Conan's Victory is Justice

Chapter 146 Irrational procedures are the key

"This one……"

Facing Gu Meimen's question, Professor Matsushita hesitated, and then answered.

"As long as I have free time every night, I will study for a period of time."

Gu Meimen smiled and looked into Professor Matsushita's eyes.

"No, no, what I need is a more accurate time range."

"Well, apart from daily travel, it's about twenty hours a week..."

"Really? I'm afraid it's not like that?"

Professor Matsushita paused, fell silent and did not speak.

Seeing this, Gu Meimen smiled lightly, and then took out a document from the table.

This is a printout of the user's homepage of a certain fiction website.

"According to my investigation, you seem to be obsessed with novels on a novel website called Aozora Bunko in Japan recently."

Gumei posted two documents on the whiteboard.

"According to your display on the homepage of this novel website, you have spent more than [-] hours of reading time and spent more than [-] yen on a novel called "The Adventures of the Shield Black Cat" this week. reward."

Gu Meimen smiled and looked at Professor Matsushita who had changed his face at this time.

"Excuse me, where do you spend your twenty hours a week?"

"This, this..."

Sweat dripped from Professor Matsushita's forehead, and he couldn't answer for a while.

Gu Meimen took out a few more documents.

These are printouts of the homepages of certain blog users.

"More than that, several students in the same laboratory as you have complained on blogs, claiming that you, as a teacher, have recently delegated a lot of work to them, but the fruits of labor have been credited to your name. Excuse me, Is there such a thing?"

For a moment, all the people present at the scene looked at Professor Matsushita in the field.

Professor Matsushita gritted his teeth with a glow on his back.

"Mr. Lawyer, what you have done is a complete violation of my right to privacy! This kind of evidence should not be established!"

"No, no, you made a mistake."

Gu Meimen raised a finger and shook it slightly in front of him.

"Mr., although you seem to have a lot of knowledge in physics and chemistry, but in terms of legal knowledge, it is like a blind man feeling an elephant. He thinks what he touches!"

Gu Meimen turned her head to look at the court, and said with a smile.

"May I ask the court, is my way of collecting evidence legal?"

The judge nodded without hesitation: "The method of obtaining evidence by the defendant's agent is legal and compliant, and there is no such thing as an infringement of the right to privacy!"

Gu Meimen's evidence collection location is on a well-known novel website, which is a public place on the Internet.

As long as it's done in public, it's not illegal.

Provided there is no violation.

"Then it's pretty obvious."

Gu Meimen paced slowly in the courtroom.

"A lot of evidence shows that the research results on the arsenic compound were not developed by Professor Matsushita, and cannot guarantee the research results. Therefore, he cannot be a witness in this case, and the plaintiff's evidence should be invalid!"

The judge was still hesitating just now, how to make a judgment on this evidence.

As soon as Gu Meimen's debate came out, his problem was solved immediately.

"The defendant's attorney's point of view is valid, but the plaintiff's evidence is invalid!"

Immediately the judge struck down the hammer.

Feiyingli frowned.

Before the trial started, she used her past legal reputation to invite the famous Professor Matsushita.

But she never expected that this professor would be so unreliable, he would hand over all the work to his students, but she would seize the fruits of their labor.

I didn't expect that Gu Meimen would conduct such a detailed investigation, even revealing other people's private whereabouts on the Internet.

"This is obviously something that is generally recognized by the academic community!"

Before being taken down, Professor Matsushita was still arguing vigorously.

"Haven't you guys studied chemistry? Trivalent arsenic is poisonous! What if it wasn't my own research! This kind of evidence can be invalidated. What kind of court is this? You guys are so ridiculous!"

From the incomprehension of the liberal arts by the masters of science.jpg
Xiao Ai shook her head in the auditorium.

The old man didn't understand a fact.

In court, whether trivalent arsenic is toxic or not is not the key.

Whether the procedure of evidence is reasonable or not is the main thing.

His evidence did not come from himself, but was done by his students, so he cannot be a witness, and the evidence will be invalid if the procedure is not reasonable, it is as simple as that.

"Does the plaintiff have any other evidence?" The judge looked towards Fei Yingli.

Fei Yingli frowned, and then stood up again.

"In court, I apply to call new witnesses."

Gu Meimen raised her eyebrows.

There are also witnesses. It seems that the other party has prepared a lot.

The judge nodded: "Agreed to the application."

Soon, a thin figure was brought up.

After seeing the whole picture of the witness, Xiao Ai in the auditorium frowned.

This witness was familiar, they had only met before.

It was the defendant in the last lawsuit, the piano sonata case, who had served as their client Asoshi.

After being brought up, Asoshi had a complicated expression on his face, and glanced in the direction of lawyer Gu Meimen.

She didn't expect that in the last lawsuit not long ago, they were still allies.

But in this lawsuit, he became an enemy.

Looking at the former client, Gu Meimen's face remained unchanged.

This is the case in court, there is no permanent firm position, let alone two lawsuits, even if it is the same lawsuit, there will be situations where they will turn against each other.

Under Fei Yingli's gaze, Aso took out report documents one by one.

"These are the report documents of the residents of Moon Shadow Island who had physical examinations at this doctor's clinic in the past."

Feiyingli showed the reports one by one for everyone to watch.

"We can see that in the past three years, the physical condition of the residents has been getting worse year by year, with inexplicable weakness, dizziness and nausea. These all appeared after the construction of the factory. It is about 25% higher, and we have every reason to suspect that it is the result of factory pollution.”

"It can only be suspicion, right? Lawyer Concubine."

Gu Meimen answered immediately.

"In fact, from the beginning to the end, you have no clear evidence to judge that the health problems of the villagers are the result of this substance."

"Why can't you doubt it?" Fei Yingli stared at Gu Meimen's face, "If I remember correctly, Gu Meimen's lawyer used the same evidence as me in the piano sonata lawsuit to argue that Moon Shadow Pollution may exist on the island. I’m just repeating what you said at the time.”

"Yes, I have used the evidence you mentioned before."

The ancient beauty does not change its color.

"However, does this conflict with the argument I just mentioned? You can only doubt, not be sure."

Paused.

"Besides, these are two lawsuits, right? Even if I used this evidence in another lawsuit, what does it mean?"

(End of this chapter)