I can see the commodity price curve

Chapter 162 Court standoff, Zhang Yue's ultimate hole card
Time passed quickly, and two days later, the Zhongzhou Court responded to the mutual lawsuits between Haagen-Dash and October Food Factory.

Zhongzhou People's Court Announcement
本院定于2022年4月16日上午10:20分，就哈根达诗状告十月食品厂配方侵权，以及十月食品厂状告哈根达诗名誉侵权一案公开审理。

If there is an objection, both parties may raise an objection to the Zhongzhou Court 48 hours before the hearing.

Special announcement.

Zhongzhou People's Law

2022. 4, 11

Academy Seal.jpg!
As soon as this information came out, another wave of enthusiasm was set off.

Everyone knows that this lawsuit is not as simple as an ordinary civil lawsuit.

If the October Food Factory fails, not only will it have to pay Haagen-Dash a huge amount of compensation, but the production of Xingkong Ice Cream and Xingkong Ice Cream will also be discontinued.

It is no longer possible for me to go to the supermarket and spend 5 yuan to eat ice cream with the same taste as Haagen-Dash single ball in the future.

If Haagen-Dash fails, this well-known foreign company will also be greatly affected.

The stock has evaporated by several billions, and it may lose the throne of the king of cold drinks.

As for the attitude of the masses, although there are many well-known anchors, they openly stand on the side of Haagen Dash.

But in this Internet age where everyone has the right to speak, it's not just that you are famous, so you can say what you say.

More people directly supported Shiyue Food Factory, and some even made negative comments in the comment area of ​​these well-known anchors.

Some words were so fierce that they almost greeted all relatives and friends of these big anchors.

Seeing that the situation was not right, these big anchors immediately closed the comment area of ​​the relevant video.

As a result, the crowd became even more angry, and the comment area of ​​the relevant video was closed, and everyone ran to comment on other videos of these big anchors.

Soon, some people found that their comments were deleted again.

Not reconciled, they continued to post, and then continued to be deleted.

So in the next two days, the anchor and fans started a fierce struggle between bad reviews and deleted reviews.

Everyone originally thought that this matter would continue until the trial.

However, what happened next was beyond everyone's expectations.

On the morning of April 2022, 4, Haagen-Darsch posted an announcement on its official website.

According to the announcement, in addition to its own gourmet laboratory, Haagen-Dash has also specially invited official testing agencies from 17 countries, including China, to conduct component testing.

As a result, the results of the measurement all proved that the ingredients of Starry Sky Ice Cream and Haagen-Dash Ice Cream are exactly the same.

At the back of the announcement, pictures of the test reports of these 17 countries and a list of ingredients are attached.

The ingredient list details the ingredients and grams of sugar, protein, lipids, and inorganic salts in Starry Sky Ice Cream.

Haagen Dashi even directly @五月食品厂, asking the other party whether the ingredient list is true.

Everyone thought that October Food Factory would not reply, or even if they responded, they would directly deny it.

Unexpectedly, 23 minutes after the announcement was made, the Kuaisha official account of Shiyue Food Factory actually went directly to @Haagen达诗:

This is indeed the ingredient list of Starry Sky Ice Cream, please remove it immediately.

In addition, October Food Factory will add a clause in the complaint that you deliberately disclosed our core business secrets.

As soon as these words came out, all the audience fell silent.

Although Shiyue Food Factory's reply on this matter is still righteous, but this kind of righteousness seems to be completely cruel.

Because if this is really the recipe of October Food Factory, it means that October Food Factory is indeed plagiarizing the recipe.

As for the outcome of the trial, it has already been announced.

Those big anchors also opened the closed comment area one after another, but no one came over to post bad reviews anymore.

Even the negative comments in the comment area of ​​other videos disappeared.

Many people who knew the situation of October Food Factory called Zhang Yue one after another, wanting to ask what was going on.

But they found that Zhang Yue's phone had been turned off.

Not only Zhang Yue, but also Wu Dachuan, Zhan Susu, Tan Xuemei and other high-level officials could not be contacted.

For a moment, the entire October Food Factory fell silent.

If it weren't for the fact that a large amount of ice cream is still being sent to supermarkets every day in the factory, they would have thought that production had ceased.

Of course, ice cream and ice cream have indeed been distributed, but the enthusiasm of the masses to buy continues to decline.

