If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Tang Yidong's words were full of meaning.

Ye Qiu could naturally hear it. only.

Ye Qiu didn't care.

He just pulled out a piece of information indifferently and said unhurriedly.

"First of all, regarding what the prosecutor stated, our client Jiang Ge’s primary subjective point is to kill Gan Wuxin. We do not agree with this."

"We would like to ask how the prosecutor specifically confirmed Jiang Ge’s primary subjective wish?"

At the prosecutor's seat.

Tang Yidong frowned.

Isn't this something that has been confirmed? Why are you asking now?

Moreover, since you don't agree, why are you saying it now instead of just now?

Is this Ye Qiu trying to pass the lawsuit? Using stick methods to mess around and even confuse right and wrong?

The more Tang Yidong thought about it, the more he felt that it was possible, and he sneered secretly in his heart.

"The prosecutors confirmed Jiang Ge's primary subjective intention to intentionally kill someone based on the relevant chain of evidence. Ye

Qiu smiled slightly when he heard this and said unhurriedly.

"Then please show the relevant evidence to the prosecutor."

As soon as he said this, everyone at the scene was stunned.

What do you mean by asking the prosecutor to show evidence?

Is it possible that you still want to overturn the irrefutable evidence?!

Even at the lawyer's table.

Bai Xiaotu has a clue Doubts.

You must know that the most powerful weapon of the prosecution is the complete chain of evidence.

And Lawyer Ye asked this question.

Could it be that he really has a way to overturn the chain of evidence?

Thinking of this,

Bai Xiaotu's clear eyes lit up..

At the prosecutor's seat,

Tang Yidong sneered.

Sure enough, this Ye Qiu wanted to use litigious tactics to find loopholes in his evidence!

But it's a pity.

He may not have thought of it!

How complete the prosecution's evidence chain is!

In court trials, evidence comes first!

Want to use unscrupulous litigation tactics?

Then let me crucify you completely!

At this time, Tang Yidong was confident, pulled out a few pieces of material, and said

"This part is the video surveillance data of Jiang Ge rushing into the alley and killing Gan Wuxin."

"Before Jiang Ge rushed into the alley, she had already obtained the bottle filled with wine in advance."

"The prosecutor reminds the defendant to pay attention to this!"

"Jiang Ge got the murder weapon in advance!"

"Instead of attacking with a weapon obtained during the conflict!"

"Therefore, from the beginning, Jiang Ge's purpose of intentional murder was very clear, and he was fully prepared!"

"Otherwise, why would she obtain the murder weapon in advance?"

The trial live broadcast room.

After hearing Tang Yidong's words, netizens couldn't help but discuss it.

"Although I am very unhappy with the prosecutor, what he said is indeed correct. The evidence is very complete."

"That's right, I can't find any refutation on this point. Jiang Ge probably committed the murder intentionally."

"So I don’t understand. Isn’t Lawyer Ye giving the other party a chance?"

"After the prosecutor's questioning, if he can't answer the question, the presiding judge's tendency will change!"

"......"

Zhang San frowned and looked at the court hearing.

He quickly thought about what angles Ye Qiu could use to defend himself.

But he couldn't think of it. After all, the evidence was irrefutable, how could it be overturned?

The scene of the trial.

Faced with Tang Yidong's powerful questioning.

Ye Qiu just chuckled lightly and said

"It is true that Jiang Ge obtained the murder weapon in advance, but it does not mean that Jiang Ge's first purpose was to kill someone intentionally."

As soon as Ye Qiu said this, everyone was stunned!

They had obtained the murder weapon in advance, and you still said you didn't want to kill someone intentionally?

What a joke!

Prosecutor.

A gleam of joy flashed in Tang Yidong's eyes, and Ye Qiu seemed to be doing the same. I'm so anxious, I made such a mistake and came back!

"If the opposing lawyer confuses right and wrong and ignores the law,"

"Then the statement and question session can be suspended."

"Next, let the presiding judge make a decision!"

Tang Yidong made a stern application.

At the trial seat,

Luo Zhendong stared at Ye Qiu speechlessly.

What other outrageous words can you say!

Are you the law itself?

If you say it is not, then it is not?!

Luo

Zhendong banged the gavel, asked seriously

"The defendant explains"

"without justifiable reasons"

"The question and answer session will be suspended!"

Seeing this scene.

Netizens were a little anxious.

"If you are not Lawyer Ye, why are you so unreliable?"

"It’s really just hard evidence and law!"

"It’s over, it’s over!"

"Now the previous advantage is also given back!"

The court hearing.

Ye Qiu faced pressure from all sides.

He remained calm and composed, and just smiled calmly.

"Basis for our statement"

"Among the video evidence provided by the prosecution"

"We can clearly see that there is a watermelon stall at the entrance of the barbecue restaurant, with cut watermelons and a watermelon knife on it."

"If Jiang Ge's first thought was to kill, then why didn't she use the watermelon knife, which is easier to kill, instead of using a beer bottle?" As soon as she said this, the whole audience was stunned.

Then there was a sudden realization.

That's right. , killing people, isn't a knife more useful!

