The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 228 Just after the court session, the blood pressure went up

a few days ago.

Jiang Daping found him and asked him to help defend.

Just to be on the safe side.

He deliberately searched for the opponent's information and past records.

Do what they do.

Before defending, you must first understand the relevant situation of the opposing lawyer.

And these...

The plaintiff's litigator will be named on the copy of the complaint.

Only by knowing yourself and the enemy can you win every battle.

but……

In order to inquire about the identity of the other party's lawyer, he spent a lot of effort.

Because the copy of the indictment has been destroyed by Jiang Daping.

He was looking at it in a hurry and didn't notice who the other party's litigator was.

At last.

It was he who went to the court in person to obtain the files, case facts, and evidentiary materials before the trial, and only then did he find out the identity of the opposing lawyer.

But found...

The other party's lawyer was just an ordinary little lawyer.

without any fame.

The previous lawsuits were all civil lawsuits.

There are very few criminal cases.

And the odds of winning those civil suits...

Surprisingly low.

In other words.

The other party is a rookie.

In addition, this lawsuit is a private prosecution, and the success of the lawsuit depends largely on the level of the lawyers of both parties.

The [-]% chance he said was still a conservative estimate.

"It's good to win steadily."

After hearing this, Jiang Daping breathed a sigh of relief.

Take it easy for now.

The lawyer he is looking for now is much better than Zhang Wei.

When Zhang Wei encountered something, he would only ask him to seek forgiveness.

This lawyer is different.

Be confident.

The professional ability is extremely strong, and it is powerful at first glance.

And beside him.

Jiang Erping also looked at his lawyer anxiously, and never looked at Feng Cuihua from the beginning to the end.

"Don't worry about it."

His lawyer smiled slightly.

He said in a calm tone: "I, Song, have fought criminal cases in Jincheng, not one hundred, but dozens, and the winning rate has remained above [-]."

"As long as the other party's lawyer is not Zhang Wei, the chances of winning this lawsuit are still high."

Jiang Erping heard the words.

Couldn't help swallowing.

He looked at Wang Dachui who was beside Feng Cuihua.

this lawyer...

It was the litigator hired by his mother who was responsible for the whole process of prosecuting the four of them.

But according to his lawyer...

This is a vegetable chicken.

Let him not worry too much.

only……

Hearing his own lawyer's evaluation of Zhang Wei, he always felt that something was wrong.

Zhang Wei?

Isn't that a more vegetable chicken?
After receiving the subpoena, Zhang Wei was the first person he approached.

but……

Zhang Wei didn't even dare to take this case.

He thought for a while, and couldn't help but said, "Ahem, Lawyer Song, I think... even if Zhang Wei comes, it should be a piece of cake, right?"

But the lawyer rolled his eyes.

Become humble: "Compared with Zhang Wei, I am still slightly inferior."

All the arrogance just now disappeared.

Instead, he suddenly restrained himself.

Jiang Erping: "..."

And on the other side.

Jiang Sanping, who was also sitting in the dock, also looked at the lawyer he hired for 3 yuan.

Participated in court for the first time.

Inevitably some apprehension and tension.

But his lawyer was very indifferent, and began to tell him the details that he needed to pay attention to after the trial.

And guarantee...

It will definitely save him from going to jail and successfully reduce the maintenance responsibility.

"The responsibility for support needs to be based on many aspects, and it has a lot to do with the ability of the family to bear. This judgment...you definitely don't have to bear the main responsibility for support."

Listen to the lawyer.

Jiang Sanping nodded silently, feeling more at ease.

Among the four brothers.

What he fears most is to take care of Feng Cuihua.

If it is apportioned to him...

One of him and his wife must give up his job to take care of the elderly.

but……

His son is in the third year of high school this year and is about to take the college entrance examination.

It is the critical time to spend money.

He can't share this trouble.

at the same time.

Jiang Siping...

