Great Lawyer

Chapter 129 Two Plans ([-])

Du Jiuyan handed the six iron rings to Granny Liu: "Does Granny know when this money was in your purse?"

Mrs. Liu was also very surprised. She stared at Du Jiuyan's hand for a long time, then turned it over and over again, "I don't know."

"I don't know." Du Jiuyan held the iron ring and said to the crowd: "I gave her the iron ring as a reward two days ago, and she put it in the money bag. I guess the money will not be used. So for a while, it's going to stay in her pocketbook."

"What do you mean?" Ou Heng asked.

Du Jiuyan said: "Because her eyes are almost half-blind, she can't see things that are close to her eyes, not to mention the distance."

Everyone shouted, and some people commented: "She is almost blind, so how can she see that it is Wang Lei in the middle of the night?"

Ou Heng's complexion changed slightly.

Xue Ran's hand clenched suddenly, and his brows were tightly knit together.

"Grandma Liu, when did your eyes start to lose sight?" Du Jiuyan asked.

Mrs. Liu thought for a while, and replied: "It's been a while, maybe seventeen or eighteen years. When I was young, I loved embroidery. I kept embroidering and embroidering. When I got old, my eyes couldn't see clearly."

"Then, someone rushed out of the main courtyard that night and met you head-on, did you see the other person's face clearly at a glance and recognized Wang Lei?"

"No." Mrs. Liu replied: "I saw a figure at that time, that man ran very fast, I saw a tall and big black figure, but I didn't see who it was."

As soon as these words came out, everyone inside and outside the yamen who heard clearly was shocked!

How did the woman who couldn't see clearly be sure to be Wang Lei.

"So, when did you know that the man belonged to Wang Lei?" Du Jiuyan asked.

The mother-in-law recalled it, she was a little uncertain, she thought for a while and said, "I don't remember, it's Wang Lei anyway."

"Isn't this nonsense?" People shouted outside the door.

"That's right, I said yes without seeing the face clearly, because I think Wang Ling deserves to die, so everyone pushes the wall down."

Wang Lei nodded repeatedly, echoing in a low voice: "That's right."

Du Jiuyan glanced at Heng with a tense face, then cupped his hands and said to Fu Tao: "My lord, after the three elements have been asked, let me ask one more question, inside and outside the yamen, how did you determine that the murderer is Wang Lei?"

Fu Tao looked at Jiao San.

"My lord, it was the people from Miao's mansion who reported the case, saying that Wang Lei entered Miao's mansion at night and killed Miao Peng, and the mother-in-law saw it with her own eyes, so we went to arrest him." Jiao San replied.

Du Jiuyan asked again: "Then, who will report to the official?"

"It's a steward of Miao's mansion." Jiao San said, and shouted outside: "Bring steward Su here."

Frog brought Steward Su up, he knelt down, and replied: "Returning to my lord, before the villain came to report the crime, the family had already spread the word that Wang Lei went to the mansion to kill people and rob things. Our second master let me know." When the villain comes to report the case, the villain will come."

After Guanshi Su finished speaking, everyone was stunned, and they still didn't figure out who was the first to confirm that the person who killed people at night was Wang Lei.

"My lord, through the rhetorical questioning of three elements, the student believes that the timeline is not accurate, there are doubts and loopholes in the route, and the most critical witness, Granny Liu, her confession cannot be adopted at all." She paused slightly, and said loudly: "So , this case not only cannot be settled, but needs to be thoroughly investigated again!"

"Good!" someone shouted outside.

"At first I thought that the case must have been done by Wang Ling, but just now Mr. Du passed the proof, I think this case is very problematic."

"I think so too."

"Listen carefully to what is said inside. Don't make it so hard to listen to Mr. Du's lawsuit, and feel that you are also a lawyer who has been arrested. Look at what you are capable of, and make a noise to death."

The two people who spoke were not convinced, stared at the man, and couldn't help but pay attention to the situation in the yamen.

