Subverting the Classics: from Journey to the West

　　However, at this moment, a cold voice suddenly came from outside the door:

　　"I don't agree with Teacher Qin Yu's statement that the structure of nine times twelve is the same. The watershed in the structure of the writing you mentioned is probably just a coincidence, not even the author's intention. Rigorous, giving people such an illusion, the red academia has long concluded that Mr. Cao Xueqin made a mistake in writing due to a serious illness in his later years or other reasons, so all the reasons for the changes in the plot were created.

　　Therefore, it is not impossible for Gao E to obtain the original manuscript of Master Cao Xueqin for creation, on the contrary, it is very likely ' '! "

　　From outside the door, a man in a Chinese tunic suit walked in. The man was in his fifties and was looking at Qin Yu with a serious face.

　　"Professor Lin?"

　　Wang Chunlai looked overjoyed at this moment. The person here was his old friend and eldest brother, one of the researchers in the red academia, Lin Dongshan!

　　He quickly got up to give up his seat to Lin Dongshan.

　　He didn't expect Lin Dongshan to come here, and he also came to question Qin Yu?

　　This made him overjoyed. After so many days of fermenting the Red Mansions incident, finally a researcher of red studies stood up!

　　"I know this person. I saw him speak on the Red Chamber on TV before."

　　"Yes, I've seen him before. This person is considered an authority in the academic world, and his prestige is very strong."

　　"Before, he made many questioning people speechless!"

　　The audience in the live broadcast room was surprised. I didn't expect that the people from the red academia finally came. It seems that they are not ready to accept Qin Yu's statement so easily.

　　"Professor Lin?" Qin Yu smiled at this moment, and the people who came were more authoritative.

　　Afterwards, he said sternly: "I don't want to understand what the red academia thinks, and I don't agree with it. I only know that the ghostwriting said that I proposed it. Before I proposed it, you even praised the last forty times as Classic, considered to be the masterpiece of master Cao Xueqin.

　　Whatever question you ask, I can explain it for you to prove my point. "

　　Lin Dongshan had his hands on his back at the moment, his expression was indifferent, and he said lightly: "It's true that you brought it up in ghostwriting, but I still want to say that you are wrong, because I still think that the last forty times are the essence of life. soul."

　　That's right, he came this time to overthrow Qin Yu's point of view and save the previous mainstream recognition in the red academia.

　　How could they be overthrown by a [-]-something-year-old boy who has been studying for decades in the academic world!

　　"Haha." Qin Yu laughed, expressing incomprehensible.

　　Lin Dongshan said at the moment: "Let's not mention this matter for now, just follow what you said, can you explain everything clearly?"

　　"That's right, but it's only the first eighty episodes, and it's roughly." Qin Yu said.

　　After hearing this, Lin Dongshan said, "Okay, then, let me ask Mr. Qin Yu, how would you explain the time of Lin Ruhai's death?"

　　On the side, after listening to Wang Chunlai, he immediately said: "I also want to ask one question, Qin Keqing's illness and death are inconsistent with the unearthed documents and judgments, as well as Jia's mother's birthday, including Jia Baoyu's age and..."

　　As if he had found a backer, his confidence became higher, and he asked so many questions in one go, questioning Qin Yu.

　　He sneered in his heart at the moment, Qin Yu literally shot himself in the foot. The structure of the text he just said was logical and rigorous, but he dared to explain everything he could say. Isn't this courting death?

　　These are questions that the red academia has not been able to come to a conclusion after so many years of research, can he answer them?

　　If he can answer a fart, it depends on how he makes a fool of himself!

　　The audience were all excited at the moment, can Teacher Qin Yu answer it?

　　You must know that these questions are indeed very difficult. Now the red academia has not researched them. Can Teacher Qin Yu do it?

　　Qin Yu smiled lightly at the moment, and said, ".. Okay, then I'll give you an answer today."

　　In fact, Qin Yu knew for a long time what questions these two people were asking. After all, there are only a few of the researches on Hongxue, and there are only a few that are logically wrong. Even if they ask questions, there is nothing.

　　Qin Yu continued: "Jia Yingchun is a person everyone is familiar with, and everyone knows about her life experience. If she is really someone who likes to watch the Dream of Red Mansions, if you study it carefully, you will find a problem, then Even in the ancient books that have been handed down on the market today, the description of Jia Yingchun's life experience is completely different.

　　The second young lady was pardoned by her father's ex-wife.

　　The second lady came from the pardon of the father's wife.

