

"By the way, I will help the water friends to urge the update, will the next video be released?"

Look here.

Qin Mu straightened up like a carp, and jumped up from the bed.

It has been a week since the last video.

The trial is over.

Almost ready for the next update.

As for the video suing the whole network...

He planned to wait for the dust to settle before giving a surprise to the fans of Xiaopozhan.

after all……

In this incident, the whole network criticized him.

Only the fans of Xiaopozhan ate melons rationally and did not line up randomly.

This is very commendable!

Subsequently.

He simply recorded a video and added part of the live video of the court's public hearing to the video.

It also includes the delightful verdict in the verdict!

The plaintiff's claim is dismissed and the verdict is not guilty!
and.

There is a difference between dismissing a lawsuit and dismissing a claim.

After the ruling to reject the lawsuit has become legally effective, if the lawsuit is filed again, the court shall accept it if the conditions for filing a lawsuit are met.

It should mean immediately.

But the dismissal of the lawsuit is quite different.

After the judgment of dismissing the claim takes effect, the parties cannot file a new lawsuit based on the same facts and reasons and the claims.

That is to say...

In court, what Xia Qingqing said was still to be appealed, but it was actually not accepted.

The only thing she can do is to appeal the decision of the case to the higher court.

Request the higher court to review and retry the judgment of the case.

The four of them can no longer be prosecuted.

If the higher court finds the verdict and rejects the appeal request...

That also means the case is settled.

Further appeals will not be entertained.

It took two hours.

He just finished editing the next video and posted it on a website.

At the same time, I brushed the new comments from time to time.

With the addition of 1300 lucky points, as soon as the video was released...

Gained massive exposure.

Broadcast volume continues to rise.

In just one hour, it reached [-].

And the comment area, also did not disappoint him, and brought forth new ideas again.

"Zhu Yuanzhang found 8 people and established the Ming Dynasty. Jesus found 12 people and established the largest church. I found 4 people today and fell to the bronze five."

"Fighting landlords all night last night, guess what happened to me? I didn't sleep all night!"

"When there is an avalanche, there is no snowflake that does not avalanche."

"As we all know, not seeing each other every day is like every other day, sharpening a sword in ten years, and half a sword in five years."

"Who would have thought that an 18-year-old young girl like me was only 14 four years ago!"

"..."

these comments.

The interpretation of nonsense to the extreme is no different from saying nothing.

None of the comments discuss case-related content.

Watched for 10 minutes.

Qin Mu suddenly realized that he wasted another 600 seconds on these useless comments.

Helplessly smiled.

He clicked on an up account called "Ma Xiaotiao".

In one of his videos, he found his comment section.

as predicted.

The comment area here is already fried.

"The up update video is coming next, the verdict, the verdict is true, the verdict is simply gratifying!"

"I knew that UP will never disappoint people, and that being brave and innocent is what the people want!"

"That is, why should someone who is brave enough to pay the bill for other people's problems?"

"Have you noticed that the case this time is too ordinary, the previous video ups and downs sent two or three people in..."

"That's for sure, there are so many platforms in the whole network, last time our platform sent [-] people in!"

"..."

Netizens at Xiaopozhan used their imaginations and even set up a quiz to vote.

Guess how many people he will send in this time.

The options are from low to high, which are 10 people, 50 people, 100 people, 200 people, and 300 people.

Most people choose the range of 200 people.

Looking at these comments, Qin Mu was a little dumbfounded.

These netizens...

Know him too well.

He hid it so well that he didn't reveal anything about the prosecution, and they still guessed it.

There are still so many people who choose the interval of 200 people.

This is too much to believe in myself.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng, a community.

Xia Qingqing returned to the residence with Yuan Cuilian, who was almost fainted.

The verdict this time...

The stimulation to them is very great.

None of them could accept the result of only paying 8000 yuan.

This is no different from sending beggars!
"Mom, don't worry, I'm going to make a video of the verdict. There are so many people who support us online, they will definitely speak for us!"

"After the video is done, we will go to appeal!"

"We can use all kinds of rights protection methods, and we must let more people know the truth!"

Xia Qingqing comforted her.

Yuan Cuilian nodded, and it took a long time for her to recover.

