Reborn I just want to concentrate on studying

Chapter 298 Sometimes Debates Need Sensibility!

The matter of meeting Zhao Qiang can wait for a while, the most urgent task right now is to study this topic of debate.

Tomorrow's first debate competition is scheduled to start at nine o'clock in the morning, but it is already past noon, which means that there is only half a day left for discussion.

"Should Liu Bang be killed... This debate is too obvious, isn't it? It's obvious...Xiang Yu let Liu Bang go, and then he was defeated. If Liu Bang was killed at the Hongmen Banquet, then there would be no such mess later What happened..." Zhan Chao shook his head after finishing speaking: "To be honest, I think Liu Bang should be killed, the disadvantage of the opposing side is too obvious."

Liang Ruimin also nodded: "I think what Zhan Chao said makes sense."

Xing Yingdan looked at Yi Yang: "What do you think, Yi Yang? Where do you think we should start?"

Yi Yang lightly bit his nails and thought for a moment, then looked up at Lai Subin, saw that he was smiling and didn't intend to interfere with them, so he sorted out his thoughts, and said slowly: "Well... this kind of debate topic It’s different from what we’ve encountered before.”

"The previous debates were often a certain proposition with two sides. Let the pros and cons stand on one side, so even if you just think about it, you can come up with an argument. But this kind of historical choice debate, I don't think Looking at it from a backward perspective, we should look for the answer from the political, cultural, economic and other factors of that era based on the special background of the Chu-Han struggle..."

Liang Ruimin smiled: "Ah, you didn't say anything."

Yi Yang looked at Liang Ruimin, smiled, and continued: "Well... I think we can think about this topic in this way... Our argument is that Xiang Yu shouldn't kill Liu Bang, so think about it in reverse and kill Liu Bang. What will happen if Liu Bang is killed, and what will happen if Liu Bang is not killed? From our standpoint, the advantages of not killing Liu Bang must outweigh the disadvantages, so what is the benefit to Xiang Yu of not killing Liu Bang, as long as we can find the answer to this question , we have our arguments on this topic.”

At this point, everyone was a little frustrated.

On the road.

Yi Yang shook his head: "After thinking about it now, it's better to think about it this way...Have you watched Huang Zhizhong's game?"

……

I was not proficient at the beginning, and it was not an easy task to find the required materials in the library of Nuoda University. Fortunately, there are computer search software now, which can find the corresponding book location, and librarians do this.

Even if you lose, this process will be very meaningful.

Zhan Chao is of course happy with this.

The search for information has begun.

"All right, let's go to dinner first, then go back to the hotel and split up."

Xing Yingdan and Zhan Chao are both science students, and they don't know so much about history by nature. Even if Liang Rui is in the liberal arts elite class, Yi Yang's words are obviously beyond the outline, and she is also very confused.

Before checking the information, everyone felt that this topic of debate was unfriendly to the opposing side, but after checking the information, everyone found out...

"Liu Bang is just a representative of that interest group. If Xiang Yu kills Liu Bang, will there be a Zhao Bang? Will there be a Li Bang to replace him? If killing a person can eliminate an interest group, then Isn’t this kind of politics too childish?”

"Ah."

After having dinner together, Yi Yang was still thinking about the topic, and didn't realize the agreement with Zhao Qiang until he returned to the hotel and the phone rang.

Yi Yang said earnestly: "In debates, logic is always the priority and rationality is the main priority. However, Huang Zhizhong has some classic competitions that bypass rationality and use emotion to impress the audience and judges."

After hearing Zhan Chao's question, Yi Yang smiled confidently and said, "I guess the other party will definitely think from this angle, but it's actually easy to refute... Well, Xiang Yu can't win the world, just like letting go of Liu Bang." Is there any necessary connection between the things?"

Xing Yingdan said nonchalantly: "It's okay to go for a casual stroll, I'm just a little stuffy in my head, maybe it's good to go out and get some air, it doesn't matter what I wear, and neither do other people's opinions."

The huge floor-to-ceiling windows are bright and clear, the sunlight is not glaring, and it shines obliquely on the desk in a certain position. A certain boy was a little tired from reading, so he stared at the light bar on the desk in a daze. Suddenly the light disappeared, and he turned his head to look Look, the girl sitting next to him closed the curtains, he smiled embarrassedly, and continued to study, the girl smiled with satisfaction, and gently touched the boy's hand.

Xing Yingdan was a little surprised, "What do you think?"

It just so happened that he didn't have any ideas right now, so Zhao Qiang proposed to take a walk around, and he agreed.

Yi Yang sighed slightly, nodded: "All right."

"Huh?" Zhan Chao was obviously taken aback.

