The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

But actually.

Being bitten by a dog is not uncommon and happens from time to time.

When he returned to Shanshui Garden Community...

I have seen several large dogs chasing others, or seeing dogs led by others galloping straight up.

Besides chasing people...

Dogs off leash may also be aggressive or playful with other dogs.

If you are not careful, it will easily lead to disaster.

……

at the same time.

In a living room of a nursing home.

Wan Zhongyuan looked at a gorgeously dressed woman in front of him, who looked rather rich, with an ugly expression on his face.

"I don't care, anyway, either he loses money, or your hospital loses money."

"My dog ​​is a rare foreign breed, and I can't find a few in China. Do you know how much effort I spent raising it?"

"It's like my son to me."

"That old bastard beat it to death, you must pay compensation, or I will call the police!"

The woman was trembling with anger, her eyes were red.

In her hands...

He was still holding the pet dog that was beaten to death on the spot.

The head is already bloody.

It looked very miserable.

"Ms. Cheng, your son... your pet dog died, and we can understand the grief. You must pay for the loss, but at this price..."

Wan Zhongyuan looked at her, and reminded with some embarrassment: "This price is too unreasonable."

After the incident.

He has asked the staff in the yard to investigate the breed of the pet dog.

The breed is indeed rare.

But at best, it is in the early ten thousand.

But the woman named Cheng Chuxiao in front of her opened her mouth like a lion and directly demanded [-] yuan in compensation!

"Why is it unreasonable?"

When the woman heard this, she said angrily, "I have raised Binbin for three years, three full years! Do you know how much painstaking effort it took?"

"I get along with it day and night every day, and the relationship with it, you can't understand it at all!"

"You think I'm asking for [-] yuan? I just give it an explanation and seek justice for it!"

"Although it has gone to heaven, it will always live in my heart. I can't let it die in peace!"

"5 yuan? Do you think I value this 5 yuan?"

"Keep your eyes open and see, which item on me is not worth tens of thousands?"

She glared at Wan Zhongyuan with shame and anger on her face.

She just felt insulted.

Simultaneously.

Show off your wealth on the spot to the employees of the surrounding nursing homes.

aggressive.

a time.

Wan Zhongyuan and the staff of the surrounding nursing homes looked at each other, not knowing how to refute.

In terms of clothes...

Cheng Chuxiao is indeed from a wealthy family.

There is no shortage of money.

"Xiao Chu, why don't you... you should pay less attention to this matter, after all, it's just a dog."

aside.

A white-haired old man suddenly stepped forward with a cane, and couldn't help but persuade him.

"dad!"

Cheng Chuxiao heard the words, and complained again: "Why do you say that? What is a dog? Binbin is a member of my family. I have always treated him as my own. Today he died, and I have to ask for it. Give me justice!"

talking.

She turned around and stared at Wan Zhongyuan and the others again.

A gesture of calling the police immediately if you don't lose money.

And this persuading old man...

On the other hand, his face was livid, and he didn't speak any more.

"Fairness? What kind of justice do you want?"

suddenly.

Qin Mu's voice came from outside the reception room.

Everyone heard the news and looked.

I saw Qin Mu taking Zhang Qingyuan...

He walked into the reception room without haste.

"Okay, you murderer is finally willing to come out, hurry up and pay!"

Seeing this, Cheng Chuxiao directly ignored Qin Mu.

A pair of eyes fixed on Zhang Qingyuan.

It was as if there was a deep hatred between the two of them.

Zhang Qingyuan glanced at the big dog lying motionless on the ground, with an unnatural expression on his face.

A little dodge.

In any case, he was the one who beat the dog to death.

He can lose money.

But you can't be fooled by this.

And it's not all his fault, if it wasn't for Cheng Chuxiao not pulling the rope, it wouldn't have caused the subsequent incidents.

"Losing money? Why should we lose money? It's you who should lose money."

Qin Mu took a step forward and stood between the two of them.

He said calmly: "It's fine to bring your pet into the nursing home, and you can walk the dog without leash, and let it move freely. The reason is that the danger is all caused by you."

"We are now formally pursuing 10000 yuan for mental damage, shock, and nutrition from you."

"Pay the money and you can go."

Just now it was far away.

He heard Cheng Chuxiao's arrogant voice.

therefore.

in the discourse.

Not at all polite.

When others are polite to him, he will be polite to others.

To deal with such unreasonable and arrogant people...

He didn't have to be polite either.

And he had just finished speaking.

Then Cheng Chuxiao, who was opposite her, trembled with anger, her face flushed.

He glared at Qin Mu.

He blurted out and scolded: "What are you? Why are you turning black and white here? My dog ​​was killed by him, and I still have to pay? What are you kidding?"

The voice fell.

The entire living room suddenly became silent.

Except for her and her father...

