As a Lawyer, You Sent the Judge In?

 Chapter 280 Being kicked out of the court! Su Bai: I’m going to fight you! (Best)

Presiding judge Hu Jun and Su Bai looked at each other.

 Withdraw your gaze.

 The prosecution and the defendant each hold different opinions on the determination of this case.

　Seeing that no one could convince anyone, the trial defense fell into a state of anxiety.

  Can actually.

 The final decision to adopt the statements made by the prosecutor and the defendant rests with him.

 The main deciding factor lies with him.

to be honest.

 Since the charge of picking quarrels and provoking trouble is brought to public prosecution, a prison sentence will generally be imposed.

Why?

Because in general, the crime of picking quarrels and provoking trouble has a wide scope of application, and how to make a judgment depends on the understanding of the presiding judge.

 That is the so-called right of legal interpretation.

 The defendant's statement has a certain basis, but if he thinks that the prosecution's statement has a basis, he can fully adopt it without any influence.

 This case.

 The above mentioned it very seriously and Wang An has contacted him.

  The prosecutor will provide a reasonable basis for the accusation, and he will just go through the process.

Facing the dispute between the two parties, Hu Jun, as the presiding judge, was silent for a few seconds, and then spoke to Su Bai:

“The defendant entrusted a lawyer to state that Zhang, Li, Xue and others used reasonable behavior to defend their rights.”

“Then can I ask, is this reasonable process just to hold up a sign and go to the door of someone’s company to defend their rights?”

“Can’t they report it or make a reasonable complaint resolution to the relevant departments?”

 “I support rights protection.”

“I don’t support this kind of unreasonable rights protection.”

Su Bai:.

 Support for rights protection?

 Are you not sure why you use this unreasonable way of defending your rights?

 In this case, the necessary methods have already been carried out, and there is definitely no other way, so this method of rights protection has to be used.

Is the presiding judge really unaware or pretending not to know?

Su Bai hasn't spoken yet.

 At the defendant's seat, Lao Xue said directly:

“Don’t we want reasonable complaints to be resolved?”

 “But this **** thing can be solved!”

"ah?"

“We complained from the beginning, but we kept putting it off until the incident happened, and there was no news.”

 “We don’t want to solve it, do we?!”

 “Is it solved?!”

“There is no other way. We can only go to their company to defend our rights. What’s the problem with this?”

"If our matter can be solved early, can we still go to their company to defend our rights and claim our legitimate rights and interests? There is no need at all. We can only use this method to defend our rights. Do you understand? ?”

 Lao Xue became excited as he spoke.

Hu Jun immediately banged the gavel: "Silence, silence!"

“The defendant should be quiet and pay attention to maintaining discipline in the courtroom!”

 Dong dong dong!

 The sound of the gavel falling was deafening.

Facing the presiding judge, Lao Xue calmed down and said, "Okay."

Su Bai then continued to add: "Presiding judge, you heard just now that our client did not not protect his rights, but that he had no choice but to choose this way of protecting his rights."

 “From a legal point of view.”

“Regardless of why we use this method of protecting our rights, I would like to ask, is there anything wrong with our client’s method of protecting our rights?”

 “Has it caused damage to public order?”

“Is it a malicious way of defending rights?”

“Since it has not caused any adverse impact on other situations, why did the prosecutor want to prosecute our three parties?”

“We believe that the prosecutor should drop this case.”

“Instead of using generic charges to accuse our client of related matters!”

Mahu remained silent after hearing Su Bai's statement.

The lawyer appointed by the defendant himself said that this is a common crime.

 I guess I understand in my heart that the court can make a judgment based on provocation and provoking trouble.

 You gather people together and make trouble in front of someone else's company. I can just regard it as provoking trouble, so there is no problem at all!

Let’s talk again.

In the court trial, everything depends on the presiding judge.

 As the prosecutor, I only need to make simple supplements.

.

 ….

 At the judgment seat.

Facing Su Bai's several questions, Hu Jun did not answer but said directly: "Please keep quiet, the attorney appointed by the defendant has not yet appointed the attorney to speak."

“We are still in the process of answering whether Zhang, Li and Xue were provoking quarrels and provoking trouble in this case.”

“Please pay attention to the attorney appointed by the defendant.”

“You can only speak out when you are asked. When you are not asked about the lawyer appointed by the defendant, the defendant’s lawyer must remain quiet. I am here to remind you.”

“If there is another time, please ask the bailiff to take the defendant’s lawyer away from the court hearing.”

 The presiding judge's reminder and malicious targeting made Su Bai take a deep breath. He had learned about Shun'an Real Estate Co., Ltd.

ˆ is the second development company in Anxian County.

 But in the representation of this case, the court so blatantly supported the prosecutor? !

