You became a lawyer and sent the judge in

Chapter 183 Judge: Two years?At least three years to start!

adjournment stage.

The most nervous ones are Wu Guoxing's parents and Wang Yuan's parents.

Because this trial is about whether Wu Guoxing and Wang Yuan will face serious criminal punishment,
Wu Guoxing's parents are fine...

After all, the defense lawsuit just now was aimed at Wang Yuan.

Even if Wang Manhua didn't understand the law, he could tell from the trial that the questioning just now was very unfavorable to Wang Yuan.

No matter how you look at it, it is a trend to send Wang Yuan in.

Wang Manhua looked at Wei Hao nervously: "Lawyer Wei...why are you in adjournment now?"

"Judge...will you be sentenced after the trial?"

"Lawyer Wei...do you think we can win this lawsuit?"

Wei Hao sorted out the litigation materials in front of him, frowned slightly, and turned his head to look at Wang Manhua.

"The adjournment is a full panel and there needs to be some discussion about this proceeding."

"This lawsuit... I don't know if I can win the lawsuit."

"It is estimated that the court still needs to listen to the statements of the two parties.

The sentence has not yet been determined, and the sentence will not be announced on the spot. Regarding the sentence, there should be some small details that need to be discussed.

But the specific situation is beyond our control, and it still needs judges and trial members to make judgments. "

"You asked me... I don't know how to answer you."

"Okay, I understand Lawyer Wei."

"Thank you, Lawyer Wei."

Hearing Wei Hao's perfunctory and inaccurate answer, although Wang Manhua was a little unhappy, he still expressed his gratitude verbally.
.
....
the other side.

Wang Yuan sat on the defendant's seat, looking nervously at the bailiffs on both sides of her.

I am afraid of my future in my heart.

Shouldn't she be sentenced?
.
...

But she is only in her early 20s now, which is her best age, if she is really sentenced...

Then if she goes in and stays for two years, won't it be all over?

Wang Yuan looked at her parents.

As soon as Xu Li saw her precious daughter suffering, she couldn't bear the distress.

She also wanted to go to Xie Jingmei to plead for mercy.

but.…

Su Bai stood up, said a few words to the staff at the side, and the staff stopped him directly.
.
 …
at the same time.

The collegial panel discusses the room.

The three members of the collegial panel, Zhou Guangyu, Yang Qifan, and Li Peng, discussed in more detail about various matters of this case.

The most important of these are the specific sentencing of Wu Guoxing, whether Wang Yuan committed negligent death, and judging whether the sentence recommended by the prosecution is appropriate.

The three sat opposite each other, sorting out the relevant litigation materials about the trial, as well as the content of the defense stated by each party.

After Zhou Guangyu sorted out the relevant content at hand, he looked up at Yang Qifan and Li Peng.

"Is there any objection to revoking Wu Guoxing's first-instance judgment in this trial?"

"Isn't this already confirmed? There is definitely no objection to revoking the first-instance judgment."

"Before the trial started, we had already conducted some research on the case, and there were indeed certain loopholes in the first trial.

The sentence was too light.

The key point is that during this trial, the litigant has already raised the fact that Wu Guoxing did have serious criminal circumstances.

The defendant had no cogent rebuttal. "

"It's not a problem to revoke the judgment of the first instance. The key is the punishment for Wu Guoxing."

"Should it be fixed-term imprisonment or life imprisonment.

After confirming this point, we will further consider whether the sentencing suggested by the litigant is less, and whether Wu Guoxing may reach the level of death reprieve. "

"I think this is the factor we should consider."

"Well, I think what Qifan said is very reasonable. Regarding the criminal suspect Wu Guoxing, the most important thing is his sentencing."

"Intentional homicide is a relatively serious case, and the murderer is a strange woman. Due to his own personality, he committed the homicide violently. In this case, he should be given a heavier sentence. There is no problem with that."

"But Qifan... The litigant only proposed life imprisonment, and you still want to give a suspended death sentence. Are you going to be the king of Hades?"

Li Peng laughed and joked.

Yang Qifan smiled: "Don't you need to consider many situations?"

"Although the lawsuit proposed by the litigant is life imprisonment, the judgment of our court should be based on the facts."

"Hmm! That's right!"

Zhou Guangyu nodded.

"Wu Guoxing's judgment took into account the issue of the sentence, and there is no objection to the judgment of the more serious circumstances."

"What about Wang Yuan?"

"How should Wang Yuan's negligence cause death?"

Zhou Guangyu looked at the other two and asked.

After Li Peng was silent for a few seconds, he said:

"Wang Yuan's negligence caused death. According to the performance of both parties in the lawsuit, the objective facts of the litigant are relatively sufficient, and Wang Yuan cannot refute it subjectively."

"From Wang Yuan's specific subjective point of view, it cannot be verified, but from an objective point of view, how can I say..."

"There is a causal relationship between Wang Yuan's behavior and Fang Zhizhi's death in terms of criminal responsibility."

"The judgment of Wang Yuan is mainly based on the amount of responsibility she bears."

"What do you two think?"

"Well, I agree with this point of view, and I also think that the prosecutor's understanding of this case may not be detailed enough. The recommended sentence is only two years. I think Wang Yuan should bear the main responsibility for criminal relations in this case, resulting in Heavier episodes."

"According to the scope of the sentence for the crime of negligent death, if serious circumstances occur, the sentence should be 3 to 7 years. The two-year sentence recommended by the prosecution is obviously not appropriate."

"Ok?"

"How did you judge that this produced a serious plot?"

Zhou Guangyu looked at Li Peng and asked.