Wan Zhongyuan, the staff of the nursing home, Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and other old people all showed expressions of disbelief.

There was even the sound of gasping for air.

Looking at Cheng Chuxiao's eyes...

It also brought a certain kind of admiration.

As if she had done something extraordinary.

The breathing of everyone could be heard throughout the living room.

"This... This is our court's legal adviser, Qin Mu."

after a few seconds.

Wan Zhongyuan reacted.

He hurried forward and stood between Qin Mu and Cheng Chuxiao.

He wiped the cold sweat from his forehead.

She tactfully said to Cheng Chuxiao: "Ms. Cheng, it's better to be more polite. Some people... may not be the ones you can offend."

The phrase "what are you" just now really scared him.

in a nursing home.

As the vice president, he didn't even dare to yell at Qin Mu like that.

The rest of the colleagues who know the truth...

He even yelled "Brother Qin" one after another, wishing to treat him like his own brother.

after all……

Qin Mu's brilliant achievements are obvious to all.

Offending Qin Mu is of no benefit at all.

If you accidentally send yourself in, it's over.

If you make a good relationship, you can help me out if you encounter any troubles in the future.

But this Cheng Chuxiao is fine...

He yelled at Qin Mu directly.

It startled him.

Qin Mu is irritable...

She might not be the only one involved.

"Legal advisor?"

Cheng Chuxiao didn't realize the seriousness of the problem, but frowned.

She curled her lips and muttered: "The name is quite popular, I seem to have heard of this name before."

Subsequently.

She looked at Qin Mu coldly, and snorted again: "But since you are a legal consultant, you must be very familiar with the law, and you should know how to compensate for the death of a pet if it damages other people's property or pets, right?"

The voice fell.

She clearly felt that something was wrong with the atmosphere in the living room.

The look on everyone's face...

All a little weird.

It seems that she said something wrong.

And behind Wan Zhongyuan.

Qin Mu also stared at her coldly, and smiled back a little angrily.

This Cheng Chuxiao...

He actually asked him if he knew the law.

"According to the "Civil Code", damage to other people's property is a tort, and civil liability must be borne, such as restoration of the original state, compensation for losses, etc."

He thought for a while, and directly read out the relevant provisions in the Civil Code.

Recite the original text.

There is no difference of one word.

For damage to the property of others...

If restitution is possible, it should be.

If the original packaging cannot be restored, the damages shall be compensated.

But this situation...

It is aimed at the party at fault who is completely infringing.

This time it seemed that Lao Zhang killed the dog, but in fact it was caused by not pulling the leash.

"This is monitoring. You can see that you didn't lead the leash, which caused this large dog to run around in the nursing home and rushed towards the elderly in our hospital."

Qin Mu's expression was cold.

He casually took out the surveillance camera obtained from the surveillance room and displayed it in front of Cheng Chuxiao.

in monitoring.

You can clearly see the specific situation at the time of the incident.

The dog kept rushing towards Zhang Qingyuan.

as a normal person...

The first reaction was that the dog wanted to bite him.

and so.

Only then did Zhang Qingyuan take the act of beating the dog to death.

"According to the provisions of the Civil Code, torts need to determine the party at fault, and the party at fault in this matter is entirely yours."

Qin Mu looked at the aggressive and unreasonable Cheng Chuxiao in front of him, and said coldly, "We don't need to bear any responsibility."

Any infringement of...

Both need to assess the fault party.

For example, in a traffic accident, after the accident, the traffic police need to issue a letter of responsibility.

This serves as the basis for compensation and punishment.

Pet dogs do not have human rights and cannot constitute so-called personal injury.

It is a type of property.

After Cheng Chuxiao's pet dog was beaten to death by Lao Zhang, strictly speaking, Lao Zhang violated Cheng Chuxiao's property rights.

but……

Infringement happens for a reason.

It is caused by the dog jumping towards the person first.

It wasn't that Lao Zhang took the initiative to kill the pet dog for no reason.

"What do you mean?"

Cheng Chuxiao's expression changed upon hearing this.

Staring at Qin Mu, he asked, "You mean, my Binbin died in vain?"

Her face was frosty and angry.

Obviously on the verge of forbearance erupting.

Qin Mu's incomparably "indifferent" words...

It almost made her angry.

She never expected that these cold and heartless words would actually come from a 37-degree mouth!

Such a lovely dog, who is considerate, has been with her for three years.

Now lying on the ground cold.

But some people say...

Dogs are property, and if there is infringement, the party at fault must be held accountable.

And the fault is not with the other party.

"Since you know the law so well, and you said that you need to walk the dog on a leash, I'll ask you, which law says that when I take my dog ​​out, I need to walk the dog on a leash?"

She looked at Qin Mu angrily, and simply accused Qin Mu legally.

all the time.

