The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 229 Zhang Wei Wants to Recruit Wang Dahammer

Give the four of Jiang Daping a chance to defend themselves.

And he just finished asking.

Jiang Daping stood up impatiently: "Judge, what they say is one-sided, you can't believe them."

"This is my uncle, this is my third aunt, this is..."

"They have the closest relationship with my mother. They were bewitched by my mother and misunderstood us. Their testimony is unacceptable..."

Jiang Erping also said: "This is just a matter between us and my mother. No matter how good their relationship is, it's just hearsay, and they don't understand the truth at all."

in the dock.

Jiang Sanping also showed a strong desire to survive, and kept defending himself: "When did we say that we will not support? Instead, it was my mother. A few years ago, she insisted that she lived in a nursing home and did not need us to support her."

Jiang Siping heard the excuses of the three elder brothers, and quickly said: "Yes, if it weren't for that incident, our relationship has always been very good, and it is not what they said at all."

on this matter.

The reactions of the four brothers were surprisingly unanimous.

The desire to survive is overwhelming.

Justify yourself constantly.

but……

But Zhou Quanmin asked in a deep voice: "There must be a reason for things to happen. Some of the things in their testimony just now, are they true?"

Just now.

These elders of Jiang Daping and others have told many unfilial things about the four of them.

For example.

During the Chinese New Year, Feng Cuihua was kicked out.

It is said that Feng Cuihua was not even given dinner.

And in the past five years, I have never returned to my hometown, and I have never greeted.

"This...this this..."

When Jiang Daping and the others were asked this question, they all faltered.

Talk hesitantly.

Facing the scrutiny of Zhou Quanmin and the collegial panel, they dare not make up lies at will.

These things……

It did happen.

If you really want to check it, you can find it.

"Presiding judge, judges, whether these things happened or not can only prove that there is a conflict between our party and the plaintiff, and it cannot explain the fact of abandonment."

at this time.

The defense lawyer beside Jiang Daping stood up and took the initiative to answer instead: "When getting along with parents, conflicts and quarrels are inevitable."

"It's just like the old man Feng Cuihua said that he doesn't need a few people to support him. It's an obvious angry statement."

"Our client had an argument with old man Feng Cuihua because of a misunderstanding..."

Jiang Erping's defense lawyer also stood up and defended: "Yes, the testimony of these witnesses can only be used as a reference, and it can only prove that the relationship between the two parties is not good, and cannot explain the fact of abandonment."

Followed by.

Jiang Sanping and Jiang Siping's lawyers all came forward one after another.

Defend your party.

The first piece of evidence presented by Wang Dachui was suppressed and doubted.

indeed.

These evidences are not direct substantive evidences.

Just personal impressions.

And these witnesses are mostly people close to Feng Cuihua.

Inevitably there will be some bias.

It can only be used as a basis for court reference.

"In addition, we have a second piece of evidence."

Seeing this, Wang Dachui said coldly: "These are the bank account flow and consumption bills of our party, Mr. Feng Cuihua, over the years."

He looked indifferent.

Not in a hurry.

There was no panic.

before the trial.

Qin Mu conducted several simulations with him, and among them, he questioned this series of evidence.

The scene in front of me...

He has already experienced it.

"These bills are enough to prove that our party has never received any financial assistance from Jiang Daping and the others in the past five years."

"And, five years ago, our client's wife passed away and lost the family's source of income."

"In the past five years, old man Feng Cuihua has never had any financial income..."

talking.

He then continued to present the series of evidence he had compiled.

In these bills...

It clearly shows that Feng Cuihua has not had any profitable income in the past five years.

As an old man in his seventies.

She has lost the ability to work independently and cannot obtain financial resources on her own.

plus age...

It is the stage of needing child support.

but……

The four Jiang Daping did not provide any financial assistance.

As a result, Feng Cuihua has been relying on half of her life savings for these years.

Wang Dachui's voice just fell.

After the dock.

Four lawyers stood up one after another and continued to question: "These evidences can only prove that no online transfer support has been provided."

"It is not enough to prove that our party did not give cash to Feng Cuihua in private."

"Yes, according to the principle of litigation, unless you can complete the evidence, this accusation will not stand."

The rebuttals of the four were also very sharp.

It even puts forward the principles of evidence production in the procedural law.

Evidence is missing.

The effectiveness of the evidence plummets and cannot be used as independent evidence.

because……

What Wang Dachui proposed can only prove that Jiang Daping and the others did not transfer money for support.

Not enough to prove they didn't give cash.

And the fact that cash was given...

It is very difficult to prove.

The so-called principle of high probability applies only to civil cases, not criminal cases.

"We have a third point of evidence."

Wang Dachui was expressionless, and took a deep breath: "These are cases from a certain hospital in Jincheng, which is enough to prove that Jiang Daping and the others did not sign and did not show up during the hospitalization of our client."

