Monster Girl Sanctuary

I carried May Belle into Tater Town, giving not a single fuck about the strange looks we got from the other monster girls out and about as I took my gorgeous holstaur to Scalia's inn. The musty tavern-like interior had a few patrons sitting down for an afternoon meal. Among them was Jacob Mercer, the older breeder who sat between a lizard girl and what looked to be a hawk girl. He nodded at me with a smile and got right back to his own canoodling.

"We'll need your best room," I said, beaming at Scalia.

"How you gonna pay this time?" she asked, her forked tongue flicking suggestively.

"We've got a crop of moon-tubers growing on the farm. Trade you a full sack of them."

Her eyes widened with interest. "How soon?"

"Damn soon," I grinned. "Ivy, the wood elf you've seen around town with me, can make plants grow faster and make it rain on our plot every day."

She smiled back and looked over at May Belle. "You're about to be made the luckiest girl in Tater Town, aren't ya?"

She could scarcely speak. This whole time, May Belle had been cooing, giggling, and writhing in my arms, planting kiss after kiss on any part of me she could reach. "...All my holes," she muttered, drool dribbling down her chin.

"Yep, that's what I figured," Scalia giggled, hand over her mouth. "By the look of you, either you were about to get marked or it's your birthday."

She handed us the key and we made our way into the room. It was the same room we'd shared before, with Daisy and Autumn, so I felt comfortable already. I laid May Belle down on the bed and noticed with some shame that I never gave her the chance to put her top back on. her bare, unicorn spit-soaked titties were exposed this whole time, leaking droplets of cream every few steps or so. I thanked God that Mercer didn't notice.

"Shit," I groaned at the epiphany.

"What?!" May Belle asked, instantly tense and frantic. "Why are you looking at my boobs like that? Don't you like them? Oh my gods, am I fucking up already? Oh, Bucky-Baby what's--"

I placed a finger on her lips and grinned. "No, it's not any of that. You're perfect. I just forgot to let you put your top all the way back on before I took you here."

"Oh," she said, her muscles instantly relaxing, melting again in my arms like butter under a summer sun. "Who fucking cares?"

"Right," I nodded, ripping off her bottoms as well. The buxom holstaur was now entirely exposed to me, and she instinctively parted her legs, desperate for me to take in the sight of her.

"It's all for you. Every inch, every... hole. I'm all yours, Bucky-Baby." Her little cow ears flicked happily, and her tail whipped back and forth, at least the part of it that she wasn't lying against.

She lay there on the simple straw mattress, inviting me with her eyes to have my way with her body. She looked just like a goddess. Her full breasts were a healthy color and perfectly round, capped by pink nipples that seemed to beckon me. They were as soft and bouncy as pillows, begging to be touched and worshiped. Her flat tummy and skinny waist led to her beautiful, long legs. Between those perfect legs was her gushing pussy, already dripping thick girlcum onto the sheets.

My cock, which had been hard since I got her alone in this room, began to pulse with excitement. Tearing off my clothes, I grabbed her hips and pulled her closer to me.

"You wanna hear something interesting, Bucky-Baby?" she giggled.

"What is it?" I asked, groaning as my tip grazed her opening.

"I just noticed today that we've been getting XP whenever you fuck us--this whole time."

My dick went soft. Not out of lack of arousal--it's just that this revelation was so monumentally important that every other part of my body besides my brain had basically just shut down.

"How long have you known this?" I asked, trying not to freak out. Autumn would murder her if it turned out to be more than a day.

"I noticed it this morning, after you left. I checked my HUD because Daisy said she gained two levels and didn't know why. It was the same for me. I'm level 6 now."

"This is huge!" I said, trying not to freak out.

She leaned forward and tugged on my cock. "No, this is huge. Fuck me, Bucky-Baby."

Right. I needed to get my mind back on track. This would have to wait until we were finished here. I grinned down at her and she melted at the look I gave her, moaning as my cock slid inside. Slowly, I worked my way in deeper and deeper, savoring the feel of her tight pussy wrapped around my shaft. With each push, I started to pick up speed, sawing into her cunt with all the force I could muster. 

"Fuck me, Bucky-Baby! Oh my gods, you're so big! So deep!" May Belle shrieked like an animal, and her hands flew to my shoulders, clutching me tightly as I booked her a ticket on the pleasure train.

I kept going, not wanting to slow down for even a second. My heart raced, my lungs burned, but I couldn't stop. I felt my stomach muscles tighten as I continued to pump my hips, driving myself in and out of her. I noticed the telltale signs of her first climax of the session: the eyes rolling back, the tongue starting to peek out from the lips, and, of course, the lewd clenching of her pussy walls.

"Oh fuck!" she gasped. "I'm gonna cum already! I can't help it, Bucky-Baby!"

"Me too, May Belle," I grunted, and it was the gospel truth. Hearing the sounds of her desperate cries of ecstasy was enough to send any hot-blooded straight guy driving straight over the edge of climax with a foot slammed down on the proverbial gas pedal.

"Oh by Paragon's love, Bucky-Baby!" she screamed. Her cum mixed with mine as I shot load after load into her womb. She kept squealing and wriggling for minutes after I'd already cooled down, tugging lightly on my hair and wrapping her legs around my back to keep me inside her once she sensed I'd finished.

