The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 204 Ma Ming, MVP of this game!

They are all Ma Ming's classmates and know him well.

in their impressions.

Although Ma Ming joined Qin Mu's sect a little earlier and knew a little more dharma than them, he was not so awesome.

What Ma Ming said just now...

Sonorous and powerful, directly hit the point.

The expression on Lawyer Tian Shulan's face is enough to explain everything.

After Ma Ming spoke.

This seemingly awesome lawyer's expression became serious.

"In addition, in the law, there are three elements to constitute the crime of abetting."

Plaintiffs.

Ma Ming directly bypassed the public prosecutor and Shi Liangping, and continued: "First, there must be an intention to instigate a crime, and the consequences of instigating a crime must be foreseeable."

"Tian Shulan's actions were obviously deliberate when she was short of money, in order to achieve the purpose of defrauding other people's money and then illegally possessing it."

"Second, objectively, there is an act of instigation."

"According to the evidence presented by the public prosecutor just now, it is sufficient to prove that Tian Shulan once instigated, persuaded, and guided Meng Lei."

"Third, the person who is instigated needs to have a certain ability to take responsibility."

"But Meng Lei is now an adult and does not belong to persons with disabilities, dementia, mental retardation, etc. Tian Shulan must bear the criminal responsibility of abetting and abetting for this!"

From Ma Ming's mouth, laws and theories were laid out.

impassioned.

Sonorous and powerful.

Tian Shulan's lawyer frowned upon seeing this.

Obviously thinking about strategies to deal with it.

And this scene...

Shi Liangping who was next to Ma Ming was also shocked.

He looked at his client blankly with a complicated expression.

He is not a novice lawyer and has fought many lawsuits.

but……

I have never seen any client who refuted the opposing lawyer in court like Ma Ming.

This is simply a heifer flying on a plane, so awesome.

……

Jincheng.

In the nursing home.

A few middle-aged people who stopped temporarily watched and watched, addicted to watching.

Stand still.

did not leave.

The staff of the nursing home patiently explained to them the situation of the previous trials of "Science".

"This couple... is more ruthless than the other."

A middle-aged man looked at the two people in the dock and couldn't help but sigh with emotion.

The husband and wife are fighting in court.

Both tried to punish each other.

lead to……

In this trial, the public prosecutor gave a suggested sentence of 14 years and 12 years.

"I think...it's because Qin Mu got involved."

The middle-aged man in the car sales industry sighed with a bit of vigilance in his eyes.

His expression was a little unnatural.

Turn your head sideways.

Trying to find Qin Mu among the crowd watching the live broadcast in the yard.

It's as if there's a ticking time bomb here.

but……

There are too many people in the yard.

Everyone is watching the live broadcast attentively, gathering together to discuss related plots from time to time.

Occasional bursts of cheers erupted.

"Okay! This Ma Ming has two brushes. This example is good. Instigation is instigation. As long as there is behavior, she is an accomplice!"

"This Tian Shulan still hasn't given up, and has been trying to get rid of the crime."

"Marry a chicken as a chicken, marry a dog as a dog, Xiao Meng is such a good young man, she doesn't want to see him being bullied in prison, does she?"

"If there are no accidents, the case should be concluded today, right?"

"..."

Zhang Qingyuan and others were emotional.

Seeing Ma Ming's performance, they couldn't help applauding.

And in the crowd.

Looking at Ma Ming's performance, Qin Mu also showed a gratified expression.

these days.

He was free, so he communicated with Ma Ming remotely.

Informed Ma Ming of his thinking, experience and methods of defense.

But let's talk about it.

Ma Ming's performance in court shows that he has worked hard.

And in the live broadcast of the trial.

After thinking briefly, Tian Shulan's lawyer put forward a sharp rebuttal: "The evidence presented by the public prosecutor just now can only prove that our client has abetted the behavior."

