Great Lawyer

Chapter 128 Three Points of Dialectics ([-])

"That's Liu Gongzai, the leader of the A-character group, and the one with the highest score in the southwest test before you." Qian Daoan took the opportunity to come in, whispered something to Du Jiuyan, and hurried out.

It turns out that this is Liu Gongzai, Du Jiuyan knows it.

"My lord, the little one really didn't kill anyone." Wang Ling kept kneeling, twisting and turning to say something but didn't dare, now he was able to speak when he was free.

Miao Ying stared, and said with a sneer: "The murderer, of course, will not admit his murder."

"Fart your mother, if I say I don't have it, I don't have it." Wang Ling scolded angrily, "You have wronged me, even if I die, I will turn into a ghost and haunt you."

Wang Ling yelled, Fu Tao was very annoyed, he patted the gavel and said: "Qu Jing, if you don't ask me to talk again, I will slap my mouth."

"I really didn't kill anyone." Wang Lei shouted.

There were people laughing inside and outside, and someone said in a low voice: "Mr. Du, why did you defend Wang Lei this time? Wang Lei must be right in this case, and only a person like him can do such a thing."

"Mr. Du is probably in danger this time. He has won Southwest so many times, so he might lose this time."

"Yes, you see that the two senior gentlemen from Southwest are here today."

The crowd groaned.

Ou Heng saluted with Xue Ran and Liu Gongzai, Xue Ran nodded and said: "Play steadily and keep your own ring."

"Criminal cases are difficult to say, but easy to say. At your level, there will be no problem in guarding against arrogance and impetuosity."

Ou Heng stepped forward to listen to the training, and answered repeatedly, "Students, remember."

Xue Ran turned his attention to Du Jiuyan. This time he came to listen. Firstly, it was because Du Jiuyan had fought Sanchitang for the fourth time, and there could be no difference. Litigation lawyers have high requirements for their defense ability, and they also have extremely high requirements for the sensitivity of evidence and case.

Some litigators, when they do civil lawsuits, they win all the battles, but when they come to criminal cases, they are confused and unable to start.

This is because they are not familiar with the business and are not keen enough in the business.

Ou Heng is now the plaintiff, and the evidence is conclusive and the case can be settled. Therefore, no matter how Du Jiuyan argues in this case, Ou Heng only needs to keep all the existing physical and witness evidence.

Ou Heng also knew it very well, so he stood aside and waited.

Everyone was looking forward to how Du Jiuyan, who was defending an acting case for the first time and was also defending a rogue, would fight this lawsuit.

"My lord, my lord," Wang Lei was still shouting for grievances, Fu Tao pointed at the yamen servant, and the whole room roared with laughter, even Ou Heng had a smile on his face.

Wang Lei was so rascal that he made everyone angry.

"My lord." Du Jiuyan stepped forward suddenly, cupped his hands and said, "It's common sense for him to cry out for injustice. If I talk to him, I think he will calm down after he understands the truth."

The yamen servant retreated, Fu Tao nodded slightly, "Tell him the truth, if you are messing around, I will not be polite."

Du Jiuyan should be, walked up to Wang Lei amiably, bent slightly, and whispered in his ear: "Just say one more word, and I will dispose of you after you leave the court."

Wang Lei was taken aback.

"My lord, he understands the pros and cons of it, so he won't talk anymore." Du Jiuyan finished speaking with a smile, and bowed his hands at everyone, covering everything from inside to outside, "Du Jiuyan in Xiasanchitang, today is the defendant Wang Lei. Not guilty plea."

Whoa!
Everyone exclaimed inside and out, and even Fu Tao showed surprise. He always thought that Du Jiuyan was going to plead guilty for Wang Lei.

The difference between innocence and guilt, the result that the former wants is innocence, while the latter is to reduce the defendant's punishment on the basis of guilt.

Unexpectedly, she was innocent from the start.

This kid really has the courage to swallow the sky.

Ou Heng was also shocked, and became more and more nervous. How should Du Jiuyan defend his innocence?

"Don't panic!" Liu Gongzai looked at Du Jiuyan with a smile, and said to Ou Heng.

Ou Heng cupped his hands and looked at Du Jiuyan quietly.

"I don't know if you have written a short story book. At the beginning of a story, there are always three elements." Du Jiuyan raised three fingers, "These three elements are what I want to prove today."

"One, time!" Du Jiuyan shook out a hand-painted overhead structure diagram of Miao Mansion, marking the southeast, northwest and seven courtyards in the mansion, the location and purpose of each courtyard, "According to the file, at three o'clock in Haishi , Wang Lei climbed over the wall from the junction of Hu's house and Miao's house and entered. Go straight to the left and follow the path to the kitchen. He took the kitchen knife and went to the main courtyard. After killing Miao Peng with twelve knives, he stole seventeen pieces of property Go out the door and be caught by Mrs. Liu!"

"But that's the case, Mr. District."

Ou Heng clasped his hands, and said: "Yes! He went in around [-]:[-] pm, left around [-]:[-] pm, and stayed in the courtyard for [-] quarters of an hour." Then he said: "Later, I went to the gambling shop to verify that he arrived at [-]:[-] pm. It's time for him to return to the Fortune Inn, hide his belongings, and then go to the casino."

"I have personally verified the time from Miao Mansion to Fulai Inn and back to Yuqian Village, and it is exactly fifteen minutes." Ou Heng said.

"Mr. Qu is careful." Du Jiuyan said: "But the defendant Wang Lei didn't say that." She repeated Wang Lei's route and said: "He said that when he entered that night, the dogs of the Hu family were barking and fighting in the yard. , He had just heard Gengzi’s voice before this, and calculated back and forth, it should be less than a quarter of Haishi.”

