The beginning was serious, and the opposite side was scared by me and called the police!

Chapter 231 It's too late for you to kneel down to your mother
Jiang Siping heard the words.

The body trembled.

After his three elder brothers were reprimanded in court, it was finally his turn.

"From the descriptions of Jiang Daping and the other three, it can be seen that the old man Feng Cuihua has been partial to you since she was a child and let you do everything, but is this how you treat your mother?"

"Ask yourself, is there any gratitude in the support plan you proposed?"

in court.

Zhou Quanmin seemed to be addicted to scolding, and continued to scold: "You are still a teacher, do you still have the so-called teacher's morality?!"

"Teaching and educating people, after teaching, is educating people, you are responsible for educating those flowers of the motherland how to behave!"

"You have no example, you can't set an example, and instead you abandon your parents and family relationships. A teacher like you is simply a black sheep!"

Among the four brothers.

Jiang Siping's identity is the most special, belonging to the teacher.

It's still at the head teacher level, and has the most dealings with students on weekdays.

Precepts and deeds.

But his behavior is so...

The effect of teaching by precept and example can be imagined.

These future flowers of the motherland will inevitably be missed by him one or two!

"You said that you have no time to take care of the elderly Feng Cuihua because your mother-in-law is also sick in bed, and the condition is even worse."

Paused.

Zhou Quanmin took a deep look at Jiang Siping, who was bowing his head, and said coldly: "It is a duty to support the elderly, but it cannot be a reason to abandon your biological mother!"

"To be honest, even if you treat your biological mother like this, I can't imagine how much you will take care of your mother-in-law!"

in his tone.

Doubt.

My mother could ignore it, but she used another old man to take care of her as an excuse.

Few people would believe this kind of thing.

5 minute later.

Zhou Quanmin scolded everyone.

in court.

Silent.

The other members of the collegial panel nodded unconsciously.

Obviously.

What Zhou Quanmin said was what they wanted to say.

And in the auditorium...

Zhang Qingyuan and others rarely spoke to discuss.

They all stared blankly at Zhou Quanmin.

this moment.

The image of Zhou Quanmin was extremely upright in their hearts.

In the previous cases, during the trial stage, Zhou Quanmin was always objective and fair, and did not reveal his personal tendencies.

And this case...

It seemed that he was completely pissed off, and actually scolded the four of them in court.

Every word of these words has reached their hearts.

Very relieved.

And in the dock.

The four of Jiang Daping lowered their heads, their faces flushed.

The facial expressions were the same.

These things they did were publicly pointed out by the presiding judge and accused in court, and they were a little embarrassed.

They finally...

Still have a sense of shame.

"Boom-"

Zhou Quanmin struck the gavel again.

Looking at Jiang Daping who was silent, he said in a deep voice: "Now, please discuss freely with the defendant and renegotiate a reasonable support plan."

"In the plan, it is necessary to take care of the elderly's daily life, financial assistance, emotional sustenance and other aspects."

This link...

It is not a trial session, but a discussion session.

And to support Feng Cuihua...

The court gave priority to the opinions of Jiang Daping and the others.

If the plan proposed by the four is reasonable, the court will support it.

……

Jincheng.

Legal Pioneer Law Firm.

Zhang Wei was staring at the screen intently, watching Jiang Daping's reaction.

This link...

In fact, there is no confrontation between the two sides.

Wang Dahammer, whom he was optimistic about, has no use for him, and has been sitting in the lawyer's seat watching the play.

This is the end of the case.

It is necessary for Jiang Daping to elaborate, state the situation of each family, and discuss a reasonable support plan.

but……

The support plan they mentioned just now is really irritating.

The judge couldn't stand it anymore.

Immediately went off the field and reprimanded the four of them.

"The best way is actually for the Quartet to undertake more financial support responsibilities, and take turns taking care of the elderly..."

Zhang Wei frowned and analyzed it again.

Combined with the respective family circumstances, a reasonable financial aid can be worked out.