Although it is not impossible to sell one piece, the phenomenon of selling it out as soon as it appears like before does not exist at all.

Even in October, there was a backlog of goods in the food factory.

Finally, on April 2022, 4, the day for the trial arrived.

At the gate of Shiyue Food Factory, all the high-level officials are gathered here, and the leader is Zhang Yue.

He turned his head and looked at the others strangely: "What are you doing? Everyone returned to their posts.

It's not a big deal, it seems to make you nervous. "

For this trial, Zhang Yue only brought Zhan Susu and Zhou Cangming, as well as the two hired lawyers, and did not bring anyone else.

It's just that whether it's Wu Dachuan or Wu Qingshan, their faces are full of worry.

Hearing what Zhang Yue said, Wu Qingshan suddenly gritted his teeth: "Mr. Zhang, don't worry, so what if we lose the lawsuit?
As the saying goes, a strong dragon does not overwhelm a local snake, no matter how rough that Pierre is, he has to be coiled by me.

After a while, I asked a few brothers to stand guard at the gate of the court, blocked the other party and threatened him with a meal, and then gave him all the tricks of the whole person.

Make sure this old boy is obedient.

Ouch, why did you hit me? "

Zhang Yue glared at him angrily: "You guard the warehouse for me honestly, thinking of crooked ways every day.

Believe it or not, I will give you the position of warehouse supervisor directly? "

"I..." Wu Qingshan wanted to say more, but Zhang Yue had already got into the car and disappeared from the intersection in a blink of an eye.

In the car, Zhan Susu suddenly handed over the mobile phone: "Look at this."

Zhang Yue was taken aback, because he found that Zhan Susu's mobile phone displayed the live broadcast room of Haagen Dachshund.

The camera in the live broadcast room was aimed at the entrance of the Zhongzhou People's Court.

There is also a reminder above: After communication between Haagen-Dash and the person in charge of the court, the entire trial will be broadcast live.

At this moment, the live broadcast room has already gathered tens of thousands of people.

Zhang Yue couldn't help but said: "This Peel seems to be determined not to give up until he kills Shiyue Food Factory!"

Zhan Susu looked at him helplessly: "I said, how sure are you?"

Since Zhang Yue admitted last time that the formula of Xingkong Ice Cream is exactly the same as that of Haagen-Dash single ball, Zhan Susu has asked him this question several times.

But every time Zhan Susu asked, Zhang Yue always talked about him.

So far, she still doesn't know what Zhang Yue thinks.

Zhang Yue smiled slightly: "You shouldn't ask me this question, but ask Cang Ming.

The recipe was researched by him, and this lawsuit is also led by him.

Although I accompanied the whole process, I was just a tool person.

Do you think a tool person is qualified to answer this question? "

Zhan Susu immediately looked at Zhou Cangming, and Zhou Cangming's face instantly turned bitter: "Sister Susu, how can I be sure?
Although we are innocent in this matter, we are restrained because of the patent protection clause.

I can only do my best. As for whether I can win, only God knows. "

Zhan Susu's heart sank instantly.

Zhou Cangming is technical, but now Zhang Yue asked him to appear in court as a party, which is actually somewhat embarrassing.

Of course, the two lawyers who followed were mainly involved in the defense.

But seeing the frowning expressions of the two lawyers, she knew the result without asking.

Soon, a group of people came to Zhongzhou People's Court.

At this time, the gate of the court was full of reporters from all walks of life. Obviously, these reporters also knew that today was a big news.

Seeing Zhang Yue getting off the car, these reporters were about to surround him, but they were blocked by a person.

It was Qin Fangjie.

Qin Fangjie sent Zhang Yue to the second floor, and his voice suddenly became softer: "Xiao Zhang, today's affairs are a bit difficult!"

Zhang Yue smiled slightly: "Thank you Brother Qin, you don't have to worry. As the saying goes, a strong dragon can't overwhelm a snake, and Haagen-Dashi can't beat me."

Qin Fangjie glanced at Zhang Yue blankly, and finally said: "I have specifically asked our dean.

Although Haagen-Dash is a foreign company and has certain policy inclinations, the matters between you can definitely be handled fairly and justly. "

Zhang Yue's expression was instantly solemn: "Thank you, Brother Qin."

Don't look at what Qin Fangjie said is calm and calm, but Zhang Yue, who is familiar with the world, knows that Qin Fangjie must have interceded for him a lot.

