The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 269 Presiding Judge: Please the old plaintiff don't sleep
Nor will it comply with the demands and carry out divorce judgments and property divisions.

Such evidence...

It is an illegal collection and violates the privacy rights of others.

The other party can even counterclaim the matter in court and demand reasonable compensation.

"what?"

After Han Tianming heard this, his eyes widened.

He showed a puzzled face.

He was full of confidence.

He thought he had found the other party's loophole, but Qin Mu didn't even bother to answer.

The loophole he found was actually limited to civil litigation.

Evidence collected illegally in criminal proceedings...

It is still approved.

"That...that..."

He hesitated and stammered, unable to speak a word for a long time.

And beside him.

Another person in the dock suddenly stood up and said stubbornly: "Then we also published the whole thing on the Internet seeking truth from facts. Why did we publish false content? How did we slander it?"

In order not to go to jail.

They racked their brains, and their brain cells were consumed rapidly.

They were all trying to refute Qin Mu with various excuses.

Cheng Chuxiao succumbed in court, saying that she would pay as much as she wanted, but Qin Mu still refused to let go.

Obviously.

They could only confront Qin Mu, trying to defeat each other theoretically.

This is the free debate session in the courtroom.

They all have the right and qualification to speak.

And this man just finished speaking.

Han Tianming's eyes lit up, and he quickly echoed, "That's right, what we published is not true? We all speak the truth. Could it be that telling the truth is also a violation of the law?"

The rest stood up one after another.

One person agreed.

"We didn't slander you from beginning to end, we just spread the real incident. As for those who accuse you, it's all the spontaneous behavior of those netizens."

"They scolded people, what does it have to do with us? We just want more people to know about it, and they don't know right from wrong."

"In the article we circulated, we also said that we didn't lead the dog. Netizens also saw it. We didn't hide anything at all!"

"This matter, we should not count it as slander, right?"

"..."

Everyone seemed to have found a breakthrough.

Including Cheng Chuxiao, all 17 people showed excitement.

It seems to have caught a life-saving straw.

In the lawsuit, Qin Mu kept saying that they spread false content, which led to the cyberbullying.

But actually...

Their articles did not deliberately hide anything.

It was about Cheng Chuxiao who went to a nursing home without a leash, but the dog chased an old man and was finally beaten to death by the old man.

Those netizens who love dogs are full of love and actively joined the cyberbullying, and they have no direct relationship with them.

At best they...

It just played the role of a media and announced things that the public didn't know.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng.

nursing home.

yard.

Li Weiguo, Song Tiancheng and others also heard the speeches of 17 people including Cheng Chuxiao.

They looked at each other for a while.

"Who read that article? Didn't they hide the truth?"

"Isn't it possible to find a turning point for them? Doesn't it constitute a crime if there is no dissemination of false content?"

"It seems to be like this. I once heard Xiao Qin say that if the dissemination is a fact that has already happened, it is not even considered an illegal act, let alone a crime."

"..."

The old men frowned.

Can't help but feel a little worried.

Having been in contact with Qin Mu for so long, they have somewhat learned some legal knowledge.

Exposing real events on the Internet without violating other people's privacy...

It will not constitute illegal and criminal.

If they just spread the content that the dog died...

Subsequent cyberbullying was spontaneously formed by netizens, so they do not have to bear criminal responsibility at all.

The defense they found...

It can even help them get rid of crime directly!

"It shouldn't be possible, right? Zhang Wei has given up resisting. Although he has lost every lawsuit, his level is really good."

"I also think that Zhang Wei must have thought of this, and they probably didn't understand it."

"Have you noticed that they did this...the performance of actively pleading guilty and accepting punishment is gone? There is no chance of reducing the sentence."

"I actually admire their courage, daring to confront the angry Xiao Qin head-on."

"..."

The crowd whispered.

After careful analysis.

Don't worry.

Now they are in Qin Mu's field, and they don't believe that these amateurs can defeat Qin Mu.

Even Zhang Wei shook his head when he saw it.

illustrate……

In this case, they had no hope.

at this time.

in the projection screen.

After Cheng Chuxiao and other 17 people finished speaking, Qin Mu took the initiative to stand up.

The corners of the mouth curled up.

With a hint of sarcasm: "You guys just said...you didn't spread false content?"

Like the contempt of the king.

Cheng Chuxiao and the others shrunk their necks, but still bit the bullet and nodded.

Insist that what they spread is the truth.

rather than false content.

"Bullshit!"

Qin Mu was not polite, and reprimanded: "The article you posted on the Internet did not hide anything, but it exaggerated the bad behavior of our old man one-sidedly, and emphasized that our old man beat a dog to death and was extremely arrogant. Deny compensation."

