The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 227 Where there are old people, there must be Qin Mu
The son is in the critical stage of high school again.

Buying learning materials, taking tutoring classes and the like all require a lot of expenses.

them……

Never get into this kind of trouble again.

If it is really impossible to shirk the responsibility of support, then they should also bear the smallest part.

after all……

Among the four sons, their family is the worst.

It should be less.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng.

A school, staff dormitory.

Jiang Siping returned home with a puzzled face.

"This lawyer...is he really sick?"

He frowned, puzzled.

I just went to the law firm and wanted to consult legal aid.

but……

This lawyer seemed to dislike him very much.

In other words, if the level is not good, this problem cannot be solved at all.

Even the money went back the same way and got it back.

That is to say...

He ran for nothing today.

Nothing was solved.

"Didn't the lawyer say anything?"

After listening to his story, his wife couldn't help persuading her, "Why don't we call Mom?"

Jiang Siping turned around.

Glancing at his wife, he said impatiently: "How many times have I told you that you can't make a call, you can't make a call, this call must not be made!"

"She is almost 80 years old. After the beating, she was recruited. You will raise her?"

"You have to go to work now, and you are still teaching the graduating class of the third year of high school. How can you have so much energy to take care of her?"

"She just wants to use this method, let us compromise!"

"Among our brothers, whoever calls will be unlucky!"

"They definitely don't know how to fight, and I don't even know how to fight!"

He scolded his wife.

The benefits are explained.

But his wife hesitated to speak, and didn't agree with him very much.

"Also, I am selecting the title of teacher, and it is at a critical moment."

Jiang Siping took a deep breath, and said in a deep voice: "If she is recruited, she will gossip to other people in the dormitory building, and my reputation will be ruined!"

This is also a large part of the reason.

Their house is allocated in the school.

The neighbors are almost all teachers.

Look up, not look down.

Once there is any rumor, the whole school will know it the next day.

He really can't afford the risk.

its so.

It's better to simply point to the lawsuit.

"Then...what if the lawsuit is lost?"

The wife next to him asked abruptly.

Jiang Siping froze for a moment.

Immediately snorted coldly: "I'll go ask the lawyer tomorrow, find a more reliable one this time, and see what the lawyer has to say."

This time he went to ask a lawyer.

Didn't get any useful news.

After Zhang Wei had listened to his narration, he directly said that there was nothing he could do, and returned the money to him.

Not a word was said.

Based on his understanding of the law, he felt that his actions could not constitute a crime.

At most, the court judges that the four parties shall bear the responsibility for maintenance respectively.

of course.

He is not a professional, so he still needs to find a reliable lawyer and ask about the situation.

……

three days later.

Jincheng.

nursing home.

After submitting the submitted materials to the court, Qin Mu was free again.

this case...

He knows it can be thankless.

But after knowing what happened to Feng Cuihua, he couldn't help but stand up.

Things like Feng Cuihua...

Actually there are many.

On weekdays.

It is often seen that father and son, mother and son turned against each other and refused to support the news.

He can't control the others.

But since he met Feng Cuihua, he couldn't let these people go.

"It's been several days, and no one really called..."

Lying on a deck chair in the yard.

Qin Mu, who was fishing, put down his phone and couldn't help muttering.

The court summons is expected to have been served long ago.

but……

Feng Cuihua's four sons didn't react at all.

According to Zhang Qingyuan, these sons are very strong.

As if carved out of a mold.

None of them called to apologize.

Take care.

After receiving the subpoena, they should all have consulted a lawyer.

The lawyer's first suggestion should also be to seek understanding.

This is a private prosecution case.

There is also an apology and admission of mistakes, and a chance to withdraw the lawsuit.

But the bones of Feng Cuihua's four sons were harder than he imagined.

"That's fine, there is something that can be settled in court."

Qin Mu shrugged and complained.

Feng Cuihua's heart is very soft.