This angle is really reasonable!

At this time, at the prosecutor's seat,

Tang Yidong was also confused.

Ye Qiu's question was really tricky.

It completely stuck on a point that the prosecutor did not pay attention to..

And Tang Yidong didn't understand. How many times did Ye Qiu watch the surveillance video before he noticed the existence of the watermelon knife!

When he investigated, he didn't even think about this aspect!

However, Tang Yidong didn't intend to understand. After he It seems that this is nothing more than sophistry!

He has such a mountain of evidence, and he is still worried about losing?!

But Ye Qiu didn't care about Tang Yidong, he just looked at the trial seat and said directly

"Jiang Ge did not go for the watermelon knife, which is enough to explain Jiang Ge's first thought, that is, the primary objective is not to kill Gan Wuxin directly, but to focus more on stopping Gan Wuxin and rescuing Chen Yue"

"We hope that the collegial panel can take into account common sense"

"Instead of blindly judging Jiang Ge’s subjective intention based on the results."

"This can easily lead to unjust, false and wrongful convictions."

On the trial bench.

Luo Zhendong was a little surprised.

Ye Qiu's defense angle was indeed eye-opening and more in line with common sense.

Ye Qiu's last sentence made more sense.

Many times, the judges don't just want to see what happened. As a result, common sense still needs to be considered.

This is the people-oriented judicial practice.

Unintentionally,

Ye Qiu has taught himself a lesson.

From this, Luo Zhendong couldn't help but fall into thinking.

Under normal circumstances, he really wants to kill someone. If so, there is no reason to leave the knife unused and use the beer bottle.

Therefore, is it a bit arbitrary to simply define subjective will based on objective results?

Luo Zhendong has a certain tendency in his heart.

However, he does not intend to make a judgment directly.

He needs to see how the prosecutor explains.

If the prosecutor cannot give a strong rebuttal, then the collegial bench really needs to consider it.

Jiang Ge’s first thought is to stop it, not to kill directly.

Boom!

"Prosecutor, do you want to explain?"

Luo Zhendong banged the gavel and looked at the prosecutor's seat and asked......(To read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

Seeing that Ye Qiu actually won over the presiding judge's preference.

Tang Yidong frowned greatly.

This guy.

The level of criminal prosecution is really high!

In the face of ironclad evidence, he was still able to find a defense reason!

But that's okay.

Although Ye Qiu caught him by surprise.

But the advantage still lies with him!

Tang Yidong took a breath, adjusted his mentality, and said

"Presiding judge, we do not agree with the other party’s lawyer’s reasons!"

"Because whether it is a watermelon knife or a beer bottle, they are both weapons that can cause death."

"Especially when Jiang Ge was in a state of urgency, she most likely did not realize the existence of the watermelon knife, but casually picked up the wine bottle on the ground as the murder weapon."

"So the crux of the matter is that she subjectively had the intention to kill, not what weapon was used! Hearing this, Ye

Qiu smiled slightly and said

"We do not accept the prosecutor’s rebuttal"

"Chief Judge, we apply to play a video material"

"application passed!"

As the video played, Ye Qiu pointed to the key points.

"This video is from the barbecue restaurant surveillance ten minutes before the conflict between Gan Wuxin and Jiang Ge."

"The prosecutor's investigation of the scene may not be complete enough. They simply examined the video during the conflict without reconstructing the entire incident."

"It is clearly visible in the video that ten minutes ago, Jiang Ge and Chen Yue asked the waiter to cut watermelons for them at the watermelon stand at the door. Therefore, Jiang Ge and Chen Yue both knew clearly that there was a watermelon knife here. of"

"And since Jiang Ge knows that the watermelon knife exists and is outside the door, and the beer bottle is in the beer frame, then Jiang Ge subjectively wants to kill someone. Whether it is obtaining or using the watermelon knife, it is obviously faster."

"Therefore, the prosecutor's counterargument is not valid."

Boom!

On the trial bench.

Luo Zhendong knocked the gavel and said

"Prosecutor, please continue to explain!"

On the trial bench.

Tang Yidong's expression changed slightly.

At the same time, he was secretly annoyed.

This guy was so well-prepared for these details!

However, it's okay, it's just a small omission, and it can't affect the overall situation!

But don't give it to Ye anymore. Qiu had a chance!

This person's level of criminal prosecution was too high, and he was no match for him!

Then Tang Yidong thought about it carefully, and then slowly explained

"Even if Jiang Ge knows about the existence of the Watermelon Knife, she doesn’t necessarily have to take it."

"Because there were eight male perpetrators including Ma Jiantao at the time, if Jiang Ge got the watermelon knife, it might directly trigger Ma Jiantao and others to stop him."

"So she chose a beer bottle! This made Gan Wuxin's eight companions relax their vigilance! Only in this way can she have a chance to kill Gan Wuxin!"

Tang Yidong felt that his explanation was very accurate.

However, after hearing Tang Yidong's words,

Ye Qiu said with a half-smile.