If you don't want to take the elderly to your home to support...

Then they need to pay some more money to support the alimony of the nursing home.

Generally speaking.

One person pays one thousand a month, which is actually about the same.

after all……

Sending them to a nursing home saves them a lot of trouble.

There is no need to assign special personnel to take care of the elderly's daily life, diet, etc.

Second.

Sending the elderly to a nursing home does not mean that there is no need to take care of the elderly.

Responsibilities of maintenance include financial and spiritual companionship.

when necessary...

It is still necessary to take turns to accompany the elderly for a period of time, to talk about homely things and so on.

This is the most reasonable solution.

however……

dock.

Jiang Daping and the others started the discussion again, and quarreled while chatting.

"Boss, your family's financial situation is good, and you can definitely pay a little more. Let's pool some money to support the expenses of the nursing home every month."

"I checked Mom's current nursing home. It's relatively expensive, more than 3000 a month. Let's find a cheaper one, [-]."

"My son is going to be admitted to college soon, and I need to save more money, up to 500 per month."

"Bah! If you pay 500, then I can't exceed 500!"

"There is also an escort, why don't we each take turns for a month?"

"Impossible, I don't have time!"

"..."

Just started.

The four of them had a good chat.

But as they talked, they were full of anger and quarreled with each other.

Do not suffer from widowhood but suffer from inequity.

It is obviously inappropriate for the four sons to bear the responsibility of supporting them equally.

And every family is different.

Some burdens are heavy, and some burdens are small.

Some have high incomes and some have low incomes.

Followed by.

The defense lawyers of the four Jiang Daping also joined the "discussion" in order to protect the rights and interests of the parties.

"From a legal point of view, although the support responsibilities of each child are equal, our party's economic income is relatively low, so it should be considered."

"If you want to say that, then my client has a lot of grandchildren in his family, and his children left their grandchildren to him to take care of, without giving him a penny. How can we afford such a large expense?"

"My client's mother-in-law is currently at home and needs to be taken care of, and she usually has to go to the hospital for treatment, which is also a huge expense."

"Our client can afford more escort time, but it should be reduced financially!"

"..."

The discussion among the four lawyers was fairly peaceful.

They are all discussing the legal maintenance situation.

But between the lines, they are trying to reduce the responsibility for maintenance.

Opposite each other's words.

a time.

The court suddenly became a vegetable market.

In order to discuss this maintenance issue, they quarreled like hell.

Zhang Wei: "..."

Looking at this scene.

The corner of his mouth couldn't help twitching, and he sighed lightly.

Whether it is the boss or the second child, or the third child and the fourth child, they all feel that the plan proposed by the other party is unfair.

Both believe that the other party should bear more responsibility for maintenance.

The four discussed for a long time.

A plan acceptable to the Quartet was not discussed either.

If there are many sons, it will become a problem when it comes to supporting them.

That's just how human nature is.

No matter how filial you are, you will feel unhappy when you see yourself doing your best to take care of your parents, but your brother ignores them or shows a little negligence.

What's more, it will give birth to the idea that my mother is not alone, why should I take care of it alone.

this kind of thing.

It abounds in everyday life.

Many old ideas think that having more children can prevent old age, but in fact there are not many.

Sometimes there are more brothers and sisters...

Worse than an only child.

At least the only child enjoys all the love and care of their parents, and it is a matter of course that they have to bear all the support obligations.

……

Jincheng Court.

Second Criminal Court.

dock.

Jiang Daping and the others were still arguing, all of them blushing.

Discussed for a full two hours.

A suitable solution could not be discussed either.

All proposed proposals were rejected by the other three.

And in the auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan and the others watched with relish and listened intently.

No one dozed off.

"It's a lot more interesting than a free-for-all debate session."

"In my opinion, they didn't want to support Cuihua at all. After discussing for so long, there was no result."

"After discussing for so long, the boss is the one who is most willing to pay, and the amount reaches 600 yuan per month."