She took the dog out without ever holding a leash.

Her dog is also very docile.

Never hurt anyone else.

But such a kind and lovely dog...

I was beaten to death by an old man today!

Not letting the other party lose money, she couldn't swallow this tone no matter what!

"Article 30 of the "Animal Epidemic Prevention Law" promulgated a year ago clearly stipulates: Units and individuals raising dogs should be regularly immunized against rabies vaccines in accordance with regulations; Rope and other measures..."

Qin Mu looked calm and said lightly.

Compared with the excitement of women...

He was quite calm.

No waves.

Since the other party wanted the law, he simply found the corresponding law for the other party!

This may be difficult for others.

But for him, it's just a search in his mind.

This law...

It was also introduced a year ago, and it is aimed at the behavior of walking dogs in many places without leashes.

"What did you say?"

After hearing this, Cheng Chuxiao froze on the spot.

Can't believe it written all over his face.

She just asked casually.

In my impression, neither the Civil Code nor the Public Security Management Regulations stipulate that dogs must be kept on a leash when walking.

But Qin Mu...

But it was a word of mouth, and he directly said the original text of the law with reason and evidence.

Even the number of articles is clearly stated.

She unbelievingly took out her mobile phone and searched the Internet for the law that Qin Mu said.

result……

The astonishing discovery was exactly as Qin Mu said.

It belongs to Article No.30.

The original text above is exactly the same as what Qin Mu just said!
"I just saw your dog. He didn't wear a dog tag or a leash, which is a serious violation of the law."

When she was in a daze.

Qin Mu's voice continued: "According to regulations, a fine of less than 1000 yuan should be imposed."

"And your behavior of not holding the dog leash is illegal and not protected by law."

"There is a causal relationship between not keeping the dog on the leash and the death of the pet dog, so the fault is naturally yours."

Qin Mu explained the fault party in detail from the perspective of legal logic.

Because Cheng Chuxiao's behavior was an illegal act, which caused a causal loss, Cheng Chuxiao was naturally at fault.

It shouldn't be someone else.

"Bullshit!"

Cheng Chuxiao blushed when she heard this, and it took a long time to utter the four words.

Trembling with anger, she stretched out her finger and pointed at Zhang Qingyuan.

He said dissatisfiedly: "Even if according to what you said, I am not at fault for not pulling the rope, then he killed my dog, is there nothing wrong?"

"According to your logic, if I break the law, others can beat me to death on the road at will?"

What annoys her the most is...

His dog died.

up until now.

In the nursing home, no one came out to sympathize with her dog.

They were all trying to find a way to excuse the dog killer.

This legal counsel...

It even directly stated that there will be no compensation for a penny!

"Your logic is wrong."

Qin Mu looked at Cheng Chuxiao who was about to break the defense, and said lightly: "Dogs have no human rights, they are property, and you..."

He glanced at Cheng Chuxiao.

He pauses for a moment.

He said very seriously: "Only from a legal point of view, you are an individual."

When Cheng Chuxiao heard this, she was even more furious.

The implication of these words...

It is already clear.

It was tantamount to calling her inhuman in disguise.

"For the loss of property, it is natural to determine the fault party, but for the casualty of personnel, the person who caused the criminal injury should be judged, and it cannot be generalized."

Qin Mu said slowly: "Besides, you also watched the video at that time, the dog was chasing the elderly in our hospital."

"The old man in our hospital is 78 years old, old and frail, and in a vulnerable position."

"Whether your dog has the intention to attack or not, in the eyes of ordinary people, an unfamiliar dog came to bite people. It is understandable for the elderly in our hospital to kill it."

"This is a legitimate defense in the face of an ongoing danger."

"Or, emergency avoidance."

After analyzing Cheng Chuxiao's illegal behavior.

He then analyzed Lao Zhang's behavior.

Taking self-defense actions because one's own safety has been illegally violated can be called justifiable self-defense.

And emergency avoidance...

Also known as emergency asylum, it refers to an act that damages another minor legal right as a last resort in order to protect the country, public interests, the person, property and other rights of oneself or others from ongoing dangers.

The focus is on the method of losing the other party's rights and interests when the personal and property safety is violated.

Subjectively, the perpetrator has no criminal intention or negligence, and the purpose is to protect greater legal interests.

Objectively, when two legitimate rights and interests conflict and only one of them can be preserved in an emergency, the law allows the sacrifice of a smaller right for the protection of a larger one. This behavior is ultimately beneficial to society.

therefore.

Emergency avoidance is a legal act.

For example, if you are about to starve to death, you can kill any prison beasts you see to fill your stomach.

Pandas, golden monkeys, alligators...

Eat as much as you want.

Because what it preserves is a human life, and the life of a mere animal is far less valuable than a human being.

Or, a museum curator is threatened with a dagger around his neck when someone steals.

