If you are asked to popularize the law, will you sentence the judge to ten years?

Chapter 86

In the dock.

Zhou Kai and Liu Xuan were both stunned.

No, you, no...

Can you, he, play your cards according to the routine?

Why did you have to give it away when you first came up, and why did you send it directly to the presiding judge?!

Do you think this is a magical city?

How dare you be so arrogant!

Zhou Kai couldn't help but said:

"Plaintiff's lawyer, you are so alarmist......."

Boom, boom, boom!

Suddenly a huge gavel sounded.

The presiding judge Song Huihuang banged the gavel, looked at Zhou Kaida expressionlessly and said

"Warn the defendant once!"

"Do not disrupt the normal court proceedings!"

"Otherwise, you will bear corresponding legal liability!"

Song Huihuang suddenly warned.

Zhou Kai was choked instantly.

He realized that he should not break the rules again.

But he still couldn't help complaining in his heart.

Damn!

This presiding judge has changed too fast!

He is really so scared. Is this Ye Qiu?!

However, from Song Huihuang's perspective, of course he is afraid!

Although the overall situation of Lanshan is more important, his own future is also very important!

You know, this is a live trial.

I don't know. How many people are watching!

This guy Zhou Kai actually dares to violate the rules continuously.

This Ye Qiu is not a soft persimmon!

This has given him an opportunity, and no one can take advantage of it!

In fact, if it were not Ye Qiu who was standing on the plaintiff's bench, Qiu.

Song Huihuang still has some confidence to fool him.

But Ye Qiu's strength. What is most clear now is not the netizens and the parties to the case.

It is the legal practitioners in the courts everywhere.

Even if we don't mention Ye Qiu's rectification of Shadu and Tangdu, The Supreme People's Court has issued various notices regarding the public affairs, procuratorate, and law.

Let the court personnel learn from Ye Qiu's court trial and make an analysis report!

What kind of treatment is this?

Then if Ye Qiu really catches something, the highest department I will definitely not ignore it.

When the time comes, let alone Lanshan.

I am afraid that Shendu will be implicated.

At the same time, Song Huanghuang is also vomiting blood in his heart.

Ma De, what kind of wolf destroyer is this Ye Qiu!

Why shouldn't he mention it unfairly? A suggestion. He was actually labeled as not recognizing the law!

Obviously, if he sided with Emperor Qi without any reason, he might have gone in at 18!

Sun Zhiming and Wang Haiyue also looked at each other in the trial seat. They didn't dare to speak up.

As a member of the court in Lanshan, they were naturally on the side of the emperor. So they all felt that there was no problem with Song Huihuang's decision. But who could have expected that this Ye Qiu was so ferocious! He was outside the law. The madman really deserves his reputation! He will be sent away if he disagrees with you, it is simply scary! Outside the court hearing. Seeing this scene. Netizens got excited!

"Good guy! Good question! Lawyer Ye started to kill!"

"Hahaha, if you interrupt me, why don't I give you a sewing machine package?!"

"What happened to the presiding judge? It’s not like we, Ye Shen, can’t send it to the presiding judge!"

"Ha ha ha ha!"

Zhang San couldn't help but sigh.

Ye Qiu's method of solving problems is so skillful and sharp.

It seems that there is no need to worry about the presiding judge's targeting.

After all, this is a live trial. If the presiding judge goes too far, he will really get himself involved.

Shendu. Emperor

Enterprise headquarters.

Chairman's office.

Emperor Enterprise CEO Ma Huaxun looked at the court trial with no expression.

He was also watching Zhang San's live broadcast room, so he knew these barrage clearly.

But he didn't care, In this era, the winner is king, and whatever you win is correct.

Even the official will take care of you, so what does it mean to be shameless?

Interest and power are the most important! However

, the situation in the court hearing at this time.

Ma Huaxun frowned

"Jia Anping, what's going on?"

"Zhou Kai, is this messed up?"

Minister of Justice Jia Anping said quickly

"Chairman, don’t worry"

"It should be fine"

"This leaf autumn"

"I just took the opportunity to scare people."

"This is just a trivial matter. It is impossible to end the trial just because of this matter."

"And the presiding judge just gave a simple warning, which was equivalent to reminding Zhou Kai that it was nothing serious."

"As for Zhou Kai"

"He did have a minor violation"

"But what he said is still very good."

"He was mainly delaying the effectiveness of Ye Qiu's evidence."

"If this is successful"

"In the future, courts can do this"

"Those small studios that want to sue us, Imperial Enterprises, etc."

"Litigation costs will be greatly increased in the future."

