You became a lawyer and sent the judge in

Chapter 81 Penguins are amazing, but I am even better at studying penguins!

On the presiding judge's seat, Cao Liqiang looked at the litigation materials in his hand expressionlessly, and frowned slightly.

Then he looked at the defendant:
"The plaintiff has finished his statement, and the defendant is now invited to make a statement on the application for litigation."

Chen Chao sorted out the materials of the lawsuit, and at the same time sorted out his own emotions, and then said:
"We object to the request of the litigant."

"First, in response to the claim made by the litigant that we plagiarized, we deny this and raise questions. How can the other party determine that we have plagiarized?"

"Secondly, it is even more untrue that the litigant claimed that we used our huge volume and platform to monopolize and promote unfair competition because we refused the cooperation of the litigant."

"We have never done this kind of behavior at all, and the delisting is the internal processing regulations of the platform.

Therefore, the matter raised against the litigant and infringed on the rights and interests of the litigant is completely "self-considered" by the litigant.

And this kind of self-belief has no factual basis. We believe that the other party's request to re-list it should be rejected. "

When Chao Chen finished reading the second point, he looked up at the litigant's seat, then looked down at the litigation materials, and continued:
"Third: Based on the first point, we did not plagiarize, and the damage to the interests of the litigant was entirely caused by the other party's own factors. We also did not guide public opinion, and we did not bear the responsibility. We applied to dismiss the litigant's request."

"Fourth: The expenses related to our application for our litigation shall be borne by the losing party."

"Judge, we have finished our statement."

After Chen Chao finished his statement, he looked up at the presiding judge's seat.

Chao Chen's rebuttal is simple.

First, we did not plagiarize, second, we did not plagiarize, and third: we still did not plagiarize!
Anyway, to sum it up, there is one meaning, we did not plagiarize.

And we don't have any violations. The removal is because you violated the regulations, not because I engage in monopoly.

Anyway, this hat can't be put on my penguin's head, my penguin is aboveboard, never engage in plagiarism, and monopolize this set.

Gee.

If this is said, who will believe it?

Penguin, feel your conscience and ask yourself, do you believe it yourself?
In this regard, Penguin's shameless point of view is, if you refuse to accept it, you sue me?
I have to let you bear the legal fees. The main thing is to kill them all and increase your litigation costs.

have to say.…

Penguin Legal has a way of doing this.

At the plaintiff's seat, Su Bai saw Chao Chen's eyes falling, and the two looked at each other.

Li Xuezhen said in a low voice: "Lawyer Su, you should go to court..."

"This person, leave it to me to watch..."

"Lawyer Su, I've already practiced it so far. I'm going to watch whoever dies in court..."

Su Bai: "?!?"

As a lawyer and a highly educated person, tell me you believe in luck?

Good guy!
6...
"Cough cough."

Su Bai coughed dryly: "Don't stare now."

"Oh."

Li Xuezhen's tone was low, and then she thought of something joyfully and said, "Then I'll watch it later."

"?"

Well very 6!

This pure and stupid female college student is completely crooked now!

Su Bai took a deep breath, didn't say anything more, just said silently in his heart: This... I shouldn't have made it wrong, right?
Ah!
Absolutely not!

How could such an upright lawyer like him teach a crooked pure female college student?
Su Bai comforted himself in his heart.
.
.... ...

On the presiding judge's seat, the presiding judge Cao Liqiang looked down at the litigation materials.

After making a summary in my mind about the litigation applications of both parties.

Then he looked up at Su Bai who was sitting on the litigant's seat, and said slowly:
"The party being litigated has finished its statement. Next, the litigating party is requested to present new evidence, factual basis, or legal provisions in accordance with the evidence provided or in court."

Boom boom boom!
The gavel sounded.

The presiding judge Cao Liqiang's eyes fell on Su Bai.

Su Bai realized that the first key point had arrived!

The most critical first point of this lawsuit lies in one aspect, that is, whether Penguin constitutes plagiarism!
But the problem is...
It is difficult to define the point of plagiarism?