Even if you entrust a lawyer to defend you, you no longer have the right to raise questions?

 Let the bailiff directly take the person away from the scene? !

 Outrageous!

 What are the behaviors of Zhang, Li and Xue?

 It can be seen as standing in front of someone else’s house holding a sign and asking for money.

  Have not beaten, threatened, insulted or other things that harmed the legal rights of others.

 Just like this, not only was the case filed, but also the prosecutor filed a public prosecution. Is it fair to say that?

 It definitely doesn’t make sense!

In this case, he retorted and was even warned like this.

　　　…

Su Bai looked at Hu Jun quietly on the bench, while Li Xuezhen on the side said angrily: "Send him in!"

 The trial continues.

The presiding judge was sorting out the litigation materials, skipping what had just happened, looking at the defendant's seat and continuing to ask for relevant details.

“The defendant parties Zhang, Li, and Xue organized other people to beg for compensation and carried out the begging at the door of Shun’an Co., Ltd.”

“Is your purpose just to ask for corresponding compensation?”

"Yes."

 Lao Xue opened his mouth to answer.

 Lao Xue organized the request for corresponding compensation. In this regard, Lao Xue was also willing to take responsibility, so he was the first to answer when asked during the trial.

After Lao Xue opened his mouth to answer, Hu Jun glanced at Su Bai and struck the hammer.

“The factual conditions related to this trial and the relevant evidence clues have been roughly improved.”

 “Now enter the adjournment.”

　　　….”

 The court is adjourned.

 When the members of the collegial panel left the court hearing room, Su Bai didn't know what to say.

 This court hearing.

 It’s a lot of pressure!

Li Xuezhen said in a low voice: "Lawyer Su, the court is adjourned. The presiding judge this time has such an obvious tendency that I can't stand it anymore..."

“However, I have found where the inspection and review department is!”

"Um!"

"Um?!"

Looking at Su Bai's puzzled eyes, Li Xuezhen narrowed her eyes and said, "This is Lawyer Su. I have found it with a map."Su Bai:...

 As for what Li Xuezhen did, Su Bai could only say that it was well done!

.

 ….

 In the collegial court discussion room.

This time the court was adjourned. Hu Jun did not want to discuss whether the defendant should issue a verdict.

 The judgment can definitely be made, because the right of legal interpretation lies with him.

What needs to be discussed is how to further explain the judgment in this trial.

Regarding this point, Hu Jun discussed with the two judges and finally settled on the most critical point.

 According to Article 4 of Picking Quarrels and Provoking Trouble, gathering a crowd to disrupt social order will be punished.

However, in terms of prison term, the charges against the prosecutor may be shortened.

 The content of the discussion is that Lao Xue will be sentenced to one year and six months, and the other two will be sentenced to six months.

If you refuse to plead guilty, you can ask the prosecutor to continue to supplement the trial content.

 For example, did Lao Xue and the other two induce others to go and claim compensation?

If this thing is decided, then the sentence will not only be one year and six months, but at least two more years!

Of course, regarding how to persuade other people, you can go to Wang An.

 The rest is not a problem.

 After a discussion on this matter, the court was held again soon.

.

 ….

 At the court hearing.

 Presiding judge Hu Jun began to inquire about the relevance.

 Mainly inquire about the specific situation of the three defendants, and accuse the three of them of seeking quarrels and provoking troubles by making collective claims.

“Three defendants, what is the purpose of gathering so many people?”

“The purpose is to demand the compensation we deserve and to give us an explanation.”

 “Give you an explanation?”

“By gathering so many people to claim compensation, doesn’t it mean that the company is threatening to compensate you?”

“In this case, you think the compensation does not meet the relevant requirements, so did the relevant departments give you a reply, or did they mention the amount of compensation?”

“You have gathered, does this potentially mean to force Shun’an Real Estate Co., Ltd. to compensate you?”

 “Have you ever thought about it this way?”

 In response to such a targeted question from the presiding judge, Lao Zhang, Lao Li and Lao Xue looked at each other, not knowing how to answer. They didn't know whether they should answer yes or no.

 So he turned his attention to Su Bai.

Su Bai raised his hand to signal, but was ignored by the presiding judge.

In desperation, Lao Xue took the initiative to speak: "The main reason why we gathered so many people at that time was because there were many people and strength. With more people, Shun'an Real Estate Co., Ltd. was able to pay attention to our request."

“Otherwise...he always ignores us, and I’ve been there several times myself and was kicked out by the security guards.”

“Our idea is very simple. We are not forcing Shun An Co., Ltd., we are just asking for the compensation we deserve, as well as our legal rights.”

 “Why doesn’t he pay us what we deserve?”

"Someone who is not far away from us can pay half as much compensation as we do. There is something wrong with this. We don't agree with it, and he took advantage of our absence to do some dirty tricks."