"By then, there may be far fewer lawsuits troubling Imperial Enterprises."

When Jia Anping said that, a cold sweat broke out down his spine.

To be honest, he really didn't expect that

Ye Qiu could be so ferocious.

Let's just be a little more arrogant at home.

You're going to give me a blow when you come up. The presiding judge sent him away!

He didn't play by the rules at all, and he really didn't talk about martial ethics!

But it was okay.

This was the home court of Lanshan.

Not to mention the collegial bench.

It was the Lanshan Court.

Ye Qiu would not be allowed to act so randomly.

So actually you don’t have to worry too much.

After hearing this, Ma Huaxun also relaxed his brows and nodded.

"Can"

"If I win this time"

"The legal department’s bonus is indispensable"

"Imperial Enterprises want to move towards high-end original brands and routes"

"This time it just serves as a benchmark to resolve the image that has been plagued by lawsuits."

Ma Huaxun is now working hard to transform the imperial company and take the high-end route.

It is destined to need a good image.

Therefore, it is not a good thing to be involved in lawsuits.

Although Ma Huaxun does not care about the group of netizens who only know Bibi.

But after all, the company has to cut leeks. Make money.

You have to make money from the pockets of these poor people.

When Jia Anping heard Teng Huama’s words, he quickly assured him and said

"Rest assured, Chairman, this lawsuit will definitely be won."

"I heard that the legal fee for Ye Qiu from Qingshu Studio was one million."

"Coupled with Ye Qiu's reputation, he can be said to be a very good person."

"As long as Ye Qiu loses, the rights protection costs of all studios will increase greatly in the future."

"Maybe in the next few years, no one will dare to file an infringement lawsuit against Imperial Enterprises."

Ma Huaxun nodded slightly.

At the court hearing.

On the trial bench.

The presiding judge Song Huanghuang secretly took a deep breath.

He controlled his expression, then knocked the gavel, looked at Ye Qiu and said

"Plaintiff, continue your argument."

At the plaintiff's table.

Bai Xiaotu's clear eyes couldn't help but shine!

The presiding judge!

He bowed his head!

As expected of Lawyer Ye!

It's so cool!

On the side.

Ye Qiu just smiled indifferently.

He had expected everything.

At this time, listen After hearing the words of the presiding judge, he spoke calmly.

"good judge"

"We continue to state"

"Determination of copyright plagiarism"

"The plagiarism standard we determined is not the plagiarism of the characteristics of the work as warned by the other party’s lawyer."

"But the second point: the originality of the work."

Hearing Ye Qiu's words, the three judges Song Huihuang couldn't help being stunned.

The originality of the work?

Wait, this......

In the dock.

Zhou Kai and Liu Xuan’s eyes lit up!

This Ye Qiu!

It’s so addicting to show off!

You really think you can do anything, right?

He actually proposed originality as a criterion for plagiarism!

This point can be said to be the lowest standard applicable in all infringement and plagiarism cases! the reason is simple! fundamental!

There is no way to prove originality!

Who doesn’t have a shadow in the current game works?

It is really difficult to prove this!

It’s truly completely original, and it’s estimated that only one will be released every ten years!

And Green Tree Studio’s mobile games obviously don’t have originality!

In other words, even if he has a certain degree of originality, there is no evidence to prove it!

Ye Qiu wants to make a fuss about this! (If you want to read Baoshuang novels, go to Feilu Novel Network!)

You are simply asking for trouble!

Zhou Kai couldn't help but want to show off.

Teach Ye Qiu how to behave.

But I remembered Ye Qiu's fierceness just now. and the presiding judge’s warning.

I was frightened for a moment

"Humph, give you time to be arrogant"

"When my turn comes, I will absolutely crush you to death!"

Zhou Kai looked at Ye Qiu and hummed in his heart.

Boom!

At this time, at the trial seat,

Song Huanghuang asked calmly.

"Litigation party, how do you prove the originality of your work?"

"In other words, where is the originality?"

Different from Zhou Kai's desire to express himself,

Song Huanghuang felt relieved.

If Ye Qiu's defense was not good, then he would have reason to make a judgment.

Song Huanghuang had seen Ye Qiu's sharpness.[]

He just wants to end this case safely now.

The best thing to do now is to let Emperor Qi win the case.

At the very least, Ye Qiu could not achieve all his demands.

If the worst case scenario.

Song Huihuang didn't dare to guarantee anything.

After all, he wanted to keep going up. at this time.

