Madman Zhang San: That Hammer, You Are Finished

Sha Yuliang slowly suppressed the uneasiness in his heart and stood on the high platform: "I will now announce that the plaintiff Du Haitao v. the defendant Feng Yuquan's civil tort case is now open for trial."

"Next, please explain the plaintiff's point of view based on the facts."

In the plaintiff's box, Song Yunian stood up in response, first glanced at the opposite side with a complicated expression, and then said, "Hello, Lord Judge."

"On the afternoon of August 3, 2022, my client Du Haitao's 11-year-old son Du Xiaoliang was playing near Du's house."

"It just so happens that the door of the nearby villager Feng Yuquan's house is unlocked."

"Du Xiaoliang went to the Feng's house to play and saw that there were two vines planted in the Feng's courtyard."

"Du Xiaoliang fell to the ground after picking grapes and was found to be poisoned by pesticides."

"And all of this was caused by Du Xiaoliang accidentally eating grapes that had been treated with pesticides at the home of the defendant Feng Yuquan."

"Based on the above facts, we demand the defendant to compensate one million yuan in compensation, and make an apology to Du Haitao's family in front of the village headquarters of Youshui Village!"

cough cough...

Sha Yuliang coughed lightly, looked at the defendant's seat and said, "Does the defendant have any objection to the plaintiff's accusation?"

He originally intended to hit the hammer, but think about it.

The third brother is here, give him a face.

Lin He slowly got up and said solemnly, "Comrade Judge, we do not agree with the accusations made by the plaintiff."

"The plaintiff just said that Du Xiaoliang was able to enter the Feng's house to play because the Feng's house was not locked that day."

"However, that afternoon, the Feng family and their wife were not at home, but went to the fields to do farm work, and there was no one else at home."

"Let me ask, who would go out without locking the door when there is no one at home? This is not common sense."

"Moreover, according to our client's recollection, the door of the house was locked that day."

"From this, it can be inferred that Du Xiaoliang's behavior was theft."

"It's just that because Du Xiaoliang was a minor and was already dead, we did not prosecute."

"Therefore, the plaintiff blamed Du Xiaoliang's death from poisoning on our side, which I think is very unreasonable."

Hearing this, the three of Sha Yuliang nodded secretly.

For the plaintiff in the case of touching porcelain by the family of the deceased, they also hate to see it.

But since the plaintiff has sued, the three of them, as judges, naturally have to do their jobs well.

In the Dragon Kingdom, there has been a saying that human life is greater than the sky since ancient times, and there have been cases of compensation before, and the three of them can only act according to the procedures.

According to the scene of the trial, which side's argument has the upper hand, choose to pronounce the verdict.

cough cough...

Sha Yuliang continued to ignore the small hammer at hand and coughed lightly: "Do the plaintiffs have any different objections to the defense lawyer's point of view?"

In the plaintiff's box, Song Yunian looked at Lin He with some confusion.

Considering whether to continue working with him.

Go ahead, it's a little dangerous. After all, the third brother is famous, and it is a common thing to send the opposite lawyer in.

Don't do it, you have already received the money, and the client is sitting next to him. If you just admit it, how should you explain it to the client?

For a while, Song Yunian had a hard time deciding.

Du Haitao looked at Song Yunian strangely and whispered, "Lawyer Song, come on, it's your turn!"

Song Yunian gave him a dissatisfied look, I don't know it's me, do I need you to remind me?

Ugh……

Song Yu sighed young, and finally reason overcomes fear.

Decided to continue working with Zhang San.

He asked himself that he had never done anything illegal in his life. At most, at some point, he would encourage his client to pay and sign the contract as soon as possible.

These little bugs are no big deal.

take me in?

There is no reason.

After thinking about this, Song Yunian felt a lot more relaxed and said, "Since the Feng's house is locked, how did Du Xiaoliang enter the Feng's house??"

"The defendant's lawyer is so certain that the Feng family was locked at the time. Do you have any evidence to prove this?"

Song Yunian also knew that the fault of this incident was still on his side.

However, since he is the plaintiff's agent, it doesn't matter who is right and who is at fault, what matters is how he can win the case.

As long as the defendant could not produce evidence that the Feng family had locked the door at that time, they would be partially responsible for Du Xiaoliang's death.

After all, the poisonous grapes were in the defendant's house, and the door was not locked. Isn't this objectively creating certain dangerous conditions.

Hearing this, Lin He smiled lightly: "No matter how good the lock is, it can't stop a thoughtful thief."

"As I said just now, no one in the Feng family was at home at the time. Do you think they would not lock the door? This is not common sense, right?"

"Since you want to question something that is obviously unreasonable, please show the evidence that the Feng family's door was unlocked at that time."

This……

Song Yunian's face was aching. He originally wanted to dig a hole for the defendant, but he didn't expect to bury himself.

They have evidence that the woolen door is unlocked.

The reason why I said this just now is to argue with the defendant. Even if the argument fails, at least let the judge on the stage know that this matter is suspicious.

When the judgment comes, let the judge take this factor into consideration and assign certain responsibilities to the defendant.

Lin He smiled and said to the stage: "Comrade Judge, I think you must be wondering at this moment. Since the Feng's house is locked, how did Du Xiaoliang enter the Feng's house?"

"I have two photos of Feng's gate here. Maybe after reading it, you will have the answer."

Lin He said, took out the pre-printed color photo, and gestured to Sha Yuliang.

Sha Yuliang said without hesitation, "Post a photo!"

The clerk ran all the way, took the photo from Lin He and sent it to Sha Yuliang.

In the first photo, it is a dilapidated gate, with a small door in the gate, tied by a small iron chain.

Compared with the first photo, the second photo has an extra big hand. The big hand pushes the small door, the small iron chain is straightened, and the small door is also left with a gap of more than ten centimeters.

After seeing the photo, Sha Yuliang stared at Lin He suspiciously, not knowing what he meant.

Lin He explained with a smile, "There is only one truth. The gate of Feng's house is dilapidated. If you usually go out, the small door for people to go in and out is tied with a small iron chain."

"Although it is locked, it is not easy to use."

"As long as you push with your hand, you can push open a gap."

"According to this inference, Du Xiaoliang should have sneaked into Feng's house through this gap that day."

After hearing this explanation, Sha Yuliang nodded secretly.

Although the explanation of the defendant is complicated, it is also in line with common sense.

No, it is very common sense.