"But in fact……"

"According to the provisions of the Criminal Law on abettors, it refers to instilling one's criminal intent into a person who does not have criminal intent by means of persuasion, inducement, instruction, instigation, bribery, threats, etc., so that he commits a crime according to the instigator's criminal intent. .”

"In this case, before Meng Lei met our client, he engaged in illegal money lending activities while in college, and the criminal intent has always existed."

"Regardless of our client's instigation, his criminal intent did not originate from our client."

"therefore."

"The evidence presented by the public prosecutor is not enough to prove that our client is an abettor."

In front of the court everyone.

Tian Shulan's lawyer played brilliantly and once again shocked the trial court.

In the nursing home.

Seeing the sudden reversal scene, Zhang Qingyuan and others couldn't help being stunned for a moment.

"The lawyer...what did you just say? According to the criminal law, Tian Shulan is not an abettor?"

"This lawyer has two brushes, Tian Shulan can see that he has lost all his money."

"Meng Lei's lawyer didn't say a word on this occasion."

"I feel like the case is about to be overturned again..."

"..."

Everyone frowned, and couldn't help worrying.

What Tian Shulan did...

They see it.

Simple emotion told them that this kind of person should also go in with Meng Lei.

But Tian Shulan's lawyer...

Obviously taking advantage of legal loopholes, trying to plead guilty to abetting a crime.

"Xiao Qin, look, this case... is it going to be overturned?"

In a hurry.

Zhang Qingyuan and others turned around and looked at Qin Mu.

in the crowd.

Qin Mu withdrew his gaze, nodded and said, "If you start with instigating a crime, you may indeed be overthrown."

The level of this lawyer is indeed not low.

Found a flaw in the criminal law about abetting crimes, and launched a focused attack.

According to the criminal law.

An instigator refers to instilling one's own criminal intent into a person who has no criminal intent by means of persuasion, inducement, instruction, instigation, bribery, threats, etc., so that he commits a crime according to the instigator's criminal intent.

An abettor constitutes an abettor.

There is no such thing as instigation.

And in fact.

Meng Lei has been engaged in illegal possession activities of borrowing money.

Logically, Meng Lei must have criminal intent.

and so.

Even if Tian Shulan had abetting behavior, it could not be judged as abetting a crime.

"However, even if they can plead the abetment, they cannot escape the verdict of joint crime."

Looking at Zhang Qingyuan and the others with gloomy expressions, Qin Mu continued.

"Joint crime?"

Zhang Qingyuan and the others froze for a moment, showing astonished and puzzled expressions.

at the same time.

crowd periphery.

A middle-aged man standing watching the live broadcast noticed the commotion of the old people, and finally found Qin Mu from the spot where the old people were focusing.

There was a "click" in my heart.

The body couldn't help shaking.

The tragedy that once swept the entire car sales industry in Jincheng came to mind again.

The replacement of auto parts was originally an industry practice.

but……

After Qin Mu sent Niu Huan and others in from the perspective of theft.

Many 4S shops and auto repair shops dare not mess around anymore.

It was discovered before, but only one refund and three compensation.

The cost is small.

It's no big deal to be found out.

But now...

If found out, you may go to jail!
In general.

Qin Mu has become a lingering nightmare for their pedestrians.

Wen Qin's expression changed, not just talking.

"Do you want to...send my dad to this nursing home?"

While peeking at Qin Mu.

The middle-aged man couldn't help but slander.

……

Yangcheng Court.

First Criminal Tribunal.

Lawyer Tian Shulan's rebuttal continued to echo in the courtroom.

For a moment, others were speechless.

in the dock.

Tian Shulan breathed a sigh of relief seeing her lawyer's wonderful performance.

As expected of the lawyer she spent a lot of money on.

The best lawyer in Yangcheng.

The level of defense was extremely high.

And beside her.

Meng Lei's expression at the moment was extremely ugly.

because……

His defense lawyer, that is, the legal aid lawyer, was feeling sincerely: "This lawyer is amazing."

Admired endlessly.

His face was full of reverence.

