Beiyang 1917

But Tukhachevsky returned to the army for only 3 days and did not work hard. The 1st Army was starving because of the huge shortage of food and ammunition. In addition, the returned prisoners of war could eat in the prisoner-of-war camps of the Volga Federation. Satisfied, I have worked so hard to give up the generous treatment from the Volga Federation, but when I come back, I am reduced to a second-rate army, and all supplementary supplies are ranked behind the cavalry army. Will the morale and mood of this team not be affected?"

It was the commander of the 1rd Army of the Soviet Union who stood up to fight for the 3st Army. Karl Ivanovich Berzin, who led his troops to defeat Kolchak's enthusiasm in the Chelesaray Iron Triangle defense operation before , The analysis is quite in place. Of course, it also expresses the dissatisfaction in the hearts of Tukhachevsky and the original Eastern Army troops. Why should the 1st Army be ranked behind Budyonny’s Cavalry Army in the process of reorganization and supplementation? after?

"Karl Ivanovich, I cannot agree with your statement. Budyonny's 1st Cavalry Corps has priority in obtaining personnel and equipment supplements. It was Moscow's decision to withdraw the Eastern Front and Southern Front and reorganize the troops of the two places into It is understandable that the decision was made during the Volga Front Army. In the Battle of Ufa, only Budyonny’s cavalry division fought to the end and retreated to the left bank of the Volga River in an organized manner. The model and example for the Russian Red Army to follow is a decision made by the Supreme Military Council”

The Chief of Staff of the Front Army, Chernavin, obviously moved out of Moscow to suppress Berzin. We all know that the Third Army fought well a while ago. At this time, it is the backbone of the northern defense of Nizhny Novgorod. Chernavin did not He was so stupid as to use his title of chief of staff to quarrel with Berzin. In his opinion, Berzin had a very hot temper, and he might not be able to gain the upper hand if he provoked him, a poor chief of staff. {dyz{co{first{first{中{文{网{co{

"I didn't say that Budyonny's cavalry army can't get the priority of personnel and equipment replenishment, but because of this, it is only a matter of course that Budyonny's troops can be dispatched in time. Otherwise, why should we give priority to restoring and replenishing the cavalry army? ?Similarly, it is only natural that the 1st Army, which has not been replenished with food, personnel and equipment in a timely manner, needs more time to recover and reorganize before starting operations.

更何况,米哈伊尔尼古拉耶维奇提出的调第1集团军来北线接访下诺夫哥罗德,而把第3、第5两个集团军的主力集中起来腾出手向东进攻收复切菜萨雷,这样围魏救赵调动南下的高尔察克主力回头的打法,我看没有什么不好,比让战斗力虚弱还远没有恢复的第1集团军长途跋涉离开铁路线,赶150公里路去东边向吉季斯的第10集团军靠拢的打法要合理的多”

Berzin, the commander of the 3rd Army, obviously did not intend to entangle Chernavin with the small calculations that could not be put on the table, but directly brought the topic to the new strategy proposed by Tukhachevsky in the telegram. above.

伏罗希洛夫闻言眉头紧皱,在这厮看来,图哈切夫斯基是在挑战自己这个方面军副司令兼前敌总指挥的权威,在北线收缩兵力抓紧时间补充和恢复第3、第5两个集团军的实力,而在南线让第10、第8、第1三个集团军和布琼尼的骑兵军集中兵力拖住高尔察克的脚步,到时候等白卫军的战线拉长而后勤保障距离过远的机会,一鼓作气在北线发动反击拿下切菜萨雷,直捣喀山切断高尔察克的退路。

As soon as Kolchak returned to aid, the troops on the southern front chased after him and beat them. The Volga Front Army encircled the north and the south, and the elimination of Kolchak and his main White Guards was just around the corner.

“卡尔伊万诺维奇,根据目前的情报,高尔察克南下部队的西集群是5个骑兵师近6万人,东集群是6个步兵师加2个骑兵师近9万人,而我们在南线的第10集团军是7个步兵师一共也就7万人不到,就算第8集团军北上增援到位,也只有11个步兵师11万人出头一点,在加上布琼尼的骑兵军2万人不到,在南线我们只有13万兵力,要对付高尔察克武装到牙齿的15万大军,困难很大”

Chief of Staff of the Front Army Chernavin's mathematics is obviously good, but the analysis of the comparison of troops is not bad at all.

“正因为如此,图哈切夫斯基的第1集团军加入南线作战就至关重要,如果第1集团军及时向东靠拢第10集团军,那么我们就能在南线集中17万人的部队,这样无论如何都不会在高尔察克的15万人面前吃亏起码守住战线毫无问题,到时候等我们的第3、第5集团军在北线发起反击,我们在总兵力上将大大超过高尔察克的白卫军,可以一劳永逸的合围并歼灭对方”

Voroshilov waved his arms and said confidently, staring at Berzin and Kamenev with a hint of fanaticism and anxiety in his eyes.

"Krement Yefremovich, what you said is certainly true. This was also a decision discussed and approved by the Front Army Command before, but the situation is always changing. We didn't take into account the shortage of food in Saransk then. Seriously, the troops were confused in the face of hunger, and the troops of the Cavalry Army and the 1st Army were originally two front armies, and the two sides even almost exchanged fire in order to collect food and grab supplies, guns and ammunition brought by trains."

"Under such circumstances, the 1st Army obviously needs a longer rest period before it can take on new tasks. Tukhachevsky emphasized in the telegram that he was the one who brought the 1st Army to Volga due to the extreme shortage of food on the southern front. The rendezvous between the left bank of the river and the 10th Army, in addition to consuming the food of the 10th Army, could not provide greater support in terms of combat effectiveness.

What's more, Kolchak's cavalry troops have already passed Aratli, and may cut off the advance of the 1st Army on the way at any time. At that time, his 1st Army will not be able to resist the opponent's 5 Cossack cavalry divisions on the wild plain. the impact of

Kamenev, the political commissar of the Front Army, had clearly made up his mind that Tukhachevsky's troops could not leave the city and the railway line and head east, that would be given to Kolchak's cavalry troops to destroy them, for nothing Food is absolutely not okay

“谢尔盖谢尔盖耶维奇,您怎么看?难道图哈切夫斯基的第1集团军能守住萨兰斯克?我觉得这根本不可能,高尔察克就是冲着萨兰斯克去的,他4万新整编的部队枪都只有3万支不到,怎么抵挡对方武装到牙齿的6万骑兵部队的进攻,何况从莫斯科转来的情报,对方还有10个重机枪营和10个炮兵连的火力伴随”