The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 230 The judge angrily reprimanded the Quartet!

At this moment, Wang Dahammer, who was facing them...

It's like a big mountain.

They exhausted their methods and racked their brains, but they didn't take advantage of it.

Plus……

In this case, the laws of nature, human feelings and secular public opinion all sided with the other side.

It is almost impossible for them to defend successfully.

What they can't understand is...

I thought Wang Dachui was a rookie, but I didn't expect him to be able to hide so deeply.

hard to imagine.

With such strength, how did Wang Dahammer's defense win rate reach 30%.

"Boom-"

two hours later.

A solemn gavel sounded, echoing in the court.

Zhou Quanmin scanned the crowd below.

Shen Sheng said: "The debate on the constitution of the crime of abandonment is over here, and now we are entering the stage of discussion on the responsibility of support in this case."

After two hours of discussion.

Both parties have stated all their defense views on whether the crime of abandonment is constituted or not.

All that needs to be said has been said.

Will enter the trial of the next focus of this case, that is, maintenance responsibility.

The defense lawyers for the four of Jiang Daping only questioned the crime of abandonment.

As for maintenance responsibilities...

This is stipulated by the law and must be supported, and there is no room for discussion.

No matter what happens, they have to bear the maintenance responsibility.

Those who need support in court...

Only in the delineation of maintenance responsibilities.

According to the provisions of the "Civil Code", all children, regardless of their age, need to bear the maintenance responsibility.

If there are many children, the support responsibilities will be distributed equally, and each child has an equal responsibility to support their parents.

of course.

If there is a maintenance agreement, the maintenance responsibility shall be borne according to the content of the maintenance agreement.

maintenance agreement.

Generally, it is jointly formulated by parents and children, agreeing on the content that each child is responsible for, the amount of maintenance to be paid every month, and so on.

But actually...

Many children and their parents will not sign the so-called maintenance agreement unless it is necessary.

Mostly by virtue of self-consciousness and initiative.

However, it is inevitable that some children will not get along with their parents, resulting in conflicts and unable to assign support responsibilities.

At this time...

You can only go to court and obey the court's judgment.

in the dock.

Jiang Daping's eyes widened when he heard Zhou Quanmin's words.

Didn't respond for a while.

"This... this... how did this enter the discussion of the responsibility of support?"

He turned his head sideways and looked at his defense lawyer in puzzlement.

Just defended for two hours.

Even though he didn't understand the law, he could tell that the defense lawyer on his side was the real deal.

actually...

He was beaten by the opponent, a lawyer whose defense success rate was less than 30%.

Still being beaten four by one!
"The situation is not very optimistic, something unexpected happened."

His lawyer blushed, bowed his head and explained: "But don't worry, we are discussing the responsibility of maintenance now, and I will try my best to get you the least responsibility."

The voice fell.

Jiang Daping was struck by lightning.

His lawyer didn't say so, but the implication was clear.

Whether the crime of abandonment is constituted or not...

The four of them were completely defeated!
The battle is about to collapse, and his defense lawyer has already started looking for the next battlefield, trying to stabilize the front.

And next to him...

Jiang Erping, Jiang Sanping, and Jiang Siping also realized the situation one after another, and their expressions were not very good.

"We believe that our party, as the boss, should have set an example on the issue of parental support. We are willing to take the initiative to take responsibility and invite the other three brothers to discuss together to allocate support responsibilities."

Jiang Daping's defense lawyer took a deep breath and spoke in a deep voice.

Attempt to take the initiative in the responsibility of maintenance.

As long as they can take the lead...

Then there is more room for them to operate.

however……

He hasn't finished speaking yet.

Jiang Siping's defense lawyer stepped forward and retorted: "There is no law that stipulates that the boss should take the lead in dealing with the issue of maintenance responsibility."

"The old man Feng Cuihua used to be the best to the fourth child, and had the best relationship with the fourth child. I think we should follow the old man's wishes and let our party take the lead."

Obviously.

He also understands the importance of striving for dominance at this time.

If you lose your dominance...

Subsequent allocation of support responsibilities may be extremely unfavorable to them.

"Presiding judge, judges, I think supporting the elderly should be determined by financial ability, and among the four sons of our client, the economic situation is the best."

Jiang Erping's defense lawyer also couldn't wait to stand up.

Fight for the interests of the parties.

The economic situation has always been the primary consideration when providing support.

"Judge, I think..."

Not to be outdone, Jiang Sanping's defense lawyer also stood up.

a time.

All parties began to actively assume the responsibility of Feng Cuihua's support, and quarreled constantly.

The competition is getting fiercer.

Can't wait to fight.

And this scene...

Once again, Zhang Qingyuan and others in the auditorium were eye-opened and dumbfounded.