Seeing this, Meng Lei couldn't help itching his teeth with hatred.

If he had money, he could also hire an awesome lawyer.

It would not be possible to be assigned to this legal aid lawyer who had just become a regular trainee.

Just when he was worried.

plaintiffs table.

His old classmate, Ma Ming stepped forward again.

Faced with Tian Shulan's defense lawyer, he retorted: "Abetting a crime is indeed stipulated in the criminal law."

"But Tian Shulan's behavior, even if it does not constitute abetting a crime, constitutes a joint crime!"

"In criminal law, there are four conditions for joint crime."

"First, objectively, an accomplice needs to have one of the acts of execution, organization, instigation, and assistance, and Tian Shulan clearly abetted in Meng Lei's crime of defrauding others of money."

"And, after committing a crime, share the defrauded money and squander it."

"Second, on the subjective side, there is a common criminal intent among the accomplices."

"During the existence of the husband-wife relationship, there is no evidence that Tian Shulan refused or dissuaded Meng Lei from continuing to defraud other people's money, that is, she knew that the behavior was suspected of illegal crimes, but she still acquiesced in it and enjoyed the proceeds of crime."

"Third, on the object requirements..."

While looking at the manuscript in his hand, Ma Ming stated the prepared rebuttal points one by one.

Unconsciously.

The situation in court has changed again.

Meng Lei could clearly feel the smile on Tian Shulan's defense lawyer's face froze.

It seems that Ma Ming did not expect such a move.

"Excellent lawyer."

Next to Meng Lei, the legal aid lawyer who had just become a full-time regular expressed his heartfelt emotion again.

A few black lines appeared on Meng Lei's forehead.

God damn lawyer.

He and Ma Ming are college classmates, and they know everything about each other.

How could Ma Ming be a lawyer?
But I have to say that Ma Ming played very well in court.

Watching him kill his wife...

Somehow, he suddenly didn't hate Ma Ming so much.

……

University classmates.

"Ma Ming is really a heifer chasing a bull—awesome."

"No, no, it should be the bull bull crying for the heifer—that's awesome."

"A cow and ten bulls, if I ask you—that's pretty darn good."

"It's obviously a heifer visiting relatives—it's awesome."

"..."

Watch the trial live.

Ma Ming's college classmates were amazed.

They tried their best to think of all the compliments.

He did not hesitate to praise Ma Ming.

Lawyer Tian Shulan's speech was indeed bloody.

They almost thought it was turned over again.

did not expect……

Ma Ming made another wave of wonderful operations, and fought back against the manuscript.

If abetting a crime fails, then it is directly classified as a joint crime.

all in all.

Tian Shulan must go to jail today!

"If the sentence can really be sentenced, Ma Ming has contributed a lot today. It's really extraordinary to learn from him."

"He's so handsome, a real man, he should go to court and send his classmate's wife in!"

"Then here comes the question, Shi Liangping didn't speak much in this trial, should he still pay the lawyer's fee?"

"This is the most non-existent lawyer I have ever seen."

"..."

In the classmate group.

All the students were very excited.

It turns out.

Studying the Fa is useful, not only can you send your classmates in, but you can also send your classmates' wives in.

If Ma Ming hadn't acted this time to turn the tide...

Meng Lei and Tian Shulan are really likely to be separated for more than ten years!
And in court.

After Ma Ming spoke, the rhythm of Tian Shulan's defense lawyer was obviously disrupted.

The joint crime proposed by Ma Ming fully meets the constituent requirements.

joint crime

There is no requirement that the abetted person have no mens rea.

It refers to two people, or a gang of more than two people, who jointly obtain benefits from illegal and criminal activities.

Coupled with Tian Shulan's instigation, acquiescence, never dissuading, and joint spending to defraud money...

There are few defensible loopholes.

"Boom-"

The presiding judge struck the gavel.

After both sides questioned and refuted all the evidence, they entered the next free debate session.

in the free debate session.

