Subverting the Classics: from Journey to the West

　　"It seems that most of the audience can't wait any longer. Well, I'll follow the theme of today that I said after class yesterday, and come to explain it to everyone."

　　After he finished speaking, he opened the courseware with multimedia, and put the following line on the big screen: "The Prosperity and Decline of Jia's Mansion in a Dream of Red Mansions".

　　"In the last class, we talked about this point, but because the get out of class is over, it will be a topic today.

　　In A Dream of Red Mansions, Jia's mansion was very prosperous in the early stage, and then the ending was very miserable, and the prosperity must decline. This is probably the intention of the author's deliberate arrangement.

　　Most people look at the Dream of Red Mansions and think that the previous writing is very good, but I think it is a vulgar opinion. Those who don’t pretend to understand will say so. In fact, the real essence of Dream of Red Mansions is the latter part. Why do I say this, it is natural There is a reason. "

　　(About the part of Dream of Red Mansions, I won’t write too much in the original text, and it is estimated that everyone is not interested, so I will write it around ghostwriting, and everyone can understand it.) Zero.

Chapter 99

　　(This part of the story will not describe too much of the original text, and everyone can understand it.)

　　Wang Chunlai began to explain, and told a lot of stories about the original text. He was full of emotions, and time passed before he knew it.

　　After talking about more than half of it, Wang Chunlai took a sip of water and then continued: "Back to the topic, first of all, the story told by Dream of Red Mansions is, on the surface, the situation of Jia's mansion from prosperity to decline.

　　In academia, there are many people who say that the first [-] palindrome are well written, beautifully written, and fascinating, but they think that the latter [-] palindrome are not good, and even have some conflicts with the previous article, they are considered to be unfinished works.

　　However, what I want to tell my classmates today is that the first [-] chapters of A Dream of Red Mansions are well written, but the real essence is the last [-] chapters.

　　It seems that there is some conflict between the writing and the previous article, but the author is using this method to set off prosperity and decline. This is the author's good intentions. Unfortunately, not many people can detect it, but say that what he wrote later is not good. , is really sighing. "

　　Having said this, Wang Chunlai sighed, believing that the writer was misunderstood, and felt sad for him. There are not many people like him who can understand the author's heart.

　　"Hey, I really remember the plot in Houlou Dream, it's really a pity."

　　"Sadly, the ending of this famous novel is really not very good, it is much more tragic and solemn than the other three famous novels."

　　"Is it really like what Professor Wang Chunlai said, it's actually the author's intentional actions. No wonder I didn't feel right when I read the book before."

　　……

　　At this moment, Zhang Yulan sat next to Qin Yu and asked in a low voice, "Mr. Qin Yu, do you have any opinions? I always feel that what Professor Wang said is wrong, and I don't agree."

　　After hearing this, Qin Yu smiled slightly, then looked at Wang Chunlai on the podium and said, "Professor Wang, I have a different opinion from yours. I think the following forty chapters cannot deny their literary value, but they are written in It's really not as good as the previous article, and there are still many conflicts in the plot. For example, it can be seen from the previous article that Qiaoer should be married to Ban'er, but later it is written that he married a rich man.

　　Moreover, in the TV series, it was adapted that she was sold into a brothel by her uncle, and was finally rescued by Grandma Liu.

　　Also, it was hinted in the previous article that Lin Daiyu's ending should be to become the princess of the North, but she died in the end. "

　　Qin Yu directly threw out two opinions, ready to see what this Wang Chunlai would say.

　　"Okay, Teacher Qin Yu is starting to attack!"

　　"That's what I've been waiting for. If Teacher Qin Yu doesn't speak the whole time, then there's still something to watch?"

　　"Hahaha, I feel like a fierce debate is about to begin!"

　　"Although I also like Mr. Qin Yu very much, what Professor Wang Chunlai said seems to be a mainstream cognition in the academic world. It seems that Mr. Qin Yu's point of view is not correct?"

　　……

　　After Qin Yu opened his mouth, the barrage in the live broadcast room became more lively, and the number of viewers had risen from a few hundred thousand at the beginning to more than [-] million.

