The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 335

Next to the lawyer's desk.

The parents of Le Jian, Ji Chunchun and others looked at each other, and they all focused on the lawyer they hired.

The lawyer they got...

It is the lawyer of Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

only……

For some reason, although the lawyer named Wang Dachui took their case, he did not represent them personally.

Instead, he handed it over to his lawyer.

seem……

I'm a little scared of them and don't want to be next to them at all.

"Dear presiding judge, all jurors, we disagree with two things about the content of the other party's prosecutor's complaint."

The lawyer next to them also stood up and said in a deep voice: "First, our five clients are all between the ages of 12 and 13, and under the age of 14. They are persons responsible for restricted behavior."

"Their age and experience are not enough to have a complete understanding of the world, and they are still in the stage of shaping values, outlook on life, and world outlook."

"They went astray and caused physical and mental harm to Sun Luoling. I am deeply sorry, and hereby extend my sincere apology and repentance to the victim's family."

talking.

He turned around, looked at Sun Hai, and bowed deeply.

but……

Sun Hai didn't appreciate it, and just gave a cold snort.

Didn't even look at him.

And the lawyer gave a wry smile, and continued: "We don't want the tragedy to happen, but since it has already happened, we think, can we be more tolerant to these children who have gone astray?"

"Their future is still very young. The reason why they commit crimes is because they are immature and reckless."

"When the Law on the Protection of Minors was established, it was actually intended to protect the physical and mental health of these young people and ensure their healthy growth in a good educational environment."

"Therefore, we believe that the sentence is too severe for him, and he should be transferred to a juvenile prison for corresponding punishment."

"Second point, what the prosecutor just said is a little inappropriate."

"Although our party recorded the video, it was not intentionally sent to various group chats, but the video was disseminated due to a mistake. Its motive was not to deliberately humiliate the victim."

"I implore the presiding judge and jurors to investigate carefully."

After finishing his defense.

The lawyer bowed deeply to Sun Hai again, and then returned to his lawyer's seat.

And Sun Hai...

But he was blown away by his defense angle.

Juvenile Management Office!

He may not be familiar with this place before, but after communicating with Qing Lan in the past two days, he has learned a little bit about it.

domestic.

There are two extremely loose prisons, one is a juvenile prison and the other is a prison for the elderly.

Basically it cannot be called a prison.

It will not have a physical and psychological transformation effect, and it can even be said to be a vacation.

There is no overworked work in senior prisons.

And the Juvenile Management Office...

There is no physical work, basically the same as the school, but the management is stricter.

The main activity every day is to read books and accept ideological transformation.

after all……

It is impossible to use child labor anywhere.

The other side raised this point.

It is clear that he wants to help these five little devils get rid of their guilt!
"Boom-"

at this time.

The presiding judge sounded the gavel and said in a deep voice: "After the statements and defenses of both parties, this court will now summarize the focus of the dispute in this case."

"The public prosecutor believes that the defendant's behavior has an extremely bad impact and should be sentenced to fixed-term imprisonment, while the defendant believes that their behavior should be mitigated according to law and handed over to the traffic control office."

"Next, enter the link of proof and cross-examination."

Followed by.

Under the auspices of the presiding judge, the trial proceeded very efficiently.

Directly entered the next stage of proof and cross-examination.

The public prosecutor was the first to stand up and listed all kinds of evidence of crimes committed by Le Yirou, Ji Chunchun and others.

Such as Sun Luoling's minor injury identification certificate, disability certificate, audio and video recording certificate, monitoring certificate, classmate's statement, etc.

The evidence...

A complete chain of evidence has been formed, which can support their criminal behavior from various angles.

Almost undeniable.

In addition, the public prosecutor also cited other bad deeds of the five of them during their school days.

For example, a group of people beat a boy to a concussion. Afterwards, the two parties chatted privately and lost a sum of money.

When school is over, he often blackmails and threatens his classmates and asks others to hand over their living expenses.

These things……

There is certification and physical evidence, as well as school monitoring to prove it.

"From the above, we can see that Le Yirou, Ji Chunchun and other five people organized a series of black and evil crimes in the school, which caused physical and mental persecution to the victims. They have been suspected of serious violations of regulations and disciplines, and violated the corresponding laws of our country. .”

The public prosecutor took a deep breath and complained in a deep voice: "For them, ordinary punishment is not enough to alert and reform them."

in fact.

After receiving the case, their procuratorate held a meeting to discuss the case.

finally.

Most people still believe that exceptions should be made when they are due.

This kind of campus crime...

If it is not punished, it will be banned repeatedly in the future.

Le Yirou, Ji Chunchun and others will not realize their mistakes at all, but will intensify them.

Continue to bully other students.

The Law on the Protection of Minors does protect minors, but those students who are bullied are also minors.

