I was watched by the Internet police during the live broadcast of law popularization?

Chapter 252 The verdict of not guilty, the issue of accountability in the case...

This is a very serious problem!
Because it involves procedural violations, the confession obtained is naturally invalid.

And often when faced with such a problem, these people will choose to make mistakes...

You said you encountered unfairness during the interrogation, what about the evidence? ?

Faced with the other party's repeated questions, Wang Hua, who couldn't answer, could only look at Li Chen for help.

He has no proof...

"Judge, I want to interrupt the other party..."

Li Chen directly interrupted the other party's speech and said, "Actually, it is very simple to verify the authenticity. As long as Prosecutor Wang shows the video at that time, he can prove whether Wang Hua is lying."

"According to the relevant regulations, when the Wuxie Association is taking statements, they should also turn on their law enforcement equipment. Regarding this point, I have not seen it when reviewing the papers."

"If it is said that the members of the Wushu Association are enforcing the law impartially, then why didn't they submit the video of the law enforcement at that time."

"Why is there no such important thing? Isn't this enough to explain the problem?"

"Without the video equipment of the Wushu Association, can we think that the source of their confession was obtained in violation of regulations?"

I suspect that you have a problem with law enforcement, so you should produce relevant evidence to prove that you have no problem, otherwise there is a problem.

"Prosecutor, why don't you hand over the video of law enforcement from the Wushu Association together?"

Judge Zhu looked at the prosecutor when he heard this.

As a law enforcement officer, he also knows about this issue.

Some people try their best to solve the case...

"There must be a video, and I will send it to the next court session."

Faced with the judge's questioning, Prosecutor Wang could only find a reason to fool him.

Judge Zhu couldn't help frowning when he heard the words: "Why do you want to do it next time?"

Prosecutor Wang was speechless.

Brother, where are you on?Did you bring the wrong script with you when you went out today? ?
After being a prosecutor for so many years, it was the first time he encountered such an uncooperative trial judge...

"I announce that the case is now temporarily adjourned for half an hour."

After speaking, the three judges walked out of the trial court together. There are many things they need to continue discussing...

Now that the case has developed like this, whether it is still necessary to continue the trial is the biggest question.

The three judges came to the lounge and began to discuss such issues.

Is the confession procedure legal?

The three of them knew what to do now?
All three have different ideas.

The judge of the collegial panel believed that this kind of thing was repeatedly prohibited, and since it was discovered, the interrogation should be stopped and the relevant specialized department should be ordered to re-investigate.

Judge Zhang believed that all of this was caused by the other party's deliberate delay, and that the case should continue to be heard and the original judgment should be upheld.

Judge Zhu believes that the case should be re-investigated, and by the way, check whether there is any illegal operation.

Half an hour later, the three re-entered the trial court, and Judge Zhu announced the conclusion of the collegial panel: "Due to the complexity of the case, the collegial panel made the following decisions after discussion:
First: For the real situation of the case, our court will re-designate the Wushu Association to start the investigation.

Second: Regarding whether there are any violations by the Wushu Association, it will be handed over to the relevant departments for serious investigation. "

"Adjourn now!"

After finishing speaking, Judge Zhu tapped the hammer, and the case was officially adjourned.

Seeing the three of them walk out of the courtroom, Li Chen also started to organize his things.

This case has serious problems from the beginning, and of course it cannot continue to be tried.

The most ridiculous thing was the inquiry of Prosecutor Wang:
You know that is not the same as the truth, why do you have to sign your name on the statement, have you read every statement above?
what a joke...

How can a normal person have the heart to resist when faced with such a problem?

If the law enforcement officers want to talk heart-to-heart, few can resist...

Luo Dazhuang once said such a sentence:

Extorting confessions by torture is not only because it can lead to unjust, false and wrongly decided cases, but also because it is procedurally unjust.

If we ignore the rules and only pursue substantive justice, justice may be achieved in a certain case, but this opens a Pandora's box, and every innocent citizen may become the target of punishment.

If you want to add guilt, there is no excuse!

The tragedy of killing thousands of people by mistake and not letting one go will continue to repeat itself.

In one of his lectures he quoted a famous person:
Means represent justice in the making and ideals in action.

Man cannot achieve a just goal through unjust means, because the means are the seed and the end is the tree.

Extorting confessions by torture is undoubtedly a poisonous seed from which no tree of justice can grow.

In order to prevent extortion of confessions by torture, Longguo also specifically amended relevant laws to directly exclude confessions and testimonies obtained through illegal means.

The reason why Mr. Luo was angry was that some people did something and were not held accountable after being discovered.

And it is precisely because there is no accountability that various violations have arisen.

The main reason for this is the unreasonable cognition of law enforcement units.

They believe that although the methods used by the investigators are simple and crude, their motives are good.

The object of their work is criminals.

And criminals are often cunning...

To put it bluntly:

If you don't commit a crime, it's impossible for the tricks to be used against you.

A crime pollutes the water, an unjust judicial decision pollutes the water...

It is conceivable what is light and heavy...

A week after Li Chen returned to Shanghai, he also received a call from the trial court.

On February 27th, Li Chen came to the trial court to participate in the trial.

The District Attorney's Office has changed...

And the direction of the defense in this court trial is no longer Wang Hua's intentional murder...

In the trial court, Wang Hua explained the details of the whole incident, including why he killed himself with a knife.

And Li Chen also expounded his defense opinions according to his own statement of defense.

"The sentencing begins now!"

Judge Zhu stood up and read Wang Hua's latest verdict:

"Wang Hua's intentional homicide case was investigated by the Martial Arts Association..."

"After a public hearing by this court, the collegiate panel concluded after a comprehensive discussion that because Wang Hua had been bullied by others for a long time, the situation of holding the knife was for self-protection, and it did not have the purpose of intentional injury, nor did it cause practical consequences.

At the time of the case, Wang Hua also used defensive means, and was forced to fight back when he was threatened by others. Although the means were extreme, it was also to stop the infringement of others. Because the judgment was justified self-defense, the defendant Wang Hua is now in court. freed! "

Hearing the verdict, Wang Hua's parents stood up excitedly.

They really didn't expect that the case would be overturned, and Wang Hua didn't expect that he would be innocent.

Li Chen silently packed his things and prepared to return to the magic capital.

In such a case, it is reasonable to change the verdict of not guilty, but what he cares about is another group of people.

Since Wang Hua is innocent, the other group of people should be held accountable, this is in line with the true sense of fairness...

　There are many plots that cannot be described, including the behavior of the bully, which has not been written.

　　Hmm... He must have done something to make Wang Hua a legitimate defense.

　　
　
(End of this chapter)