Xing Yingdan was slightly taken aback, frowned and said, "Well... what are you going to do?"

Several people were dumbfounded.

"The significance of the debate is to make the truth clearer and clearer. You have to know that the audience can see a wonderful debate better than you. When you each present your own opinions and arguments, the audience's gains are sometimes It’s even more rewarding than the players.”

"You..." Xing Yingdan was slightly taken aback just as Xing Yingdan spoke.

Zhan Chao and Liang Ruimin were also contemplating, Xing Yingdan sighed, and said with some nerve-wracking: "I can't help it, I didn't expect the first match to be so difficult... Now the draft of the first debate has not come out, but we are questioning and asking questions." The link can be prepared in advance. The main reason is that the time given is too short. There is only half a day to prepare for tomorrow's game... Sigh, but don't be discouraged. Your on-the-spot skills are very good. It's time to watch the improvisation."

"According to the inertia of history, any battle that can be defined as a war level will definitely not be decided by a few people. It is the result of the struggle between two or multiple interest groups with different core interests."

"The struggle for hegemony between the two parties is, to be precise, a struggle between two interest groups."

Xing Yingdan shook her head: "Oh... our instructor is really..."

There are two libraries in Tunghai University. The second library they are in at this time is a new type of library built after entering the 21st century. From the outside, it looks like a red square building, which is jokingly called the Red Building by the students of Tunghai University.

Zhan Chao laughed loudly: "This is training us."

She just went back and put on a pair of small leather shoes.

Liang Ruimin said, "Where is our teacher Lai?"

Because it was a hotel booked by the competition organizing committee, it is naturally impossible to give everyone a single room, but Yi Yang is rich now, so of course he doesn't want to share a room with another person, so he told Zhan Chao that he snores at night , In order not to affect his rest, he decided to open another room at his own expense.

This is also his first visit to the university library.

And the more specific and detailed this purpose is, the more you will gain.

At this moment in a separate room, Yi Yang answered Zhao Qiang's call.

At the end, Zhan Chao even lost his mind, and whispered angrily: "Why, why let Liu Bang go! It's time to kill Liu Bang!"

But it was not without gains. Everyone spent an afternoon searching a lot of information, at least they had a deeper understanding of the history of that era.

"Oh, forget it."

Xing Yingdan turned around and asked Yi Yang, "Do you have any idea?"

Everyone took turns to search for information, and there was already a thick stack of books in front of them.

Several people looked at each other, and Xing Yingdan looked at Lai Subin: "Teacher Lai, what do you think?"

Yi Yang nodded.

When I came out of the library, the sky turned from sunny to cloudy, and the high clouds painted the sky grayish white. Fortunately, there was no sign of rain.

It's getting a little dark, but not completely dark yet.

this is university...

Zhao Qiang's hotel is more upscale than theirs, but it's not far from here.

Zhan Chao couldn't help but said: "What's the benefit of not killing Liu Bang? Not killing Liu Bang... History has not proved that Xiang Yu will be defeated by Liu Bang?"

Then they started the work of searching for information.

Yi Yang remained silent, his eyes fixed on the front.

This debate is different from the ones played in school before. To win, it must be based on the arguments provided by the history books. For pure science students like Xing Yingdan and Zhan Chao, it is still a headache to find historical materials One thing, but this made them a little excited.

"One of them is taking a bath, and the other is watching a drama."

After sighing with emotion, he still sighed slightly, turned his gaze back, and placed it on his desktop.

Yi Yang thought about it carefully, but still shook his head: "Well... I thought about a few directions to argue, but none of them are very ideal."

"Should I call Zhan Chao and Liang Ruimin?"

"Who?"

Yi Yang said calmly: "I'm going to go shopping nearby, don't you want to go out too? I'll call you."

Yi Yang scanned the library.

Yi Yang silently watched the small movements of the young couple not far away, feeling warm.

"The situation at that time was that in order to attack the boss Qin, there were many people who rebelled. It can be said that all heroes rose together, but Xiang Yu and Liu Bang were two relatively large forces."

The library has a total of four floors, with a huge interior space. The first three floors are paper study rooms, and the fourth floor is an electronic data room.

Xing Yingdan looked at Yi Yang: "Yi Yang, do you have any ideas? You are an argument."

"But actually... Well, as far as I know, the background of that era was not like this."

Because of this, Yi Yang also realized a truth, learning must be done with a purpose to be the most efficient.

A person with a clear direction and a clear purpose, in a free atmosphere, trying to do what he likes... a person who can be with him.

Yi Yang is also a little troubled. Although he can indeed find some "benefits" of letting go of Liu Bang's ambiguity in the historical materials, it is still a little weak to make an argument based on this.

