You became a lawyer and sent the judge in

Chapter 471 The shocked defendant, how did he know?

Among all parties involved in the entire court hearing.

No one thought that Su Bai would suggest that Liu Xuewei's death was a case of conspiracy to kill.

after all.…

Based on the available evidence and corresponding facts.

Liu Xuewei was killed by Xie An.

There is no doubt about this.

This can also be determined from other people's descriptions.

Another thing is, conspiracy to kill, why do you want to commit conspiracy to kill?

What is the justification for conspiracy to commit murder?

In this case, based on the evidence and investigation, there is absolutely no need for conspiracy to kill!

Therefore, the content of Su Bai's statement was unexpected by all parties involved in the trial.
.

....

At the court table.

As a criminal investigator in this case, Chen Bing couldn't help but frown slightly when he heard Su Bai's inquiry.

He is mainly responsible for follow-up and criminal investigation of this case.

During the investigation stage of the case, he conducted many investigations on the criminal suspects and their relatives.

It was finally confirmed that this case was a passionate intentional homicide committed by Xie An.

But is it a case of collusion?

I had this idea when I was handling the case, but there was no in-depth investigation.

Because the facts of this case are already clear.

And Xie An also admitted his crime.

There was no need to conduct an in-depth investigation into whether there was collusion.

In response to Su Bai's inquiry, Chen Bing answered:

"During the criminal investigation, our specific circumstances of the case are presented in the investigation report."

"We believe that this case was a deliberate crime of passion committed by Xie An, and there was no in-depth investigation into conspiracy to commit murder."

"Ok."

Su Bai nodded after hearing this answer, and then continued to state:

"presiding judge."

"We believe there are still many doubts in this case."

"First of all, let's talk about Xie An's motive for killing. Xie An's motive for killing was to vent his anger on his daughter."

"But venting one's anger and committing a murder just to vent one's anger is too weak as a motive for murder."

"This is the first point of confusion."

"The second point of doubt is during the criminal investigation of this case."

"As Xie An's daughter, Xie Lirong is a direct participant in this case."

"The multiple confessions are inconsistent with the actual situation. What kind of mentality do you have?"

"Why did you change the content of your confession over and over again and give different statements many times?"

"What's the purpose of this?"

"If anything, Xie Lirong doesn't remember the specific circumstances of the case very clearly."

"Then how do you confirm that the final confession is true and reliable?"

"Are there any auxiliary conditions for necessity or indirect evidence for necessity?"

"The third point of confusion is that in this case, Xie Lirong and her family have been asking for property from Liu Xuewei."

"That is to say, blood-sucking in a practical sense."

"Xie An's attitude towards Liu Xuewei is a normal attitude towards a son-in-law. The relationship between the two people is far from reaching the level where anger would threaten the other's life."

"Based on our investigation, the corresponding relationship evidence provided by law enforcement, and Xie An's confession."

"Xie An also stated that his relationship with Liu Xuewei is not bad, and the conflicts are not deep."

"Why didn't Xie An think of solving this matter at the first time?"

"In other words, during the process of committing the murder, why didn't he ask Liu Xuewei for his opinion before committing the murder?"

"Didn't Liu Xuewei explain the true situation of the conflict between him and Xie Lirong during this process?"

"According to Xie An's confession, Liu Xuewei did not explain this point."

"From the perspective of the entire criminal process, this is completely inconsistent with normal people's thinking and normal people's logic."

"How could anyone commit murder just because of a conflict that could be resolved with a casual word?"

"In other words, injuries can be carried out in retaliation, but according to the forensic identification, Xie An stabbed Liu Xuewei three times."

"The locations of these three cuts are the abdomen, chest, and heart."

"It can be seen that the chest and heart areas are very lethal areas."

"This also shows that Xie An committed an attack because he wanted Liu Xuewei to die."

"Is it reasonable for Xie An to want Liu Xuewei to die because of some conflicts and misunderstandings that can be resolved? This is not reasonable at all!"

"Furthermore, in terms of interests, what benefit does killing Liu Xuewei bring to Xie An?"

"There is no benefit, and Liu Xuewei will also lose a stable source of wealth."

"So from various angles, Xie An's motive for killing Liu Xuewei, or the motive for killing with passion, is completely unable to meet the criminal motive basis."

"There is absolutely no motive for the murder."

"So we believe that this case does not belong to a passion-based murder crime."

"It was a premeditated crime."

Su Bai stated three doubts and pointed them out in court at the trial.

These three doubts are attributed to law enforcement, and no specific investigation content has been presented.

Therefore, it is very reasonable to point it out in court at the trial.

Faced with these three doubts stated by Su Bai.

On the judgment seat.

As the presiding judge, Hu Yuxiang frowned slightly.

This trial was to discuss the issue of defendant Xie An’s prison term.

But now?

Now the victim has entrusted a lawyer to put forward a relatively shocking point of view.

And all doubtful points were stated accordingly.