After hearing what Du Jiuyan said, Fu Tao frowned tightly.He looked at Ou Heng and said, "Mr. Ou, it's your turn."

Ou Heng's hands were sweating, and he had to say that even he had doubts about this case after listening to what Du Jiuyan said just now.

"Attack his shield with his spear!" Xue Ran whispered.

After Ou Heng's mind cleared up, he immediately thought of a solution. He came forward and cupped his hands, "The student asked."

Fu Tao nodded, and Ou Heng went up to ask Granny Liu, "Did you know Wang Lei before this?"

"I know." Mrs. Liu said: "He is in Shaoyang City, who doesn't know, he is a bad guy."

Ou Heng nodded, and asked again: "If you only look at the figure through the screen, do you know Wang Lei?"

"I don't know." Mrs. Liu said.

Ou Heng said to Fu Tao: "My lord, since you have doubts about Mrs. Liu's testimony, why not give her a try."

Fu Tao nodded, "Yes."

Ou Heng asked people to move the screen, and found five men who were similar in stature to Wang Lei outside the door. They also changed into yamen clothes, and covered their heads, faces and hair with cloth on their heads.

Mrs. Liu stood in the courtyard, and Ou Heng said, "Look, Mrs. Liu."

Five men, including Wang Lei, strode down from the steps of the yamen, imitating the way the criminals escaped that night.

"Who is Wang Lei!" Ou Heng asked.

Mrs. Liu raised her hand and pointed at the person on the far right, saying: "This is it."

As soon as she finished speaking, Wang Lei took off the hood, threw it on the ground, and said, "Damn it, this doesn't count, let's do it again."

"Thank you all." Ou Heng clasped his hands, helped Mrs. Liu up, and said to everyone: "To know a person, you don't have to see the face clearly, but also through their voice, tone of voice, accent, and walking and running posture."

"Just now, Mrs. Liu recognized Wang Lei from five people at a glance, which is enough to prove that as a witness, her testimony cannot be questioned." Ou Heng said.

Fu Tao also nodded.

Xue Ran nodded slightly, with relief in his eyes. The key person in this case is Mrs. Liu. As long as her testimony is credible, then the questions and answers Du Jiuyan just said are all nonsense!
"Ou Heng, you have the same demeanor as you did back then." Xue Ran said with a smile.

Liu Gongzai also nodded slightly, and glanced at Du Jiuyan, seeing that the boy was still calm and unhurried, he couldn't help frowning again.

I always feel that this kid must have some bad idea because of his virtue.

"As for the other two of Mr. Du's three certificates, there is no need to argue any further. They are all inferences based on the plaintiff's one-sided statement." Ou Heng said: "Therefore, they have no effect."

Fu Tao looked at Du Jiuyan.

"Mr. Qu, in your opinion, what is the difference between the things I listed just now and the things you investigated in the yamen?" Du Jiuyan said.

"You have no witnesses, everything is one-sided."

Du Jiuyan said: "Suppose, as you said, Wang Lei entered the mansion at three o'clock in Haishi, and in the middle of taking a knife, killing, stealing and escaping, he would abduct Mr. Miao's bedroom and go to the west to pretend The account book room, and then quickly ran back to the inn, hid the stolen goods, and chose another one, which everyone knew was Miao Peng's stolen goods to gamble."

"What do you think is the basis for all this to be established?"

"The two points you mentioned don't count among them."

"Have you ever filed a lawsuit?" Du Jiuyan looked at Ou Heng, "If you think that what I said is not true, you can find an argument to refute you. You have been biting that it is not true. Are you a dog?"

Ou Heng was stunned for a moment, pointing at Du Jiuyan, he didn't expect that Du Jiuyan suddenly changed his seriousness, and actually copied the words to curse people.

"You...how can you curse people."