"They still want to transfer Cuihua? Why?"

"..."

While watching the discussion.

Zhang Qingyuan and the others also started talking to themselves.

This session is indeed more interesting than the dry legal debate.

The four of them were chatting, and then they began to talk about trivial matters in daily life, complaining about each other's faults, and constantly pointing out faults.

It greatly satisfied their gossip.

Just two hours.

They are almost familiar with the various behaviors and deeds of Jiang Daping and the others.

"Boom-"

at last.

in court.

Zhou Quanmin couldn't stand it anymore, and took the initiative to ring the gavel.

The discussion among the four was suspended.

Shen Sheng said: "This is the end of the discussion on the responsibility of support, and the court will be temporarily adjourned!"

Done.

He stood up and left the court with all the members of the collegial panel.

"What's going on? Why don't you let them continue the discussion?"

Seeing this, Zhang Qingyuan looked at Qin Mu in confusion.

Qin Mu smiled slightly, and explained: "I guess it's because they can't solve it internally, and it can only be decided by the court."

This kind of event...

The court will give priority to mediation and discussion between the parties.

But the four of Jiang Daping are really weird.

Even if it goes to court, it still cannot discuss a plan accepted by the Quartet.

"To be honest, I still admire you a little bit. After sitting for more than four hours, you are still so passionate."

Subsequently.

Qin Mu couldn't help looking at Zhang Qingyuan, Li Weiguo and others beside him, and said with emotion.

He sat for so long.

Butt hurts a bit.

However, Zhang Qingyuan and these old people in their 80s and [-]s are all in good spirits.

Not sleepy or tired.

He was a little ashamed of himself for a young man.

at this time.

Feng Cuihua and Wang Dachui from the plaintiff's seat also walked towards him.

Wang Dachui let out a sigh of relief, and said to Qin Mu, "It should be stable this time."

His expression was a little excited.

In this trial, he played very well.

With one against four, they won't lose the wind, and they will be crushed all the way.

But Feng Cuihua seemed a little tangled, as if hesitating to speak.

Qin Mu saw this.

Looking at her, he said seriously: "Now is the adjournment session. When the court starts, the collegial panel is expected to read the verdict. You should think carefully about whether you want to withdraw the charge of abandonment."

This is the last chance.

Before the judgment is read out, the dismissal of the charges in privately prosecuted criminal cases may be announced.

But Feng Cuihua heard the words, but did not speak yet.

Zhang Qingyuan rushed to say: "Cuihua, you have seen their reaction just now, they don't have any remorse, don't be soft-hearted, it will only be worse if your heart is soft-hearted!"

Li Weiguo, who was next to him, also said, "Yeah, I didn't agree that they should be sentenced, but they discussed it for two hours, and the highest one was only 600 yuan a month. What's the use of such a son?"

He has only two sons.

But the money for the nursing home is shared by the two sons.

After all, he didn't live in their house, so he didn't need to bother his two sons.

And Jiang Daping and the others...

No idea of ​​support at all.

Really hateful.

Feng Cuihua swallowed, and glanced at the four sons in the dock.

Looking at Qin Mu again, he asked, "If they are sentenced...do they really not have to go to jail?"

Qin Mu nodded: "No need."

The crime of abandonment is rather special.

I'm really going to send it in...

At that time, no one will support them, and there is actually no substantial difference from abandoning the elderly.

This judgment is not in line with the original intention of the legislation.

So basically it would be probation.

"Then... I won't withdraw the lawsuit."

Feng Cuihua gritted her teeth and made a difficult decision.

It was as if all her strength had been exhausted.

……

the other side.

dock.

During recess.

Jiang Daping also looked at his lawyer anxiously and asked about the situation of the case.

"The situation is not optimistic. The crime of abandonment should be established. You still have the last chance now."

His defense lawyer smiled wryly, and pointed to Feng Cuihua in the auditorium calmly.