　　After Wang Chunlai heard Qin Yu's words, he smiled slightly and said, "Isn't Mr. Qin Yu's point of view exactly what I just said?

　　Some people think that the previous text is better than the latter, but they cannot appreciate the author's good intentions. It is through this contradictory way of writing that the author sets off a style in the text and makes the ending unexpected for everyone. A sense of disparity. "

　　He was a little smug in his heart, he just said this question, he didn't expect Qin Yu to directly post it like this to make him slap in the face, it made him feel very comfortable.

　　At first he thought that Qin Yu was really here to pick on the thorns, could it be that Qin Yu was here to flatter him on purpose? !

　　"This is a bit interesting. It seems that Teacher Qin Yu's point of view is the same as those who are non-mainstream people who discuss red studies, and they all think that the latter text is not acceptable."

　　"Unfortunately, Professor Wang Chunlai's interpretation seems to be true, and the hidden methods of these literati are generally invisible."

　　"I have also read the relevant materials. What Professor Wang Chunlai said is indeed recognized by the current academic circles. What Teacher Qin Yu said is a non-mainstream view, which is basically denied, and there is a lot of controversy."

　　"Mr. Qin Yu's interpretation of Journey to the West is very wrong, but are you not familiar with the Dream of Red Mansions?"

　　……

　　Many people began to question Qin Yu. After all, Qin Yu was only in his twenties, and he was able to study the book Journey to the West. Not on the level of a professor, it's justified...  

　　At this moment, Zhang Yulan below frowned and said, "Professor Wang, I have the same opinion as Teacher Qin Yu. This is already very controversial. I feel that it is not good for you to make a direct conclusion like this?"

　　"The beautiful school girl has spoken!"

　　"Okay, does this school girl like Teacher Qin Yu, otherwise how can you support Teacher Qin Yu?"

　　"It's interesting, someone has stood up to support Teacher Qin Yu."

　　……

　　Wang Chunlai adjusted his glasses and said with a smile: "Very good, it is very good for young people to have their own opinions, but sometimes insisting is not always right, being stubborn and unable to accept the real statement, this kind of spirit On the contrary, it is pedantic and should be paid attention to.”

　　After saying this, Qin Yu also laughed and said, "I feel that this is the most suitable word for you, Professor Wang."

　　He has no scruples anymore. He had looked down on Wang Chunlai after hearing about Wang Chunlai's views. Now that it has been confirmed, there is no need for him to continue to keep secrets.

　　However, after he said these words, there was a lot of commotion in the classroom and in the live broadcast room.

　　"Fuck, this is starting to rage?!"

　　"Mr. Qin Yu is really just, if you don't agree, you will open up!"

　　"Hahaha, there is a good show to watch!"

　　"Okay, I'm not a team in this wave, let's see who is more powerful."

　　... ...

　　The students in the classroom were also in an uproar. This was the first time they had encountered this situation. The two teachers in the school actually quarreled in front of the students in the classroom?

　　Wang Chunlai's expression darkened slightly at the moment, and he said in a low voice, "Mr. Qin Yu, what I said is the mainstream recognition in the academic world. If you have a new point of view that can overthrow me, I will gladly accept it.

　　But if not, please don't make trouble, this is my class. "

　　His words were already an order to evict guests. He wanted to dare Qin Yu to go out, and he was not allowed to continue making trouble.

　　After listening to Qin Yu, he said lightly: "The dignified generation of professors, such a large literary organization, even put a ghost-written article on the altar, but belittles the previous article written by the original author, it is ridiculous!".

Chapter 100

　　After saying this.The classroom, which was originally a little noisy, suddenly became silent.

　　Everyone was stunned, looking at Qin Yu in shock, the boss staring, his face full of incredulity.

　　"What did Teacher Qin Yu just say?"

　　"The back is ghostwriting?!"

　　"Fuck, how is this possible, is it true?"

　　"I'll go, if Teacher Qin Yu doesn't speak, he will have an earthquake when he speaks!"

　　Everyone was stunned. He didn't expect Qin Yu to say such a sentence. He actually thought that the following article was not written by the original author of Dream of Red Mansions, but was written by a ghost! !

　　This sentence is like a blockbuster, making everyone unable to calm down.