"Let me ask you, our old man Zhang Qingyuan was chased by a large dog at that time, and with a cane in his hand, it is not in line with human nature to fight back against the dog?!"

"After the dog was beaten, it showed its viciousness, and our old man beat him to death. Isn't that reasonable?"

He looked at Cheng Chuxiao and the others.

He said coldly: "According to legal presumptions, after a dog is beaten, there are usually two reactions, either to run away with its tail between its legs, or to show its ferocity and fight back."

"In the video, we can clearly see that the dog didn't run away, but continued to rush towards our old man, and our old man continued to fight back with his crutches."

"Let me ask, if the dog runs away after being hit, with my old man Zhang Qingyuan's 78-year-old physical ability, how can we still chase a mature dog?"

talking and talking.

Qin Mu stretched out his hand and pointed to Zhang Qingyuan who was beside him on the plaintiff's seat.

He signaled Zhang Qingyuan to say a few words.

But found...

Zhang Qingyuan sat on his seat with half of his head tilted.

"Whoosh-"

There was a snore.

It seems that because the trial was too boring, there was no chance for him to play.

It may also be that I was too excited last night, thinking about traveling to Europe too late and getting sleepy...

"Cough cough."

He coughed a few times to wake Zhang Qingyuan up.

On this solemn occasion...

He didn't expect Lao Zhang to be able to sleep.

And the court parties.

I also saw the scene where Lao Zhang fell asleep and snored.

Looks vary.

top.

Zhou Quanmin and the members of the collegiate panel looked at each other with black lines all over their faces.

Very speechless.

Shen Sheng advised: "The old plaintiff, please pay attention to your behavior. This is a court, which represents the solemnity of the law. Don't sleep anymore."

in fact.

He is no stranger to Zhang Qingyuan.

On weekdays.

When he tried those criminal cases, Zhang Qingyuan would always sit in the auditorium.

Heard it with gusto.

Occasionally come across some uninteresting cases...

He listened and fell asleep directly.

But this time...

He was sitting in a different position than before, not the auditorium, but the plaintiff's seat.

He didn't care about the auditorium sleeping.

After all, there is no law that stipulates that observers cannot doze off.

Available as plaintiff...

He fell asleep on the spot in court. It was the first time he had tried a case for more than ten years.

"Presiding judge, it may be that our elderly have suffered unbearable cyber violence these days, and their physical and mental state is not good. Please forgive me."

Qin Mu hurried forward and explained something to Zhang Qingyuan.

And the plaintiff's seat.

Seeing that everyone's eyes were on him, Zhang Qingyuan was a little dazed.

He looked around blankly.

For a while I thought the case was over.

"Don't sleep."

Qin Mu rolled his eyes and explained in a low voice.

This is the court.

This case is more likely to cause a national sensation.

Falling asleep here will have extremely bad effects.

Zhang Qingyuan blushed.

I can only bite the bullet, cheer up, and sit up straight.

And this scene...

It was also noticed by Cheng Chuxiao and others.

A feeling called contempt emerged in their hearts by coincidence.

This trial...

It's about whether they go to jail or not.

Their spirits are highly tense and they have been trying their best to save themselves.

But Zhang Qingyuan was fine.

When they desperately rescued themselves, they fell asleep instead.

It seems that they don't take them to heart at all.

at the same time.

Qin Mu said again: "Besides, you said that you did not conceal the facts, so I would like to ask, after the incident, the police came and made a referee. Why is there no mention in the article?"

This sentence.

Ask them again.

first half.

Qin Mu said that they unilaterally exaggerated and publicized Zhang Qingyuan's responsibility, and they could refute it.

But this paragraph...

It didn't appear in the article.

When they wrote and disseminated this matter, they did not tell about the judgment made after the police appeared.

There was no such thing as Cheng Chuxiao disobeying the referee, making trouble on the spot, and being detained administratively.

"According to the legal definition, false news refers to news that does not fully conform to the truth, and has one-sided exaggeration or one-sided concealment of content."

Qin Mu snorted coldly, and said lightly: "And what you have done is completely spreading false news, spreading rumors on the Internet, and slandering other people's reputation, which constitutes a crime of defamation!"

After a few words.

Cheng Chuxiao and the other 17 people were in a daze again.

Everyone was completely defeated.

Qin Mu fought against 17 of them by himself...

Not at all down.

No.

To be precise, it is crushing.

They finally came up with two life-saving points, but Qin Mu refuted them lightly.

And the lawyers beside them are on the bench.

Seeing this scene, Zhang Wei shook his head slightly.

Quite helpless.

He had already thought about what these people had racked their brains to come up with.

Qin Mu's actions are tight-knit.

Now that they have sued them, they must have confirmed their criminal behavior, and there is no point of sophistry.