He can be sure that as long as these four people apologize and admit their mistakes, they won't even have to go to court.

But they insist on electing the court.

Subsequently.

He stood up and went to Wang Dahammer's office.

I plan to finalize the details of the trial with Wang Dachui.

this case...

For now, the evidence is clear.

According to the many evidences provided by Feng Cuihua, as well as the testimonies of neighbors, etc., it can be confirmed that the other party has abandoned behavior.

and.

Because of that serious illness, the four sons did not come to the scene and did not sign in time, which caused Feng Cuihua's body to be injured to a certain extent.

It is enough to judge the other party as a crime of abandonment.

Now the crux of the matter is...

How many years should the other party be sentenced and how much maintenance responsibility should be borne.

"Tell me, this case... How should I handle it?"

Wang Dachui sat on the seat and looked up at Qin Mu.

Straightened his posture.

A look of listening carefully.

Qin Mu has already taken the judicial examination, but has not yet obtained his lawyer's license.

Unable to defend others at this time.

therefore.

The case is still being prosecuted by him.

But he is very self-aware.

Know your deficiencies in criminal matters.

Coupled with Qin Mu's brilliant record in the criminal field...

He has long been mentally prepared to be a tool man.

Qin Mu couldn't help rolling his eyes when he saw him lying flat.

I thought about it.

He still said seriously: "In the past judicial practice cases, there are very few examples of actual punishment."

"In this case, there is a high probability that the sentence will also be probation."

Abandonment can allow private prosecution.

but……

It is not the same as the private prosecution of insult and defamation.

This happens between family members, usually relatives who are related by blood.

When the court makes a judgment, it will take into account the impact on the plaintiff.

For example.

If Feng Cuihua's four sons are sentenced to real punishment, they will be detained and put in prison...

That comes down to it.

Feng Cuihua is still unsupported.

As for relatives like Feng Cuihua's daughter-in-law to take care of her...

That is even more impossible.

The "Civil Code" stipulates that a spouse has no obligation to support each other's parents.

Taking care is affection, but not taking care is not illegal.

There are only Jiang Daping and others who need to bear the obligation of support.

Combine these.

Judgments in judicial cases are often sentenced to probation and ordered to bear the obligation of maintenance.

"So, the direction of the lawsuit in this case...is to try to implement the crimes for the four opponents, get a suspended sentence of more than three years, and teach them a little more lesson."

Qin Mu took a deep breath and said in a deep voice.

As for whether Feng Cuihua wants to forgive in court...

That's their family business.

It's not his concern.

"This direction of litigation...I like it!"

Wang Dachui's expression lit up after hearing this.

Nodding again and again.

After he knew the behavior of Jiang Daping and the others, he was extremely angry.

A person who can abandon even his parents...

Character will definitely not be better.

"But...we still have to predict the defense direction of the opposing lawyer to prevent being caught off guard."

Subsequently.

Wang Dachui said with some worry.

Excellent lawyers do all kinds of homework and preparation before the trial.

Avoid confusion during the trial.

The four of Jiang Daping encountered criminal private prosecution, so they will definitely hire the best lawyers.

Be fully prepared.

"Then let's simulate it."

Qin Mu also did not underestimate the enemy, nodded and said.

"A mock trial?"

Wang Dahammer's eyes widened, and he instantly understood what Qin Mu meant.

Qin Mu nodded, and said seriously: "I'm here to simulate the defense lawyers of Jiang Daping and the others, let's defend one-on-one."

To find out what the other person is thinking...

The best way is to mock the trial.

Actually.

Many top law firms will conduct mock court sessions before the court session, so as to know themselves and the enemy well.

Wang Dachui swallowed.

Suddenly bewildered.

Dare to love his opponent...

Suddenly it became Qin Mu.

"let's start."

Qin Mu didn't think so much, and the two sat opposite each other.