　　The second lady is from the ex-wife of Zheng's father.

　　The second lady was sent by the concubine of the pardoned father.

　　The second miss is the daughter of the pardoned father, and the political father raised it as his own daughter. "

　　After Qin Yu said this, Lin Dongshan and Wang Chunlai were both slightly puzzled, wondering what Qin Yu meant when he said this.

　　These things, they naturally know, they are the researchers of Dream of Red Mansions, it is impossible if they don't even know this.

　　However, this is rather biased, and in their opinion, it is not an important role, so they did not conduct research, and there are many logical problems in Dream of Red Mansions, and the larger logical problems are not understood. Who will study this? .

Chapter 112

　　They didn't know what Qin Yu meant when he said this now.

　　After Qin Yu finished speaking at this moment, he continued: "The descriptions of these five ancient texts are all different, what is the reason for this?

　　We all know that the sources of the ancient manuscripts of the Red Chambers are all based on the corresponding basis. Could it be that it was copied by hand?

　　Obviously, this is even more impossible. The first four are short sentences, and the last one is a long sentence. How could this be a copying error? Could it be that the eyes of the people who copied it were made by bull's eyes, and the long and short sentences could not be discerned?

　　Therefore, since it is not hand-written, and the ancient manuscripts are based on the source, then there is only one fundamental reason for this situation, that is, Cao Xueqin is reconsidering, revising back and forth, and has not yet thought about it, and has not finalized it. So we will be able to see so many versions in the future.

　　This, I believe you should have no doubts, right? "

　　After Qin Yu finished speaking, Lin Dongshan and Wang Chunlai thought for a while, and they really had no doubts about this.

　　Seeing that no one had any doubts, Qin Yu continued: "In this case, with this basic understanding, all the problems you raised just now have been solved, and there is no problem at all.

　　Cao Xueqin was not seriously ill in his later years, so the writing of the last forty chapters of A Dream of Red Mansions was messed up, because there were inconsistencies from the very beginning, there are so many versions, do you want to say that Cao Xueqin was ill when he first started writing the book Too heavy to write a book?

　　Therefore, these are due to the fact that Master Cao Xueqin did not finalize the draft and revised it repeatedly, which caused these problems.Including the time of Lin Hairu's death, Qin Keqing's illness and death, and the issue of the fifth album judgment.

　　In fact, these put it bluntly, it only involves the modification of the ending of individual characters and some simple text changes, and does not affect the overall situation. "

　　After Qin Yu's voice fell, Lin Dongshan said, "Didn't you say that you have finished writing a dream of Red Mansions in a total of [-] chapters?"

　　"Yes, it's almost finished, but does it mean the draft is finalized?

　　I would like to ask, even if you have finished writing a composition and thesis, you need to revise it repeatedly until you are satisfied, not to mention Cao Xueqin's masterpiece, Dream of the Red Chamber? "

　　As soon as these words came out, everyone nodded their heads one after another. This is indeed the truth. How can it be said that a book with so many words (bgaa) has been finalized. According to the rigorous style of these literati, it is indeed impossible.

　　After Wang Chunlai listened, he frowned slightly, thinking about how to refute Qin Yu.

　　On the side, Lin Dongshan said directly: "If you say so, then the logical errors of the last eighty episodes can also be explained as you said. Master Cao Xueqin has not finalized the draft, which is why this result is caused. How can you say that it was written by Gao E himself?"

　　After saying this sentence, Wang Chunlai's eyes suddenly lit up. This sentence is wonderful. Lin Dongshan is indeed a researcher of red science, and his thoughts are faster than his.

　　"This person is really amazing. It's really a trick to use Teacher Qin Yu's words to refute Teacher Qin Yu."

　　"This person is not to be underestimated. He used to be so impassioned on TV that many people were overshadowed."

　　"This time, Teacher Qin Yu may have really met an opponent!"

　　Everyone is very interested, this is getting more and more lively, it looks very intense, and they want to know if Qin Yu can continue to prove it.

　　After Qin Yu heard Lin Dongshan's words, he immediately smiled and said, "Professor Lin, what you said was just to raise the bar.

　　The mistakes before the [-]th chapter and the logic mistakes after the [-]th chapter are not the same concept at all, they are fundamentally different.

　　Eighty times before, I have just said that it can be rounded up with only a few byte changes. This is the performance of the unfinalized draft.

　　And the next forty chapters can be changed not only by changing a few bytes, but even a paragraph. This involves the core ideological issue of the whole book, which is quite different from the previous two completely different ideological styles.

