If you buy fake goods online, you will buy 100 million more!

Chapter 218 The Law of Conservation of Pig Teammates

Jiang Bai was not surprised that Du Yansen refused to plead guilty.

Although he didn't know much about this lawyer Du, but after the violation of regulations and his license was revoked last time, no matter how he said it, he should learn a lot from it, right?

You can't learn a lesson in vain. You don't make any progress at all, but you still raise the violation to the level of crime...

That's a real idiot.

So Jiang Bai didn't believe from the beginning to the end that Du Yansen instigated Zhang Renjie to threaten and bribe the victim.

This is more like Zhang Renjie biting people with a mad dog.

Since he was innocent, Du Yansen would definitely plead not guilty.

After he finished speaking, he cast a cold glance at Zhang Renjie and sat back.

"Defendant No. [-], do you have any objection to the content of the complaint?" Chen Zhonghan asked Zhang Renjie in a deep voice.

The latter swallowed hard, his lips trembled, and he said with difficulty: "I, I have objections."

Um! ?

Hearing this, Chen Mengzhe's eyelids twitched, and his face immediately changed.

He quickly turned his head to look at Zhang Renjie, and kept blinking at him, the crow's feet could kill a fly.

Du Yansen refused to plead guilty because he was confident in pleading not guilty.

But Zhang Renjie's case has already been well-documented, and there is absolutely no possibility of innocence, so he can only find a way to plead guilty.

Therefore, before the court session, Chen Mengzhe told him repeatedly that after going to court, he must actively plead guilty and accept punishment, apologize to the victim, compensate the victim, and strive for a commutation of sentence.

Chen Mengzhe sorted out and summarized a number of statutory and discretionary commutation circumstances in advance, trying hard to help Zhang Renjie get a few years commutation.

But when he opened his mouth, he completely disrupted the rhythm.

Chen Mengzhe was so anxious that he quickly winked at Zhang Renjie.

But the latter ignored it at all, and continued to argue.

"I admit that the three recent medical accidents are related to me, as well as obstructing testimonies, replacing exams, and buying and selling certificates. I admit all of these."

"I don't admit to practicing medicine illegally! I'm not practicing medicine illegally!"

Zhang Renjie panted heavily, and shouted loudly: "I have a doctor's qualification certificate. Although I am not the one who took the exam, this certificate was issued to me!"

"How can you say that I am practicing medicine illegally?"

"Besides, the past medical accidents mentioned by the prosecutor just now were indeed related to me, but they were not caused by me."

"It's like the mother who died on the operating table because of bleeding after giving birth. I have tried my best to save her."

"I'm just a doctor, not a god. Some people can be saved, but some people I really can't save. It can't be my fault..."

Zhang Renjie was excited and shouted loudly.

From the side, you can clearly see the spittle stars splashing around.

Chen Mengzhe's complexion was extremely ugly.

Zhang Renjie's sophistry really opened his eyes.

Since they were all found to have hired gunmen to take the exams, the medical qualification certificates thus obtained are naturally illegal and invalid.

He used such an invalid certificate to prove that he was not practicing medicine illegally...

Not only will it not help in reducing crimes and sentences, but it will also leave a very bad impression on the collegial panel.

And this impression will directly affect the final sentence.

Chen Mengzhe was so angry that his face was crooked.

the other side.

Looking at this familiar scene, Zhang Wei couldn't help showing a smile on his face.

Yes, that's the taste, that's right!

According to the "Law of Conservation of Pig Teammates", a pig teammate will neither be created nor disappear out of thin air, it can only be transformed from one kind of show operation to another show operation, or transferred from this defender to another defender...

Seeing Chen Mengzhe being stabbed in the back by his teammates, Zhang Wei was like drinking a bottle of ice cream in a hot and dry desert.

No, plastic bottles are not cool enough, it has to be canned!

This feeling is just one word, it's so refreshing!
There are so many wonderful things in the world, why should one be caught in the pit of death?
Why can't you go and cheat other people?
Seeing that Chen Mengzhe had such a day, Zhang Wei regained his mental balance instantly.

As for Du Yansen...

He even grinned so much that the corners of his mouth reached to the roots of his ears.

As a lawyer who was cheated by Zhang Renjie, he saw another lawyer was also beaten by him.

He is very cool.

After some operations by Zhang Renjie.

Chen Zhonghan rapped the gavel, and said in a deep voice: "Since the two defendants have objections to the indictment, we are now entering the stage of proof, cross-examination and court debate."