They have suffered physical and psychological persecution, and they are also entitled to hold these perpetrators accountable.

"Presiding judge, the opposing public prosecutor."

At the bar.

The lawyer stood up again and continued to elaborate on his point of view: "There is something wrong with the evidence just now."

"We didn't intentionally spread the video to various group chats, it was just because of a momentary mistake that we sent it to the wrong group."

This defense point...

It was discussed by several lawyers from their Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

The point of the prosecutor's complaint is that they deliberately released the video of Sun Luoling's ragged clothes and distress, which caused great harm to Sun Luoling's reputation and psychology.

but……

As far as he knew, the five of Le Yirou didn't have this idea.

Purely misplaced.

The motives of the two are completely different, which also determines the severity of the nature of the crime.

The former is unintentional.

The latter is to deliberately trample on the personal dignity of others and damage the reputation of others, and the consequences are quite serious.

"You said they didn't forward it on purpose, do you have any evidence?"

The prosecutor frowned and asked directly.

During the trial.

Any claim made by either party needs to be supported by corresponding evidence.

"As far as I know, our client had already vented his anger and let Sun Luoling go back to the dormitory."

The lawyer took a deep breath and defended: "What they did was not something that was upright and worth showing off. There is no need to forward the video to other groups to show off."

"On the contrary, this will expose their bullying of Sun Luoling and attract the school's attention."

"I believe that any normal person would not do this, right?"

He did not start directly from the point of view of evidence, but drew logic.

This is a matter of motivation.

in criminal trials.

In the absence of direct evidence, it is necessary to make corresponding inferences about the criminal motive.

For example, someone inadvertently shared a video with color in the family group, and many people viewed the video.

Suspected of the crime of disseminating xx items.

But he argued that he just wanted to forward it to the trumpet, and accidentally sent it wrong.

This motivational question...

It can be inferred logically and the corresponding results can be obtained.

Laws are strict.

Criminal trials need to be rigorous to the details of every step.

Another example.

Zhang San was a truck driver who accidentally helped someone deliver drugs to another city.

Spotted by the police, but pleaded that he didn't know there were drugs in the cargo.

original.

According to the criminal law, if he transported without knowing the truth, it would not constitute a crime.

However, after interrogation, the police found that he paid 3000 yuan for a trip, but this time he received 10000 yuan.

This is not clear.

therefore.

The criminal law will characterize it as knowing that there is a problem with the goods and is an accomplice to the crime.

Sometimes motives can be denied without sophistry.

And the angle of this lawyer's defense...

It is based on the logic of the parties, trying to minimize the "psychological harm behavior" of the five people.

This is the defense idea under the personal guidance of Zhang Wei of their law firm.

If successful, there is every chance to win the treatment of the juvenile prison.

however.

The prosecutor was unhurried.

He stood up and reminded: "Although the logic you put forward is correct, it does not rule out that after venting, their desire to vent was not satisfied, and they deliberately spread the video."

"During the law enforcement process by the public security officers, we can see many times that they repeatedly reiterated that they are only minors. Obviously, they already know that minors do not need to bear any responsibility for committing crimes, and they have nothing to fear."

"Therefore, we have reason to believe that they intentionally spread the video out of secondary revenge."

Done.

The public prosecutor once again took out the law enforcement recorder at that time and played it in court.

"You let me go, I'm not yet an adult, why do you arrest me?"

"Zhang Qiang from the class next door broke her bones. You didn't catch her. We just scratched her a few times. Why should I be arrested?"

"Let go of me, you can't catch me!"

"..."

Several crisp voices came out.

It was Le Yirou, Ji Chunchun and others who spoke.

When they were first arrested, their attitudes were a little arrogant and unruly.

The defense lawyers of Le Yirou and others immediately changed their expressions after seeing this evidence.

The self-confidence just now...

It disappeared instantly.

He couldn't help turning around, looking at Le Yirou and the other five in the dock.

did not expect……

When they faced the police, they were not timid at all.

He can also say such things with righteous words.

In this way, his logical reasoning did not work.

Judging from their behavior, it is very likely that they forwarded this video to the group because of secondary revenge.

"From logical inference, the probability that they forwarded the wrong video is not high."

After the public prosecutor showed the evidence, he continued: "And after the video was released, there was a 2-minute retraction time. They had enough time to react and withdraw it."

"But they didn't choose to cancel it, but let it continue to be forwarded and spread in various groups, obviously with impure motives."

"It physically bullied and persecuted Sun Luoling first, maliciously spread insulting videos, trampled on Sun Luoling's personal dignity, and secondly, the right to reputation. The circumstances are extremely bad, and naturally they should be severely punished!"

The voice of the prosecutor.

Word by word.

Constantly echoed in the courtroom.

But the defense lawyer's face became more and more ugly.

There was a sudden silence.

(End of this chapter)