"And it led to serious consequences, resulting in the damage of our client's body function."

"These are physical fitness tests, physical function test reports..."

Facing the rebuttals and doubts of the four people.

He didn't rush to refute, but threw out the complete third piece of evidence.

The evidence...

Qin Mu took Zhang Qingyuan and Feng Cuihua to the hospital to collect them.

And the wrong side...

Obviously Jiang Daping and the others.

The hospital is extremely cautious about the operation of the elderly. Without the presence and signature of the family members, it refuses to proceed.

Clear case evidence exists.

And as soon as this evidence is thrown out...

The defense lawyers of Jiang Daping and the others were visibly taken aback.

Obviously.

This later added evidence was beyond their expectations.

They didn't prepare in advance.

"and also."

Wang Dachui glanced at the four of them, with a kind of heroic and dry air: "These are the recordings of the phone calls that the old man Feng Cuihua made to the four defendants when we decided to sue a week ago."

"Everyone can listen."

Done.

He took a record player out of his hand and pressed a button.

Feng Cuihua's voice suddenly came from inside.

"Boss, I, I... I have no money for retirement, you..."

on the phone.

Feng Cuihua's voice seemed very old, with a hint of pleading.

But Jiang Daping's voice...

But he was full of air and refused directly without any respect.

Followed by.

It is the content of the conversation between Jiang Erping, Jiang Sanping, and Jiang Siping.

"Our client actually didn't want to sue them, but what they did really hurt an old man's heart."

Wang Dachui stared at Jiang Daping and the others, taking advantage of the victory to pursue them: "Judge, judge, you can imagine, talking with your mother on the phone like this, full of dislike and disgust, how bad their usual behavior would be. ?”

He took his chance.

Question after question kept bombing.

The defense lawyers of Jiang Daping and the others were caught off guard and could only defend passively.

initiative...

Unknowingly, I regained control.

And in the auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan and others watched the scene where Wang Dachui was in high spirits and verbalized the four of them.

Also followed excitedly.

"Good! Good! Curse these sons of bitches to death!"

"What are you talking about? Are you scolding my Cuihua? Old Mr. Zhao, I've been annoyed by you for a long time!"

"Ahem, calm down, it's a court now."

"Xiao Qin, you helped to defend the sledgehammer, right?"

"..."

Several old people lowered their voices and got together.

Can't help but look at Qin Mu.

As a senior old man in the courtyard.

They are very clear about Wang Dahammer's strength.

years ago.

Before Xiao Qin came, the disputes in the courtyard were all handled by Wang Dachui.

In case of trouble, the first reaction is to reconcile and muddle through.

Encounter those things that cannot be reconciled and can only go to court...

Wang Dachui's winning percentage is also pitiful.

Good thing...

There are very few lawsuits in the court.

He, the legal adviser, has been muddling around like this until now.

Qin Mu smiled slightly when he heard this.

Looking at the current defense in court, I am generally satisfied.

Not in vain, he accompanied Wang Dachui to conduct five mock court sessions, which almost drove Wang Dachui crazy.

Wait for two days.

With his lawyer certificate, he can use his identity as a trainee lawyer to "fight side by side" with Wang Dahui.

Even if you pass the lawyer's license, you must go through a one-year internship.

During the internship.

Incapable of independent handling and defense.

Can only be accompanied by "old lawyers".

It's the same as driving on a high-speed license.

……

Jincheng.

Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

Seeing Wang Dachui's wonderful performance, Zhang Wei's eyes were also shining.

"With one against four, you won't lose the wind, and there is a tendency to crush it. This is a bit powerful..."

He was a little excited.

Wang Dachui's performance was completely beyond his expectations.

The throwing out of evidence one by one caught the opponent by surprise.

And from the aspects of justice, filial piety, public opinion, etc., they successively attacked the opponent.

Show no mercy.

A lawyer of this caliber...

to be frank.

In his law firm, there is no other person besides him.

so that...

He had the idea of ​​recruiting with a lot of money.

If Wang Dachui could come to his law firm to help him...

His law firm will definitely grow rapidly, and is expected to become the veritable No. [-] law firm in Jincheng!

What he lacks now is top talents who are proficient in criminal defense!

And Wang Dahammer is undoubtedly the most suitable candidate!
As for Qin Mu...

The level is simply too high.

The point is that it's too dangerous.

Every time he was with Qin Mu, his luck would become extremely bad.

Now he dare not work with Qin Mu at all.

Qin Mu probably didn't like the salary he offered.

after all……

The development of his law is all due to Qin Mu.

exactly.

Half of the law firms in Jincheng have received "favor" from Qin Mu.

"If Wang Dachui can win this lawsuit with one against four, I will go to him personally!"