"First try the case of defendant No. [-] instigating a crime."

"Does the prosecutor have any evidence to present?"

"Have!"

Shen Tianci stood up, held up a USB flash drive and said, "I have a recording evidence here, and I request to play it in court."

After the judge agreed, the clerk took the USB flash drive and inserted it into the USB port of the computer to play the audio file.

Soon, the sound of two men talking came from the loudspeaker.

"...You should know a lot of people from the procuratorate and the court, right? Can you help me find connections?"

"Don't drag me if you want to die!... You want to send me in too!?"

"Then what do you say!?"

"Now it's because three people have called the police...if they can be dealt with..."

"Yes, you are right, I understand!"

After the recording was played, Shen Tianci said, "This is the sound extracted from the Fu Hai Hotel's monitoring. After careful analysis of the sound waveform by experts, it can be confirmed that the two parties talking are the two defendants in court."

"The time of the conversation was on X, X, which was the night before Zhang Renjie committed the act of obstructing testimony. At that time, he had just been released on bail pending further investigation. He came out of the Changhe Street Police Station and met with Du Yansen at the Fuhai Hotel. The topic of discussion was medical treatment. Accident."

"And Du Yansen came up with an idea for him. The original words were 'get them done'. The 'they' here refer to the civil plaintiff No. [-], [-], and [-] behind me."

"It was under the influence of this sentence that Zhang Renjie implemented the act of obstructing the testimony. This point can also be corroborated from the judgment of the causal relationship before and after time."

Shen Tianci's resonant voice resounded in the courtroom.

"It can be seen from this that Du Yansen's words caused Zhang Renjie to commit a criminal act that met the constitutive requirements and set up an abettor."

Chen Zhonghan nodded slowly, looked at the defendant's seat, and asked, "Defendant, do you have any objections to this evidence?"

"We have no objection to the authenticity, legality and relevance of the evidence, but we do not approve of its strength of proof!"

After finishing speaking, Zhang Wei smiled slightly and said to the judge: "Your Excellency, the defender requests to replay the recorded evidence just now."

The judge naturally agreed.

soon.

The recording starts playing.

But this time, Zhang Wei yelled "Stop" before it played much.

The clerk presses pause.

Zhang Wei looked around and said, "Just now the public prosecutor focused on the second half of the recording, but ignored the content at the beginning of the recording."

"Please play it again."

"Please pay attention to the content of the conversation between the two at the beginning."

The clerk played the recording again.

Zhang Wei yelled "stop" again at the same place.

Then he said: "I believe everyone has heard that in the first half of the recording, Zhang Renjie once proposed to let our party go for a relationship. Everyone understands the so-called relationship."

"And what did my client say?"

"He sternly refused, and mentioned an example of a colleague who was held criminally responsible."

"Through this sentence, I have reason to believe that our party absolutely has no subjective will to operate in violation of laws and regulations. It can also be explained from the side that the 'fixed' he said is not the threat and bribery that Zhang Renjie understands."

Zhang Wei glanced at Zhang Renjie, and then said:

"It is also sufficient to see that the second defendant, Zhang Renjie, committed the criminal act of obstructing testimony, based entirely on misunderstandings and his own subjective malice!"

"Our party cannot foresee that Zhang Renjie will misunderstand what he said, nor can we foresee that Zhang Renjie will commit criminal acts."

"He did have negligence and did not accurately and rigorously convey his meaning to the parties, but this does not mean that he was convicted of abetting a crime!"

As soon as Zhang Wei finished speaking, Shen Tianci immediately said, "I disagree with the defender's statement."

"The first half of the recording can only show that defendant No. [-] Du Yansen had no intention of bribery, but it does not prove that he has no intention of other criminal acts."

"In addition, according to the judicial interpretation, when the instigated person has the intention to commit an illegal act, even if the instigated person originally instructed a method that is difficult or even impossible to lead to the result, the instigated person may change the method until the result occurs. In such cases, the abettor shall not be exonerated from responsibility."

"In other words, even though Du Yansen did not intend to obstruct the testimony, Zhang Renjie was indeed influenced by him to commit the crime, and Du Yansen needs to take responsibility for it!"

Zhang Wei immediately retorted: "I don't agree, I think..."

The two had a heated debate on whether Du Yansen was an abettor.

You say what I say, and don't give in to each other.

In the auditorium.

"Ah..."

Chu Meiyan covered her mouth and yawned cautiously.

Jiang Bai glanced at her, smiled and shook his head.