"What do you mean? Don't they want to take the responsibility of supporting them? Now they are all taking the wrong medicine."

"I ignored none of them before, but now they are vying to take the lead?"

"I'd like to see what the hell they're going to do."

"It's really been a long time. I don't care about abandoning my mother on weekdays, and everyone has become a dutiful son in court?"

"..."

For the actions of the four lawyers...

Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and others scoffed, extremely disdainful.

Contempt from the bottom of my heart.

They knew exactly who Jiang Daping and the others were.

But now...

Actually, in front of everyone in the collegial panel, each of them actively took responsibility.

Very hypocritical.

Qin Mu looked at this scene, also a little speechless.

The practice of these lawyers...

He does understand.

after all……

It is reasonable, legal and reasonable to respect the old, love the young, and respect filial piety.

No lawyer dares to refuse to bear the responsibility of maintenance in court.

Even if they are unwilling to take responsibility, they still have to pretend to be filial sons.

otherwise……

Once the presiding judge or other judges of the collegial panel have a bad impression, it is very likely that they will be sentenced to more maintenance responsibilities.

now.

The matter has gone to court.

The division of maintenance responsibilities in the future will depend entirely on this court judgment.

and.

If they can get the lead certification of supporting Feng Cuihua, they will be qualified to instigate the other three families in the future.

The person in charge can also act positively and violate negatively, and bear less responsibility for support in the future.

……

at the same time.

Jincheng.

nursing home.

In front of the projection screen, there was also a lot of curses.

"Bah! How shameless! Don't you dare to be arrogant in front of the judge now?"

"Jiang Daping and the others are really carved out of the same mold, seeking advantages and avoiding disadvantages. They pretend to be so good in front of others, but they are not even human in the future."

"On New Year's Eve, Cuihua can be kicked out to live. What kind of good thing can such a person be?"

"I used to love to answer and ignore it, but now I'm scrambling to support her. Is it because I'm afraid that others won't know?!"

"..."

These old people are all seven or eighty years old.

I am used to seeing the vicissitudes of life.

But the faces of the four Jiang Daping brothers still disgusted them.

On weekdays.

All kinds of abandonment, after going to court, first found out all kinds of involuntary reasons to justify.

Now it is even more anxious to fight for the right to maintenance.

unknown……

They thought they had no choice but to leave Feng Cuihua alone.

For this kind of person...

They have always been the most despised.

They don't hate rich people, they earn it by their ability.

But people like Jiang Daping are really hateful.

And there are many such people in life.

At least in their decades of experience, they can often hear that some family has committed crimes and produced an unfilial son.

"Fortunately, my son is quite filial. Although he seldom visits me, he still sent me to a nursing home."

"It's actually pretty good to be able to live in a nursing home."

"Yeah, it's better than having an unfilial son. If I have such a son, I will sever ties with him immediately."

"People nowadays just don't like stick education. They are afraid of being hated by their children. We used to be beaten from childhood to adulthood, and we never saw anyone who hated their parents."

"..."

yard.

These old people who couldn't go to the scene suddenly began to discuss the way of raising children.

they feel.

Feng Cuihua's biggest problem is that she didn't educate these four sons well.

It is understandable for a son to be unfilial.

But the four sons are not filial...

Most likely, it was Feng Cuihua's problem.

And their way of raising children is also very simple.

If the child is disobedient, hit him!
If the child makes a mistake, hit him!
If the child dares to talk back, hit him!
If the child dares to fight back, he will be beaten to death!
If you are young and still able to fight, you have to fight more.

As the saying goes, the depth of love is the depth of responsibility.

If you don't fight when you are young, you can't play anymore in the future, and some of them regret it.

And in the crowd.

Wan Zhongyuan listened to the "parenting scriptures" of the old people around him, his face was a little cloudy.

Others just discuss.

But he...

Really ran into this problem now.

He had an extremely rebellious, not very filial son who was always against him.

And his son is now in his 20s.

He has hit and beaten, scolded and scolded, and even verbally severed the relationship between father and son...

But to no avail.

Hearing these old people's "alarmist talk", he suddenly became anxious.

after myself...

Won't end up like Feng Cuihua?
Thinking of the scene when I was kicked out by my son and daughter-in-law after I was 80 or [-] years old...

He shivered involuntarily.

"no!"

"This bastard is hopeless. I'll save more money now that I'm young..."

Wan Zhongyuan swallowed and murmured.

No matter how reliable my son is...

There is no money to rely on.

He must take advantage of the fact that he can make money now to save a little more pension for himself.

Simultaneously.

Make another property announcement.

Not a penny of his property was left to his son!

……

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

"Boom-"

After the defense lawyers of the four Jiang Daping spoke one after another, Zhou Quanmin sounded the gavel.

Interrupted the people who were fighting for the priority of maintenance.

