The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

To know.

The rule of the mock trial is to eliminate 32 regions according to the score.

It is not simply calculated by the outcome of the court case.

because……

In some cases, the drawn parties are different.

Some parties have a natural advantage.

It would be unfair to judge in this way.

and so.

During the mock trial, no matter which side is drawn, the defense strategy is the top priority.

It's about the competition committee...

That is the final score of the Bar Association.

And the direction Qin Mu proposed during the defense stage...

Undoubtedly, he was seeking his own death.

……

at the same time.

Law Study Alliance Forum.

With the convening of the mock trial on the third day, the popularity of the forum rose again unprecedentedly.

There are more than five times more posts than usual.

Most followed post...

It's all about mock trials.

"Brothers, have you watched the live broadcast? Up's trial has already begun!"

"Good guy! Ten moot courts are in session at the same time, the pinnacle of the national lawyer industry!"

"Where can I watch the live broadcast? Does anyone have a link?"

"It's over, the case drawn by UP is too disadvantageous, this can win me and shit on my head!"

"Up actually wants to plead not guilty? Awesome, can you plead not guilty in this case?"

"..."

in the forum.

Netizens are very excited.

Many law students are always paying attention to the moot court.

after all……

This is a major event in the legal world.

of course.

There are also many netizens who don't know where to watch the moot court, and are begging for links everywhere.

It didn't take long.

Someone updated a post with links to ten live broadcast rooms.

Instantly aroused heated discussions.

First floor: Thanks to the landlord, good people have a safe life.

The second floor: I just went to the next ten live broadcast rooms, and the cases became more and more outrageous.

The third floor: As expected, it is a peak competition, but there is no ordinary case.

Fourth floor: Up's case is a bit difficult to fight, it's a bad nature, and it's out of luck.

Fifth floor: This competition system seems to be a discussion elimination system, if the score is not enough, it will be eliminated.

Sixth floor: Up can't do a round trip, right?Usually fierce as a dog, soft-legged shrimp in the competition?
Seventh floor: Is there any big boss in the forum who is proficient in law, how can the crime of negligent death be defended as innocent?

Eighth Floor: I just asked my teacher, and he said he didn't understand either.

Ninth Floor: The actions of Zhang San and Li Si fully meet the constituent elements of the crime of negligent death. It is basically more difficult to defend and get rid of the crime, right?

Tenth Floor: To be honest, I think the sentencing proposals put forward by the other party's prosecutors are all right. Each person is only a year and a half old. After all, it is a human life.

Eleventh Floor: One and a half years is not too much for negligence leading to the death of others.

Twelfth floor: I also think the sentencing proposal put forward by the other party is quite reasonable. If up seeks probation, the joint Zhang Wei may be able to overthrow the other party!

Thirteenth floor: Are all the upstairs newcomers?Some people are actually worried that up will lose in court? up Have you lost before?
Fourteenth floor...

under this post.

The number of floors is soaring at an alarming rate.

The old fans were not at all worried that Qin Mu would lose.

Since becoming Qin Mu's fans, they have seen too many incredible things.

There is already a kind of blind worship and belief in Qin Mu.

……

Magic City.

A venue, the Eighth Moot Court.

"Boom-"

After listening to Qin Mu's defense, the presiding judge was also a little surprised.

But he still presided over it seriously: "Since this is the case, the focus of this case will be on the guilt or innocence of Zhang San and Li Si. Next, we will enter the link of proof and cross-examination."

Followed by.

The three lawyers on the prosecution bench began to sort out the materials at hand and sort them out by categories.

"Presiding judge, judges, this is the testimony of old man Sun, an eyewitness we collected at that time. Old man Sun admitted that he saw Zhang San and Li Si throwing two firecrackers into the pond with his own eyes."

"Here is the forensic examination certificate of the cause of death. It is determined that Wang Er's death was caused by excessive fright and drowning. At the time of the incident, only Zhang San and Li Si threw two firecrackers into the pond."

"Here are the confessions of Zhang San and Li Si. The two confessed to their plan to throw firecrackers into the pond."

"This is Wang Er's family situation..."

Two criminal defense lawyers from Yangcheng presented evidence in the moot court in an orderly manner.

Every evidence...

All point to a certain element of the crime of negligence causing death.

combine.

It can be accused that Zhang San and Li Si's behavior constituted the crime of negligent death.

