Hundreds of schools follow

Chapter 39
After the second refutation, after a drink break, the scene calmed down a bit.

Ying Li exchanged looks with Han Sun and Fan Ya, and finally nodded.

"The talk has entered a good stage, the next refutation, only Siye can bear this scene, Teacher Fan Zi, please!"

Fan Ya nodded silently, then stood up and looked directly at Tanying.

Tan Ying also took a deep breath.

He knew that he couldn't avoid this question no matter what.

Not only him, but everyone in the audience was looking forward to this moment.

Argumentation is, after all, argumentation, and its seriousness is unquestionable.

Once Tanying is allowed to pass the test, it means that Jixia Academy has recognized his theory, and he will be responsible no matter whether it is right or wrong, honor or disgrace in the future.

Right now, under the circumstances that one refutation and another refutation have failed one after another, and all the scholars are dumbfounded.

No matter how much Fan Ya cherished the bachelor, she had to resort to ruthless tactics.

Facing Fan Ya's stare like a servant, Tan Ying's mental strength has also risen to the peak.

"Please." He nodded.

Three refutations, start.

Fan Ya: "If I insist that the earth is disk-shaped, how do you explain it?"

Tan Ying: "..."

Fan Ya: "Don't worry, think slowly."

Tan Ying: "Students have no solution."

Fan Ya: "Yes."

Tan Ying: "Yes."

Tan Ying then turned to Ying Li: "Master, Si Ye has already refuted me."

Three rebuttals, finally.

Ying Li: "..."

The audience: "..."

After a long silence, Ying Li asked tremblingly: "Is it really the end of these two sentences? Don't you want to discuss it with Xie Lun?"

Tan Ying nodded and said: "I have already told Pang Xuebo that if you want to refute me, it is enough to make a counterexample. Just now, Si Ye killed me with one blow. Why do you need to say a third sentence?"

Ying Li asked unwillingly: "The ground is in the shape of a plate, so is it really invulnerable?"

Tan Ying nodded again: "This site, if it has a suitable shape, a suitable angle, a suitable speed, and a suitable track, it makes sense. If it doesn't make sense, how can I bring it up with Si Ye's talent? Arguing strongly is nothing but self-inflicted humiliation."

Ying Li then looked at Fan Ya.

Fan Ya just nodded slightly:

"One word on the stage, the audience thinks a lot. Scholar Tan knew that there was such a flaw, so he heard it and refuted it.

"Although the earth is flat, I have not refuted the roundness of the earth.

"Only because Scholar Tan and Pang Xuebo said the phrase 'one counterexample is enough' when they refuted it, which means that the earth is round is the only theory, so facing the horizon at this time, I had to admit defeat.

"I also hope that Scholar Tan will take this as a warning, and guard against arrogance and impetuosity in the future, and think twice before speaking."

Tan Ying could only smile wryly.

Who is the enemy of the theory of the circle of the earth?

Only the horizon said it.

Even in later generations with extremely rich arguments, no matter what kind of evidence the round earth theory presents, the flat earth theory can always be resolved with a strange special situation.

The earth is a disc, which is a relatively perfect horizon model.

Theoretically, as long as the disk is designed ingeniously, it is unlikely to be cracked without using a certain level of mathematical tools.

But such a tool can only be used when it is publicly recognized and understood by most people.

Using a certain principle here, XX points, is no different from metaphysics.

It is even more nonsense to talk about the astronomical evidence of the future.

If you have to argue strongly, of course there is a point of view.

But Tan Ying believes that with Fan Ya's talent and learning, he has already considered every angle.

It is better to admit defeat than to get away with it and make a strong argument to humiliate yourself.

As for saying "one counterexample is enough" when facing Pang Mu, this is really a big flaw of getting carried away, and Fan Zi taught it well.

During the silence of the audience, more and more people also recalled this "killing with one word".

As Fan Ya said, a master's move has already contained thousands of thoughts in one sentence.

More importantly, this is still Fan Ya, Fan Zi's endless thoughts.

To refute Tanying, indeed, one word is enough.

It is true that Tanying has quite a creative idea, but it is still too early to make a theory.

