As a Lawyer, You Sent the Judge In?

Chapter 350 Witness Statement: There is only one disease in the world - the disease of poverty!

 Witnesses appear in court to prove from the side that the purpose is not to make profit.

 This aspect of judgment is stable!

So Su Bai applied to the presiding judge for witnesses to appear in court.

Facing Su Bai’s application, Duan Qingshui, as the presiding judge, did not refuse.

  After all, this is a normal court appeal.

 Besides, the witness is already sitting in the witness box, so there is no reason not to appear in court and give a statement.

 Looking at several people suffering from chronic leukemia sitting in the witness box.

Duan Qingshui banged the gavel: "I agree to the appeal's request."

 “Now let the witnesses begin their statements.”

“Please answer the first witness, as a buyer, what do you think of Lin Yong’s behavior of purchasing pirated drugs on his behalf and selling them?”

There were three witnesses at the scene. The first witness was a middle-aged man in his 30s.

Facing the presiding judge’s questioning, the first witness stood up and spoke:

 “Presiding Judge.”

“To be honest, I learned that Lin Yong wanted to appeal the second trial and needed witnesses, so I immediately wanted to go to court to testify for Lin Yong.”

“My opinion is very simple. Lin Yong is not trying to make money at all.”

“It’s all nonsense to say that Lin Yong is purchasing medicines for us just to make a profit!”

“Lin Yong’s family is not short of our money. He is engaged in foreign trade. We all know this.”

“Sometimes when we are short of money, we are even given discounts and free delivery to help us old patients.”

 “If he’s making a profit, then who do the others?”

“To say that he is subjectively and deliberately seeking profit, I think this is all slander!”

“Who is deliberately making a profit? How about giving money away even if they don’t make money? Which business person is so charitable?”

“To put it bluntly, someone must have deliberately messed with him!”

“Presiding judge, I personally think it is very likely that the lawyer sitting in the prosecution seat deliberately slandered Lin Yong.”

 “I think this should be investigated clearly! This is the key point!”

 The first witness was obviously a little emotional when he said this.

 And he has been emphasizing that this matter was deliberately framed by the genuine drug dealer.

 As the first witness showed a strong subjective tendency, Duan Qingshui, as the presiding judge, immediately stopped the first witness’ statement.

“Well... the collegial panel already understands your views on Lin Yong.”

"But whether there is slander or not, the relevant departments have investigated clearly. Please sit back in your seat."

He then continued: "Please give the second witness his opinion on Lin Yong."

 The second witness looked to be about 40 years old and was not that excited.

 The views expressed are also good. He believes that Lin Yong has no subjective intention to make profits, and he also expressed his own opinions.

“Presiding judge, Lawyer Su has made it very clear just now. If Lin Yong wants to make money from us, then he can raise the price very high.”

“Some people bought it even if it costs 5,000 yuan, because the price of genuine medicine is too expensive.”

 “Why didn’t he mention it?”

“And you are willing to help us buy medicine on our behalf?”

“You must know that it is very difficult to purchase some medicines from abroad that are not allowed in China and bring them back.”

“Furthermore, it is a crime to do these things. I think Lin Yong is also very clear about this.”

“Taking such a big risk will result in nothing profitable being investigated in the country.”

 “For what?”

“It’s not just because of us patients, he cares about our illnesses and worries that we can’t afford medicine.”

“There is another point that I also want to express, that is, even if Lin Yong really makes money, how much money does a bottle of medicine make after deducting the smuggling costs?”

“Is this a lot of money for committing a crime?”

“I have always thought Lin Yong is a good person, a truly good person.”

“But there are no ifs. My point is that Lin Yong did not deliberately make profits because of this.”

 “Because it doesn’t make sense from every angle.”

“President, this is my opinion about Lin Yong.”

 After the second witness finished expressing his opinion, the third witness began to express his opinion.

 The presiding judge looked at the third witness.

 The third witness is an old woman nearly 60 years old, with a vicissitudes of life on her face.

 But the whole person looks very neat in terms of clothes.

Facing Qingshui’s questioning, the old lady was silent for a few seconds, then looked up at the presiding judge’s seat.

 Then he turned to look at Lin Yong at the appellant's seat. After looking at him for a few seconds, he looked at Duan Qingshui again.

 “Presiding Judge.…”

“I don’t know what to say about Lin Yong’s views...”

　Duan Qingshui: “It doesn’t matter, just say whatever comes to mind.”

"I will make a judgment on the relevant laws based on the key contents of your statement."

 “Okay, thank you, presiding judge…”

  The old lady nodded: "I took the initiative to apply to Lawyer Su for this court appearance."