Ma Ming looked at the thick manuscript in his hand and continued to perform exceptionally.

There is a great potential to win the MVP of this lawsuit.

"Our side believes that Meng Lei has repeatedly defrauded other people's property, and illegally possessed it, and refused to return it. Tian Shulan instigated, acquiesced, and never dissuaded him during this process, and should also be regarded as an accomplice."

"Tian Shulan's actions met all the elements of a joint crime."

"During the marriage after marriage..."

In order to establish the victory as soon as possible.

Ma Ming has always been active in the front line of free debate.

Even the public prosecutor and Shi Liangping...

It's like a backdrop.

And on the defendant's side.

Meng Lei's legal aid lawyer couldn't hold back a word for a long time.

Nothing decent to play.

On the contrary, Tian Shulan's defense lawyer has been trying his best to fight for it.

The battle line has been shifted from abetting crimes to joint crimes.

Attempt to plead guilty to joint criminality.

but……

He didn't prepare for the angle Ma Ming proposed in advance.

There was no time to react at all.

Not sure where to start.

two hours later.

"Boom-"

The presiding judge struck the gavel.

Scanning around the scene, he said in a deep voice, "Temporary adjournment for half an hour."

Say it.

After taking a deep look at the MVP Ma Ming, he left the court with everyone in the collegial panel.

And in the dock.

Tian Shulan quickly looked at her defense lawyer, and asked nervously, "Can I...can I get a suspended sentence?"

This is her biggest concern.

As long as she can get probation, she can stay out of jail.

This is what the defense lawyer guaranteed to her before the trial.

"Ms. Tian, ​​I'm sorry, the other party's...plaintiff is really a bit powerful, and it's hard to refute the joint crime."

The defense lawyer smiled slightly apologetically.

"so what?"

Tian Shulan's heart sank, her face turned pale.

The lawyer thought for a while and said seriously: "Probation is generally applicable to fixed-term imprisonment of less than three years."

Bang!

The voice fell.

Tian Shulan slumped down on the chair.

The whole person is not well.

On the other hand, Meng Lei was in a happy mood, and even had the urge to go to the plaintiff's seat to thank him.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng.

nursing home.

After the adjournment.

Zhang Qingyuan and the others all looked back, their eyes revealing a look of regret.

I am deeply moved.

"Finally, the sentence is coming. I wonder how long these two people will be sentenced?"

"After this case is over, I don't know when I will see such an amazing defendant."

"To be honest, I'm still a little bit reluctant to end the case."

"I don't know if there will be a second part..."

"..."

The crowd gathers together.

It seems that the TV series that has been chasing updates is about to usher in the finale.

There are expectations, but also reluctance.

After watching so many live broadcasts of Meng Lei...

It would be a lie to say that there is no emotion.

of course.

This kind of feeling is not sympathy and reluctance, but fear that I will never see such an outstanding defendant again.

Of those defendants they've met...

Meng Lei doesn't say that he can rank first, at least he can enter the top three.

Not everyone can lend out a house on their own.

And out of the crowd.

Those middle-aged people...

Before I knew it, I watched the entire trial of the case.

Standing feet are sore.

Suddenly.

A middle-aged man came back to his senses and widened his eyes: "Oh shit, where is my dad?"

He looked left and right, searching in the crowded yard.

Just now I just watched the trial.

He actually lost his father who came with him.

And several other middle-aged people also came back to their senses and shouted loudly.

"My dad didn't see it either!"

"Dad, where are you?"

"Mom, where are you?"

"dad……"

Several middle-aged people kept shouting.

But there are too many old people in the yard.

Hearing their shouts, they all turned their heads and looked at them suspiciously.

At this moment.

The staff of the nursing home hurried forward: "It's like this. I saw you guys were too engrossed just now, so I found a stool for them, and they are sitting there."

talking.

He pointed to a few old people who were chatting with Zhang Qingyuan and others.

Seeing this, the middle-aged men breathed a sigh of relief.