That's how courtroom arguments are most of the time, dull and uninteresting.

Both parties are nothing more than constantly using legal provisions, judicial interpretations, classic cases, etc. as supporting means to prove their own views and refute the other party's views.

To outsiders, many of the theories may seem a bit incomprehensible.

Obviously, according to common sense, it should be like that, but the lawyer decided to pass a certain judicial interpretation to forcibly reverse the nature of this matter.

It becomes a look that goes against ordinary people's common sense.

But that's court debate.

Common sense sometimes differs from the law.

In this case, the boring court debate will become even more boring.

Chu Meiyan curled her lips and said, "This trial is really boring... If this continues, I will really fall asleep."

Jiang Bai whispered: "This is how the trial is, but it seems that this debate is almost over, and there should be a good show to watch."

The voice just fell.

"Boom-"

Chen Zhonghan sounded the gavel to end the debate.

This also means that the court investigation against Du Yansen is basically over, only one final statement is missing.

From the present point of view, Du Yansen is more optimistic about the situation, and most likely he will not be identified as an abettor.

Of course, the final judgment depends on the intention of the collegial panel.

Chen Zhonghan glanced at it, and said in a deep voice: "Next, we will launch a court investigation on Zhang Renjie's case."

"After the last trial, Zhang Renjie's crimes of medical malpractice and obstruction of testimony have been basically cleared up. Prosecutor and defendant, do you have any new evidence to present?"

Both parties said no.

In fact, if there were no unexpected circumstances in the last trial, Zhang Renjie would have been sentenced for these two charges long ago.

For the crime of medical malpractice and the crime of obstructing testimony, the facts of the crime are clear, the evidence is sufficient, and there is nothing to argue about.

Chen Zhonghan nodded and said, "Okay, then the court's investigation will focus on the other four charges that Zhang Renjie is suspected of, namely: the crime of substituting for an exam, the crime of illegal medical practice, the crime of buying and selling documents, and the crime of fraud."

"Does the prosecutor have any evidence to present?"

Shen Tianci nodded and said, "The public prosecutor requests witnesses to appear in court."

"agree."

Soon, the witness was brought into the courtroom by two bailiffs and put on the witness stand.

This is a middle-aged man in his early forties, thin and wearing glasses.

Since the witnesses belonged to the public prosecutor, the public prosecutor took the lead in asking questions.

At the beginning, there were some basic questions, in order to let the members of the collegial panel understand the witness, and also to make his subsequent testimony more easily admissible.

The witness’s name is Fang Hai, 43 years old this year. He once studied at a famous medical university. He had good academic performance and a promising future, but he was ordered to drop out of school because he accidentally rubbed his backpack on the buttocks of a female classmate while queuing for food in the cafeteria. .

Step into society.

Since he did not have a degree certificate, it was difficult to find a satisfactory job. Fang Hai once lived in distress, so he became a "substitute for the exam".

The main service targets are students in medical universities and those who apply for medical qualification certificates.

He has completed the final exams for many students, and has also helped several people obtain medical qualification certificates, including Zhang Renjie.

After some inquiries.

Fang Hai told the whole story about how he contacted Zhang Renjie back then, and how he helped him pass the test instead of the exam.

And a notebook is provided.

In the notebook, Fang Hai recorded the basic situation of all "clients".

Including name, age, substitute test content, remuneration, etc.

After Shen Tianci finished asking, Chen Zhonghan looked at the defendant's seat and asked, "Does the defender have any questions to ask the witness?"

Chen Mengzhe shook his head slowly: "No."

"Okay, the witness is out."

Fang Hai was taken away by the judicial police.

His question will be heard in court later.

The trial court is still investigating Zhang Renjie's criminal facts.

Shen Tianci got up and said: "According to the confession of the certificate and the laptop evidence, it is enough to prove that the defendant No. [-] Zhang Renjie, the physician qualification certificate for the physician qualification certificate on the x -year X -month x day, is replaced by others!"

"The evidence for the crime of substituting an exam is solid, and there is no doubt."

"In addition, due to the substitution of examinations, Zhang Renjie's practice of medicine in the past ten years is illegal, and he is guilty of illegal medical practice!"

The voice just fell.

Zhang Renjie immediately stood up and shouted: "No! I don't admit it!"

　Thanks to Da Xinzi for the 68000 starting point coin reward, thank you big brother~
　　Thanks to book friends 20220822112838256 for rewarding
　　
　
(End of this chapter)