Start to take on the role, regard yourself as the defense lawyer of Jiang Daping and the others, and gradually sort out the defense ideas and procedures.

After combing for 10 minutes.

He looked again at Wang Dahammer who was still in a daze.

Remind: "We have a simulated trial without a judge, and start directly from the presentation of the indictment."

Follow the normal process.

The collegial panel and other judges enter the court and read out the court discipline, which is the stage for the plaintiff to present the indictment.

Wang Dahammer came back to his senses.

Hastily said: "We sued Jiang Daping, the defendant, and in the past five years, we have never..."

He recounted the drafted indictment and accused the other party of his crimes.

Just finished speaking.

Qin Mu retorted in a deep voice: "We believe that our defendant did not commit any act of abandonment."

"There are family conflicts between the four of us and Feng Cuihua, so the relationship has deteriorated, but the circumstances did not constitute the crime of abandonment."

in defense.

He tried to directly deny the abandonment.

Only in this way, "one's own party" may not have to bear criminal responsibility.

Wang Dachui swallowed again.

Judging from Qin Mu's statement of defense, the focus of the trial was whether the crime of abandonment was constituted.

Followed by.

He began to list the series of evidence they possessed one by one.

And Qin Mu is concerned about these evidences...

Rebuttal one by one.

Faced with the pressure from Qin Mu, he was not to be outdone, and fought bravely.

The proof and cross-examination link lasted for half an hour.

The two sides entered the most critical part of the free debate.

And in this part...

Qin Mu launched an all-out counterattack, throwing out a series of defense points.

"First of all, in terms of the objective composition of the crime of abandonment, the objects of abandonment specifically refer to three types of people."

"Respectively, due to old age, disability, disease and other reasons, they have lost the ability to work and have no source of income; although they have a source of income, they are unable to take care of themselves due to illness, old age, disability, etc.; due to youth or mental retardation and other reasons, without the ability to live independently.”

"Except for these three categories of people, the rest do not constitute the crime of abandonment."

"Although Feng Cuihua is old, she enjoys subsistence allowances and has a meager source of income. She should not be an objective object of abandonment."

"Second, the criminal law for the crime of abandonment stipulates that the motive of the crime should be deliberate and despicable, such as treating the elderly as a burden."

"However, our client turned against the old man because of a misunderstanding, and had a conflict. It was just a resentment, and he didn't deliberately refuse to support him."

"There is a reason for the legal motive, and it is justifiable in everyday logic."

"Third, the constitution of the crime of abandonment needs to meet the abominable circumstances. In the judicial interpretation, the aggravated circumstances include the serious injury and death of the victim due to abandonment; the displacement and begging on the street due to abandonment; the impoverishment due to abandonment; the suicide due to abandonment... "

"However, Feng Cuihua's life has not reached such a level. So far, her life is good."

"fourth……"

Sitting opposite Wang Dahammer.

Qin Mu fully explained the series of defense points he listed just now.

These defense points are all based on the constitution of the crime of abandonment.

Trying to plead guilty of abandonment.

And Wang Dachui was a little stupid when he heard the defense points one after another.

He has studied criminal law for half a year.

I thought that although there was some distance between myself and Qin Mu, the gap was not that big.

But after listening to Qin Mu's series of defenses...

He just found out.

I am so naive.

In just 10 minutes, so many defense points were listed.

Each article addresses a relevant legal loophole.

unknown.

I thought Qin Mu had a whole book of criminal law hidden in his mind.

Just the first one...

He didn't know how to refute.

The composition of the crime of abandonment does provide for three types of people.

Except for the three categories of people, the rest do not constitute the crime of abandonment.

original.

He thought that Feng Cuihua was old, without a job, and without a source of income.

But what Qin Mu said...

It just occurred to him that there is such a thing as subsistence allowances.

"It's time."

Listening to Qin Mu's urging.

He drooped his face and was about to cry.

The opposing lawyer in this simulated trial...