Facing such a sophisticated Fan Ya, if he argues forcefully, he will only walk step by step into the abyss Fan Ya built for him, and I am afraid that he will be carried out in the end...

Looking back at the first refutation and the second refutation at this time, Tan Ying didn't seem to be so decent.

To refute Pang Mu, the deception of Confucianism does not understand mathematics, and Tan Ying's words are even more sophistical. Now that I think about it, the cause and effect are inevitably a bit vague, but Pang Mu's scruples about his identity did not go into details with him.

The second objection is to Zhou Jingzhi, he didn't say a word at all, and it all depends on Si Qinghuang's solution, Fan Yayuan said.

Looking at it now, Fan Ya seems to be a bit early to make a move, and another academic doctorate may be enough to refute Tan Ying.

Don't even talk about academics. At this time, even the bachelors present are all gearing up.

"Oh, I didn't hear it right, and I wanted to ask the host to refute it."

"Tanying's words are true, but there are many mistakes and omissions. Si Ye has shown mercy to him."

"It's all because Pang Xuebo and Zhou Xuebo spoke too early and deliberately gave way, otherwise I would be enough to refute him."

Sitting on the main stage, Ying Li could clearly see the people in the audience.

Just now, they were afraid of being ashamed, and all of them shrank back.

Seeing Si Ye win again now?
OK, I'll satisfy you.

Boom!
Ying Li hit the debate hammer on this, and said after the audience was quiet:

"Scholar Tan has misunderstood Lianlun Qingtan, but it's still not a refutation.

"Si Ye only said that the earth can also be disc-shaped, but he didn't overthrow the earth's circle.

"Since it's all speculation, whether the ground is a circle or a disk, it's all okay.

"This refutation, Si Ye caught Tanying's flaws in his refutation, and he won a big victory, but it is too early for Tanying to say defeat at this time.

"Look, quite a few learned scholars are eager to try, waiting to refute your more flaws.

"Come on, any scholar who wants to talk about something, you might as well raise your hand and let me see it."

Hearing this, the people who were just eager to try shrank back instantly.

Asking questions in such a clear talk also requires courage and talent.

Otherwise, if you ask stupid questions, you will be ridiculed.

They just saw Tan Ying's defeat, and they couldn't understand it. Who could ask the really tricky question?
Seeing these people lower their heads again, Ying Li just shook his head and smiled.

Don't talk about arguments, how can these people who don't even have the courage to stand up see Tan Ying clearly?
Looking at Tan Ying again, she responded generously to three criticisms, and finally fell in front of Fan Ya.

How tragic and lonely this is.

At this time, Yingli's expression was invisible to others, but the young queen sitting beside Yingli could hear it clearly.

Well, you Yingli, taking advantage of your position as the host, secretly flirting with Tanying, right?
The young queen immediately broke the silence, looked at Tanying from a distance with a smile and said:

"Tanying was only sixteen years old, and he had just entered the palace for the first time. He was able to win one victory, one draw, and one loss in the face of three refutations here.

"Even me, I haven't heard such a wonderful talk for a long time.

"If I host it, this is the right time to end it.

"But I just heard that the host thinks Tan Ying is 'too early to say goodbye', and seems to want to provoke him to argue again.

"It's good to listen to a wonderful talk, but Tan Ying has obviously tried his best, and Si Ye's rebuttals have exhausted his willpower, let alone sacrificial wine?

"The host insists on saying this, in my opinion, I'm afraid it's going to embarrass Tanying."

When Ying Li heard this, a hideous look suddenly appeared on her relatively plain face.

Old woman, you've crossed the line!
I clearly care about Scholar Tan, but you misinterpret it maliciously and deliberately make him hate me, you have done all kinds of evil!
However, before she could respond, she saw Tan Ying following her words, and she nodded with the young queen, as if thanking her for the rescue.

The young queen's face was instantly joyful, and she returned a seductive smile with a thousand twists and turns.

what……

Ying Li trembled and covered her mouth.

No……

Don't just fall into this old woman's trap so easily!

My sister didn't mean that!

It's even more impossible for the young queen to be a good person!
(End of this chapter)