Detective Files II

Chapter 135 Who is lying
"What do you think?" After Pilan left, Tian Yang asked Tian Mi: "This little girl lives in the same room as you, and you were the first to find out about it, so you should speak up first!"

Tian Mi shook her head and said, "It's not urgent. I was thinking about a problem when I was free during the day."

"what is the problem?"

"This morning, when you proposed to divide into two groups and ask questions separately, didn't you think that someone's reaction was very problematic?" Tian Mi asked Tian Yang.

Tian Yang understood: "You mean Xiao Yiran, right? His reaction is indeed a bit abnormal, and he questioned the procedure before he started to follow the procedure. Eight out of ten people like this have ghosts in their hearts, but they can't just do it like this. Conclusion, after all, we also learned about the relationship between Xiao Yiran and Li Weiming through the mouths of Hao Peng and Piran. If we say that Xiao Yiran is afraid that we will learn that he and Li Weiming have had conflicts, so preconceived and biased, so be on guard in advance There is nothing wrong with it. After all, both the real suspect and the suspicious person are afraid of the sight of the police, but the former is to get rid of the crime, while the latter is afraid of causing trouble."

"I still think there is something wrong with Xiao Yiran. When you announced Li Weiming's death today, he questioned the procedures for making transcripts so quickly. He seemed to be calm and thoughtful. Just imagine, a normal person suddenly heard that a friend or The classmate died unexpectedly. The first reaction should be shock, even unbelievable. After all, the sudden news, good or bad, takes some time to digest." Tian Mi insisted on her own opinion, and tried to persuade the other two people: "Do you want Don't you think Xiao Yiran's 'digestive ability' is a little too strong?"

"I agree with Tian Mi's statement." Lu Xiangdong did not argue with Tian Mi this time, but chose to agree: "At that time, six people were in front of us, and everyone was surprised to hear that Li Weiming had died. There were only two people at the scene. Personal exception."

"Xing Junting and Xiao Yiran?"

"Yes, it's the two of them. Xing Junting knew about it beforehand, so it's a completely normal reaction not to show surprise, and also because of the prior knowledge, since we called everyone together, he has been very depressed. This state continued until the questioning time."

Lu Xiangdong paused for a moment, then turned to talk about Xiao Yiran: "Xiao Yiran is different. When Tian Yang said that Li Weiming was dead, he showed a surprised expression like everyone else, but unfortunately, although during the conversation with him, he His attitude is quite calm, and his emotional control is not bad for this age group, but his acting skills have not yet reached the level of perfection, the surprised movements stay on his face for too long, and at the same time his eyes are too vivid, these details They have already betrayed him. I suspect that he knew about Li Weiming's death before Tian Yang announced the news of Li Weiming's death."

"Dr. Lu thinks that Xiao Yiran is suspected?"

"I won't make such an arbitrary conclusion." Lu Xiangdong raised his index finger and shook it left and right: "I just want to say that during the process of Tian Mi's testing of Xiao Yiran, Xiao Yiran's self-protection and demonstration told me that he was trying to cover up things. , I’m afraid it’s not the part that Hao Peng has already told us.”

"Ah?" Tian Mi was surprised when she heard the words: "You mean, the conflict between Xiao Yiran and Li Weiming is not just what Hao Peng said before? Hao Peng still has reservations?"

"Not necessarily, what I mean is that Hao Peng probably doesn't know about Xiao Yiran's secret."

This answer was far beyond Tian Mi's expectation, which made her feel unbelievable and curious, and hurriedly moved to Lu Xiangdong's side, asking the bottom line: "How did you deduce it?"

"Then let me ask you, if you beat me up with Tian Yang, and I died the next day, Cheng Feng investigated the case, separated you from Tian Yang in advance, and asked you to find out the situation, would you hide this paragraph? ?" Lu Xiangdong asked Tian Mi with an example.

Tian Mi couldn't help but glared at him: "You really have no taboos when you speak! If it was the situation you mentioned, I guess I would say it because..."

Speaking of this, she suddenly understood, with a suddenly enlightened expression, she slapped herself on the forehead: "Oh! I understand! If the conflict between Xiao Yiran and Li Weiming is what Hao Peng mentioned before, Xiao Yiran will not hide it So dead! Hao Peng is his good buddy, he will not fail to understand the other party's personality traits, if he has not discussed it in advance, he will be stubborn by himself, which will only increase suspicion! Frankly admitting the conflict with Li Weiming, on the contrary, he can be with Li Weiming The two of Hao Peng are witnesses to each other!"