Qin Fangjie waved his hand indifferently: "Thank you, there is only so much I can do, I wish you luck!"

When Zhang Yue came to the trial hall, Pierre and Xu Rong had already arrived.

While Zhang Yue looked at Peel, Peel also looked over, with a sneer on his face.

Zhang Yue didn't care, he just found a seat in the auditorium and sat down, then pouted at Zhou Cangming.

Zhou Cangming understood, and stood in front of the defendant's seat with two lawyers.

As time went by, the auditorium gradually filled up with people, but because of the environment, the scene was very quiet.

Soon, the time came to 10:15, and judges and other office staff entered the venue one after another.

"Okay, it's time.

I announce that Haagen-Dash's lawsuit against October Food Factory for using its own commercial patented formula is now open for trial.

As for October Food Factory suing Haagen Dash for infringing its right of reputation, because the circumstances of the case are relevant, the results will be announced after the trial of the case is over.

I don't know whether the plaintiff and the defendant have objections? "

As soon as he finished speaking, Peel stood up: "Your Honor, I have objections."

After finishing speaking, he pointed at Zhou Cangming: "As far as I know, this Mr. Zhou is just the person in charge of the laboratory of Shiyue Food Factory.

And what Haagen-Dash is suing is October Food Factory, so I hope that Mr. Zhang Yue, the legal representative of the factory, will attend. "

As soon as these words came out, everyone looked at Pierre in a different way.

You should know that regarding the response to this lawsuit, since October Food Factory sent Zhou Cangming, it means that he must have made a lot of preparations in private.

Now Peel suddenly proposes a substitution, and directly hits the opponent by surprise.

To know the defense link of the plaintiff and the defendant is the most important part of the judge's sentencing.

If the preparation is insufficient, it is likely to affect the verdict.

The judge suddenly looked at Zhou Cangming: "Is what Mr. Peel said true?"

Zhou Cangming immediately stood up and said, "It is indeed true.

But there is a reason for this, because the formula of Starry Sky Ice Cream was researched by me.

I have more right to speak about this matter, so Mr. Zhang asked me to defend, hoping to express it more clearly. "

Peel immediately shook his head: "This is just a refusal, as the owner of October Food Factory, if you don't even know the formula of the food, wouldn't you be too incompetent?
And I can think that this is the other party's contempt for Haagen Dash. "

Zhou Cangming wanted to say more, but Zhang Yue suddenly stood up: "Mr. Peel, are you sure you want me to go up?"

Pierre was taken aback, apparently not expecting Zhang Yue to have such a reaction, not only was he a little taken aback: "What do you mean?"

"Nothing interesting, I just wanted to tell you that the reason why I sent Cang Ming up was not to despise anyone.

It's because I speak sharper, I'm afraid you won't be able to stand it for a while! "

As soon as this remark came out, the official live broadcast room of Haagen-Dacht immediately exploded:
"Fuck, did I hear you right?"

"Yeah, I still admire this foreigner for what Peel said just now.

At the same time, I also want to see how October Food Factory responds.

I speculated on several results. No matter what October Food Factory does, it will be at a disadvantage in terms of momentum.

did not expect……

No wonder Zhang Yue was able to establish such a large enterprise, and he really has two brushes. "

"It is indeed very good, but it is a pity that in the face of absolute facts, no matter how strong the ability is, it is useless."

Pierre's face also darkened: "Really? Then I would like to see how sharp Boss Zhang's words are."

Zhang Yue slowly stood up from his seat, and then came to Zhou Cangming's side.

Zhou Cangming said with a bitter face: "Boss, I..."

"It's okay, you go to the audience to watch, I wanted to exercise you, but unfortunately the other party didn't give me the chance!
Next time, next time I will let you appear in court. "

Even though the atmosphere was very tense, Zhou Cangming couldn't help being stunned.

How do you listen to the tone of the boss, did you want to come to court by crying and shouting?
I don't want to go up at all, okay!

Zhou Cangming, who had suffered from insomnia for three consecutive days, thought so.

Zhang Yue naturally didn't pay attention to Zhou Cangming's psychological activities, he sat on the dock, as if he didn't care about what happened today.

The judge said: "Okay, now let the plaintiff state what happened."

Peel stood up and began to tell.

Of course, everyone knows the content of the narration.