This was completely inconsistent with the progress of the trial that he had expected.

After Su Bai finished his statement, Hu Yuxiang said:

"Does the victim's lawyer think that the circumstances of the murder being appealed for in this trial are different from the actual circumstances?"

"Yes, Judge."

"So regarding the above three doubts, is there any basis for the victim to entrust a lawyer?"

"Yes, our basis is based on these three doubts. Law enforcement should have investigated and summarized these three doubts."

“However, based on the existing evidence and conditions, there is no strong basis for persuasion.”       “So we believe that these three relatively doubtful questions should be addressed.”

"Make a detailed investigation."

The key to this case lies here.

When proposing a detailed investigation into three doubtful points, it is necessary to see whether the presiding judge agrees.

If the presiding judge agrees with this view, then the trial does not need to continue.

The trial can be suspended directly.

Law enforcement parties are required to conduct a new investigation and evidence collection on this case.

Of course...if the presiding judge disagrees, it is not impossible to continue the trial.

However, in this case, it may be necessary after the second trial is completed.

Request the procuratorate to protest and conduct a retrial process.

In terms of the process, it is a little more troublesome, but in general, there are three doubts about it.

Still need to conduct further investigation.

After all, if you can't get an accurate answer to these three points, what's the point of this case?

It’s a mystery!

Regarding Su Bai's answer, Hu Yuxiang sat on the bench and remained silent, thinking about how to respond.

On the other side, Xie An and Xie Lirong were in the defendant's seat and the relevant person's court seat.

But he seemed a little flustered.

Previously, this case was carried out step by step according to their plan.

However, I heard Su Bai's statement and Su Bai's request at the court hearing.

Xie An's face was slightly uneasy.

It was originally promised that he would bear this crime, but now he needs to conduct an in-depth investigation.

It is Xie Lirong and others who are investigating. What if an in-depth investigation is conducted and the true situation is revealed?

Then wouldn't he bear this crime in vain?

And the previous plans were all in vain?

However, although Xie An was a little flustered in his heart, he did not show too much during the trial.

after all.…

If you behave abnormally in court, it is likely to attract the attention of the presiding judge and other criminal investigation personnel.
.

....

The court hearing fell into a rare silence.

In the public live broadcast, many comments about the case popped up.

Many of these comments include people who have some knowledge of this case.

He raised his own questions about the current situation of the trial.

"Based on my previous understanding of this case, I thought it was a case of increased sentencing."

"I thought that the letter of understanding issued by Xie Lirong as a relative did not have legal responsibility and obligations, so I sentenced Xie An to death."

"But who would have thought that Lawyer Su would finally come up with a big trick and think that there were other people involved in this case!"

"This... I am still superficial after all!"

"Haha, same thing. Every time Lawyer Su brings up the situation at the trial, most of it will be confirmed."

"This case has already confirmed Xie An's criminal behavior."

"But whether there was collusion...it's hard to say!"

"Don't talk about anything else first. Now that the trial has stopped, let's see what happens next!"

"..."

Attention returned to the courtroom.

At the trial table, Hu Yuxiang further considered Su Bai's request.

Then a question was raised:

"The scenario put forward by the victim's lawyer just now is that Liu Xuewei was killed in a conspiracy."

"So what was the motive for the conspiracy to kill?"

Su Bai also expected that the presiding judge would ask this question.

Be prepared to answer.

The presiding judge's inquiry hit the target that Su Bai had prepared.

Su Bai said: "The motive for conspiracy to kill..."

"It's to get Liu Xuewei's remaining property!"

After hearing that Su Bai, as the victim's lawyer, directly surmised everything.

Xie An and Xie Lirong looked extremely ugly in the court hearing.

no.…

The case itself has been determined!

It was Xie An's crime of passion, but what's going on now?

Now, as the victim's attorney, Su Bai not only stated what they planned at the trial.

And also state their main purposes.

This case...should there be any reversal?

Xie Lirong and Xie Anxin suddenly had such a feeling and thought in their hearts.

A trace of panic appeared on Xie Lirong's face unconsciously.

He stared closely at Su Bai who was sitting at the victim's lawyer's seat.

I hope that the other party can provide no other evidence except this guess.

Otherwise...

They are in real trouble.

After noticing Xie Lirong's eyes falling on Su Bai, Li Xuezhen sat next to Su Bai obediently and stared back.

"?"

Why are you looking at Lawyer Su?

Are you nervous or anxious?

Li Xuezhen turned her head and whispered: "Lawyer Su..."

"That Xie Lirong, when you made your statement just now, you acted very panicked."

"It must have been said!"

"Otherwise there would be no such performance. They killed Liu Xuewei just to plot Liu Xuewei's property!"

"..."

Su Bai nodded silently when he heard Li Xuezhen's words.

He knew this, otherwise he would not have expressed it directly at the trial.
.

....

PS: Please give me a monthly ticket~

(End of this chapter)