After she finished speaking by herself, she frowned and thought for a while, and asked another question: "Then there is a contradiction here. If two people are suspected and discussed in advance, why did Hao Peng say so much so loudly?" Regarding the matter between Li Weiming, Miao Xiao, and Xiao Yiran? If the two of them hadn't discussed it beforehand, then Xiao Yiran could have told the part that Hao Peng could help testify, and concealed the so-called "Hao Peng didn't know about it" from Lu Xiangdong. Okay? Doesn't it look more real this way?"

"So what is your conclusion?"

"Is it possible that Xiao Yiran and Hao Peng did have a discussion beforehand, but Hao Peng didn't abide by the agreement?" Tian Mi boldly assumed: "What Pilan mentioned just now about Hao Peng and her scaring Li Weiming together, can he possibly I didn’t miss a word! I don’t think he is a big trumpet through and through!”

"What you said is not impossible. Even a fool will have a heart. Although Hao Peng is acting carefree, he may not really have a heart." Tian Yang supports Tian Mi's judgment: "But If you have any doubts, you need to investigate carefully! Moreover, in this way, what Piran said will be involved again."

"I think there are several possibilities for Pilan's incident," the topic circled around, and then returned to the matter of Pilan and Hao Peng's partnership to play tricks on Li Weiming. Tian Mi took the initiative to express her opinion this time. : "The first possibility is that what Piran said is the truth. Hao Peng did act alone, and as he himself said to Piran, there was no malice, it was purely a prank, to play tricks on Li Weiming, and Piran did it for Xiao A small revenge for Li Weiming's bad words and deeds in the past; the second possibility is that Piran did not lie, but Hao Peng did. Inexplicably, he became an accomplice; the third possibility is that Piran lied, and the two of them had already reached an agreement to murder Li Weiming."

"Oh, and about the recording of Miao Xiao's phone call, Piran deliberately saved the few sentences that Miao Xiao said that he wished Li Weiming would die separately. Is there another purpose, and is it true that no one else heard the recording? However, these two points still need to be proved." After Tian Mi analyzed the matter of pretending to be a ghost, she added a comment on the recording.

"Which of these three hypotheses do you prefer?" Lu Xiangdong asked.

"To be honest, the first one," Tian Mi said truthfully: "First of all, I subjectively think that although Piran has a weird personality due to her growth environment, she is not a vicious girl in her bones, and her statement also makes sense Secondly, my second assumption is doubtful, that is, Li Weiming was alive after being frightened that time, which is equivalent to scaring the snake out of the grass. After one success, it will only be more difficult for Hao Peng to attack Li Weiming afterwards. logic."

"The third assumption is even more suspicious, except for the same reason as the second point." Tian Yang finished the last point for her: "If Pilan and Hao Peng conspired together, why did she come to fight with him?" We confess this matter? How about describing ourselves as the innocent one? Once the accomplice is bitten out, it is impossible to completely clear it up. It is illogical for her to do so.”

"That's right, that's what I want to say!" Tian Mi snapped her fingers.

Tian Yang glared at her reproachfully: "If Mom sees this here, it will mean that your behavior is not elegant enough, not ladylike enough!"

Tian Mi stuck out her tongue, giggling.

Lu Xiangdong looked at the two of them thoughtfully, did not speak, his eyes were a little dazed, as if he had lost his mind suddenly.

"Dr. Lu, what's the matter?" Tian Yang noticed the change in his state, thinking that he was tired after a day: "If you are tired, go to bed early, we will not miss this night, anyway, what should be analyzed is almost the same , only the verification confirmation is left."

Lu Xiangdong shook his head slowly: "I'm not tired. I'm thinking about a few questions."

Neither Tian Mi nor Tian Yang spoke, they looked at Lu Xiangdong intently, waiting for his next words.

"The first question is, why is Li Weiming so afraid of the legendary female ghost? Is it just a superstition? Whether it's going to a haunted house, or secretly competing with Hao Peng at night, he never acts alone. Do you firmly believe that everyone else is safe and sound, but you are the only one haunted by a female ghost? Is it because of an unfounded girl temple? Or someone gave him such a psychological hint, or some other reason? For example, life experience. "

The question Lu Xiangdong raised was exactly what Tian Mi had been faintly surfacing in the past few days. She had been wondering why the three girls, including a superstitious person like Pi Lan, were not frightened like that. The young man was scared out of his wits?

"Second question, I heard that Li Weiming is a person with good family conditions and spoiled by his parents." Lu Xiangdong then said: "Envy or jealousy will swell to a certain extent, and resentment will arise. This point cannot be ignored. .”

"You mean...Piran?" Tian Mi asked uncertainly.

Lu Xiangdong nodded, then shook his head again: "Think for yourself."

(End of this chapter)