Uncle, please restrain

Chapter 216
Su Zuo asked such a question, and then immediately said: "Is it possible that he conspired against the deceased on a temporary basis and forced the deceased to death? Is it possible that it was because of what he said at that time that made the deceased Did the deceased suddenly have the idea of ​​suicide?"

Qin Wen said coldly: "Lawyer Su, what you said is just a hypothesis."

Su Zuo smiled: "Isn't what Lawyer Qin said also a hypothesis?"

Qin Wen sneered: "At least I proved that there were problems in the report issued by the police at that time, at least it proved that there were no other people around the deceased before he died. Based on this alone, the police report on the suicide certificate was flawed. "

Su Zuo laughed: "Lawyer Qin means that the deceased did not commit suicide, but homicide? Then what does this have to do with my client? Even if the deceased was murdered by others, how could it be determined that my client killed me?" What about it? Lawyer Qin, your reason is too far-fetched, right? Moreover, the reasons given by the plaintiff are all untenable, can I think you are making a false accusation?"

Qin Wen didn't answer Su Zuo's question, and said directly to the judge: "Your Excellency, I would like to invite No.3 witness, a police officer who handled the case at that time."

The judge asked Su Zuo's opinion again, and Su Zuo did not object, so the judge sent the witness to come in for questioning.

As before, Qin Wen first asked: "Officer Huang, may I ask you 13 years ago, you handled a suicide case by jumping off a building, and the deceased was named Lu Ning, do you still have any memory?"

"Of course I have an impression." Police Officer Huang answered Qin Wen's question very calmly: "Because the two suspects involved in the case were of unusual identities and their relationship with the deceased was somewhat complicated, we investigated for a long period of time and visited Many witnesses were gathered, and a lot of evidence was collected, and the case was decided after a lapse of one month."

Qin Wen picked up the documents in his hand and asked Officer Huang: "At that time, Officer Huang should be the main person in charge of this case, right?"

"Yes." Police officer Huang still had some doubts on his face, as if he didn't know why they brought up this old case again, and it was a suicide case.

Thinking of this, he couldn't help but glanced at the dock, not only a little surprised to see Fu Jun sitting in the dock.

Qin Wen asked directly: "Officer Huang, do you know the defendant?"

Officer Huang reluctantly nodded his head: "Yes, he was also involved in the case 13 years ago."

How could he not remember such a character, the young master of the Fu family, but how could this handsome and handsome young master be sitting in the dock right now? What did he have to do with that case back then?
Although police officer Huang was puzzled, he didn't dare to say anything more, for fear of saying something wrong, after all, this Fu family was not something he could easily offend.

Qin Wen asked: "What is his relationship with the deceased?"

Officer Huang said in a low voice: "I heard that it was the deceased's ex-boyfriend. The deceased had some contact with him before he was alive, and he was also present when the crime happened."

Qin Wen said: "Then did you ask why he was there at that time?"

"I asked. I asked him and the family members of the deceased. It was the family members of the deceased who begged him to go. The family members of the deceased were worried that the deceased would think about it and commit suicide. They wanted him to persuade the deceased, so he went. Who knows , arrived at the scene, it was already too late, at that time, the deceased had already jumped off the building for half an hour."

Qin Wen continued to ask: "Then did you investigate after the incident?"

"Of course we have investigated it." Police officer Huang didn't seem to understand why Qin Wen asked: "We have investigated this case for nearly a month. How could we have not investigated it, including the deceased's connections before his death? Those who were closely related to the deceased are the focus of our investigation, their call records, who they have met recently, and whether they are suspected of paying for murder, we have naturally investigated all of these."

Officer Huang didn't say anything. The reason why they investigated so carefully at that time was because of Fu Jun's request. He suspected that Lu Ning did not commit suicide.

Although Lu Ning's younger sister also raised such a question, they didn't pay much attention to it, but what Fu Jun said had a different weight. Of course they had to investigate carefully, especially that Tang Chu, they investigated it very carefully. It was very detailed, but in the end, he still didn't find anything suspicious about Tang Chu, so he committed suicide.

Qin Wen didn't say anything, just said: "I looked at the certificate issued by the police at that time, and there are three main points that can prove the suicide of the deceased. First, the deceased had suicidal intentions before his death, and he committed suicide more than once , This point, the doctors and nurses in the hospital, including the family members of the deceased, can prove it, and the deceased left a suicide note before jumping off the building, and the suicide note was not forged."

"Secondly, the deceased did not have any grudges with anyone during her lifetime, so no one would want to kill her. Thirdly, no suspicious traces were found at the scene of the crime to prove that other people were present at the time of the crime, so the police can It is confirmed that the deceased committed suicide, I say so, right?"

Officer Huang couldn't figure out what was wrong with Qin Wen's words, so he replied, "Yes."