In the auditorium.

The surrounding lawyers showed their approval when they saw Yangcheng's lawyer's complaint.

Moot court cases are set.

but……

The collation of evidence, the direction of the accusation, and the estimation of sentencing all need to be handled by the party concerned.

After the trial is over.

The competition organizing committee, that is, the Bar Association will score it.

Even if they are allowed to play, there is no guarantee that they will do better than the two criminal defense lawyers in Yangcheng.

"The evidence for the accusation is remarkable. Jincheng and the others probably won't be able to stand up to it."

"Unless they can find out the loopholes in the evidence and overturn it, all three elements will be met, and the crime of negligent death must be established."

"Qin Mu probably doesn't know how to cross-examine his half-assed strength."

"I thought about it just now. These evidences are ironclad evidence, and it is almost impossible to be overthrown."

"..."

Everyone in the auditorium shook their heads and whispered.

Zhao Baiqin showed even more sneer and sarcasm, looking at Qin Mu with more and more disdain.

"It turns out that this level..."

He shook his head.

Just wanted to get up and leave and head to the other moot courts to see what's going on.

Seeing Qin Mu standing up on the defendant's defense bench, he said loudly, "The evidence presented by the other party is all right. Our parties, Zhang San and Li Si, did indeed throw firecrackers into the pond."

"His behavior has a certain causal relationship with Wang Er's death, and our party should indeed bear the corresponding responsibility."

"but……"

Speaking of it.

Qin Mu changed the subject, and said in a deep voice, "But I don't think the actions of the two of them constituted a crime, so they should not bear the corresponding criminal responsibility, and only need to pay civil compensation."

The voice did not fall.

The two lawyers in Yangcheng retorted: "With the hard evidence, the actions of Zhang San and Li Si fully meet the three requirements. How could it not constitute a crime?"

Defendant's counsel.

Feeling the tense atmosphere around him, Zhang Wei couldn't help swallowing.

He wanted to stand up and say something, but found that he couldn't keep up with Qin Mu's train of thought.

He was just trying to plead probation.

But Qin Mu wanted to take off directly.

"Of course it doesn't constitute a crime!"

Qin Mu held his head high and said calmly, "According to the evidence you presented just now, our parties Zhang San and Li Si did indeed throw two firecrackers into the pond, and the cause of Wang Er's death was indeed related to the sound of the firecrackers."

"But according to the eyewitness old man Sun's recollection, only one firecracker was heard at that time."

On the prosecution bench.

The two criminal defense lawyers in Yangcheng were stunned for a moment, and quickly looked it up in the case description.

Find……

It was indeed as Qin Mu said.

In Old Man Sun's statement, he also said that he heard a firecracker.

The two looked at each other.

Looking at Qin Mu again, he snorted coldly, "So what? One sound of firecrackers is enough to convict!"

indeed.

As long as the firecrackers go off, it is enough to prove that there is a causal relationship between the deaths of Zhang San, Li Si and Wang Er.

All three elements are also met.

however.

Qin Mu was not in a hurry, and the corner of his mouth curled up: "The three elements are indeed met, but there is only one firecracker, which means that it is very likely that one of the firecrackers thrown by our party has misfired."

"That is to say, there is no direct connection between the behavior of one of them and Wang Er's death."

"Then the crime of negligent death committed by the two of our parties that you are suing does not meet the constitutive requirements, unless you can prove that both firecrackers went off!"

moot court.

Qin Mu's voice was sonorous and powerful, echoing in the small room.

Everyone present...

They were all shocked by Qin Mu's new point of view.

I hurriedly read the "original topic" of this trial case.

Find……

Indeed, as Qin Mu said, the original description of the case refers to "a sound of firecrackers".

It is very likely that this is a small detail that the author of the question did not notice, it is insignificant, but Qin Mu found it out and used it.

On the prosecution bench.

The faces of the three lawyers from Yangcheng became ugly, and they instantly understood Qin Mu's defense idea.

Qin Mu intends to...

With a sound of firecrackers as the direction, their accusations will be disintegrated.

According to the principles of criminal procedure law.

Because criminal punishment is an extremely severe punishment, it is necessary to be cautious, and there must be no doubts in any link before the case can be put on trial.

As for the point Qin Mu raised...

It happens to be the biggest loophole in this case!