If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 74 Excessive Interpretation
Seeing Liu Lin looking over, several people in the auditorium discussed it and one person stood up.

"I am Xincheng District Public Prosecutor Zhang Tian. I was in charge of this case back then. I raised the issue of Shi Hao's criminal intent and it was later recognized by the court of first instance. Let me explain it."

Liu Lin nodded and signaled to Zhang Tian that he could start.

Although this view was recognized by the Xincheng District Court, it was originally the prosecutor's charging opinion at the beginning. From Zhang Tian's perspective, it was considered more appropriate.

"Actually, we don't simply believe that Shi Hao has the intention to continue claiming compensation just because he accepted interviews with the media."

Zhang Tian faced Zhai Ming and explained patiently:

“We came to this conclusion based on a comprehensive analysis of Shi Hao’s various behaviors before and after the incident, as well as several communications with Youen Company.

First of all, Shi Hao and Youen Company signed a compensation agreement on June 20, 6XX, stipulating that Youen Company would pay him 13 yuan, and Shi Hao promised not to hold Youen Company responsible again.

Then on June 6, just two days apart, Shi Hao went to the supermarket to buy milk from Youen Company and kept the receipt.

Let me ask, what is the purpose of Shi Hao buying milk when he knows that there is something wrong with the milk from Youen Company?I think combined with his move to retain the small ticket, we can put a question mark here for the time being. "

Shi Hao almost slammed the table: "What happened to me buying milk? I bought milk for..."

Ren Zhen grabbed Shi Hao and pulled him back to the stool.

The three judges on the trial bench glared at Shi Hao at the same time, and Zhang Tian also turned to look over.

"You don't want to tell me that you bought milk just to drink it, do you?"

Zhang Tian's tone was calm, but his words were somewhat sarcastic.

Chang Jiahang stuffed a piece of chocolate into Shi Hao's mouth and blocked his mouth.

"Brother Hao, calm down, don't talk, just listen."

Being pulled by these two little brothers, Shi Hao also knew that he had lost his composure. He chewed hard twice, drank two more mouthfuls of water, and turned his head to the side.

"The defendant paid attention to controlling his emotions."

Liu Lin's tone was quite stern, and he looked at Zhang Tian again, asking him to continue.

Ren Zhen wrote something on the paper, and then glanced at the angry Shi Hao next to him.

Regarding what Zhang Tian mentioned, Ren Zhen naturally also learned about it from Shi Hao.

According to Shi Hao, he bought a bottle of milk with the latest date to see if Youen Company had made any improvements after being exposed.

The conclusion is not.

This was also one of the reasons why Shi Hao later accepted an interview with the TV station.

Although the words of the person involved cannot be fully believed, after spending so many days together, Ren Zhen gained a better understanding of Shi Hao's personality.

Combined with the circumstances of the case, he knew that [-]% of what Shi Hao said was true.

For Shi Hao, a young, promising and high-spirited man at the time, who was not short of money and had just successfully defended his rights, it was completely understandable that he was dissatisfied with Youen Company's behavior.

According to Shi Hao's thinking, although I accepted your compensation, I just won't hold you accountable anymore.

But your product still has problems, so if I tell the truth in the interview and let more people know about this company's behavior, is there any problem?

Isn't this what a passionate young man should do?
Do you understand what social responsibility is?
Shi Hao's thoughts were so simple.To use an older description, Shi Hao is a typical angry youth.

But it was such an inconspicuous act that became the reason for the public prosecution to attack him.

"On June 6, Shi Hao's interview was broadcast on the TV station. After the program was broadcast, Youen Company suffered great pressure from public opinion.

It was under such pressure that Shi Hao took the opportunity to file a claim of 200 million from Youen Company.

Counting from the signing of the compensation agreement, Shi Hao bought milk from Youen Company two days later, and then accepted an interview with a TV station. This series of actions is enough to prove that Shi Hao has already intended to make another claim against Youen Company. Of. "

Zhang Tian sat back in the gallery: "This was our analysis at the time. Although I am not the prosecutor today, if the judge asks me for my opinion, I think my opinion will be the same as five years ago."

"Public prosecutor, after listening to the explanation of the original prosecutor, is there anything else you need to add to this issue?"

Although this was the first time he heard this explanation, Liu Lin did not turn around to discuss it with others this time.

Facing Liu Lin's question, Di Ming was silent for a while.

Zhang Tian actually didn't say anything too new. What he said was basically reflected in the materials.

The only thing that can be heard is that when they filed the prosecution, they focused on Shi Hao's behavior of buying milk on June 6 of that year and keeping the receipt.

Looking at this behavior purely from the evidence, it doesn't seem to be too direct.

But after listening to Zhang Tian's detailed explanation, it doesn't seem that simple?
This is the difference between understanding on paper and communicating in person.

Reading the same thing through words may not fully understand the inner thoughts of the writer.

But if you say this face to face, it is easy to see where he focuses on a certain aspect.

Di Ming, who originally thought there was something wrong with this logic, is now a little unsure.

Can this series of behaviors of Shi Hao prove that he has the intention to continue to claim compensation?
"temporarily unavailable."

Without giving a clear preference, Di Ming felt that he had to think about it again, so he signaled that he had nothing to say.

"What about the defender, your side?"

Before Liu Lin could greet him, Ren Zhen had already stood up: "Although the prosecutor of Xincheng District gave an explanation, I still think it cannot be concluded that Shi Hao has the intention to continue to claim compensation."

“First of all, although Shi Hao accepted media interviews, this was a reasonable control he could make over his own behavior as a citizen.

Under the premise that there is a problem with the milk of Youen Company, Shi Hao, as a father, is a victim of the milk of Youen Company. With such an identity, regardless of whether there is compensation from Youen Company first, Shi Hao was interviewed by the TV station, It's all a very normal thing. "

Seeing that Ren Zhen's discussion seemed to be a little over the top, Zhang Tian subconsciously wanted to refute it.

Before he could speak, he suddenly realized that he was not here as a prosecutor today, and he could not speak at will before getting the consent of the presiding judge.

Thinking of this, no matter how many thoughts he had in his mind, Zhang Tian could only hold it back angrily.

"As mentioned just now, the milk and receipts purchased by Shi Hao on June 6 were only for TV shooting needs and did not involve other purposes."

Although he did not tell everything, it was not a lie. Ren Zhen glanced at the auditorium meaningfully:

"So in the program broadcast by the TV station, Shi Hao only appeared as an interviewee, and his interview behavior should not be over-interpreted!"

(End of this chapter)