"Now we have no place to live and can rent a house. We have to pay according to his compensation amount. If you accept it, it will be based on this. If you don't accept it, you won't get a penny. Why? Isn't this forcing us?"

“We are not forcing them to compensate us, but they are forcing us to accept their compensation!”

 “Why should we accept it?”

 “We also have the right to fight for our legal rights!”

“Just like today, presiding judge, you sit on the bench and do not consider our legal rights, but consider the legal rights of the other party. Are you a good presiding judge?”

　　　….”

 Lao Xue sat on the defendant's side and accused Hu Jun on the trial bench.

Hu Jun looked expressionless, glanced at Lao Xue indifferently, and then struck the hammer.

“Okay, defendant, you don’t need to continue talking.”

"Whether I am a good judge or not is not up to you. My judgment on you is based entirely on the laws and regulations."

“Now let’s judge the behavior of the three of you.”

“In response to the charges brought by the prosecutor, it is now determined that Zhang, Li, Xue and others organized people to provoke quarrels and cause trouble.”

 Organize people to cause quarrels and cause trouble?

If this is judged, it will be punished more severely than the general case of picking quarrels and provoking trouble!

Su Bai immediately raised his hand to refute: "Presiding Judge."

“The collegial panel determined that Zhang, Li, and Xue organized people to pick quarrels and cause trouble. Is there any relevant evidence for the organizers?”

“During the cross-examination session just now, I did not see the prosecutor submit any relevant evidence.”

“The petition also did not state the situation of the organization’s personnel.”

“Presiding Judge, I would like to ask where did you get the information about the organization personnel?!”

 Perhaps because Lao Xue directly accused Hu Jun in court, Hu Jun was particularly angry, so he decided to give Lao Xue and others a heavy sentence.

 But in fact, Lao Xue’s accusation was right!

 The presiding judge’s preference was obvious, favoring Shun’an Real Estate Co., Ltd.

Is there anything wrong with the accusation he just made? no problem!

Under Su Bai's inquiry, Hu Jun responded: "As for the organization personnel, in the relevant evidence just submitted by the prosecution, during the cross-examination session, did the lawyer appointed by the defendant fail to pay attention to one detail?"

“The prosecutor proposed that the multi-person team responsible for this protest was composed of Xue, Li and Zhang.”

“Through this point, it can be seen that Xue, Li, Zhang and others organized people to create quarrels and cause trouble.”

“The defendant shall not raise any further objection to this judgment.”

Su Bai retorted: "But the presiding judge, the evidence regarding the multi-person team's provoking quarrels and provoking troubles has not yet formed a relevant chain of evidence. This matter was indeed summoned by Xue, Li and Zhang."

“However, no illegal crime has been committed. Why should we mention that Xue, Li, and Zhang were responsible for causing trouble?”

“Forming a team to commit illegal and criminal acts must have a subjective criminal purpose.”

“Their motive is just to have an explanation and to get the compensation they deserve.”

 “There is no criminal motive!”

“So I don’t agree with the presiding judge’s ruling and the legal basis upon which it was based.”

 “I protest!”

　　　….”

At the trial bench, facing Su Bai’s protest, Hu Jun frowned.

 Then he banged the gavel hard.

 “Protest is ineffective!”

"It is your right, presiding judge, to protest against invalidity, but it is my right to protest. I do not agree with the way the collegial panel made its decision. I would like to ask the other two members of the collegial panel, do you two agree with this decision? ?”

 The other two members of the collegial panel were silent. At this time, Hu Jun was already a little angry.

“The defendant has entrusted a lawyer. It’s not yet time for you to make a statement. The court has already made a determination of relevance.”

"You can assert your rights after the trial, but now you are at the trial, and you have been warned before."

  “Statements and protests must not be made without permission.”

 “Now you are violating the order of the court.”

“Bailiff, ask the defendant’s lawyer to leave the court!”

 Dong dong dong!

 The hammer of the law struck, deafening.

Su Bai stared at the presiding judge's seat: "Even if you ask me out of the court today, I will still protest!"

 “This is my right to defend!”

"And when I exercised my right to defend, I did not conflict with your right to make a judgment, the presiding judge."

“I did not disturb the order of the trial, why should I be expelled from the court hearing?!”

 “I will not accept my expulsion from the court!”

 “President, I don’t accept it!”

Su Bai used an almost roaring voice to make statements and express his opinions in court for the first time!

 The voice echoed in the courtroom.

Besides, Li Xuezhen stared closely at the judgment seat.

 The presiding judge this time is the first person she has experienced so many court trials.

This is the worst one I have ever seen. He must be sent in for at least ten years!

.

 ….

 PS: During the double monthly pass period, please give me a monthly pass~

 (End of this chapter)