Looking at the live screen.

With flickering eyes, Zhang Wei made a decision.

He is very clear about the level of these four lawyers.

They are all at the top level in Jincheng.

Can argue against them...

It is enough to prove the strength of Wang Dahammer.

However, the court has only just started, and everything is still uncertain.

……

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

after an hour.

Wang Dachui verbally fought against the four of them, confronting their opponents head-to-head.

Without the slightest trepidation.

This scene……

It also made Jiang Daping feel confused.

Jiang Daping looked at his defense lawyer blankly, a little suspicious of life.

Before the trial.

One's own lawyer said that the other party was very good.

But the fact is...

The four of them took turns to fight, and Wang Dachui was able to handle it with ease.

as if……

These questions have been drilled before.

The answer is well-founded.

As a layman, he can tell that the opponent is very strong.

"Did I pick the wrong lawyer again?"

He swallowed, feeling regretful.

Reminiscent of the remarks made by our own lawyer before the trial...

The more he thought about it, the more he felt that the entrustment was inhuman.

The lawyer actually said that the defense was not as good as Zhang Wei.

He thought it was a humble word, so he didn't think much about it.

But now it seems...

He is really better than Zhang Wei.

Otherwise, it is impossible to be crushed in court by a lawyer with only a 30% winning rate.

Still being crushed in a four-on-one situation!
"Boom-"

at this time.

The presiding judge Zhou Quanmin rapped the gavel, and said in a deep voice, "Since both sides have stated their views to the extent that the cross-examination session is over."

"Next, both parties are invited to enter the stage of free debate on the focus of this case."

The voice just fell.

The four lawyers behind Jiang Daping and the others breathed a sigh of relief, trying to rearrange their thoughts.

The cross-examination session just now...

Wang Dachui took advantage of the situation to pursue, which put great pressure on them.

Their objections were all resolved by Wang Dahammer with various legal provisions, public opinion, and the ethics of filial piety.

Let them all put away their contempt.

I dare not look down on the "very lawyer" in front of me who has a defense winning rate of less than 30%.

"Presiding judge, regarding what the other party's lawyer said, we always believe that our client's behavior is not enough to constitute the crime of abandonment."

Jiang Daping's defense lawyer took the lead and said, "According to the criminal law, there are only three types of people who constitute the crime of abandonment."

"Respectively, those who have lost the ability to work due to old age, disability, disease, etc., and have no source of livelihood; those who have a source of income, but are unable to take care of themselves due to illness, old age, disability, etc.; those who are young or mentally retarded. , without the ability to live independently."

"According to our understanding, although Feng Cuihua has lost the ability to work, she enjoys the subsistence allowance every month..."

This defense point...

It was he who searched for the legal text for a long time before he found it.

The judicial interpretation of the crime of abandonment is specifically regulated.

Only abandoning these three categories of people constitutes a crime.

However, Feng Cuihua has a source of income and can maintain her life, so she does not belong to any of these categories.

Followed by.

Jiang Erping's defense lawyer also appeared on the stage and explained his defense points: "According to the criminal law on the crime of abandonment, the motive of the criminal act should be intentional and despicable, rather than intentional abandonment, it cannot be judged as the crime of abandonment."

"Our client has stated several times that he wants to assume the responsibility of support, but it is only because of various objective reasons that the two parties have misunderstood."

"But the motive of our actions is not despicable, and we cannot simply be convicted of the crime of abandonment."

The theory he came up with...

In fact, it is stipulated in most criminal charges.

That is, the motive of behavior needs to be intentional and the purpose is despicable.

For example, the crime of intentional homicide requires subjective intent on the one hand, and extremely despicable motives on the other.

If it's just a quarrel between the two sides, and they are too excited to kill...

It is classified as murder of passion.

The motive for the murder was not particularly despicable, it was a temporary intention.

therefore.

Such homicide should be punished lightly.

This is also why...

When many lawyers defend murderers, they will defend in the direction of passion killing.

The despicable motive of killing with passion is a lighter sentence than killing with passion, killing with anger, and killing with cruelty.

"We believe that the judgment of the crime of abandonment should be in line with the abominable circumstances. In the judicial interpretation, the aggravated circumstances include the serious injury and death of the victim due to abandonment; the displacement and begging on the street due to abandonment; ..."

Jiang Sanping's defense lawyer also continued to come forward and expressed his new defense point of view.

Subsequently.

Jiang Siping's defense lawyer also glanced at Wang Dachui, and said in a deep voice: "Judge, judges, our client..."

at this moment.

The four lawyers are all concerned with the outside world, and they are all working hard on whether the crime of abandonment is constituted or not.

Many criminal law "loopholes" have been proposed.

The question is extremely sharp.

plaintiffs table.