"Dog fights, I have done evidence collection, and it was indeed around Haishi that the riots started. The servants of the Hu family can testify about this matter. If there is any doubt, the servants of the Hu family can be summoned in court."

Ou Heng said: "The dog barks loudly, across the courtyard, you can hear it."

"He is not a gangster who kills people like hemp. Let me ask you, if you go to kill people with a knife, you can still pay attention to the sound of dogs barking. This is not in line with Wang Lei's personality of bullying the weak and fearing the hard, and being fierce and introverted."

"What personality is it has nothing to do with this case. Your testimony cannot be used as evidence."

Du Jiuyan didn't argue with him, and her purpose was not to overthrow the original timeline through deduction, so she continued to talk about her own, "Finally, the time Wang Lei left Miao Mansion was around a quarter of the hour of Haishi. He went to I went to the red building, leaned on the courtyard wall and watched a live erotic palace, and I went to the Yuqian village gambling shop at a moment's notice."

"About the living erotic palace in the Red Mansion, the lilac girl in the Red Mansion can testify that she did have fun with her guests in the courtyard that night."

"Women's certificates cannot appear in court, so they cannot be used as time witnesses." Fu Tao said.

Du Jiuyan cupped his hands and said loudly: "The above is my inference on the time of the incident. Even if there is uncertainty, it can also be disproved. The so-called timeline in the file is uncertain. As the first murderer, the defendant can Remembering the time before and after the incident, it can be seen that he was not panicked at that time."

Ou Heng was startled, and realized that he was sweating all over, thinking that the people in the litigation firm said that Du Jiuyan was cunning, now it seems that he is indeed cunning.

She said this not to convince others to believe her, but to make others not believe him.

There is a difference between the two.

"Second, the location!" Du Jiuyan continued: "As Wang Lei said, after walking through three courtyards, he saw a child sleeping in a room in one of the courtyards. It was later proved that it was Miao Peng's youngest son. s room."

"This room is separated from the main courtyard by a garden. If Wang Lei wants to go there, it will take some time to run. But obviously, he didn't go to the main courtyard, but to a courtyard with a study."

"He vented his anger in a study in that yard. I didn't find it strange when I heard it, but I went to Miao's mansion to check, but I couldn't find a study in the mansion."

Miao Ying said: "My house only has one study room, which is in the outer courtyard. But the study room in the outer courtyard is locked, and there is no sign of prying. This matter has already been checked by Mr. Jiao."

"Yeah, I also find it strange that what he said is wrong." Du Jiuyan said.

Wang Lei couldn't help but want to talk, Du Jiuyan paced to his side, stepped on his foot and twisted it, Wang Ling covered his mouth and dared not cry out the pain.

"I walked around Miao Mansion eight times, and I didn't see the study room Wang Lei mentioned until the last round." She shook out the drawing, and pointed to the courtyard on the top near the north and west, "It's the hood of this courtyard." In this courtyard, the account books of all the shops in the Miao Mansion are placed over the years."

"It was midnight, and it was the end of the month, and the light was very dark. It was reasonable for him to regard the volumes of account books as books." Du Jiuyan said: "The door was unlocked, so I went in to check. It was true that there were more than a dozen bookshelves at the bottom of the bookshelf. This ledger is yellowing."

Ou Heng frowned, and said: "Even so, it can only prove that he has been to that room."

"You're very nervous, keep interrupting!" Du Jiuyan unabashedly disgusted, "I've endured you for a long time!"

This is her usual method, using gags, provocations and sarcasm to confuse the opponent's thinking, Ou Heng looks nervous and looks at her warily, trying not to be affected.

"First of all, this is the first time Wang Lei has come to Miao's mansion, so he stumbled around like a headless chicken. He couldn't even say which yard and which direction he was in. Figure out his route that night."

"Secondly, the first time he went there, it was impossible for him to know where his kitchen was, how he knew where Miao Peng's room was, and how he could escape smoothly with the dirt after the murder. "

"Third, character!" Du Jiuyan said: "There is a witness in this case, and that is Granny Liu, the night watchman of the Liu residence. My lord, I request that Granny Liu be brought to court."

Fu Tao nodded, "Bring a witness, Granny Liu."

Granny Liu was brought into the hall, her old body seemed to be crumbling on her knees, Du Jiuyan stepped forward, looked at Granny Liu with a smile, and asked, "How much time did you spend when you went through the main courtyard that night when you were patrolling the night? "

"At most one cup of tea. I'll start from the Ruyi Gate." Mrs. Liu said.

Du Jiuyan nodded, "Then, did you meet Wang Lei and rush out of the main courtyard when you were in Zishiguo?"

"Yes!" Mrs. Liu said.

Du Jiuyan nodded, and suddenly asked, "Grandma, have you brought your money bag?"

"Bring it." Granny Liu tremblingly untied the money bag on her waist.

Everyone looked at her in puzzlement, wondering why she wanted Granny Liu's purse.

Xue Ran and Liu Gongzai looked at each other, and they both frowned, also puzzled.Liu Gongzai said in a low voice: "This kid's defense method is really perverse!"

"It's not just perverted, it's just arguing!" Xue Ran said disdainfully.

Du Jiuyan held Granny Liu's purse and handed it to Huang Shuli, "Excuse me, take a look at the money in the purse, it's special."

The scribe Huang opened the money bag, poured out all the copper coins inside, spread out the money with some puzzlement, then snorted, picked up one, and said, "This is... the iron ring at the end of the shuttlecock? "

There are six in total.

"Here, do you have any explanation?" Fu Tao asked, puzzled.

　Have you ever seen the shuttlecock hoop? It is very similar in size to a copper coin!
　　
　
(End of this chapter)