Zhan Chao thought for a while and said, "But what if we find that the facts are different from our position in the process of searching for information?"

"The combination of the two makes it even more difficult to argue. Many debate topics already have a preset answer in the minds of the audience and judges. You may even disagree with some viewpoints, but this is debate. Learn to think about problems from the opposite side of the contradiction, which will broaden your way of thinking.”

"male."

But what he didn't expect was that Xing Yingdan had already stood in front of him again just after he muttered.

……

Lai Subin said meaningfully: "That depends on how you interpret and filter the information."

"Xiang Yu and Liu Bang each entangled with many forces, but they are not the absolute superior-subordinate relationship we imagined."

"Yi Yang? What's the matter?" Xing Yingdan opened the door.

Xing Yingdan was silent for a moment, then looked at Yi Yang.

Zhao Qiang was startled: "Uh... okay, male or female?"

Liang Ruimin also nodded.

Yi Yang recalled the historical journals he had read, and after a little rationalization, he said: "During the Chu-Han War, because of the influence of film and television dramas on the general public, the impression of this period is that Liu Bang brought a Help the younger brothers, Xiang Yu brings a group of younger brothers, and the two families compete for supremacy."

After hanging up the phone, Yi Yang changed into casual clothes, went out and knocked on Xing Yingdan's door.

"Yi Yang, you must get a defense draft today, no matter how late it is!"

Tunghai University library has a lot of seats, and there are also many free places. At a glance, many students are quietly absorbing the nutrients of books here. Although there are many people, they can only hear the flipping of books and the swipe of pens in the quiet. With the rustling sound of paper, Yi Yang thought, there might be a big boss who will dominate a certain field in the silent development.

"Eh? Nonsense."

For many universities, the library is one of the landmark buildings, and Tunghai University is no exception.

This topic is very, very unfriendly to the opposing side!
It is too difficult to prove that Xiang Yu letting go of Liu Bang is beneficial to him...

Yi Yang shrugged helplessly: "I'm just proposing an idea... that is, if the other party wants to prove that Xiang Yu can win the world by killing Liu Bang, we can think and refute in this way, but I don't know what the answer is. I know, if everyone has no opinions, we can follow this line of thinking to search for information... The library of Tunghai University should be able to find things that are beneficial to us, right?"

After a pause, he continued: "History cannot be clearly explained, and neither can debate."

Yi Yang sighed slightly, he was really afraid of hearing the word "wait a minute" from a girl.

Xing Yingdan looked the boy up and down, and muttered, does this person know me?It's really embarrassing, I forgot about him...it shouldn't be, such a tall person...

Yi Yang looked at the expressions of the other people and smiled slightly. He could probably feel that their thinking was similar to his own... How should I put it, it was a feeling that "this kind of debate is interesting".

Lai Subin also looked at Yi Yang with great interest, he couldn't help but want to laugh, Yi Yang was obviously only temporarily pulled here, but now he looks like the core of them.

"I."

The three of them looked at Yi Yang, and Liang Ruimin saw that Yi Yang had stopped talking, so he asked, "So there will be a Zhao Bang? You continue to talk!"

The four of them found a small corner in the library and sat down.

Suddenly thinking of Xing Yingdan's "exhortation", Yi Yang pondered slightly, and asked again: "Can I bring another person out?"

Xing Yingdan's eyes lit up immediately, and said, "Okay! Just wait for me."

"In addition, what you have to do is not to convince others. The essence of the debate is a battle of offense and defense. If you attack, even if some opinions are not so correct, but the opponent does not defend, then you are also successful in the debate."

A tall young man in front of him waved his hand.

Yi Yang pondered slightly: "Hmm... I can't say it's an idea, but I do have some ideas."

"Men..."

At this time, Xing Yingdan had already changed into a dress. No matter how she looked at it, Yi Yang felt that it was pajamas. Her calves were white, which added a bit of cuteness, which made Yi Yang feel a little dazed for a while... It was a bit like the Xing Yingdan in his impression. Not the same.

Lai Subin nodded approvingly: "How should I put it, you can think about it this way."

Yi Yang was a little surprised: "You plan to go out like this?"

Although Xing Yingdan's idol is Hu Jianbiao, of course he has seen Huang Zhizhong's games.

Just when she was about to respond, the young man suddenly trotted over.

She felt even more embarrassed, raised her hand, and was about to say hello...

The man walked up to Yi Yang and punched him in the chest.

Xing Yingdan was slightly taken aback, her hand was still hanging in the air, and she said in her heart... what the fuck.

(End of this chapter)