Ye Qiu smiled slightly, took out a piece of material, and said

"In terms of originality, there are mainly two"

"One: It is the unique virtual value-added ability of our game"

"Namely: an original profitable mobile game model"

"There are three types of this mode"

"The first one is to extract relevant virtual items through a prize pool, which promotes a large amount of consumption by players."

"The second is a pass system that is open during specific periods, providing a new consumption space"

"Second: It is a multi-player chess mode unique to our game."

"That is: by combining games and chess, a new auto-chess model is formed"

"Detailed rules can be found in the relevant materials provided by us."

"Many players who don’t play the main game of [Clash of Clans] will go and play Auto Chess."

"Both of these were completely copied by Emperor Qi’s game."

"obviously"

"Opposite Emperor Enterprise Company"

"Plagiarized our original freemium features and gameplay modes"

"This has constituted the second point in the judgment of copyright plagiarism, plagiarism of the originality of the work."

"And because it is plagiarizing our key profit points, the plot is even more serious!"

Ye Qiu's voice fell.

Zhou Kai and Liu Xuan both looked at each other.

He thought that Ye Qiu should start from the gameplay to analyze the originality of Qingshu Studio.

This can be said to be very easy to deal with.

But he didn't expect.

Ye Qiu. He actually started from the point of profit!

This was an angle that he had never thought of!

So he didn't know how to refute it at all.

Dong Dong!

At the trial seat, the three judges all looked at the relevant materials.

Then Song Huanghuang knocked on gavel, looked at the defendant and asked

"Defendant, does it have any objection or explanation?"

Zhou Kai frowned.

Since there is no way to answer, there is only one way.

Destroy the question directly for you!

"presiding judge"

"We do not agree with the other party’s statement"

"first"

"About so-called virtual value-added capabilities"

"It’s not an original way to make money."

"Because in many games"

"There are various ways to attract players to earn money"

"That is: the ability to attract recharge consumption"

"The essence of recharging"

"It allows players to exchange money into virtual currency and then spend it"

"What the other party calls two original gold points, one is to extract character props, and the other is an open mission system."

"Essentially, profits are made through this universal process."

"Therefore, there is no so-called original virtual value-added capability"

"Secondly"

"About the original gameplay mode of Auto Chess"

"This is even more nonsense"

"Online games have always been"

"There are various board games"

"Not to mention, playing chess is a game that has been passed down by the country for thousands of years."

"The opponent just combined his game content role with chess."

"This cannot be said to be original at all, it can only be said to be the first of its kind."

"my country's copyright law protects originality rather than originality"

"At most, the other party was the first to develop this gameplay."

"But we can also create this method of playing 977"

"It's just a step slower"

"Therefore, both points expressed by the other party are rejected!"

Live broadcast room.

Netizens were all confused after hearing this.

"Ah, what does this mean?"

"I can't tell the difference either. It seems to make sense?"

"Anyway, I just don’t admit it! This is definitely changing the concept!"

Zhang San also frowned.

This week Kai is indeed very knowledgeable about copyright law and infringement cases.

These points seem to be a positive answer to Ye Qiu's words, but in fact they are all confusing concepts!

They even include attacks on Ye Qiu!

But.

You want to say that this is wrong?

In fact, you can't say.

After all, it is the tendency of the key judge.

And this is the most troublesome part of the plagiarism case.

Everyone can easily confuse the concept, because the defined concept itself is very vague. ,

Therefore.

The key is still the tendency of the presiding judge.

At this time, at the court hearing scene, at the trial seat,

Song Huanghuang took the materials and discussed in a low voice with Sun Zhiming and Wang Haiyue for a moment.

The three of them all have research on copyright, among them Sun Zhiming often tried infringement cases.

Soon,

Song Huanghuang felt that there was no problem.

As Zhou Kai said, no loopholes could be found.

Therefore, it was time to make a judgment.

So Song Huanghuang knocked the gavel and said

"Statements about the parties to the litigation"

"The collegial panel has sorted it out and can make a decision"

"That is: the profit model is a general recharge and exchange for virtual currency, and the auto-chess mode is an original gameplay. Neither of them is original."

"Therefore, on these two points, Emperor Enterprise does not constitute plagiarism!"

Seeing this scene.

Shendu.

Ma Huaxun nodded with satisfaction.

"Jia Anping, go and call Zhang Haocun, the manager of operations."

"The game Alliance Clash still has more krypton gold value that can be developed"

"After this lawsuit, we must continue to upgrade this IP and fully roll it out."

Ma Huaxun no longer pays attention to this lawsuit.

He has begun to make plans for the future of Emperor Enterprise.

How can Ye Qiu be so good?

At the home court of Blue Mountain.

He will not win after all.