Then he said: "Now kneel down to your mother and admit your mistake, maybe she will soften her heart."

But after Jiang Daping heard this, his face turned ashen.

Say nothing and refuse to apologize.

Instead, he stared at the lawyer and said dissatisfiedly: "You said it before? This case has a [-]% chance of winning. How did it happen now?"

The more he thought about it, the more he felt that he had been tricked again.

This lawyer is better than Zhang Wei.

Not to mention the opposite lawyer with a winning rate of less than 30%.

In his opinion.

This lawyer was trained by Zhang Wei, and Zhang Wei was trained by Wang Dachui.

Losing seems to be a matter of course.

"It's not my fault. The lawyer opposite... either has someone to advise him, or he's pretending to be a pig and eating a tiger."

The lawyer sighed, and said with an aggrieved face, "But don't worry too much, this case is special, even if you lose, you don't have to go to jail."

Subsequently.

He explained the concept of probation again.

Only then did Jiang Daping let go of his hanging heart.

He heard that even after being sentenced, he can live in his own home and live as usual, so he has nothing to worry about.

This sentence...

For him, it seemed to have no effect.

And beside him.

Jiang Erping, Jiang Sanping, and Jiang Siping are also complaining about their lawyers.

After learning about probation.

Not so nervous anymore.

As for kneeling and admitting to Feng Cuihua...

No one does.

……

Four 10 minutes later.

The recess is over.

"All rise!"

Zhou Quanmin returned to the court with the members of the collegial panel.

In a solemn atmosphere.

All stand.

Jiang Daping and the others looked at Zhou Quanmin apprehensively, they were unavoidably nervous when the verdict came.

"Today, the Jincheng No. [-] Criminal Tribunal conducted a five-hour trial on the case of Jiang Daping and the four suspected of abandonment."

Zhou Quanmin took a deep breath, and said in a deep voice: "After the trial, the facts of this case are clear, the evidence is sufficient, the facts of the case are beyond doubt, and the applicable law is clear."

"This court believes that respecting the old and caring for the young is a traditional virtue in our country, and it should be advocated at both the legal and moral level. The young should be loved and the old should be respected."

"In this case, Jiang Daping and the other four have abandoned their biological mother, Feng Cuihua, for the past five years. They have not fulfilled their due filial piety, and have not provided any financial, material, or spiritual assistance."

"Within five years, due to old age and frailty, Feng Cuihua lost the ability to work and had no financial resources. During the period of serious illness and surgery, none of the four Jiang Daping arrived at the scene. As a result, the operation could not be performed in time, resulting in damage to physical functions..."

"The behavior of Jiang Daping and the others violated Article 260 of the Criminal Law. The circumstances are serious and they have committed the crime of abandonment."

"The following judgment is hereby rendered:

Jiang Daping was sentenced to the crime of abandonment and sentenced to three years in prison with a five-year reprieve.

Jiang Erping was sentenced to the crime of abandonment and sentenced to three years in prison with a five-year reprieve.

Jiang Sanping was sentenced to the crime of abandonment and sentenced to three years in prison with a five-year reprieve.

Sentenced Jiang Siping guilty of abandonment, sentenced to three years in prison, suspended for five years. "

"In addition, the four of Jiang Daping should bear the responsibility for support according to law, and the support judgment is hereby made:
Jiang Daping is the eldest son of the family, and his family is well-off. He should set an example. He should give Feng Cuihua 900 yuan a month in alimony, and he should spend more time with Feng Cuihua every week through phone calls and meetings.

Jiang Erping's economic situation is the best, and he should give Feng Cuihua 1000 yuan a month as alimony, and he should spend more time with Feng Cuihua every week through phone calls and meetings.

Jiang Sanping's family conditions are relatively poor, and Feng Cuihua should be given 750 yuan a month in alimony, and should spend more time with Feng Cuihua every week through phone calls and meetings.