However, after the artistic processing of Peel's words, Haagen-Dashi instantly turned into a white-haired girl with only one word on her head:

injustice!
The judge looked at Zhang Yue again: "Defendant, do you have any objection to what the plaintiff said?

And I heard that October Food Factory has publicly admitted that the recipe released by the official account of Haagen-Dash Kuaishu is indeed the recipe for Starry Sky Ice Cream. "

Zhang Yue smiled slightly: "Of course there are objections.

That's right, the previous Haagen-Dash Kuaishu official account recipe is indeed the recipe for Starry Sky Ice Cream produced by October Food Factory.

But that doesn't mean we're copying.

Because this recipe was independently developed by the gourmet laboratory of Shiyue Food Factory, and the person in charge of the research and development is Zhou Cangming.

These documents in my hand are all the materials of Zhou Cangming's team from the beginning to the end of the research and development.

As long as you ask a professional to take a look, you can immediately tell the true from the false. "

As soon as he finished speaking, Pierre snorted immediately: "It's okay for you to deceive laymen with these materials, but it's impossible to deceive me.

I was also engaged in research and development before. Believe it or not, I can make ten copies of this kind of information in minutes, and you can't see any flaws in each copy? "

After finishing speaking, he raised his head, "Your Honor, Haagen-Dash's patent on ice cream has been published on our official website.

The other party can download it immediately as long as they move their hands. How can it be possible to spend money on research and development? "

Zhang Yue immediately became unhappy: "Your Honor, Mr. Peel is completely talking nonsense.

That's right, although Haagen-Dash's official website can indeed find their ice cream patents.

But that's just now.

I have a screenshot of the official website of Haagen-Dashboard a month ago, which was taken as information when Zhou Cangming's team was engaged in research and development and inquired about the official website of Haagen-Dashboard.

There is no ice cream recipe on it at all.

Therefore, the formula of Haagen-Dash was pasted by them in the last month.

As for the reason they did this, of course it was framed.

When I learned that the taste of Starry Sky Ice Cream is extremely similar to that of Haagen-Dash.

They immediately sent specialized business personnel to conduct research, and after cracking the formula of Starry Sky Ice Cream, they immediately pasted it on their official website, so as to beat it back. "

When Pierre heard what Zhang Yue said, his face immediately turned dark: "What?
You mean, the recipe we posted on the official website is copied from Starry Sky Ice Cream? "

"Is not it?"

"Of course not. We are Haagen-Dash, the world's number one cold drink brand. How could we deliberately copy you?"

Zhang Yue spread his hands: "I don't know about that, who knows how you work internally?
Maybe your world's number one cold drink brand is also copied. "

"you……"

"Ahem..." Seeing that the two were talking, a quarrel suddenly broke out, and the judge hurriedly said:
"Stop, everything in court must be based on evidence, and if there is no evidence, it will be regarded as slander.

Please also think twice before speaking. "

Zhang Yue hurriedly said: "I'm sorry, I was impulsive for a while, as for the evidence, I would like to ask Mr. Peel to explain.

Since you said that the recipe on your official website was not copied from me, why didn't your recipe be published a month ago? "

"It's very simple. The formula of Haagen-Dash ice cream is a commercial secret, so how could we just post it casually?"

"Really? Then why are you posting it now?"

"Because our formula has been leaked, instead of hiding it, it is better to announce it directly to defend the authority of Haagen-Dash."

Zhang Yue immediately said: "Your Honor, I think Mr. Peel's words are not true.

I mean what if, if October Foods really stole the recipe for Haagen-Dash ice cream.

As the person in charge of Haagen-Dash, the first thing I do is to sue October Food Factory instead of posting the recipe.

The reason is simple, even if the recipe is leaked, only me and October Food Factory know.

When I win the lawsuit and the ice cream production at the October Food Factory will be discontinued, this recipe, which involves commercial secrets, can still be kept secret, and there is no need to post it outside.

Unless the person in charge of Haagen-Dash is out of his mind. "

After finishing speaking, Zhang Yue looked at Peel: "Do you think there is a hole in your head?"

You..." Pierre's face darkened instantly, because he was indeed the one who suggested posting the formula.

The judge nodded: "Boss Zhang makes sense, Mr. Peel, you must give a reasonable explanation for this matter.

Otherwise, I can conclude that the recipe you Haagen-Dash posted is after deciphering the recipe of Starry Sky Ice Cream, and deliberately posting their recipe to pretend to be fake.

