Lawyer

Chapter 511 The Strange Case 2
Seeing that there was no one around, Wang Deyou said in a low voice: "The person concerned is Gao Ying, a woman who lives in the outskirts of the city, and she has a younger brother.

Lawyer Qian Wen went to the court before. It is said that Gao Ying found a partner long ago, but the family said that the man was old and had a son who was in elementary school, so they strongly disagreed with her marrying the man.Gao Ying insisted on marrying so much that she was tired of life, and the two parties almost severed the relationship between father and daughter.

The man saw that the Gao family disagreed, and there was a lot of trouble, so he stopped contacting Gao Ying and changed his mobile phone number.Since then, Gao Ying has fallen ill and always feels that her family is trying to harm her.

In fact, usually you can't see that she has a problem, but don't stimulate her, as soon as she is stimulated, she will get sick.Last year, the suburbs of the city were demolished, and Gao Ying's family was also within the scope of the demolition. The family happily signed the demolition agreement. Her family wanted a three-bedroom house and a one-bedroom house, and there was hundreds of thousands of compensation.

Her parents meant that the three-bedroom apartment would be given to her younger brother. Her younger brother was not yet married, so he could marry a wife if he had a house, and the hundreds of thousands of compensation money would be reserved for her younger brother to marry a wife.One bedroom belongs to her.

The old man favors sons over daughters, which is also in line with local customs. After all, the married daughter, the water thrown out, will belong to someone else's family in the future, so it is not bad to give her a one-bedroom apartment.

There are many families in Gao Ying’s village, and the money and houses for demolition are only given to their sons, not to their daughters, and the family went to the court to sue. There are too many such things.

After Gao Ying's parents told their children about the property distribution, Gao Ying felt that it was unreasonable and had a fight with the family.Most people get angry for a few days at most, and it will be fine after a while. The worst is that there is a gap between family members, and they will move less in the future.

But Gao Ying is different. Her brain was stimulated by the affair before. This time, the family members stimulated her again. She felt that the family members were all towards her brother, and she was not in good health in the past few years. She felt that it was all The family made a mess, and the whole family wished for her to die early, and then they had the idea of ​​revenge on the family. When Wang Deyou said this, he took a sip of beer.

At this moment, the waiter brought up the dishes, and the two chatted while eating.

"What happened later? How did she get revenge?" Fang Yi asked.

"This woman is really cruel. I don't know where she got a small bottle of sulfuric acid. After returning home, taking advantage of the family's unpreparedness, she poured sulfuric acid on her parents and younger brother.

Later, according to the forensic appraisal by the public security organ, her parents and younger brother were both seriously injured.Among them, his parents' disability grade is three, and her younger brother's disability grade is nine.The public security organ determined that she constituted the crime of intentional injury and arrested her.

Later, the public security organ heard from her parents that she was usually mentally abnormal, so the Public Security Bureau entrusted the Municipal Mental Disease Appraisal Committee and the Provincial Mental Disease Appraisal Committee to conduct two judicial appraisals of mental illness on her. No capacity for responsibility at the time of committing the crime.

Later, the police released her. "Wang Deyou said.

"I shouldn't bear the legal responsibility for being irresponsible, why was he sentenced to death later?" Fang Yi asked puzzled.

"Her parents were able to forgive her, but her younger brother refused. Later, her younger brother raised an objection to the public security organ and asked the public security organ and the procuratorate to re-evaluate her sister Gao Ying for mental illness.

The Public Security Bureau also entrusted the Institute of Forensic Science and Technology of the Ministry of Justice to conduct a judicial appraisal of Gao Ying's mental illness.Gao Ying has full responsibility.In this way, the public security organs arrested Gao Ying again. "Wang Deyou said.

"The appraisal results before and after this are different, how did the court decide?" Fang Yi asked.

"At the time, lawyer Qian Wen went to the trial. It was said that lawyer Song had locked her up, so she just went through the motions. She defended Gao Ying's innocence based on the conclusion of the previous appraisal, but the court did not approve it.

The collegiate panel believed that the appraisal staff of the Institute of Judicial Appraisal Science of the Ministry of Justice had conducted on-the-spot investigation and understanding at the scene of the crime in addition to the materials submitted for inspection. identification conclusion.

The Intermediate People's Court held that the defendant, Gao Ying, deliberately injured others by throwing sulfuric acid, causing serious injuries to three people, and his behavior constituted the crime of intentional injury.Gao Ying's injury to immediate family members was not caused by the intensification of family disputes, but was entirely caused by her personal narrow-mindedness, and the methods were extremely cruel, with extremely serious consequences, and should be severely punished according to law.

In the end, the intermediate court ruled that Gao Ying was guilty of intentional injury, sentenced to death, and deprived of political rights for life.After the verdict was pronounced in the first instance, Gao Ying did not appeal, nor did the public prosecution organ protest.The Intermediate People's Court reports to the next level according to law to review the death penalty.

Then a dramatic scene happened. "Wang Deyou finished speaking. He picked up a piece of pot-packed meat and began to eat it.

"Old Wang, don't act like a storyteller, hurry up and say the following." Fang Yi picked up a beer and poured him a glass, urging him.

"Didn't I mean I'm hungry, eat a piece of meat first.

During the review of the death sentence, because the conclusions of the previous three psychiatric appraisals were contradictory, the Provincial Higher People's Court considered it necessary to conduct a new appraisal, so it organized medical experts to conduct the fourth mental illness appraisal on the defendant Gao Ying. The conclusion of the appraisal was: the defendant Gao Ying Ying suffers from schizophrenia and has no capacity for criminal responsibility.

After the high court got the appraisal conclusion, Gao Ying was released again. "Wang Deyou said.

"What happened next?" Fang Yi raised his wine glass and asked.

"Because the opinions of the previous four appraisal conclusions were too different, the Provincial High Court decided to entrust the Judicial Appraisal Center of the Supreme People's Court to organize psychiatrists to conduct the fifth review appraisal on Gao Ying out of prudent consideration. The fifth appraisal conclusion is : Gao Ying has the ability to limit criminal responsibility when committing a crime.

The Provincial High Court reviewed and found that the defendant Gao Ying constituted the crime of intentional injury, and the means were particularly cruel, causing serious injuries to three people, two of whom were seriously disabled. The consequences were particularly serious and should be severely punished according to law.

In view of the fact that Gao Ying could not fully identify and control his own behavior when he committed the crime, he can be given a lighter punishment.The sentence was changed to: death penalty with a two-year reprieve and deprivation of political rights for life.At this point, the case was considered over, and Gao Ying was sent to prison again.

I went to the High Court this afternoon to get the criminal verdict. "Wang Deyou said.

"This case is not complicated. The key is that the psychiatric examination is more complicated. Especially after a long period of time after the crime, the psychiatric examination is difficult to imagine. But it is related to human life, so we have to do it." Fang Yidao.

"Well, that's true. It took more than two years from the case to the last psychiatric appraisal. During the last appraisal, the forensic psychiatrists not only read the file, but also asked Gao Ying's family members, colleagues, correctional staff, and criminals detained in the same room. The suspect, the first-instance judge of this case, the public prosecutor of this case and other relevant personnel conducted a comprehensive investigation, and basically questioned everyone around Gao Ying.

In addition, we also conducted investigations and inquiries on the experts who participated in the appraisal of this case several times before. It can be seen that the experts have done a lot of work in the last appraisal. "Wang Deyou said.

"Well, this kind of case is really rare." Fang Yi raised his glass and said.

(End of this chapter)