Li Peng said: "First of all, Wang Yuan did not inform Fang Zhihui of the specific situation outside the rented house at that time, and deliberately asked Fang Zhihui to dissuade her. At this point, it is difficult to judge her subjective motive."

"Furthermore, why didn't she call the police?"

"This point has been brought up by the litigant."

"Presiding judge, please take a look at the materials submitted by the litigant on this aspect."

"Judging from the materials submitted by the litigants.

The data emphatically stated that from Wu Guoxing to the rental house where Wang Yuan and Fang Zhihui lived, Wang Yuan knew about this incident, and how long did she stay between when Wang Yuan called the emergency call? "

"Stayed for more than 30 minutes, nearly 40 minutes."

"As far as women are psychologically fragile, it is obviously very unreasonable to have no action for 40 minutes."

"Obviously Wang Yuan didn't tell all the facts at the trial."

"also."

"Actually, if Wang Yuan and Fang Zhihui hadn't had any conflicts, and the investigation of Wu Guoxing had proved it, I doubt that the law enforcement would have investigated this case as a crime of intentional murder."

"So in terms of negligence, Wang Yuan has serious negligence and subjective suspicion of intentionality. I think her sentence should be more than three years."

Yang Qifan took the words at this time: "Actually, I also think so."

"However, the prosecution proposed a two-year sentence. If we follow this sentence, I don't know if the prosecution will raise other issues."

"hehe.…"

"The thoughts of the two of you have collided with mine. This time the adjournment, the main discussion is about the sentence."

"The sentencing of Wang Yuan is indeed a point that needs to be considered."

"Well, let's hear what the litigants think about this issue first."

"At that time, if it is determined to be a serious case, it will follow what we discussed."

"good.…"

"can."

Yang Qifan and Li Peng nodded at the same time.
.
 …
The court was adjourned soon, and the time was over, and the members of the collegiate panel took their seats on the trial bench again.

In the sound of the clerk opening the court again, the trial continued.

Thanks to the detailed discussions in the discussion room with Yang Qifan and Li Peng, Zhou Guangyu, as the presiding judge, had a clearer idea of ​​the case.

dong dong!

The gavel sounded.

Zhou Guangyu looked at Su Bai who was sitting on the litigant's seat, and said:
"The adjournment is over, and Wu Guoxing was sentenced to life imprisonment for the lawsuit brought by the litigant's attorney."

"What is the basis proposed by the attorney for the litigating party?"

Sentence!

Here comes the question of prison terms.

Su Bai looked up slightly at the presiding judge's seat and said:
"Presiding judge, our basis is intentional homicide resulting in death. If the sentence is based on more serious circumstances, it should be sentenced to more than ten years in prison."

"As for Wu Guoxing and Fang Zhihui, there is no great enmity between them, it's just a relationship of mutual acquaintance.

Wu Guoxing's other party's criminal behavior was entirely due to his own factors. . "

"Although it is said that Wu Guoxing turned himself in to the police after the incident, it is an established fact that he caused Fang Zhizhi's death."

"We have no understanding of it."

"Based on the above, we believe that life imprisonment should be imposed."

The difference between intentional homicide, death penalty and life imprisonment is whether it is brutal killing and whether it is premeditated killing.

And judge according to some situations.

The most important thing is whether there is a plot to surrender.

Under normal circumstances, if there is a circumstance of voluntary surrender, a reduced sentence will be considered during the trial.

The death penalty will definitely be rejected in the case of surrender.

Therefore, Su Bai proposed a sentence of life imprisonment.

dong dong!

After Su Bai's statement was over, the presiding judge sounded the gavel and looked at the defendant's litigation attorney.

At this time, both Wu Jianlei and Li Xin looked nervous, and Li Xin kept talking in a low voice.

"Lawyer Ye... you must help us well... everything is easy to talk about, such as lawyer's fees, as long as my son is given a lighter sentence, or the first-instance judgment is maintained, I will give you whatever you want."

Wu Jianlei also looked at Ye Hua anxiously. Although he didn't speak, he didn't stop Li Xin either.

Ye Hua sighed slightly, and said softly, "I will try my best."

Zhou Guangyu set his eyes on Ye Hua:
"Is there anything that the attorney for the defendant's legal representative has to say or add to the claim made by the litigant?"

In fact, Ye Hua knew very well in his heart that there was nothing to add to Su Bai's question.

If you want to supplement the sentence reduction from other places, it will be difficult for the members of the collegial panel to adopt it.

So it can only be added to the routine litigation: "Presiding judge, we have something we want to continue to state."

“The first is the criminal situation against our client Wu Guoxing.

Wu Guoxing's crime was carried out under a very emotional situation at that time, and it was not intended to be a murder against Fang Zhihui. "

"It was an impulsive crime committed under a coincidence."

"The original motive was not to kill Fang Zhizhi."

"What's more, the first thing Wu Guoxing did after committing a crime was to surrender himself, and he acted frankly and leniently."

"We believe that the judgment against Wu Guoxing should be considered from these two points."

"Judge, I have finished my statement."

dong dong!

"The defendant has finished his statement, Wu Guoxing, as a party, do you have anything to say?"

Wu Guoxing glanced at the parents who were seated by the litigant.

Shaking his head: "Judge, I have nothing to say."

"Ok."

dong dong!

When the gavel fell, there was a dull sound, which meant that Wu Guoxing was sentenced to life imprisonment, and there were no other problems.

The next step is to defend Wang Yuan's sentence.

The defense against Wang Yuan's sentence is also very simple.

It is only necessary to determine whether Wang Yuan's negligent behavior is a relatively serious circumstance.

PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

(End of this chapter)