"The distribution of support responsibilities this time is mainly reflected in two aspects."

He looked at everyone in the dock, and said in a deep voice: "One, Feng Cuihua is old and frail, unable to work, unable to get paid through labor, and needs the necessary financial assistance from each child."

"Second, caring for the elderly is a traditional virtue of our country. In addition to financial support, it is also necessary to provide spiritual counseling, comfort, and companionship for the elderly."

He took a deep breath.

Clarifies the assignment of maintenance responsibilities.

Materially, the four of Jiang Daping all need financial assistance.

same.

Mentally, the four of them must also be escorted and cannot engage in cold violence.

As for how to distribute...

Then it depends on the need to combine various circumstances, such as economic conditions, family conditions, living standards, and so on.

simply put.

Caring for the elderly requires money and time.

"Now, all parties are requested to state their respective family situations and their intended support responsibilities."

Then go on.

Zhou Quanmin did not take the lead in establishing the so-called "leader", but directly asked Jiang Daping and the others to state the scope of their intention to undertake.

Generally speaking.

In the maintenance agreement, there is a "leader".

The person in charge is the person in charge of maintenance.

But that is for those filial families who are willing to bear the responsibility of supporting them.

With a leader, you can better take care of the responsibility.

And Feng Cuihua's family...

Anyone with a discerning eye can see it, even if there is a leader, it is useless.

Can only be mandated.

soon.

Jiang Daping's defense lawyer stood up and said first: "Judge, we are willing to take the initiative to take the responsibility of supporting, and give Feng Cuihua 500 yuan of financial assistance every month."

"Our client's family is just an ordinary well-off family, with a per capita annual income of less than 2 yuan."

"500 yuan per month is already a huge expense."

"Besides, because our party has many grandchildren who need constant care, we cannot give Feng Cuihua enough time, but we can guarantee that we will call Feng Cuihua every three months..."

In front of the court.

The defense lawyer stated Jiang Daping's request.

The reasons are also quite sufficient, one is less income, and the other is less time.

all in all.

I am only willing to give 500 yuan a month, and I didn't mention meeting or receiving support from my family.

And his words...

Once again, Zhang Qingyuan and others in the auditorium were blown up.

"Good guy! You've said all these things. If you give 500 yuan a month, who will you send it to? The cost of our nursing home is three to four thousand yuan a month!"

"The key is to call every three months? Why am I raising this son?"

"He didn't mention anything about taking her home to take care of her. In case Cuihua stumbled, he didn't mention medical expenses."

"Does this mean that you want to send it away with 500 yuan?"

"..."

Unable to control their emotions, they exploded all of a sudden.

High blood pressure.

The sound was no longer under control.

The noisy voice immediately echoed in the court.

It caused the complexion of the surrounding bailiffs to change drastically.

Hastily stepped forward to advise.

"quiet!"

Zhou Quanmin frowned, and struck the gavel: "If there are any more noisy people in the gallery, the bailiff has the right to expel them from the court!"

The voice fell.

Zhang Qingyuan and the others, whose faces were flushed with anger, immediately shut their mouths.

Although this scene is up-to-date, they want to see the final judgment even more.

If you are "invited" out halfway...

That would be a big loss.

When Qin Mu saw this, the corners of his mouth couldn't help twitching.

in fact.

This cannot be blamed on Zhang Qingyuan and others.

They have seen so many court trials, and they are still very disciplined in general.

But the support plan proposed by Jiang Daping's defense lawyer is indeed too irritating.

The responsibility for maintenance has been said to be a bargain.

Also call once every three months.

Fully quantified family affection.

"Presiding judge, judges, jurors, our plan..."

Followed by.

Jiang Erping's defense lawyer also stepped forward and stated their support plan.

"We will give the elderly Feng Cuihua 400 yuan a month as alimony, and we will take the initiative to visit the elderly in nursing homes every six months."

in the plan.

There is no mention of the old man's support at home.

Jiang Sanping's defense lawyer also stepped forward and said, "Presiding judge, we plan to give Feng Cuihua 300 yuan a month as alimony."

"My client's family situation is the worst among the four brothers, and the financial affordability is limited."

"In addition, there is a son who is about to take the college entrance examination..."

From the perspective of financial ability, he tried to minimize his maintenance responsibility.

Only bear the alimony of 300 yuan per month.

As for the rest...

It is not responsible at all.

dock.

Jiang Siping's defense lawyer also stepped forward and said, "Our client is willing to give the elderly 300 yuan a month as alimony."

"It is reasonable to take the elderly to live at home to take care of them, but our client's mother-in-law is also old, unable to move, sick in bed, and needs more care..."

The defense attorney...

He even threw out a new point of view, saying that he still needs to support an elderly person.

No time to spare time to take care of Feng Cuihua.

Each one is justified.