Qin Wen didn't ask any more questions, and directly said to the judge and the jury members: "Your Excellency, members of the jury, you have also heard what Police Officer Huang said. judgment, but there is not very conclusive evidence that can prove that the deceased committed suicide.”

Officer Huang couldn't help but asked Qin Wen: "You mean, could there be other causes of death for the deceased? Of course, it may also be an accident."

Qin Wen immediately asked: "Is it possible that he killed him?"

Officer Huang was stunned: "He killed?"

"Yes." Qin Wen said: "Is there no possibility at all? The possibility of killing him?"

Police officer Huang didn't know how to answer for a while, because the result of this speculation was not [-]%, it was just the result of reasoning based on known conditions, there were no witnesses, and the conditions at the scene were not It is so easy to judge, so if we talk about possibilities other than suicide, such as accidents or homicide, they are all possible.

Officer Huang didn't answer, Qin Wen immediately asked again: "Officer Huang, let me ask you, is there any other possibility? Such as accident, such as homicide?"

Officer Huang was silent for nearly a minute before saying, "Yes."

Qin Wen got this answer, looked at Su Zuo quite proudly, and continued: "According to the certificate issued by the police, the three reasons for judging whether the deceased committed suicide are actually reversible. First of all, the first one, The deceased committed suicide many times. I believe that many mothers-to-be will have prenatal depression. In fact, there is no reason. What's more, according to the defense lawyer's statement, I think the suicide of the deceased is even more impossible. She may just be I want to save someone's heart in this way."

When Qin Wen said this, he looked at Fu Jun deliberately, and said slowly: "Of course, this is only one or two of the reasons. It is also possible that the deceased was persecuted, such as taking the lives of her relatives to persecute, but Had to commit suicide, we don't know."

Su Zuo smiled, but didn't say anything, let alone rebuttal.

Seeing that Su Zuo didn't speak, the judge motioned for Qin Wen to continue.

Qin Wen then said: "If a certain possibility of the first point exists, then the conclusion of the second point can be overturned, then let's look at the third reason. The police said that at the time of the incident, they had a close relationship with the deceased. The people did not have the time to commit the crime, and there is no evidence that they bought the murderer. The most important thing is that there was no third party at the scene of the crime, but this most important conjecture has been overturned. Now, there is Witnesses saw with their own eyes that at the scene of the crime, besides the deceased, there was another man on the roof, is this enough to explain that the cause of death of the deceased is actually very suspicious?"

"What?" Officer Huang was very surprised: "Have any witnesses seen the deceased before she jumped off the building? Are there other people with her?"

Qin Wen asked back: "Does Officer Huang think there is no such possibility? Are the police sure that at the time of the incident, there was no one else on the roof except the deceased?"

Officer Huang was speechless.

After all, at the time, that evidence was not reliable.

As the tallest building in the city at that time, Xinyang Office Building was also a famous sightseeing spot. Standing on the upper floor, you can almost have a panoramic view of the entire urban area, so people often go sightseeing on the roof, although the number of people is not a lot of.

But for them, this is already messy enough, the hard and rough concrete floor, and people often go up, stairs, fences, doorknobs, there is no way to find any useful traces at the scene, the only thing that can be clearly distinguished is the cement The footprints on the guardrail were the shoe prints of the deceased, and nothing else could be found.

So they couldn't be sure at that time. At that time, whether the deceased was alone or someone else was with the deceased. When Qin Wen said this, he couldn't answer. After a while, Officer Huang had to ask : "Are there any witnesses? At that time, we asked all the employees of Xinyang Office Building, and no one said that they had seen the deceased, and we have investigated more than once, and no one saw the deceased on that day, and no one knew the deceased. .”

Qin Wen didn't pay attention to Officer Huang's doubts, and asked instead: "Excuse me, Officer Huang, do you think it is possible that there might be other people besides the deceased on the roof at that time? Since no one saw the deceased at that time, then Naturally, no one knows whether the deceased was alone or appeared on the rooftop with others, so I say, is it possible?"

Officer Huang's expression was not very good, but he still answered truthfully: "It's possible."

Qin Wen asked again: "According to the results of the police investigation at that time, there was no way to prove whether the deceased was alone on the rooftop at that time, was there?"

Officer Huang's face became even uglier, and he did not speak.

Qin Wen immediately said: "The rooftop where the crime happened is a tourist attraction, and people often go there, so the police couldn't collect any traces at all. It can't prove how many people were on the rooftop at that time, isn't it?"

Officer Huang nodded with a gloomy face: "Yes."

Qin Wen asked again: "Since this is the case, how can the police be sure that the deceased committed suicide by jumping off the building instead of being pushed or forced to jump?"

After finishing speaking, without waiting for Police Officer Huang to answer, he directly picked up a photo: "Everyone here, please take a look, this is a photo of the roof of the crime scene. The fences around the roof are not very high. I can stand up."

(End of this chapter)