He was also looking at his lawyer, but he didn't look at Feng Cuihua from the beginning to the end.

Although Feng Cuihua's gaze...

It seems to have been condensed on him.

Just like when I was young.

"Lawyer Sun, I still have the same request as before, try to reduce the responsibility of support, and it will not affect the evaluation of my teacher's professional title."

He took a deep breath.

Before the trial, I asked my own lawyer repeatedly.

The latter is what he cares most about.

If you lose the lawsuit...

The impact is undoubtedly huge.

If he wins the case, it means that he has not abandoned him, and he can at most pay some alimony.

Although I really don't want to give it, but for his title...

He was already mentally prepared to pay.

"Don't worry, Mr. Jiang. I've learned beforehand that the other side's lawyer is not very good at criminal proceedings."

His lawyer nodded.

He showed a mysterious smile: "Besides, I have already prepared the defense direction, and I can definitely turn the tide and catch the opponent by surprise!"

For this case.

These days, he has been studying the loopholes in the law... Ahem, the provisions of the law.

Some crucial points of defense are found in it.

Just throwing out the point...

There is no possibility of losing the lawsuit!

……

Jincheng.

Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

After returning from court.

Zhang Wei hurried into his office and turned on the computer.

Logged into the trial live broadcast network.

The search found the live broadcast of the Second Criminal Court in Jincheng.

on the live screen.

The presiding judge led everyone in the collegial panel into the courtroom.

The clerk is reading the court order.

"Fortunately, we caught up."

Looking at the screen, he breathed a sigh of relief.

This time he was not able to attend the court, so he hurried back.

Fortunately, I didn't miss anything.

And in the live broadcast screen.

He saw Wang Dahui and an old woman with white hair standing in the plaintiff's seat.

in the dock.

There are four people sitting there, namely Jiang Daping, Jiang Erping, Jiang Sanping and Jiang Siping.

Beside them...

On the other hand, there were four defense lawyers sitting there, looking like they were ready for battle.

In the gallery.

There are all old people sitting.

Several of them he could even name.

For example, Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and the like.

Also.

From this crowd...

He spotted Qin Mu at a glance.

"This case... is indeed related to Qin Mu."

Zhang Wei took a deep breath with a serious expression on his face.

It was all his speculation before.

It is now confirmed.

but……

Qin Mu has never obtained a lawyer's certificate and cannot participate in the defense.

In this case, Wang Dachui came to help defend him.

"The opponent's lawyers... are all a bit strong. Can this Wang Dahammer do it?"

He frowned, a little worried.

as a lawyer.

He knows his colleagues in Jincheng like the back of his hand.

He has dealt with all these lawyers.

The fees are very expensive.

The level of business is also high.

And Wang Dahammer...

As far as he could tell, seemed to be a civil litigation attorney.

Although any type of lawsuit can be filed as long as you have a lawyer's certificate, there is still a layer of separation between civil and criminal cases.

and so.

He was very worried that Wang Dachui was defeated by the opponent.

In court, emergencies are inevitable.

Qin Mu sat in the gallery and couldn't help, so Wang Dachui could only ask for more blessings.

"Boom-"

at this time.

The court discipline is read out.

The presiding judge Zhou Quanmin glanced down, and said in a deep voice: "Now, the trial of Feng Cuihua v. Jiang Daping's abandonment case will officially begin. The plaintiff will first read the indictment and state the cause of action."

The voice just fell.

Feng Cuihua, who is in her 70s, stood up nervously, and read to the manuscript in her hand: "I... I, I... I sued my four sons for failing to fulfill their support obligations in the past five years. I... "

She spoke in a low voice.

The speed of speech is not fast.

intermittent.

Some words are not even recognized.

If you don't understand something, just tell it in spoken language.

He sued Jiang Daping and the others for all their actions towards her over the years.

For example, there is no phone call for condolences during the holidays.

Kick her out of the house.

Refuse her to come and bring her grandson.

Never gave her a penny.