The fighting power is really too strong.

He was stunned directly.

He faltered and said for a long time.

None of them hit the point.

At last.

This mock trial ended with Qin Mu winning.

"How about... let's replay."

Looking at the speechless Qin Mu, Wang Dahammer said cautiously.

Rehearsal.

That is to say, Qin Mu directly told him the solution.

By himself...

It is estimated that it will take several days to find a solution.

Qin Mu rolled his eyes.

But he still said seriously: "Actually, the first issue of minimum living allowances can be dealt with..."

Wang Dachui came from civil service.

The criminal level is indeed much worse.

If it is Zhang Wei, I am afraid that he will soon think of a countermeasure.

It can also have a more intense confrontation and collision with him.

"Oh... I see... So it can still be like this..."

But Wang Dachui kept exclaiming when he heard the "answer".

A look like I realized it.

……

Time passed slowly.

Seven days later.

Outside the nursing home.

Early in the morning.

It is a sea of ​​people, extremely lively.

Under Zhang Qingyuan's big-mouthed propaganda, all the old people in the courtyard knew about Feng Cuihua.

No matter how old they are, they all come out to join in the fun.

"Cuihua, you must win! It's a pity that the auditorium seats are limited, so we can only cheer for you in the courtyard."

"Cuihua, don't worry too much. Xiao Qin is in charge. What you should worry about are your sons."

"Let's go quickly. If it's too late, the seats might be taken by others."

"Go early and come back early, try to come back for lunch."

"..."

The old man who did not intend to attend the scene stood at the door.

They watched Qin Mu, Wang Dachui, Feng Cuihua, Zhang Qingyuan and others leave.

Look quite excited.

as a "housemate".

They are very concerned about Feng Cuihua's case.

After sending Qin Mu and others away.

Everyone hurried back to the yard and urged the staff to set up the curtain.

Sit on a small bench.

Each one was hale and hearty and extremely excited.

Waiting for the ten o'clock court hearing.

Ever since Meng Lei fell silent...

They haven't been this excited in a while.

And in a corner.

Wan Zhongyuan also moved a bench and got involved in it.

Obviously.

He is also very interested in this case.

……

09: 30.

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

Qin Mu led a large group of elderly people into the court under the watchful eye of the judicial police.

These bailiffs...

Calm down.

There was no panic.

In stark contrast to the bailiffs of the Intermediate Court.

They have long been used to the fact that dozens of elderly people come to listen at the same time.

And Zhang Qingyuan and others walked into the auditorium, and sat in their "old seats" one after another.

He took the initiative to leave the C seat in the auditorium to Qin Mu.

And Wang Dachui took Feng Cuihua to their place.

this case...

Wang Dachui is the plaintiff's lawyer, and Feng Cuihua is the plaintiff.

Walking into court for the first time.

Feng Cuihua looked around nervously.

Seeing this, Zhang Qingyuan quickly left his seat.

Walking up to her, he comforted her and said, "Don't be nervous. When the court starts later, you can answer whatever the judge asks you, and leave the rest to the sledgehammer."

talking.

He looked at a bailiff next to the plaintiff's seat, and said very familiarly: "Xiao Zhao, this is my wife, if there is anything wrong with the court later, please take care of it."

The bailiff gave a wry smile, but nodded anyway.

And in the auditorium.

Seeing this scene, Qin Mu couldn't help but widen his eyes.

Unexpectedly, Zhang Qingyuan...

unknowingly.

Even the bailiff knew it.

"Ahem, there are a lot of observers. I know all of these people, and several of them live near our nursing home."

Zhang Qingyuan returned to his seat and said casually.

Qin Mu: "..."

……

court hall.

Listen to the registry.

"Sorry, the number of observers in the Second Criminal Tribunal is full."

Listening to the staff's reply, Zhang Wei froze on the spot.

Can't help but ask: "Is it all full?"