“I really don’t know what I should say to help Lin Yong.”

“But I know very well in my heart that Lin Yong is my savior.”

“My wife and I are both patients with chronic leukemia.”

“We were all diagnosed with chronic leukemia four years ago. Lenin’s medicine... is a genuine medicine. To be honest, we really can’t afford it..."

“A bottle costs 20,000 yuan. My wife and I together make 40,000 yuan a month for the two of us.”

“Forty thousand yuan a month is nearly 500,000 yuan a year...”

“My wife and I don’t have retirement wages yet, so we usually make some money by doing odd jobs for others and picking up rags to sell.”

“But how much can my wife and I earn at our age?”

“Our combined monthly income is only 3,000 yuan.”

“It’s only 40,000 yuan a year. My wife and I have to go without food or drink for a year to afford a month’s worth of medicine.”

“My wife and I took the medicine for 40,000 yuan a month for three years.”

“The house is gone and the family is in ruins. We have a son who goes out from 6 a.m. to get off work at 11 p.m. every day. He earns more than 10,000 yuan a month, and all the money goes to us for medicine.”

“My daughter-in-law couldn’t stand this kind of life and ran away...”

 “Only one child was left, only five or six years old…”

"what to do?"

“In this situation, what else can we do?”

“Our family is already in ruins, including our daughter-in-law and daughter-in-law. If we continue to take medicine, will our son also be ruined?”

“My wife and I have always thought that living like this will only burden our family, so it’s better to die... At least it can relieve some of the burden on my son.”

“If we can leave a future for our grandson, at least we won’t be a burden, and my son and grandson can be more relaxed.”

“Just when my wife and I couldn’t hold on any longer, we found out about the cheap medicines sold by Lin Yong and started purchasing them on our behalf.”

“Although it is a little weaker in effect, it is cheap and can suppress the disease.”

“My wife and I only spent 4,000 yuan a month. Even Lin Yong, when he found out about this situation, said he didn’t even need to pay for smuggling.”

“A bottle sells to us for 1,500 yuan, and it costs 3,000 yuan a month.”

“Compared to before, this is more than ten times less!”

"Who would think of dying if they had the ability? I don't want to, and neither does my wife."

“We have been taking cheap medicine this year, which has relieved a lot of burden on my son and our family.”

 “But what now?”

“I have been taking cheap medicine for a year, but you insist on saying that this medicine is fake. How can I not know whether it is fake or not..."

“That medicine only cost us 1,500 yuan a bottle.”

"Did you say that Lin Yong was making a profit? In my opinion, not at all." "Why did he purchase these pirated medicines... Isn't it so that we patients who cannot afford genuine medicines can survive?"

“Now that there is no Lin Yong, many people have bought genuine medicines, but can we afford genuine medicines?”

“Forty thousand yuan a month, if you sell us, we are not worth the money.”

“Some patients even have suicidal thoughts in order not to burden their families.”

“My wife and I have only bought one bottle of medicine in the past two months... We share it between the two of us, why? Because we can’t afford it..."

“We don’t want to do this, but we really have no choice…”

“You have arrested Lin Yong now. We have no pirated medicine. We cannot afford genuine medicine, so we can only wait to die.”

“Who can guarantee that his family will not encounter some difficulties in the future?”

“Whether Lin Yong has made a profit this year is something we all keep in mind.”

 “Tell the truth...say something that comes from the bottom of your heart.”

“We also know that it is not good to buy pirated medicines, but... we really don’t have any solution.”

“…If you have money, who wouldn’t want to take genuine medicine?”

“Who doesn’t know that genuine medicines are better than counterfeit medicines?”

“But we can’t afford it! We are poor! A bottle of 20,000 yuan a month, even if it costs our lives, we can’t make enough!”

 “This is a fundamental disease of poverty! We can’t do anything about it!”

“Presiding judge, you said that Lin Yong made a profit... But we know best whether he made a profit or not... If you sold it to me at the original price of 1,500 yuan, how can you make a profit?”

"In my opinion, Lin Yong is not making profits... He is the savior of my wife and me."

 The statement is completed.

 The old lady's face was filled with an indescribable emotion, and her eyes couldn't help but feel moist.

He looked up at the presiding judge, then turned to look at Lin Yong.

At this time, Lin Yong's eyes were also red when he saw the old lady.

He knows best what kind of state these patients are in.

 Having no money...cannot afford genuine medicines or medical treatment. When he did not purchase pirated medicines on his behalf, many people were in a state of waiting to die.

Doesn’t he know that smuggling and selling counterfeit medicines is illegal?

he knows.

But facing so many patients, can he just stay silent?

cannot.