In particular, the law is conservative today with respect to copyright and such infringement cases.

And when Penguin's legal counsel is very good at Tai Chi...

The general meaning of playing Tai Chi is that penguins are very good at muddying the water for infringement cases.

So that the presiding judge's judgment is conservative and the lawsuit is won.

Su Bai has studied Penguin's routines, and the Tai Chi in the infringement case is not so fierce.

But Tai Chi!He will too!

Su Bai took a deep breath, and then said:

"presiding judge"

"I would like to apply to ask the other party's client some relevant questions regarding the fact that the party being sued has indicated that he has not plagiarized?"

ask questions?
This doesn't follow the routine!
Chen Chao and Kong Hao frowned slightly, usually when the other side's lawyer asked questions, it was either a trick or a mentality.

Facing Su Bai's application, both Chen Chao and Kong Hao were ready to deal with it solemnly.

On the presiding judge's seat, Cao Liqiang rang the gavel and said, "The application is approved!"

Hearing that Cao Liqiang had passed his application for interrogation, Su Bai set his sights on Chen Chao who was in the defendant's seat, and asked.

"I would like to ask Lawyer Chen, how to define copyright plagiarism?"

Chen Chao frowned slightly, thought for a while, and after confirming that there was no pitfall, he opened his mouth and said:

"According to my country's judicial regulations, there are four criteria for determining copyright plagiarism:"

"One: Check before and after the release time of the work."

"Two: Whether the work is original."

"Three: Look at plagiarism, whether the objective conditions for plagiarism are met."

"Four: Look at the comparison of the characteristics of the works, and whether the plots of the characters are the same."

"The definition of game plagiarism is code, text, art and other elements.

It includes plagiarizing the name contained in the game or the name inside the game. Finally, it refers to whether the plagiarism of the gameplay is original. "

After hearing Chao Chen's answer, Su Bai nodded slightly, and then continued to ask the second question:

"I would like to ask, Lawyer Chen, what constitutes unfair competition?"

Super Chen frowned slightly. Although he didn't know what kind of medicine was sold in Su Bai's gourd, he still said:

"Our country has seven conditions for unfair competition:"

"One, fraudulent transactions. Two, improper business practices. Three, false advertising. Four, infringement of trade secrets. Fifth, predatory pricing. Six, deceptive prize sales and huge prize sales. Seven, defamation of the other party's business reputation."

After answering, Chen Chao raised his head slightly and raised his hand to look at the presiding judge.

"Presiding judge, I have already answered the plaintiff's question."

"However, my answer doesn't seem to have much to do with this case, so I request the plaintiff's lawyer to stop questioning me."

The previous few questions are all simple legal questions, and the answers don't have much impact.

However, if the other party continues to ask this question step by step, he may be asked into a pit by the other party at any time.

and so.

Chen Chao resolutely seized the opportunity and applied to interrupt Su Bai's question.

Boom boom boom!
On the presiding judge's seat, Cao Liqiang rang the gavel: "The reporter's application is approved, and the plaintiff stops asking questions and continues to make statements."

"Good judge."

Su Bai let out a long breath, and nodded slightly.

I have to say that Penguin has a lot of legal experience!
It is impossible to dig a hole, so you can only use hard power to break the little penguin's wings.

At this moment, Super Chen noticed that Li Xuezhen had been staring at him intently.

But he didn't think too much, but put his eyes on Su Bai, wanting to listen to Su Bai's statement.

Plaintiffs seat.

Su Bai spoke slowly: "The legal provisions that Lawyer Chen said just now are all correct."

"According to the definition and definition of game plagiarism: code, text, art, including internal character names, these are all key factors, but!"

"For a game, the most important thing is one point."

"The core point of a game! The core of a game lies in its gameplay, and plagiarism of gameplay is the key to plagiarism of games."

"first."

"Crazy match-up game is an original game mode created by our client, Nanyou Studio.

Can the defendant explain why in our mini game Crazy Match, three animals are connected together and disappear, while your Happy Match is also three small animals that are connected together and disappear.