"I love you Bucky-Baby, more than anything," she said. "More than the gods. I don't care if it's blasphemy. I just love you so much."

I kissed her softly, feeling her tongue practically melt in my mouth. We lay there together, our hearts beating in the synchronized rhythm of one another.

"That was amazing," she sighed.

"That was round one of three," I grinned.

She smiled coquettishly back at me. "I wanna tittyfuck you until you're about to cum, and then just stick it right in my mouth, okay?"

Holy shit. I'd never been tittyfucked before. "You got it," I said, and she pushed me back on the bed, and soon she was on top of me. May Belle's massive mammaries easily entombed my beefy cock between them. Her puffy, perky nipples pressed against my thighs, and she spit a big sticky gob of her saliva on my cock and her boobs, adding lubrication. With all her cum still on my dick, I wasn't sure how necessary that was, but the gesture was greatly appreciated.

Being fucked by a holstaur's breasts is a truly special experience. As if the combined juices of our lovemaking and her spit weren't enough, she pressed so tightly on her tits as she stroked my cock between them that milk was gushing from her teats, soaking me, soaking the bed, and soaking my cock.

"By the gods, baby, I'm making such a mess," she whined, clearly mortified.

"Fuck, this is the best," I said. "Make all the mess you want."

Clearly encouraged by that, she picked up the pace, and I felt my cock being further stimulated by her flapping fun bags. All that hot cream and spit was making wet smacking noises as she stroked me off with her cleavage. The sensation was incredible, as you might expect, but the sight of it was even more exquisite, and I began to moan with pleasure and the heat of my arousal, my balls tightening, my cock already twitching to signal its defeat. I couldn't believe it, but I was already about to cum. I had to warn her.

"May Belle, I--" but she knew. Somehow she knew before I said it, and my cock was inside her mouth, all the way down. I released my seed into her gullet, and she swallowed every drop without even choking, keeping her lips locked around my shaft the entire time.

"Mmmmmm," she moaned around my cock before finally lifting her head and licking her lips. "That's good, Bucky-Baby. I wish I could do it again."

"There'll be time for that later," I grinned as my hands started shifting her body around. "Now I have to make love to your bubbly butt." Her tail accidentally slapped me in the face as I positioned myself behind her, and she apologized profusely, but I just laughed.

I pulled her gently toward me, letting her get used to the feeling of my length between her butt cheeks. I pried her cheeks apart, looking down at her cute pink rosebud. I rubbed my cockhead against it, prodding it gently at first, feeling out whether or not I still had enough moisture on my dick for this to be easy enough for her to handle. I decided I did, and I pushed my hips forward, watching and feeling as my cock disappeared into the gorgeous holstaur's clenching rectum.

"Ooooh!" May Belle groaned. "That hurts a bit, baby!"

I kept pushing, slowly, trying to give her a chance to adjust. Her anus was tight, but eventually I felt it relax, and I slid my cock all the way in. That feeling of being fully sleeved inside her, my balls slapping her cunt as my dick bottomed out in her ass--it was a winning sensation.

I started moving again, slowly, and May Belle began to wiggle her bum back and forth, urging me on. I picked up the pace, fucking her hard and fast, feeling my cock getting somehow even stiffer inside her. My arousal was at its peak, but I didn't want to cum yet. I kept the pace slow and deliberate, feeling her loosen and tighten around my dick with each thrust. She yipped like a lovesick puppy as I defiled her pucker, and the thought of how dirty this was urged me even closer to orgasm. Before I knew it, there was nothing I could do but cum.

I felt my cock throbbing. The final moment had arrived. I was about to mark my beloved May Belle. Times like these, I had to be grateful for the Harem Knight feat. Spending six loads in one afternoon? Utterly insane. Borderline inhuman. And yet here I was, shotgunning jism into two unique cunts, assholes, and mouths in a single day. What a life I lead.

"It's happening now, May Belle," I groaned as the first globs of my jizz flooded her asshole.

"I love you so much," she cried, weeping openly with joy. As I unloaded fully, her eyes lit up, blasting light out that shot through the windows, and I knew the act was done. She was officially mine.

We fell onto the bed, holding one another tightly, sharing kisses and speaking words of love and promises of forever. I loved all my girls, but I was truly hopelessly smitten with May Belle. It wasn't that she was my favorite, but if there was only one of them I could pick as the mother of my children, it would be her. I shared this with her, and she cried so hard and so loud that I worried someone might come in to check on us.

"Shhhh don't cry," I said. "I meant it in a good way."

"I knooow," she whined, burying her face in my neck. "I'm just so happy!"

Suddenly the door to our room slammed open, and five women collapsed inward, landing on top of each other in a pile. Autumn, Rainbow Sprinkle, Etherea, Ivy, and Daisy had all been listening to our lovemaking the entire time. I sighed, somehow unsurprised at the revelation.

"Congratulations!" I heard Autumn's voice yell from the bottom of the pile, muffled against Rainbow Sprinkle's heavy white tit.

May Belle's crying broke into laughter. And I, too, couldn't hold back a smirk at the absurdity of it. "Okay, everyone," I started. "Let's get an early dinner. And then let's have a conversation about reasonable expectations of privacy."

virgilknightley