The staff member nodded: "All are full."

talking.

Zhang Wei's registration ID card was returned to him.

On the other hand, Zhang Wei was full of bewilderment, with some doubts about life.

Nowadays.

It was the day when the four of Jiang Daping held a trial for the crime of abandonment.

to this end.

He came to the court specifically, wanting to sit in on the case.

most importantly...

I still want to see what happens to these four unfilial sons.

Unexpectedly...

Can't even get in the door.

God damn it is full.

"and many more!"

He suddenly remembered something, and quickly asked: "The people who registered before...are they a group of old people?"

The staff was a little surprised.

But still nodded.

Seeing this, Zhang Wei couldn't help but gasped.

A group of old people!

Where there are old people, there must be Qin Mu!

That is to say...

This case is very likely related to Qin Mu.

Combined with what he learned about the situation.

The mother of the four Jiang Daping also seems to live in a nursing home.

That nursing home...

It is very likely that it is the nursing home where Qin Mu lives!

thought here.

His pupils shrank suddenly, and he felt a wave of fear for no reason.

fine……

He didn't take the case.

None of the cases related to Qin Mu was dangerous.

He made a mistake this time, but he escaped unharmed.

"No, I still have to go back and watch the live broadcast."

Fortunately.

He was still a little itchy, so he quickly picked up his ID card and ran out of the court.

He narrowly escaped death.

But Jiang Daping and the others...

But Qin Mu was following him, and he was "fortunately lucky".

There is no way to see the scene.

He can also watch the trial live through the live broadcast of the trial.

……

Nine fifty.

Second Criminal Court.

Plaintiffs.

Feng Cuihua suddenly raised her head as if she had sensed it.

Looking towards the direction of the door.

At the door of the court, her four sons walked in one after another.

She was shaking.

The eye sockets were involuntarily moistened.

But these sons...

But from the beginning to the end, he didn't look at her.

Instead, they followed their respective lawyers to the dock.

He didn't mean to say hello to her at all.

Auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and others also noticed Jiang Daping and the others. .

"These four people seem to have no regrets at all."

"Sentence! Sentence to death! Don't even recognize your mother?"

"If I want to have this kind of son, I will kill him the second day after birth!"

"The attitudes and eyes of these people seem to be looking at enemies..."

"..."

They were all very angry.

Before the court session, he was pissed off by this scene.

There is a seven-day blank period before the trial.

The four never took the initiative to contact and apologize.

At this time, the court was held, and there was not a word of greeting.

He never even looked at Feng Cuihua.

adoptive son so...

It's better not to raise them.

Qin Mu sat in the public gallery and also saw these four people.

Involuntarily frowned.

His focus is different from that of Zhang Qingyuan and others.

Beside the four of Jiang Daping, stood their respective lawyers.

That's right.

It's four lawyers.

Obviously.

These few people did not contact each other, but each hired their own lawyers.

Generally speaking.

This multi-defendant case is a joint action.

After the brothers received the subpoena, they would all find the same lawyer to defend.

But the four of Jiang Daping hired lawyers separately, which is enough to prove that their relationship is not very good.

at the same time.

dock.

Sitting in his seat, Jiang Daping couldn't help looking at his lawyer.

Asked a little nervously: "This case... are you really [-]% sure?"

After being "trapped" by Zhang Wei.

He looked for many lawyers in the past few days before finding the most reliable lawyer.

And before the trial.

The lawyer has repeatedly guaranteed that he is [-]% sure.

"of course."

The lawyer smiled slightly and pointed in the direction of the plaintiff's seat.

Confidently said: "Did you see the lawyer next to him? I specifically checked the cases he defended. They are all civil lawsuits, and the winning rate is less than 30%."

"He hadn't fought a few criminal cases at all before."

"I said [-]% sure, but I still overestimated him."

The person he was pointing at was Wang Dahui next to Feng Cuihua.

(End of this chapter)