　　At this moment, Wang Chunlai on the podium was also taken aback by Qin Yu's words. He did not expect Qin Yu to say such a thing.

　　He gave a low voice and said, "Qin Yu, you are too bold, Dream of Red Mansions is a literary masterpiece, created by a great writer, do you think it is something you can defile, hurry up and take back your nonsense, otherwise you are going to tell the author Apologize!"

　　"It's ridiculous, you've been belittling the original author for a long time here, and you're holding the article written by a substitute writer, I think it's you who really wants to make amends, right?

　　At present, some of the statements about the Dream of Red Mansions are just disputes, just a few different opinions. You make a random conclusion without understanding anything, and you even use it to give lectures to college students. Don't you think it's misleading? "

　　"You!" Wang Chunlai was furious, this Qin Yu was simply too arrogant, and his ability to confuse right and wrong is somewhat formidable.

　　"It's still the original recipe, it's still the familiar taste!"

　　"Haha, I believe Teacher Qin Yu, since he dares to say it, it is impossible for him to have no evidence. He must have grasped some viewpoints!"

　　"The upstairs is right. From watching Teacher Qin Yu's live broadcast before, it can be inferred that Mr. Qin Yu is definitely not someone who is open-mouthed. Every point of his has hard evidence!"

　　"Everyone, don't trust blindly. This kind of thing still needs to be based on evidence. If it is really ghostwriting, how can the current mainstream cognition in academia be like this? Let's be rational."

　　"Yes, I still think what Professor Wang said is right."

　　In the live broadcast room, there were differences. Some people thought that since Qin Yu dared to say it, he must have evidence. Some people thought that Qin Yu could not provide evidence. Otherwise, how could the academic world not know about it, and he was the only one who knew?

　　……

　　Qin Yu said again at this moment: "The first eighty chapters of A Dream of Red Mansions are truly masterpieces written by Master Cao Xueqin, and the next forty chapters were written by his contemporaries, which is why the preceding and following chapters are created. Some of the conflicts, because it was not written by an author, of course there are conflicts!

　　And the TV series version of A Dream of Red Mansions is also quite different from the original in some places. That's because the screenwriter should have the same guess as me, and he adapted the story that follows!

　　It is undeniable that the literary value of the later ghostwriting is still not low, but it is ridiculous for you people to bring a ghostwritten article to the altar, but belittle the original author's article. "

　　On the side, Zhang Yulan was also surprised. She originally didn't agree with Professor Wang's statement, but she never thought about ghostwriting. Now, hearing Qin Yu's words, it seems quite reasonable!

　　Wang Chunlai was angry at the moment, and shouted: "It's nonsense, do you have any evidence, if you don't have any evidence, it's complete nonsense!"

　　"Well said, I also know that it is nonsense without evidence. It seems that there is still some rationality. Since you say so, then I would like to ask, the style and plot of a book are very different. Is this the possibility of ghostwriting? Is it more sexual, or is it more likely that the author deliberately changes his methods?

　　A Dream of Red Mansions is inherently controversial. You made a conclusion without evidence, yet you dare to say that other people's more reasonable guesses are nonsense? "

　　"you!"

　　Wang Chunlai's face turned red with anger, but he found that he couldn't argue, because what Qin Yu said was right, although what he said was mainstream knowledge, but there was still not much evidence, it was just speculation!

　　In the class, all the students were shocked, and they did not expect the situation to develop to this level.

　　Teacher Qin Yu's words were sharp, and Professor Wang Chunlai was completely speechless, angry that his face was red and his neck was thick!

　　"Ring bell bell bell!"

　　Just at this moment, the get out of class bell rang suddenly, making everyone recover from the tense atmosphere.

　　"Fuck, this get out of class is over, it's too fast!"

　　"That is, I haven't watched it yet. Who is right and who is wrong between these two people?"

　　"Absolutely, this debate is really exciting, Teacher Qin Yu is so impassioned, this Professor Wang Chunlai can't even let a fart out!"

　　"Let's be rational. Before there is no evidence, no one can say that the later texts of Dream of Red Mansions were written by ghostwriters. This is indeed an insult to the author!"