Never been back home.

When I was sick and underwent an operation, none of my four sons was present, and my relatives were unable to sign, and so on.

"Beast!"

Zhang Wei sat in front of the computer.

His face was flushed with anger, and he couldn't help but curse.

He has been a lawyer for so many years and has seen all kinds of scum.

But people like Jiang Daping and the others...

It's the first time seeing you.

Other scumbags are scumbags to others.

But Jiang Daping and the others were scumbags to their mother.

"Their actions... violated the crime of abandonment, so I would like to ask the court to hear this case."

in court.

Feng Cuihua finished reading the complaint intermittently, and then glanced at the dock again.

But found that the four sons did not show any shyness or acknowledgment of their mistakes.

I can only hold my heart.

He said tremblingly: "In addition, I would like to ask the court to sentence each of them to three years in prison and bear my alimony."

The voice fell.

in the dock.

Her four sons finally responded.

They all looked at her with a hint of anger and disbelief.

There are all kinds of emotions in the eyes.

Just no guilt.

"This is... really raising four white-eyed wolves."

Zhang Wei sighed lightly.

These four people...

have been to his law firm.

He also talked to these people and was very angry with them.

He also persuaded them to apologize and reconcile.

But these people obviously didn't listen to him.

……

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

"Boom-"

After Feng Cuihua finished speaking.

Zhou Quanmin looked at the dock again, and said in a deep voice, "Next, the defendant, please speak one by one, starting with Jiang Daping."

There are four defendants in this case.

Need specific circumstances and specific analysis.

Everyone has the right to reply.

Jiang Daping swallowed.

Picking up the defense draft in his hand, he read according to the lawyer's instructions: "I... I have never abandoned any behavior, and I have never spoken ill of my mother..."

Facing the scrutiny of the collegial panel.

He was not flushed and out of breath, and he justified his behavior by saying that he had many grandchildren and they were all young.

Therefore, I have no time to take care of my mother.

He needs to take care of several grandchildren at the same time, and he really can't take care of his mother.

This plea...

Naturally, his lawyer prepared it for him.

"Next, let Jiang Erping answer."

Zhou Quanmin finished listening.

After thinking for a while, he looked at the second defendant.

Jiang Erping saw this.

He also stood up and defended, "I... I didn't have any behavior of abandonment either."

"After I got married, I went to work in other places. I got together less and left more. It was inevitable that I ignored my mother's feelings. These are unavoidable."

"I've been trying to get other brothers to support me together, but they all shirked with various excuses, which led to..."

in his plea.

He also denied abandonment.

He also said that he once presided over other brothers to pay for support, but the other brothers ignored him.

Unspoken.

It's not that he doesn't support him, but that he can't support him.

"Boom-"

After listening to Jiang Erping's defense, Zhou Quanmin sounded the gavel.

Continue to look at the third defendant.

Jiang Sanping quickly stood up and said, "Judge, I didn't abandon it either. I always wanted to support her, but I..."

His excuse was that his family environment was poor.

It is impossible for one person to support them.

Restricted by the economic situation, there is no support, but it is by no means abandoned.

Zhou Quanmin couldn't help frowning after listening to the defense of the three.

Just the defense part.

The three brothers began to blame each other.

Try to shirk responsibility.

All kinds of excuses came out.

One is that there are many grandchildren in the family, and they have no time to take care of them.

One is that he tried to support him, but the other brothers ignored him.

One is that the family's economic situation is not good, and they cannot afford it independently.

"Next, let Jiang Siping speak and answer the plaintiff's complaint."

After a little thought.

He opened his mouth in a deep voice and looked at the last defendant.

Jiang Siping saw this.

He also quickly stood up and said, "I am a teacher, and my wife is also a teacher. I am still in the graduating class. I have a lot of work every day."

"I often have to work until late at night before I can rest."

"But it is our duty to take care of the flowers of the motherland, teach and educate people, and we really don't have time to take care of our mother."