In this way, it can not only suppress competitors, but also ensure that its own formula is not leaked. "

After listening to the three people's words, the netizens in the Haagen-Dashi live broadcast room were also stunned:
"Damn, it seems to make sense!"

"Yes, if the recipe posted by Haagen-Dash is the deciphered starry sky ice cream, then October Food Factory may really be wronged."

"Did I really misunderstand the October Food Factory? They are innocent?"

"Let's see what Peel says next. If he doesn't have a good reason, this matter is really difficult."

Pierre's face darkened immediately after hearing what Zhang Yue and the judge said: "It is absolutely impossible for Haagen-Dash to post someone else's formula.

The reason why we publish the recipe is simple.

Because the formula of Haagen-Dash ice cream is not complicated, as long as you have the heart, you can decipher it.

The most difficult thing for Haagen-Dash to reproduce is the super centrifuge we use.

So after knowing that the formula was leaked, in order to prove our innocence, we took the lead in announcing the formula. "

Zhang Yue immediately said: "Really?
Doesn't this just prove that we independently developed the recipe for Starry Sky Ice Cream at October Food Factory? "

After finishing speaking, Zhang Yue said to the judge: "Your Honor, two months ago, I bought a super centrifuge from the 504 factory of China National Nuclear Corporation from Yajie Food Factory.

The person who handled the centrifuge at that time was Judge Qin Fangjie of your court.

After I photographed this centrifuge, I set up a research and development team to produce cream-related products.

So there are two products, Xingkong Ice Cream and Xingkong Ice Cream.

Therefore, Haagen-Darch said in the indictment that we were suspected of stealing their ice cream formula, which is completely a false accusation.

October Food Factory is innocent! "

In the last sentence, Zhang Yue was aiming at the official live broadcast room of Haagen Dal's poems, and the meaning is self-evident.

The judge nodded, then looked at Peel: "If this is the case, October Food Factory is innocent."

At this moment, Pier suddenly smiled coldly: "Zhang Yue, I think you seem to have made a mistake.

I am suing you today, the focus is not on the starry sky ice cream from October Food Factory, but whether it is your own research and development.

It is the formula used in your ice cream, which infringes the technical patent of Haagen-Dash. "

After finishing speaking, he took out a piece of paper and said, "This is a copy of the ice cream patent applied by Haagen-Dash.

It clearly states our ice cream recipe, which is exactly the same as yours.

That is to say, even if the formula of Starry Sky Ice Cream is developed by you independently, it still constitutes a patent infringement.

You don't even know this little common sense, do you? "

Haagen-Dash live broadcast room:
"Fuck, it's over, patent infringement is the point!"

"Zhang Yue seems to have fallen into the ditch. He only pays attention to the independent research and development of Starry Sky Ice Cream, but ignores the patent itself."

"I feel sorry for October Food Factory for ten seconds. If this is the case, they are too wronged."

"There's nothing you can do about injustice, this is patent protection!
Unless the technological blockade can be broken, there is nothing left to say. "

Just when everyone thought that Zhang Yue was about to fail completely, Boss Zhang was stunned.

The next moment, he took the paper in Pierre's hand, his face changed drastically: "Impossible, absolutely impossible!

The recipe of Haagen-Dash is absolutely different from that of Starry Sky Ice Cream.

Wait, isn't that right? "

As Zhang Yue was speaking, he suddenly took out a piece of paper from his pocket and said, "Your Honor, there is something I didn't say just now.

The gourmet laboratory of October Food Factory visited the official website of Haagen-Dash one month ago to determine whether our formula collided with theirs, which constituted patent infringement.

Because after the successful development of Xingkong Ice Cream, we also found that the tastes of the two are extremely similar.

It's just that no matter how we searched, we couldn't find their formula.

In order not to cause trouble, we bought some ice cream balls from the Haagen-Dash specialty store, and then analyzed their formula ratio.

We didn't rest assured to produce it until it was confirmed that there was indeed a discrepancy between the two! "

As soon as these words came out, everyone was stunned.

The judge immediately asked: "Is there a discrepancy? Where is the discrepancy?"

"It's very simple, our starry sky ice cream uses pure chocolate, while Haagen-Dash's ice cream single ball uses cocoa butter substitute.

Why did their patent suddenly turn into chocolate?

This is not scientific! "

"What?" Everyone was stunned.

(End of this chapter)