Various plausible excuses were found.

Auditorium.

"Old Zhang, I can't help it anymore. It's not surprising that these bastards of Cuihua say such things. How can these lawyers say such things?"

"There is no bottom line at all. The four sons add up to 1500 yuan a month."

"1500 yuan is actually a lot, but they didn't mention the issue of taking care of them at home. Cuihua is 80 or [-] years old, so she can't live alone, right?"

"I don't want to spend time taking care of it, and I don't want to spend money. How can there be such a cheap thing in this world?"

"..."

Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and others looked at each other.

I almost couldn't help but swear again.

These lawyers...

For their parties, it is indeed conscientious.

But what they did and what they said made them lose their minds.

four sons.

Only 1500 yuan per month.

No phone calls, no one around to take care of me...

In addition, Feng Cuihua's health is getting worse and worse, and she has difficulty moving and walking slowly.

There is no other way but to hire someone to take care of them in a nursing home.

And normally.

The charging standard of Jincheng Nursing Home is at least 3000 yuan a month.

This is tantamount to saying...

After giving birth to four sons, he didn't even get enough money for the nursing home.

Qin Mu saw this.

Fearing that they would cause another warning from the judicial police, they hurriedly said: "This is just their statement, don't worry, wait for the final judgment."

to be frank.

This court session is the most special one.

The scenes since the court session raised his blood pressure a little in his two lifetimes.

Jiang Daping and the others...

None of them wanted to take on the responsibility of supporting them, but they all set up memorial archways.

And their defense lawyers have completely abandoned the Three Views, and have been apologizing for Jiang Daping and the others.

"Boom-"

at this time.

After the four defended, Zhou Quanmin sounded the gavel.

Calm face.

With some anger.

He said coldly: "Jiang Daping, you said that there are many grandchildren in your family and you don't have time to take care of the elderly. I want to ask, can these be the reasons for you to abandon your mother?"

He stared at Jiang Daping coldly, extremely angry.

usually.

As the presiding judge, he should be objective and fair during the trial.

But this is not the trial stage of the case.

It is the stage of distribution of support responsibilities.

Jiang Daping tried to shirk his responsibility and only assumed part of the support obligations, which also caused his blood pressure to soar.

He has tried hundreds of criminal cases.

But I have never seen a defendant with such a bad attitude who refuses to repent.

Caring for the elderly is an obligation.

No bargaining will be tolerated.

The reason for discussing the obligation of support here is mainly to analyze specific situations.

After all, some people...

The family situation is indeed a bit poor.

But the four defendants in this case repeatedly broke his lower limit of cognition.

"And you, Jiang Erping, look at the white-haired old man standing in the plaintiff's seat, she is your mother!"

Zhou Quanmin took a deep breath.

His sharp eyes swept to Jiang Sanping, and he asked in a deep voice: "When you were growing up, how much love did she give you, and now you only get you to visit her in the nursing home once every half a year?"

"And look at the alimony you gave, it's 400 yuan a month, and the four brothers add up to only 1500 yuan. What kind of nursing home do you think this can afford?!"

"In Jincheng, public nursing homes cost at least 2500 a month, private nursing homes generally cost [-] to [-], and expensive ones cost [-] to [-] a month. If you don't take care of her, how can she afford to live in a nursing home?!"

talking and talking.

Both Jiang Daping and Jiang Erping in the dock bowed their heads in shame and indignation.

They didn't expect...

The presiding judge actually spoke at this time and lashed out at them.

"Also, Jiang Sanping!"

Zhou Quanmin did not stop reprimanding, and continued to look at the third person in the dock.

"You said that your family is the worst and your income is far inferior to the other three brothers. This is indeed true."

"However, supporting parents does not necessarily have to be related to finances. Taking care of parents by your side is the greatest form of filial piety!"

"You said that your son is taking the college entrance examination. Your behavior of abandoning your mother in such a way can only set a bad example for him and promote a distorted three views!"

"Don't you worry, will your son treat you like this when you are old?!"

"After all, you treated your own mother like this decades ago. Your son has followed suit, and he will not feel any moral guilt at all!"

The voice is sonorous, heavy and powerful.

keep echoing.

Jiang Sanping also bowed his head in shame after being so directly accused.

Trembling all over.

These words……

No one had ever said that to his face.

He just felt that his mother was old, and they couldn't afford it if she got sick or something.

If it hits the hand, the other brothers will not pay, so they can only admit that they are unlucky.

However, what Zhou Quanmin said did not show him any mercy.

It seems to be reprimanding him, poverty is not terrible, what is terrible is the human heart!
"Jiang Siping, among Feng Cuihua's four sons, you are the most educated, and now you are even a teacher of the people!"

Followed by.

Zhou Quanmin turned his head and looked at the fourth person in the dock.

(End of this chapter)