Why didn't four small animals connect together and disappear, or five small animals connected together and disappeared.

But like our Nanyou studio, three small animals connected together and disappeared? "

"It's clear that Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. copied the core gameplay of Crazy Match, which was originally created by Nanyou Studio."

"same."

"In terms of naming, our side is Xiaoxiaoxiao, why did you name it?

In the public's perception, Xiao Xiao Xiao is eliminating, and Xiao Yi Xiao is also eliminating. We think that the other party is stealing the core elements of our name! "

"One more point, that is, regarding the overall framework, the overall framework of the game Happy Match produced by Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. is roughly the same as that of Crazy Match produced by us. Isn't this plagiarism?"

"According to the submitted evidence, Crazy Match and Happy Match have a very high degree of acquaintance in terms of gameplay.

Although Penguin's Happy Match has changed in code, text, art, and some details.

But the essence of plagiarism in gameplay is plagiarism of the core points of the game!It also belongs to game plagiarism. "

"That's why we applied for a judgment that the mini game Happy Xiao Xiao Yi Xiao produced by Penguin Holdings Co., Ltd. plagiarized the small game Crazy Xiao Xiao Xiao produced by our Nanyou Studio!"

"Judge, we have finished our statement."

Boom boom boom!
On the presiding judge's seat, after Cao Liqiang listened carefully to Su Bai's statement, he rang the gavel: "The plaintiff's statement is complete."

"The defense is now invited to make its statement."

After listening to Su Bai's statement, Chen Chao smiled.

What Su Bai is talking about is not exactly the same as the previous accusation against Penguin, it can only be said that there is an 80.00% acquaintance.

To sum it up in one sentence, I have seen a lot, and I can know how to answer even with my eyes closed.

After sorting out the materials that he had prepared long ago, Chao Chen said slowly, "We have the following answers to the plaintiff's questions."

"The first point is about the core of the gameplay proposed by the plaintiff.

First of all, the core of the gameplay referred to by the plaintiff refers to the connection of three small animals to eliminate, and Penguin’s Happy Elimination also uses three small animals to connect together to eliminate. "

"On this point we object."

"To make an objection, there are the following points:"

"First: Why are there three small animals instead of four, five, six, seven, and eight? That's because we think these three small animals can better reflect the fun of this game."

"Also, among the three small animals, the three in the concept of why it is three instead of four, five, six, seven, and eight are universal, and there is no originality."

"According to the law, originality refers to novelty, but three, it is just a number, not original. Nanyou Studio can't say that three of the three animals belong to them?"

"The small animals are connected together to eliminate, this side is also original, because the two games are compared."

"First: The small animals included in Crazy Match are little bears, little tigers and other animals."

"But the small animals included in Happy Match are: little lions, penguins and other animals, which are completely different from the animal elements in Crazy Match."

"Second point: Regarding the name problem mentioned by the plaintiff, we believe that the plaintiff's focus has certain problems. Crazy Xiaoxiaoxiao and Happy Xiaoyixiao are the complete names of the subject."

"Although the meanings of Xiaoxiaoxiao and Xiaoyixiao are similar, if you erase the two words in front of it, it will not be considered a subject!"

"Therefore, regarding the naming aspect mentioned by the plaintiff, we believe that there is no act of stealing the plaintiff's game name."

"The third point is the overall framework. According to the styles of the two games, the overall framework is universal and has no originality. Therefore, we believe that the plaintiff's application should be rejected."

Chen Chao finished his statement slowly.

At the same time, he also took a long breath. From the current point of view, the other party is about the same level as the lawyers in the previous lawsuits, and there is a high probability that this lawsuit can be won.

And after Chen Chao finished his statement, the corners of Su Bai's mouth raised slightly.

Through Chen Chao's statement.

It can be seen that Penguin has thoroughly studied this kind of infringement lawsuit.

But
He also has a thorough study of penguins!
As for Penguin's plan to deal with the infringement case, Su Bai studied it hard!
penguin?Come, come, let's have a good touch!
(End of this chapter)