"Remind prosecutors to pay attention to the logic of their statements"

"The prosecutor said before that Jiang Ge was in a state of urgency"

"So in such an anxious state, how could he still calculate the reactions of the other eight people, or even premeditate to make them relax their vigilance?"

"In addition, if Jiang Ge really realized that her eight companions could threaten her at any time, she should pick up the watermelon knife. After all, the knife is far better than the beer bottle in terms of killing people and self-protection."

"On the contrary, only when the first thought is to stop and there are no other thoughts, will you pick up a weapon and attack."

The court hearing was being broadcast live. After hearing Ye Qiu's words, netizens cheered loudly!

"good! Lawyer Ye said it well! It makes so much sense! Whether it's killing someone or defending myself, if I have a knife, I don't need to use a beer bottle. Am I sick? I will only give up the knife when I have no intention of hurting anyone!"

"Ha ha! As expected of Lawyer Ye, he is indeed reliable! Look at the prosecutor's face, it's all dark!"

".Damn it! What he said was all nonsense. He was completely inhumane in studying the Fa. He only wanted to send people in!"

"Let me tell you, just let Lawyer Ye send it to him!"

"presiding judge! Judge quickly! Stop dawdling!"

The scene of the trial.

Boom!

Luo Zhendong transformed into a ruthless hammer-beating machine.

"Please continue to explain"[]

Tang Yidong:"......"

Blanch!

He shouldn't have cooperated with Ye Qiu!

Now I really fell into the pit!

Contradictory logical statements will greatly reduce the fairness of one's own position, and will further affect the presiding judge's preference.

I can no longer be entangled with Ye Qiu like this.

Tang Yidong realized.

In terms of plea.

He might really be no match for Ye Qiu.

Comparing the other party's level with one's own, it is simply a dimensionality reduction blow!

But it’s okay!

His real advantage is evidence!

Ye Qiu only achieved certain results through pleading!

He only won a little bit, which was not enough to overturn all the evidence chains!

The advantage is still there!

As long as you don't continue to struggle with Ye Qiu, you can win!

So, Tang Yidong took a deep breath and said

"We think"

"The defendant’s stated reasons are still untenable"

"Because in the final analysis, Jiang Ge deliberately killed the victim, not the means used to kill the victim."

"At the same time, the defendant used subjective prevention as an excuse to explain that there was no subjective killing, which is also untenable."

"Because there is no real order of killing and stopping, but they exist at the same time!"

"That is: Jiang Ge wanted to kill Gan Wuxin to prevent him from continuing to commit violence. This is very reasonable!"

"Her murderous behavior and the fatal consequences are clearly visible in the video!"

"In addition, Jiang Ge's own testimony clearly admitted his intentional murder intention!"

"That is: when she heard Chen Yue's cry for help and screams in the alley, and discovered that Gan Wuxin violently assaulted Chen Yue"

"The first idea is to kill Gan Wuxin and stop Gan Wuxin’s behavior"

"Evidence and testimony combined!"

"It is enough to show that Jiang Ge’s primary subjectivity is intentional murder!"

Boom!

The presiding judge Luo Zhendong knocked the gavel

"Did the defendant provide an explanation or explanation?"

Luo Zhendong believes that what the prosecutor said is reasonable.

In the final analysis. (Wang Zhao)

No matter what the murder weapon was, it caused the death of the victim.

And Jiang Ge has admitted intentional homicide. It is difficult to overturn the subjective and objective combination.

The conclusion of intentional homicide.

Hearing the words of the presiding judge,

Tang Yidong couldn't help but get excited.

He really grasped the key. The presiding judge no longer favored the defendant!

Now, what can the defendant use to argue with him?!

I really don't believe it.!

You can overturn all the evidence!

Seeing this, Ye Qiu just smiled.

He was not anxious at all, he just said leisurely

"We will provide additional explanations"

"The prosecutor's argument is that our client took the initiative to plead guilty and admitted that his primary subjective intention was intentional homicide."

"Therefore, the subjective guilty plea, combined with the objective results, can prove that our client committed intentional homicide."

"However, what if there are problems with our client’s confession testimony?"

As soon as he said this, everyone was deceived.

Aren't they!

Jiang Ge's confession attitude was very clear! Could there be a hidden secret in it?!

On the trial bench, the three judges looked at each other in surprise.

This Ye Qiu , do you want to overturn the validity of the evidence?!

Boom!

"The defendant's lawyer!"

"Make a detailed statement!"

Luo Zhendong had a vague feeling that the direction of this trial was out of control.

Ye Qiu took out a piece of material with a smile and said with a faint smile.

"Among the testimonial materials provided by law enforcement parties"

"Regarding the scene in which our client was questioned"

"There is such a thing. Our client was asked why he attacked with a beer bottle. Our client said that he wanted to stop Gan Wuxin from being reckless."

"However, subsequent law enforcement officers asked, did they want to kill Gan Wuxin?"

"Only then did our client say yes"

"Obviously, this kind of inquiry is subjective and inductive."

"The validity of a testimony obtained through inducement should not be recognized!"

"We apply to the collegial panel to determine that the testimony is illegal evidence and to cancel it!"

At this moment,

Tang Yidong's expression changed instantly.