Want to get away with the law...

almost impossible.

The commutation of sentence was directly blocked by Qin Mu.

It turns out.

The person who stands on the opposite side of Qin Mu...

None of them ended well, and the consequences were dire.

Fortunately, he was just a neutral defense lawyer, never Qin Mu's real enemy.

……

after an hour.

Second Criminal Court.

"Do you have any other rebuttal ideas? Think about it quickly."

Han Tianming looked nervously at Cheng Chuxiao and the others, his expression very ugly.

within this hour.

Their thinking was extremely active, and they found more than a dozen rebuttal points.

But there is no surprise...

It was all resolved by Qin Mu.

In terms of defending in court, they are not at the same level as Qin Mu.

Many people in the dock were ashen-faced and lowered their heads.

It seems to have given up resistance.

"Boom-"

And in court.

Zhou Quanmin rang the gavel and asked, "Defendant, do you have any new points of view regarding the complaint made by the plaintiff's lawyer?"

He witnessed the whole court defense.

He saw all the "efforts" of Cheng Chuxiao and other 17 people.

pity……

These efforts are futile.

The facts of the crime have been constituted and cannot be refuted.

They also have not put forward any new and constructive viewpoints, and cannot overturn the current case trial situation.

See 17 people do not speak.

He glanced at the time, and said in a deep voice, "In that case, the free debate session is over, and we will enter the final statement session."

The final statement is a unique link in criminal proceedings.

The defendant is given the opportunity to make a final statement, to express his grievances, and to plead guilty.

Their collegial panel will also combine the speeches of the final statement, the appearance of repentance, etc., to carry out corresponding sentencing.

"Let's start with Cheng Chuxiao."

He glanced at the dock.

He directly appointed the first speaker.

And in the dock.

Seeing her speak first, Cheng Chuxiao seemed a little nervous.

It's a little awkward to speak.

It was completely different from the previous confrontation with Qin Mu in the nursing home.

"Please make a final statement."

Zhou Quanmin looked at her and reminded again.

At the bar.

Zhang Wei looked at her, lowered his voice and nodded, "Just follow the previous statement."

Defense attorney for the defendant.

He had already arranged everything and helped Cheng Chuxiao and others prepare the final statement.

Although Qin Mu got ruthless this time...

But as long as it is based on the statement, at most it is impossible to obtain a commutation of sentence.

Anyway, the result is already like this, and it won't get any worse.

"I... I am..."

Cheng Chuxiao opened her mouth, then glanced at Qin Mu and Zhang Qingyuan at the plaintiff's seat.

Just feel so ashamed.

She apologized before, but Qin Mu still refused to let her go.

And the final statement Zhang Wei prepared for her...

Almost all words of apology and admission of mistakes.

She even made her admit that she shouldn't put dogs on the same level as people, which made her very resistant and disgusted.

If you can not go to jail...

She can bear this grievance, choose to apologize and bow her head.

But Qin Mu didn't intend to let her go at all, and she couldn't get a reduced sentence.

then……

"I don't think I'm wrong, let alone guilty!"

She clenched her teeth and stared at Qin Mu.

He said something that caught everyone's attention.

The voice just fell.

Zhang Wei's complexion changed slightly again.

He can be sure that this is by no means the first sentence on the final statement he prepared!

It was Cheng Chuxiao who played freely!

see.

He could only wink at Cheng Chuxiao desperately, and coughed softly, trying to make her stop playing.

but……

Cheng Chuxiao didn't care, and didn't see his reminder at all.

Instead, he stared at Qin Mu and said word by word: "In this matter, I am the victim. My dog ​​was beaten to death by them. Why should everyone blame me?"

her face.

Full of grievance and anger.

Since the court session.

She felt that the whole world was against her.

"I am the victim!"

"Where did they... suffer? Isn't the so-called cyber violence just scolding them?"

"They didn't lose a single hair. On the contrary, it was my Binbin who was beaten to death in such a cruel way. He said that he had nothing wrong with him?!"

"If he's right, why are all the netizens talking about him but no one talking about me?"

"The eyes of the masses are discerning!"

"I implore the court to enforce the law impartially and return me and my Binbin to innocence and justice!"

when saying these words.

She was so emotional that her chest heaved up and down.

After speaking.

I just felt the depression in my chest dissipated, and my whole person felt much more comfortable.

She had been suffocating these words before, and almost suffocated herself.

only……

After she returned to her original position, she found that Zhang Wei and the others were looking at her strangely.

Zhang Wei's is complicated.

But Han Tianming and others were shocked.

"Next, Han Tianming."

in court.

Zhou Quanmin frowned slightly, but did not reveal anything.

Han Tianming swallowed.