As a last resort, the national treasure was handed over to the gangsters.

It is also regarded as emergency avoidance, and should not be regarded as an accomplice of gangsters.

These are all legal acts and should not be regarded as illegal, let alone criminal.

of course.

This law also involves another aspect of legal issues.

The above two examples are based on the value comparison between people and objects, people and animals.

but……

Suppose a train is running, only to find that the track ahead is broken.

Just in time to change lanes to another track.

But on the other track there was a child picking up stones.

at this time……

There is an obvious logical paradox in sacrificing one person to save many more.

In theory.

The lives of all the people on a train are obviously higher than one person.

But life cannot be compared in this way, which will lead to the desecration of human dignity.

and so.

The life and health of others cannot be used as emergency protection.

The operator should also bear the corresponding criminal responsibility for the crime of intentional homicide.

Emergency avoidance is the same as self-defense, and there is no need to bear responsibility.

"That is to say, our behavior is reasonable, reasonable and legal, and there is no fault at all. The death of the dog is entirely your own fault, and we have no reason to compensate you."

At last.

Qin Mu looked at Cheng Chuxiao and reiterated again.

And Cheng Chuxiao listened to this theory...

On the other hand, his face was gloomy, he gritted his teeth, and scanned the crowd present.

But found that none of the people present stood up to speak for her.

The expression on that face is only short of writing these three words "well said".

"You are determined not to lose money, right?"

She took a deep breath.

Staring at Qin Mu intently, he asked again.

Qin Mu smiled and didn't answer her.

But the attitude has been made very clear.

It's not their fault, so they won't bear it.

"How about this, Ms. Cheng, you have heard the legal terms just now, or...we will pay you 200 yuan from the courtyard as funeral expenses."

next to.

As the vice president, Wan Zhongyuan took the initiative to smooth things over.

His idea was simple.

Turn big things into small things, and small things into small things.

If the problem can be solved, it will be solved on the spot.

What hidden dangers are left in the province.

however……

Cheng Chuxiao on the opposite side did not intend to reconcile, but sneered: "I wanted to talk to you guys, but since you have this attitude, then I have no choice but to call the police and let the police handle it!"

talking.

She took out her mobile phone, in front of everyone.

Dial 110.

When she answered the phone, she also paid attention to her surroundings.

I thought that someone would be shocked by her actions, and then came forward to persuade her not to call the police.

but……

The people around showed intriguing expressions again.

There is no so-called worry and compromise at all.

Do not know why.

There was actually a little hope in his eyes.

It seemed like she wanted her to call the police.

"Hello? 110? I want to call the police. Someone maliciously killed my dog ​​and still refuses to pay. I have video and evidence..."

She just thought she was wrong, and she called the police decisively after the call was connected.

Ask the police to intervene in the matter.

After a few minutes.

She explained the location and event clearly before hanging up the phone.

Staring at Qin Mu and the others.

He snorted coldly: "Wait, wait for the police to come, I hope your mouth can still be so hard!"

Qin Mu: "..."

Wan Zhongyuan: "..."

Zhang Qingyuan: "..."

All the old people: "..."

Seeing Cheng Chuxiao's arrogant appearance, Li Weiguo and other old people watching the fun gathered together.

Discussed blatantly.

"I've lived for so many years, and this is the first time I've seen such an arrogant person dare to speak to Xiao Qin like that."

"I've explained all the laws to her, but she still doesn't believe her. She's really stupid."

"Let's guess, will she be sent in by Xiao Qin?"

"It's hard to say, Xiao Qin looks gentle, but he holds a grudge against him. Anyway, those who offend him rarely end well."

"..."

Not only are they not worried.

On the contrary, I have some expectations.

Because the police are here...

There will be a new play to watch soon.

And Cheng Chuxiao's behavior is completely worthy of the phrase "warrior".

Vice President Wan Zhongyuan gave her a step down, but she still wanted to call the police and kill herself.

in fact.

After the old Zhang incident, they gathered here for the first time.

Want to help Zhang Qingyuan.

But none of them knew the law very well, so they could only support Zhang Qingyuan in terms of numbers.

Fortunately, Qin Mu rushed to the scene.

Lay out all the laws and regulations, and express a strong attitude that you will not pay any money!

pity……

This Cheng Chuxiao is completely out of line.

Don't leave yourself a little way out.

He has always insisted on fighting against Qin Mu.

……

Two 10 minutes later.

"Woooooo-"

In the sound of sirens.

Shen Dao walked into the nursing home with several grassroots policemen.

Came to the reception room where Cheng Chuxiao was.

As soon as we meet.

Then he glanced at Qin Mu in the corner, and couldn't help but "squeaked" in his heart.

Then scan the crowd.

Shen Sheng asked: "Who called the police?"