　　For example, Cao Xueqin first wrote that Jia's house fell into a white land that was pure and pure, but suddenly it became a revival of Jia's family. Jia's mother was originally a loving grandmother, but the author suddenly wrote her as a cold parent.

　　Jia Baoyu was originally the most incompetent in the world and did not want to make progress, but the author finally wanted to make him shine.

　　This is completely contrary to the tone of the previous article. The core idea of ​​the whole film is completely wrong. Master Cao Xueqin originally wanted to describe a person who sees through the world, but suddenly turned into a person who is keen on fame and honors his ancestors. "

　　Qin Yu was impassioned, and after throwing out the contextual comparisons one after another, Lin Dongshan was temporarily speechless.

　　After Qin Yu finished speaking, he said again: "In other words, let's think about it from different perspectives. If you have finished writing a book, if you want to revise some details, will you completely change the core idea of ​​the whole book? , and it has changed so abruptly?"

　　When the words fell, there was silence in the classroom, all Qin Yu said nothing to say, and there was no questioning voice, all were conquered by Qin Yu!

　　However, Lin Dongshan calmed down at the moment and continued: "In the question I just asked, you did not answer the question about Jia's age."

　　Qin Yu nodded and said, "Yes, this question needs to be addressed separately, because this question is very special and different from the previous questions."

　　After hearing this, Lin Dongshan raised his brows and asked, "What's so special, isn't it a matter of age and birthday?"

　　"First of all, the question of Mother Jia's birthday, is it the third day of the eighth lunar month on the [-]st, or the Lantern Festival on the [-]nd?

　　The two original texts are completely contradictory, but I think that, according to the coincidence of Baochai's birthday, the birthday of the [-]nd time after the Festival of Lights is the birthday that matches the prototype.

　　This is also described in the thirty-ninth chapter of Jia's mother: old relatives, how old are you this year?

　　Grandma Liu hurriedly answered: I am seventy-five this year.

　　Mother Jia added: "I'm so old, still so healthy, how many years older than me, I don't know how I can't move at such an old age."

　　Here, it is also indicated that Jia's mother is only seventy-four years old, but the text of the seventy-one chapters says that the third day of the eighth lunar month is the celebration of Jia's eighty-nine.

　　At this moment, according to what Qin Yu said, Wang Chunlai hurriedly flipped through the original book and found that it was indeed the case.

　　"So, I can conclude that the third day of the eighth lunar month is the birthday of the editor, the eighty-year-old birthday? This age is integrated, fictitious, and obviously not the real birthday age of Jia's mother. Therefore, the seventy-one texts are Changed later!

　　This is why I just said that I can only explain general logical errors, because the texts and ancient manuscripts of the previous [-] chapters have been lost and tampered with by others. ".

Chapter 113

　　"This section, like the rest of it, is missing. It was written by Gao E and added by himself. That's why there are such obvious mistakes. This flaw is different from the previous one, so it's naturally very special."

　　After saying all this, all the audience were deeply impressed.

　　Look sideways, sigh silently, think it is wonderful!

　　What Qin Yu said was very rigorous, logically clear, and well-founded, so people had to be convinced.

　　In particular, Qin Yu can directly say a certain paragraph or even a certain sentence without even reading the original text, which is simply amazing.

　　This is definitely a great scholar, and only those who have studied the Dream of the Red Chamber in-depth can show it. They also need to have a super memory. Even a master-level researcher of red studies cannot do this level, because there are light and heavy, and the whole article There are so many words, it is impossible to memorize them all, but Qin Yu can!

　　Qin Yu was only proficient in Journey to the West. It can be said that he has devoted himself to researching it for many years, but who would have thought that he could master the Dream of Red Mansions so well, and it was almost the same as Journey to the West. It was amazing!

　　At this moment, Lin Dongshan was silent, and he frowned slightly. He had already seen Qin Yu's eloquence and his interpretation of the Dream of Red Mansions from watching Qin Yu's live broadcast on the Internet, but he still underestimated Qin Yu. Whether this person is comprehension, reasoning or not Memory ability is first class!

　　Lin Dongshan breathed a sigh of relief at this moment, and then said: "These are all your analysis, and I personally deduce that even if they can come back, it is not enough to explain the problem. I still think that Gao E got Cao Xueqin's original manuscript for creation, to put it bluntly. It is hand-copied, although there are various flaws, but it is harmless~.