His excuse was even more grandiose.

Think he's too busy with work...

Feng Cuihua was misunderstood because she couldn't take care of Feng Cuihua.

Three under five divided by two.

Clean up the abandoned issues.

Auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan and others listened to the defense of the four, their beards trembled with anger.

"Can you say this kind of thing? Because you have so many grandchildren, why don't you take care of them?"

"There are also teachers who are so busy teaching and educating people that they don't even want their mother?"

"This second child is nothing. If others don't support him, I don't care about anything."

"There's also the third child. It's understandable that the family's finances are poor, but it doesn't mean that you don't come to sign for the surgery?"

"..."

They stared at the dock.

Burning with anger.

Just after the court session, the four kept refreshing their knowledge.

Let their blood pressure...

constant increase.

That's right.

For other cases, they came to watch the fun.

But this case...

Because it happened around them and involved the issue of supporting the elderly, they felt very empathetic.

On the contrary, I didn't see the excitement, and made myself very angry.

"Cough cough, calm down."

Qin Mu looked at Zhang Qingyuan and others who were discussing more and more loudly, and couldn't help persuading them.

under anger.

They didn't keep their voices down anymore, causing the surrounding bailiffs to keep warning with their eyes.

in fact.

The defense of Jiang Daping and the others also made him a little bit overwhelmed.

Four people, Leng said four excuses.

as if……

They didn't do it on purpose.

Only because of various problems, did not go to support.

Feng Cuihua's lawsuit was argued by them as a "misunderstanding".

"The other party's defense, there is something to it at first glance. The level of these lawyers seems to be okay."

"Xiao Qin, the sledgehammer should be able to win the opponent, right? Death order, this case can only be won, not lost!"

"I think it's a bit confusing. There are four lawyers on the opposite side, and we only have one. Xiao Qin can't help yet."

"The level of the sledgehammer... seems to be a little bit worse."

"..."

Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and others continued to lower their voices.

They all looked at Qin Mu.

Worried.

It doesn't matter if you win or not in other cases.

The case is lost...

They probably won't be able to sleep in the future.

"It might work."

Qin Mu glanced at Wang Dahammer and said uncertainly.

These days.

In order to help Wang Dachui, he specially helped Wang Dachui to hold several mock court sessions.

Listed out all the defense directions of the opposing side that I had figured out, and informed the countermeasures.

In general.

The odds should still be great.

……

Jincheng.

nursing home.

In front of a huge projection screen.

The old people who did not go to the court to participate in the hearing sat around together.

Emotional.

Couldn't help cursing angrily.

The sound was earth-shattering.

"Bastard! Is this what people say? It's not someone else, it's their mother!"

"None of these four defendants is good, and the excuses they made are so shameless!"

"The third child said he had no money, and he didn't ask him to bear all the alimony, but he didn't pay any alimony."

"The most irritating thing is the boss. When he has time to take care of his grandchildren, he leaves his mother aside and doesn't care about it?"

"It is said to raise children to prevent old age, and to raise children to prevent old age. I am afraid that the only way to prevent old age is to save more money these days."

"..."

After listening to the defense of the four people.

None of these old people could control their emotions.

In the yard, there is little court discipline.

When everyone gathered together, they couldn't help complaining.

The behavior of Jiang Daping and the others became more and more contemptuous.

To raise such a son...

In fact, it is better not to raise.

Even if they went to court, they didn't have any intention of repenting.

The behavior of the four was surprisingly consistent, and they never looked at Feng Cuihua directly.

And in the crowd.

Vice President Wan Zhongyuan clenched his fists in anger, and suddenly felt empathy.

because……

He has an unfilial son.

During the betrothal gift case before, a huge conflict broke out between the two, and they almost severed the relationship between father and son.

this time.

His son didn't even call him to admit his mistake, and kept disappearing without a trace.

Now he is in his prime.

don't worry about anything.

But then getting old...