This trial...

It has many elements of dog blood ethics idol drama.

The classmates who started with 18 yuan turned against each other.

Then to the fake divorce, the husband and wife turned against each other.

In the end, they fought in court, fell in love and killed each other, and tortured each other.

It really got them.

"Okay, now we can visit the canteen and accommodation in the nursing home."

The staff member expressed understanding and continued.

A middle-aged man frowned: "The verdict is about to be pronounced, why don't you wait until the verdict is pronounced."

Several other people nodded repeatedly.

After watching the trial for so long, if you don't watch the sentencing process, you always feel that something is missing.

staff member:"……"

……

Yangcheng Court.

First Criminal Tribunal.

After half an hour.

The presiding judge led the collegial panel into the court again.

"All rise!"

After everyone stood up.

The presiding judge stood and announced: "The First Criminal Division of the Yangcheng District Court has gone through three trials, and the case of Meng Lei and Tian Shulan's alleged fraud and refusal to execute the case has now been completed."

"This court believes that Meng Lei has borrowed money from his classmates in the name of borrowing money since he was in college. After many years, he refused to return it. The facts are clear and the witnesses and physical evidence are sufficient."

"During his work, he continued to illegally defraud money from colleagues, friends, relatives, etc., and the cumulative amount reached 82 yuan, which constituted a crime of fraud."

"And after the judgment of the 18 yuan arrears was issued, together with Tian Shulan, he used the behavior of transferring property to try to fight against the court's judgment, which made the judgment unable to be enforced."

"Meng Lei's series of actions violated Article 260 of the Criminal Law and Article 310 of the Criminal Law, committing crimes of fraud, refusal to execute judgments, and rulings."

"Tian Shulan, during the continuation of the relationship with Meng Lei, has repeatedly instigated and urged Meng Lei to defraud other people's money. Without dissuasion and participation, the total amount of fraud involved has reached 53 yuan, which is a joint crime of fraud. , as an accessory."

"It is hereby judged that:

According to Article 260 of the Criminal Law and Article 310 of the Criminal Law, Meng Lei committed the crime of fraud, refusal to execute a judgment, and the crime of ruling.

According to Article 260 of the Criminal Law and Article 310 of the Criminal Law, Tian Shulan committed the crime of fraud, refusal to execute a judgment, and the crime of ruling. Both crimes were punished concurrently. He was sentenced to 11 years in prison and a fine of 18000 yuan. "

"In addition, this case is a crime of economic fraud. Tian Shulan's property was fined 82 yuan, and all borrowers were returned."

"If you are not satisfied with this judgment, you may appeal through this court or directly to the higher court within [-] days from the effective date of this judgment."

After a full 5 minutes.

The verdict of the two men was read out.

And below the court.

The expressions of the people are very different.

plaintiffs table.

Ma Ming looked delighted and extremely happy.

He has worked so hard for so long, asked for leave, skipped work, rushed to Yangcheng, and worked hard to learn litigation methods, and his hard work finally paid off!

The "old classmate" who lent him 18 yuan and didn't return it...

He was finally sent in!

By the way, he also sent his beautiful wife in.

Shi Liangping, on the other hand, looked at Ma Ming blankly with a dazed expression on his face.

This lawsuit...

He didn't say a few words before and after.

In addition to the testimony and rebuttals of public and lay people, his client is the one who talks the most.

"You...are you really not interested in becoming a lawyer?"

He swallowed, and couldn't help asking again.

And in the dock.

Tian Shulan sat slumped on the chair, her face ashen.

In the verdict, she was sentenced to 11 years in prison!
This is an unbearable number for her.

And beside her.

Meng Lei...

It is a completely different reaction.

"Where can I get money to pay the fine..."

He frowned, and the focus of his attention was not the sentence.

Instead the court imposed a fine on him.

21000 yuan!
--------

ps: Chengdu needs nucleic acid again today, and the queue time is too long.

There is only one chapter.

(End of this chapter)