Bite the scalp and stood up, and said: "Respected presiding judge, judges, regarding this matter... I am deeply aware of my mistake."

He didn't dare to imitate Cheng Chuxiao.

Instead, he honestly made a statement according to the final statement provided by Zhang Wei.

Whether or not you can get probation...

At least this time, the attitude should be correct.

"In this case, I neglected that a dog is just an object and has no human value. I should not over-amplify my emotions for it, so that it violates the legal rights of others and causes irreparable harm to others. .”

He looked up.

Looking at other people in the court, the attitude is sincere.

Trying to use my attitude...

Get a more lenient trial.

only……

He just finished.

Cheng Chuxiao, who was next to him, glared at him angrily: "What the hell is going on with you? Aren't you a pet blogger? I used to publish all kinds of common sense about caring for pets on the Internet every day, how could you say such a thing? You Is it still human?"

She stared at Han Tianming in disbelief.

His eyes were filled with disappointment and bewilderment.

Han Tianming's identity is a blogger on a certain platform, and she often read Han Tianming's articles in the past.

in her mind.

Han Tianming is a very caring person.

Share pet care skills on the Internet every day, and teach everyone to love animals.

She also followed Han Tianming's account.

After the two became friends, they both felt like they hadn't seen each other late.

She always thought that Han Tianming, like her, was a very caring and kind person.

but……

Now Han Tianming actually said such words.

He also said that pets are not worthy of being compared with people, and should not seek justice for her Binbin.

"I'm so blind, I actually regarded you as a confidant, I didn't expect you to be such a person!"

She gritted her teeth.

A distressed expression.

And Han Tianming was accused by her...

He didn't hold back the emotions in his heart anymore, and turned to each other angrily: "What's wrong with a person like me?"

"Don't forget who caused this mess?!"

"If it wasn't for your dog's grievances and justice, how could I, and they, have fallen to this point?"

"I just don't want to go to jail, what's wrong with me?"

"Love? How much is love worth? Kindness? If your kindness to pets can be placed on your father, your father will not be sent to a nursing home by you!"

In a fit of anger.

He didn't save Cheng Chuxiao any more face, and directly tore his face.

He revealed all about Cheng Chuxiao.

"you you!"

After hearing this, Cheng Chuxiao trembled with anger.

I couldn't speak a word for a long time.

"quiet!"

in court.

Seeing this, Zhou Quanmin scolded: "In court, no noise is allowed!"

Cheng Chuxiao and Han Tianming looked at each other bitterly.

That's why I chose to shut up.

"next."

Zhou Quanmin frowned and looked at the next defendant.

And the plaintiff's seat.

Looking at this scene, Zhang Qingyuan's eyes immediately lit up.

Sweeping away the listless look before.

He looked at the dock intently.

"I didn't expect that the main event is here."

He smacked his mouth and murmured in a low voice.

prior to.

It's all Qin Mu's play.

He is useless.

under boredom.

In addition to the exhaustion from last night, he dozed off.

Now the scene of Cheng Chuxiao and Han Tianming yelling in court lifted his spirits instantly.

Such a trial...

That's what he wanted to see.

Especially Cheng Chuxiao, who actually said in court that she was right.

It even refreshed his three views.

Obviously.

Cheng Chuxiao really thought she was right, that her dog's death was all his fault.

This kind of three views has been distorted to a certain extent.

in contrast.

Han Tianming was still saved.

"Sure enough, a true warrior..."

aside.

Qin Mu looked at Cheng Chuxiao in the dock, and couldn't help giving a comment.

Cheng Chuxiao's words...

Completely exceeded everyone's expectations.

There was no attitude of repentance in court, and Zhang Wei was so angry that he shut himself up.

Perhaps she felt that the sentence was already eight years and it was impossible to reduce it, so she dared to be so presumptuous.

But in fact……

Courts hear cases.

It was never said that the sentence imposed would be equivalent to the sentencing recommendation.

usually.

The court's judgment will follow the sentencing recommendations put forward by the procuratorate, and combined with the defense of the defendant's lawyer, the sentence will be commuted within the corresponding range.

Generally less than, or equivalent to, the sentencing recommendation.

But sometimes, the court will make a comprehensive judgment based on the actual situation, the undiscovered circumstances of the case, and the attitude of the defendant.

There are many judicial cases where the sentence is longer than the sentencing recommendation.

And Cheng Chuxiao's move...

It is very likely that she will win more than eight years in prison!

because……

The court can severely punish the defendant who is rebellious, has caused major consequences and refuses to repent!
The sentencing suggestions he gave were only the most basic sentencing considerations and did not apply to the sentencing circumstances.

But Cheng Chuxiao's behavior in the final statement...

But there are circumstances of refusal to repent that can be severely punished!

(End of this chapter)