 For Lin Yong, the three witnesses present today can come to court to prove his innocence.

 In his opinion, everything he did in the past two years was worth it!

 Very worth it!

.

 ….

 In the court hearing, after the third witness finished his statement.

 The court hearing fell into relative silence.

 It is not difficult to hear the gratitude and gratitude to Lin Yong from the old lady's mouth.

Why do you say that?

 Because the old lady clearly told the plight of families suffering from chronic leukemia and the effect of Lin Yong’s pirated medicine.

 Save people!

 Rescue people for free! .

 ….

 At the same time, because this trial was broadcast live in public, and the case attracted relatively high attention online.

On the live broadcast barrage, many people expressed their feelings.

“At the beginning of this case, I didn’t know much about it, but after this second trial defense, I finally understood that there is really only one disease in the world, the disease of poverty!”

 “If you have money, who wouldn’t want to buy genuine medicines instead of pirated ones?”

 “It’s not because of lack of money!”

“I really had no money and no other options, so I bought pirated medicines. Can you blame them? What’s wrong with them?!”

 “They just want to live, what’s wrong with that?!”

"Lin Yong is really willing to take care of his patients. From the results and evidence, he does not make any profit. What does this mean?"

“This shows that he has no intention of using this to make money!”

 “What a **** of medicine!”

“Hmm...that’s right. It can be seen from the words of the third witness that Lin Yong saved many families in the past two years by purchasing pirated drugs on his behalf.”

“Again, if you can’t afford genuine medicines, who would buy pirated medicines?”

“How many people are purchasing on behalf of others for free? Let’s not talk about anything else. Do you know how difficult it is to transport so many things through smuggling?”

“In terms of profit margin, it’s probably just given to foreign agents and smuggling fees!”

“Let’s not talk about anything else, from a moral point of view, I really admire Lin Yong!”

 There was a lot of heated discussion on the Internet, and most of them had a great change in the case after reading the third witness’s statement.

Yes, that’s right, Lin Yong committed a crime...but was he really doing it for profit?

 It’s not!

 Many people are even asking whether Lin Yong can be found not guilty...

 It’s just that in the answers given by legal professionals, it is unrealistic to tell.

 Because although from a moral point of view, what Lin Yong did was for the sake of many patients.

 But from a legal perspective, it does involve the crime of smuggling and selling counterfeit drugs.

If the verdict is not guilty and a loophole is opened in the domestic law, then it is very likely that some people will publicize it and take advantage of the loopholes in the law to make profits.

.

 ….

 On the other side, the court hearing.

 At the trial stage, Duan Qingshui, as the presiding judge, struck the hammer:

“The testimony of the appellant’s witnesses all ends with statements.”

“As to whether Lin Yong’s purchasing behavior was subjective and intentional for profit, do the prosecutors and prosecutors have any objections, or is there anything else that needs to be stated?”

 In the witness’s statement just now, to be honest, let’s not discuss the point of guilt or innocence.

 What the prosecutor thinks is that this situation can still be judged as subjective intentionality?

How can it be!

 So when the presiding judge asked if he had any objections, the prosecutor immediately stated that he had no objections.

It's just that...as the prosecutor's attorney, Fang Qi also knows in his heart where his position lies.

 Glee has a lot of cases in China and has a cooperative relationship with their law firm.

 Every year, seven or eight major cases are handed over to their law firm.

 In this case, they must maximize the benefits for their agency company.

When the presiding judge was questioning, Fang Qi immediately raised his hand and said:

“We understand the statements made by the witnesses in this case.”

 “But the law is the law.”

“We request the presiding judge to judge the relevant circumstances of this case from a legal perspective.”

"As for whether Lin Yong is making profits, we believe that there is a possibility of making profits because Lin Yong cannot accurately explain where the profit amount goes."

“Well, the collegial panel already understands the issues raised by the prosecution.”

 “Any other questions?”

 “No more, presiding judge.” Fang Qi said.

 After Fang Qi finished his statement, Duan Qingshui nodded.

“Since there are no other issues, and the parties have different opinions on this determination.”

 “Then adjourn now!”

“After the collegial panel has completed its deliberations, it will make a judgment on whether Lin Yong has made profits!”

 “Adjourn the court!”

 The gavel struck, and the sound spread throughout the courtroom.

Hearing the sound of recessing the court, Su Bai breathed a sigh of relief.

how to say.…

Although Su Bai does not know the outcome of the adjournment deliberations now.

  However, evidence from all aspects shows that Lin Yong did not have any subjective intention to make profits.

 This judgment must be stable!

.

 ….

 PS: Please give me a monthly ticket~

 (End of this chapter)