He was really worried that his son was the same as Jiang Daping and the others.

"Do you want to hurry up and raise another one?"

Watching the lessons learned in the projection live broadcast.

He couldn't help swallowing, and muttered.

after old age.

It is actually a very happy thing to have children and grandchildren who are married to each other and share the family relationship.

But the most frightening...

It's just that the family was unlucky and gave birth to a rebellious son.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng.

Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

"These excuses... have something."

Zhang Wei stared at the four people in the dock, muttering to himself.

in fact.

Hearing the defense of Jiang Daping and the others, he was inevitably a little angry.

But when he was angry, he quickly calmed down.

these excuses...

It seems shameless, but in fact it is closely related to whether or not they have undertaken the obligation of support in daily life.

in modern life.

The pace is getting faster and faster.

Work pressure is increasing.

Work, misunderstandings, conflicts, economic conditions, etc., are all objective reasons.

It is justifiable not to be filial in front of the elderly.

Proceeding from this aspect, the court can consider it as appropriate and have the opportunity to plead guilty of abandonment.

"I just don't know...whether Wang Dahammer can withstand the opponent's counterattack."

He pondered for a while, then looked at Wang Dahammer again.

This time.

With one against four, Wang Dachui faced great pressure.

Even with Qin Mu's help, it must be a vicious battle!
"Boom-"

live screen.

in court.

After Zhou Quanmin listened to the defense of the four, Chen Sheng said, "According to the statements of the four, let me now summarize the focus of the dispute in this case."

"The plaintiff believes that the actions of Jiang Daping and the others constitute the crime of abandonment, while the defendant denies the existence of the act of abandonment."

"The next trial will focus on whether the act of abandonment exists and whether the crime of abandonment constitutes it."

After summarizing.

He continued: "Next, enter the link of proof and cross-examination."

Evidence is required in adjudicating a case.

Evidence is required in civil proceedings, and even more so in criminal proceedings.

And this case...

It is a criminal private prosecution, so most of the evidence is collected by both parties themselves.

The voice just fell.

Wang Dachui quickly stood up and said seriously: "Presiding judge, judges, there are three main types of evidence on our side."

"The first category is the evaluation and testimony of Jiang Daping and the others among neighbors, villagers, and elders."

talking.

He presented a series of testimonies collected by himself.

There were also a number of witnesses in court.

For example, Jiang Daping's second uncle, third aunt, and fourth uncle...

These people were specially invited by Qin Mu and him.

In addition to the testimony of neighbors and villagers, the impressions of Feng Cuihua's other relatives are more convincing.

soon.

Several witnesses entered the courtroom one after another and stood on the witness stand.

Zhou Quanmin saw this.

Shen Sheng asked: "In your perception, how do Jiang Daping and the others treat their mother?"

The case involved criminal private prosecution.

A comprehensive inspection is required.

Testimonies between neighbors, villagers, and relatives can all be used as auxiliary reference sentences.

"Judge, these four bastards are really worthless, my big sister is such a good person, put on this group of beasts!"

"The last time I had surgery, I called so many of the four of them, but none of them came."

"I haven't given you any money, and I haven't returned home. If it wasn't for my sister's pension money, how could she survive until now?"

"I watched them grow up. When their father died, I was worried about their unfilial piety, and asked me to help..."

"..."

The witnesses looked at each other.

Pointing at Jiang Daping and the other four, they cursed regardless.

His tone was very harsh.

It is not worth it for Feng Cuihua.

No one spoke for Jiang Daping and the others.

"Jiang Daping, Jiang Erping, Jiang Sanping, Jiang Siping, do you have anything to refute their testimony?"

After Zhou Quanmin listened, he continued to look at the dock.

These testimonies...

They are all criticizing Jiang Daping and the others for their unfilial piety, as if whipping a corpse.

But as a judge.

He must take into account many aspects, be objective and fair, and not listen to one side.

(End of this chapter)