Feng Cuihua listened to the defense of the opposing lawyer and became extremely nervous.

What they said...

It was full of legal provisions, and she, who was not educated, hardly understood it.

only know……

They were menacing, full of momentum, and they defended very fiercely.

She was even a little worried whether Wang Dazhui could tell these four people.

……

Jincheng.

Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

now.

Zhang Wei also stared at the screen intently, watching every move of Wang Dahammer.

Now it's time for a free debate.

The four lawyers also began to question the constitution of the crime of abandonment.

each...

It's all part of the criminal law.

It is aimed at whether the crime of abandonment is constituted or not.

Even for him, it was a bit tricky to deal with these problems all of a sudden.

"I don't know if Wang Dahammer can withstand this wave of offensive..."

he murmured.

With some expectations.

at this time.

Wang Dachui, who was next to the plaintiff's seat, slowly raised his head, his expression seemed a little strange.

Facing four people.

Look calm.

He said lightly: "First of all, regarding what the other party's lawyer said, the constitution of the crime of abandonment, only the three types of abandonment are eligible. This is indeed true."

"But our client, Feng Cuihua, an old man, has lost the ability to work and cannot obtain income through labor."

"Although there is a subsistence allowance as a source of income, she only enjoys part of the benefits and should not be classified as income, so she is still among the three types of abandoned people."

"Secondly, the motives mentioned by the other party are despicable. Respecting the old and loving the young are the traditional virtues of our nation."

"Abandoning and adopting parents, ignoring parents after they are old, no matter what the reason is, isn't the motive despicable enough?"

Speaking of it.

He glanced around the courtroom, and said sonorously: "I have always believed that the law is the best manifestation of morality."

"What is morally encouraging will never constitute a crime."

"Things that are morally condemnable may not necessarily constitute crimes, but once they constitute crimes, the motives are absolutely despicable."

"Parents have the grace of life and the virtue of raising them. It is unacceptable to abandon parents."

"Jiang Siping, the four of them, their parents have never been sorry for them, and the two of them worked hard to raise the four of them to adulthood..."

Wang Dahammer's voice kept echoing in the solemn courtroom.

Many people are solemn about it.

Zhang Wei couldn't help but feel his blood rushing up as he listened.

Clap and applaud.

These remarks and starting point not only discussed the despicable motives in terms of legal interests, but also condemned Jiang Daping and the others from the perspective of natural principles and human relationships.

Parents are worthy of them.

But they abandoned their parents and ignored them, and they were condemned wherever they were placed.

Morality can be condemned, which is enough to explain the despicable motives of their abandonment.

Although they found all kinds of reasons and excuses...

But none of them can hide the fact that they abandoned their homes and failed to take care of the elderly.

"The third point, the constitution of the crime of abandonment, indeed needs to meet the serious circumstances, resulting in serious consequences."

"On this point, the previous evidence has shown that during the operation incident, Jiang Daping and the others did not rush to the scene and did not sign in time, which led to..."

in court.

Wang Dachui stood upright with his head held high, with confidence in his mind.

Once again, they verbally fought against the four of them.

A series of rebuttals flowed smoothly, extremely smoothly.

While the other four listened to Wang Dahammer's defense, their faces gradually became ugly.

A difficult debate began.

but……

No matter what direction they started from, Wang Dahammer could always refute them quickly.

It seems to know their defense thinking.

Gradually.

In this most intense court debate, Wang Dahammer's advantage became more and more obvious.

From the beginning of being evenly matched, they gradually suppressed the four of them.

With his own strength, the four of them were speechless.

"Amazing……"

Looking at Wang Dahammer on the screen, Zhang Wei expressed his heartfelt emotion.

he used to...

Seems to be wrong.

I almost missed such an excellent lawyer as Wang Dahammer.

Following this trend...

The constitution of the crime of abandonment must be established.

Next.

This thinking lawyer probably wants to go back.

For example, from the defense of innocence to the commutation of sentences, and then to the distribution of support responsibilities among the four parties.

These……

These are all things that need to be discussed in this case.

……

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

Auditorium.

Amidst the whispers of Zhang Qingyuan and others, he also gradually let go of his heart.

The defense direction of these four lawyers...

He predicted it all.

And he had rehearsed for Wang Dahammer several times in advance.

It is equivalent to knowing the answer before the exam, and he also helped explain the derivation idea.

It's almost a sure thing.

"If there are no accidents, the next step will be the sentencing and the distribution of support responsibilities."

He took a deep breath and muttered to himself.

And in court.

The free debate session gradually entered a white-hot stage.

To be precise, it was Wang Dachui who attacked the four lawyers all by himself.

The faces of the four lawyers were uglier than the last.

at last……

One lawyer resolutely gave up resistance, intending to settle for the next best thing and strive for other interests for the client.

(End of this chapter)