Jiang Siping has enjoyed more love from Feng Cuihua, and as a teacher, he should lead by example. He should give Feng Cuihua 1000 yuan alimony every month, and he should spend more time with Feng Cuihua every week through phone calls and meetings. "

"If you are not satisfied with this judgment, you can initiate a retrial with this court or appeal to the higher court within [-] working days from the date of entry into force of the judgment."

This judgment is very long.

After 3 minutes, the reading was finished.

It includes criminal penalties, as well as civil maintenance orders.

The voice fell.

The entire court fell into a brief silence again.

Plaintiffs.

Feng Cuihua's body trembled, and tears flowed down her face involuntarily.

She finally...

Send his son to the judgment seat.

At this moment, she felt extremely regretful in her heart.

I knew so.

When you are young, you should discipline them more, instead of spoiling them blindly.

And in the auditorium.

Zhang Qingyuan and others were very excited and extremely satisfied with the result.

"Relieve Qi! It's too relieved. This is an antihypertensive drug. My blood pressure has been lowered just now!"

"I have a question. If they don't accompany them, is it considered a crime of refusing to execute the sentence? Can I sue them again?"

"I remember Xiao Qin seems to have said that if there is a new crime during the probation period, will he go to jail directly?"

"I just like the way they refuse to apologize even if they beat them to death!"

"..."

first half.

They almost exploded with anger.

Fortunately, the verdict made them extremely comfortable.

And the accompanying content...

It even attracted the attention of several old people.

I have been with Qin Mu for so long.

Under the influence of ears and eyes.

They know something about the law.

The previous Meng Lei was charged with refusing to execute the judgment after the judgment was issued.

"Indeed."

Qin Mu nodded in seat C of the auditorium: "If you don't implement it, you will indeed commit a criminal offense."

During probation.

As long as there are three illegal acts, or one criminal act, they will go directly to jail.

And usually...

Those sentenced to three years in prison are all suspended for three years.

The court's verdict is five years!
It is enough to show that the members of the collegial panel extended the assessment period for Jiang Daping and the others.

Within five years, they must resolutely implement the court's judgment.

Any violation of...

will be executed.

And in the dock.

Jiang Daping and the others did not realize the seriousness of the problem.

all on this verdict...

Showed dissatisfaction.

Jiang Daping frowned: "I actually want to pay 900 yuan? 900 yuan a month, why does an old lady want so much money?"

Jiang Erping also gritted his teeth, a little dissatisfied: "My family is good, so I should pay more? Why should I pay 1000? It's not fair!"

Jiang Sanping was not very satisfied when he looked at the verdict issued before him.

Full of worry, he murmured: "750 a month, almost [-] a year..."

Jiang Siping frowned, and said unhappily: "I am a teacher, so I should give more money? What kind of reason is this?"

It was completely opposite to the reaction of Zhang Qingyuan and others.

The four of them...

Very dissatisfied with the verdict.

The most dissatisfied...

Not a criminal judgment, but a civil maintenance judgment.

The requests for companionship in the judgment were automatically ignored by them.

What they care about is that the four people have to pay different alimony, and they all think this is unfair.

but……

Everyone has no idea of ​​an appeal or a second trial.

after all……

This case has been troubled for so long, and now it is finally resolved.

Especially Jiang Siping.

Although I have to spend 1000 yuan more every month, it is over after all.

If there is another appeal, maybe something will happen.

"Actually, I don't recommend that you appeal."

The lawyer next to Jiang Daping said seriously: "This sentence is actually quite ideal, but during the probation period, there are a few things to pay attention to."

The lawyer told Jiang Daping several precautions.

For example, you can't break the law, you can't commit another crime, you need to report to the community, and so on.

"Don't worry, I'm not a fool. It's impossible to break the law, let alone commit a crime."

After hearing this, Jiang Daping said something later.

ps: This was added yesterday.

In addition, push a friend's book, the urban "I Created a Monster Club", there is a portal below.

(End of this chapter)