If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 163 Contamination of inspection materials!
"I would like to ask, is our technology so advanced now that we can do DNA identification on photos?"

Ren Zhen's question made Tan Junchang freeze.

what?
DNA?

I don't make it!

"Presiding Judge, I have no other opinion regarding this set of evidence."

Ignoring the silent Tan Junchang and Tan Junchang, Ren Zhen didn't say anything more and sat down directly.

There is no need to ask any more questions.

I'm afraid this is the first time the presiding judge has heard of DNA testing of photos in the past few decades, so he doesn't need to be more specific.

This set of evidence is invalid!

Ren Zhen believed that Luo Xinyan had definitely made a judgment in her heart at this time.

"Does the prosecutor still have evidence to prove?"

Luo Xinyan's eyes were a little strange at this time, which made Lu Yunwen very uncomfortable.

"President, due to the mistakes of the law enforcement agencies, there are flaws in the evidence in this case. I apply to re-evaluate the parrot involved in the case before re-opening the trial."

Seeing that the situation was not good, Lu Yunwen did not give in, but directly applied for an extension of the trial.

Moreover, the reason was directly named as the law enforcement agencies, without any consideration that Tan Junchang and Peng Junyang were still present.

There is nothing I can do. If I still save face for you at this time, the suspect will be acquitted!
"This"

It is relatively rare for the court to request a postponement of the trial.

But it's not impossible if the regulations are met.

Luo Xinyan quietly discussed it with the colleague next to her, obviously discussing the possibility of this application.

"President, we disagree!"

Seeing that they were about to finish their discussion, Ren Zhen suddenly stood up.

"Why do you disagree?"

Ren Zhen spoke without permission, which made Luo Xinyan a little unhappy.

Although you are in charge now, the prosecutor's application is legal and reasonable.

The need for re-identification fully complies with the relevant provisions of deferred trial in the Criminal Procedure Law.

As a lawyer, why should you disagree?

"If the parrot involved in the case was indeed bought by Cao Kunshan from Guo Tiansong, then we certainly have no reason to disagree."

Seeing that Luo Xinyan's tone was wrong, Ren Zhen explained clearly: "But what if the parrots in the animal rescue station are no longer sure to be those sold by Guo Tiansong?"

Luo Xinyan frowned and heard what Ren Zhen meant: "Are you afraid that something will go wrong during the appraisal process?"

What she actually wanted to say was, are you afraid that the law enforcement agencies will do anything to the parrots? How many of them will be given to you?
There is no need to worry about this. If there is no grievance or enmity, no one will go to such great lengths to frame you, Guo Tiansong.

"No."

Ren Zhen shook his head, knowing that Luo Xinyan was wrong: "There is something wrong with the parrots used as evidence in this case."

"Be careful what you say. You have to be responsible when you talk nonsense!"

Tan Junchang couldn't help it. His thoughts were similar to Luo Xinyan's. Ren Zhen's words almost pointed at their noses and said that there was something wrong with their law enforcement bureau.

"There are two types of parrots involved in this case. If Guo Tiansong himself did not admit his mistake and took the wrong one, there are eight sunflower parrots and ten blue-faced badan parrots, a total of eighteen. I would like to ask, what are you doing in seizing and sending them? Were the two parrots transported separately on the way back and forth from the identification?"

Ren Zhen ignored his anger and asked a question.Luo Xinyan, who originally wanted to stop Tan Junchang, swallowed her words when she heard Ren Zhen's question.

If Ren Zhen's concerns could be dispelled, the trial could continue, and she did not interrupt the two of them.

"No, there are just a dozen birds, there is no need to pack them separately."

Tan Junchang stared, as if to say that Ren really knows how to hammer.

"Then I would like to ask, how can you be sure that the parrots sent to the zoo and the parrots you picked up and returned to the animal rescue center are exactly the same eighteen parrots?"

Tan Junchang subconsciously wanted to say that of course I know, but then he remembered that he was in court now, so he had to be careful when speaking.

So he thought for a few seconds and realized, eh, it seems that I really can't be sure?

Luo Xinyan realized something was wrong.

"We have body cameras!"

Tan Junchang suddenly said something, as if he had grasped a life-saving straw.

Yes, we still have a recorder!
This is really good stuff!
"There is video from the law enforcement recorder. Is this certain?"

Tan Junchang is a little proud. When the time comes, bring the recorder over and take a look at it yourself.

I don’t believe it. With only a dozen birds, how could the zoo bring me the wrong ones?
"Presiding judge, I would like to ask the prosecutor and these two law enforcement officers, which of these photos are sunflower parrots and which are blue-faced parrots? In other words, do you know the difference between sunflower parrots and blue-faced parrots? ?”

Ren Zhen picked up two stacks of photos in each hand, both of which were evidence submitted by Lu Yunwen: "If the prosecutor and law enforcement officers can't even answer these two questions, how can they be sure that the parrots at the animal rescue station now are the same ones that were in Cao Kunshan before?" Where are the parrots impounded there?”

Luo Xinyan finally understood that Ren Zhen was not afraid of someone tampering with the appraisal process, but that he was not sure whether the parrot used for appraisal was the parrot bought and sold by Guo Tiansong and Cao Kunshan.

"Prosecutor, can you respond to the defender's question?"

Now Ren Zhen's doubts are obviously justified, and they directly affect Lu Yunwen's application for postponement of the trial. Naturally, Luo Xinyan will not ignore it.

The purpose of adjourning the trial is to re-appraise it. Now you are not even sure what is being appraised, so why should you be asked to re-appraise it?
"I really can't tell the two parrots apart."

Lu Yunwen looked at the photo for a long time. One moment he felt that the two parrots seemed exactly the same, and the next moment he felt that they seemed to be very different.

I had been studying parrots for several days before, and I thought I was getting started. Who knows, I still can’t tell the difference now.

In the end, Lu Yunwen shook his head and admitted that he couldn't tell the difference between the two parrots.

"Since the prosecutor can't tell the difference, is it necessary to re-identify?"

Ren Zhen smiled and ignored Tan Junchang. He didn't expect this big boss to give any reliable answers:

"Before the trial, Guo Tiansong and I visited the parrots at the animal rescue station. According to Guo Tiansong's judgment, among the eighteen parrots, only five are sunflower parrots and seven are blue-faced parrots.

The other six parrots were from four other species. In other words, there were six different species of parrots in one cage. The test materials had been contaminated. The defender believed that there was no need for re-identification at all! "

The test material is contaminated!
If this situation is true, then there is really no need to re-identify.

"But Guo Tiansong also said before that he might admit his mistake."

Lu Yunwen retorted.

"Yes, he will also admit his mistake."

Ren Zhen did not deny: “However, during the process of seizure and three transportations, the law enforcement agencies did not transport the parrots involved in the case separately, nor did they mark each parrot in the same way.

Even if there is video from a law enforcement recorder, it can only guarantee the situation during transportation. The recorder can't capture the situation in the zoo, right?

Is it really necessary to compare the videos before and after transportation to determine the species of each parrot?

DNA identification cannot be done with photos, so can it be done with videos? "

(End of this chapter)