"Now that your brother is gone, it's good to have you, otherwise... I really don't know what to do."

She took a sip of water and sighed.

They are a divorced family.

She raised her two children by herself.

On weekdays, teach by precept and example.

Fortunately, the two children have grown up, and Xia Qingqing has even been admitted to university.

Became her pride.

"Mom, take a break first, I'll prepare the copy, and you can read it according to these later."

Xia Qingqing comforted her again.

Continue to get busy.

after an hour.

After Yuan Cuilian memorized the copy given by Xia Qingqing, she began to record the video.

First, briefly describe the results of the judgment.

talking and talking.

Feeling sad, I suddenly felt extremely wronged.

"A human life is only worth 8000 yuan!"

"We argued hard, and ended up with a dismissal request!"

"I just want to ask those who killed my son, won't your conscience hurt?!"

"Don't think that if you win the case, you will win. We will continue to appeal until the law gives us justice!"

"The four people who killed my son are Qin Mu, Liang Chengbin, Bai Xuelan, and Hua Li. Their occupations..."

in the video.

According to Xia Qingqing's copywriting, Yuan Cuilian not only sold herself miserably, but also directly disclosed the identities of Qin Mu and the others.

In Xia Qingqing's words...

Only in this way, Qin Mu and the others will be afraid!
After the video recording is complete.

Xia Qingqing hurriedly produced it and posted it on the Internet.

get title...

It is also very simple and straightforward.

"A human life is only worth 8000, and the cold judgment has no warmth at all!" "

"This little broken website... will not post it!"

When distributing various platforms, she directly skipped Xiaopozhan.

Netizens on this platform...

She couldn't grasp it at all.

After seeing what happened to them, they were extremely indifferent, which formed a sharp contrast with netizens on other platforms!

In contrast.

She still prefers to switch to netizens on other platforms.

There is temperature.

Will think differently.

I've been helping them out online.

"I hope more people can see it and seek justice for my brother."

After posting.

Xia Qingqing began to search the Internet for ways to protect her rights, planning to use a multi-pronged approach.

……

The next day.

In the nursing home.

After several days of leave, Qin Mu returned to his post.

Finish all the work accumulated in the past few days.

Life seems to have returned to peace.

But in the afternoon.

Qinglan sent him another message: "Up, you have been raped by the Internet again. It was the water friend who told me that your information is almost being spread on other platforms."

behind the message.

is a chain of video links to other platforms.

Qin Mu frowned, feeling bad.

He just wanted to rest peacefully for a few days.

did not expect……

There is no peace for a moment.

Click on the link.

After watching the video, he couldn't help showing a strange look.

"The other party... wants to go in so much?"

no doubt.

This video was released by Yuan Cuilian and the others.

If it is just to announce the verdict and sell miserable complaints, then there is no problem.

Every citizen has the right to online information and can speak freely.

But the problem is...

In the video, the identities, occupations, etc. of him, Liang Chengbin and others were published.

I almost didn't announce my home address!
And below these videos, a large number of trolls emerged again.

All kinds of remarks that show the sense of existence emerge in endlessly.

After activating the [Void Searching Enemy] skill.

He found that the ip of these trolls had a lot of repetitions with the previous batch.

There are also many faces of "old acquaintances" who have been active before.

Spraying him is very "brilliant", and his memory is particularly deep.

"Stop bubbling, I really have no money."

Looking at the comments that kept appearing, Qin Mu sighed softly.

He is now worried that there are too many new bubbling stars.

He can't sue.

Generally speaking.

There will be no court fees for criminal proceedings.

However, these cases of his are rather special, with civil lawsuits attached, demanding corresponding compensation.

and……

The number of defamation crimes is too high and spreads all over the country.

According to the relevant litigation law, some fees still need to be paid.

For example, assistance with identification fees with various platforms, remote fees for witnesses or subpoenas, and so on.

otherwise……

The court accepted the prosecution case of 3000 people, and the cost of self-financing is too high.

And now.

He had already scooped up three waves of lottery tickets, so he really didn't dare to go again.

Go on.

The second prizes of each lottery appeared frequently in Jincheng, and the lottery center definitely wanted to fry the pot.

--------

ps: Small question in class, do the students know what crime Xia Qingqing is involved in?
(End of this chapter)