"You're annoying. How did you get into Group A? I don't think you're even as good as Diao Qin." Du Jiuyan gave Ou Heng a blank look, "Don't tell me that I insulted you. If you don't agree, sue me, sue me." If you win, I will count you as ruthless."

In the back, someone coughed, and Ou Heng woke up suddenly, almost falling into Du Jiuyan's trick.

right!He doesn't need to find a reason to refute Du Jiuyan, he just needs to keep his arena from being broken by her.

As for her arena, he doesn't need to test and counterattack.

As long as he keeps it, he wins.

Rebuttals are for the accused.

calm down!

"Count!" Du Jiuyan scolded, and glanced at Liu Gongzai and Xue Ran by the way, their hearts were blocked, and they were dizzy with anger.

Du Jiuyan coughed, "My lord, do you agree with the three points I just proved?"

"I have no objection. You said that all witnesses and time are insufficient, which is correct. But your objection is the same, because there is no evidence or witnesses."

Du Jiuyan nodded and sighed.

"Mr. Du," Wang Ling was frightened. He looked at Du Jiuyan and said, "You, you can't admit defeat."

Du Jiuyan looked at Wang Lei and said, "You can't lose if you lose, but it's not easy to win."

Someone shouted outside: "It's better to overthrow all the cases and re-investigate."

"Ah!" Du Jiuyan snapped his fingers and cupped his hands at the speaker, "This uncle reminded me that since the case has come to the point of overturning the case and re-investigating evidence, we might as well take a step back and see This case."

"Mr. Ou, what do you think?" Du Jiuyan said.

Ou Heng replied: "No, the evidence in this case is obvious, and the testimony of the witnesses is not problematic, so there is no need to overthrow it."

"Assuming I didn't ask you." Du Jiuyan waved his hand in disgust, and said to Fu Tao: "My lord, let's take a step back now and assume that Mrs. Liu did not recognize who the murderer who escaped from the main courtyard was, and then deduce. Verification, you see it works."

"If you have evidence, I will agree." Fu Tao said.

Xue Ran and Liu Gongzai looked at each other, both were shocked, Liu Gongzai said: "She actually prepared two plans."

This kid not only reacts quickly, but also has a good command and strategy.

It was like two parallel knives, but after pulling out one, it was her real murder weapon.

Xue Ran's face darkened and he didn't speak.

Du Jiuyan walked half a circle in the courtroom, "In criminal cases, we first talk about the motive of the murder. Then Wang Lei and Miao Peng did not know each other before the day of the crime, there is no doubt about it."

The crowd nodded.

"Then, his motive for killing was because of some subtle tongue-in-cheek conversation between the two that afternoon. He killed Miao Peng, and then came out and bumped into Mrs. Liu..." Du Jiuyan looked at Wang Lei, "If you really killed Miao Peng, you bumped into Mrs. Liu, so what would you do then?"

Wang Lei rolled his eyes and said, "Kill her to silence her, because she saw my face!"

"Yes!" Du Jiuyan said: "A grown man is still a rogue who kills without blinking an eye. After he killed someone, he ran into a weak woman. Killing her is just a casual thing. If you kill her, then it doesn't exist. The fact of Wang Lei's murder will be confirmed after the trial of this case."

"My lord, is what the student said reasonable?"

Fu Tao nodded, and said: "There is indeed some truth. The spirit of slashing people with twelve knives must be extremely tense. It is not surprising to add another person to be killed at this moment!"

"My lord, this inference is still unfounded. After Wang Lei killed the man, he threw the knife by the bedside. It was not easy for him to kill Mrs. Liu. If he couldn't kill her, it would cause commotion and alarm others. His best reaction at this time was, It's a bet that Mrs. Liu didn't recognize him and ran away quickly."

Fu Tao nodded, "I don't rule out the possibility."

"Since both are possible, then I will continue with my deduction." Du Jiuyan said: "The other party didn't kill Mrs. Liu for any reason, but left without fear."

　She first used Wang Lei's timeline to overthrow the original evidence, but Xue Ran and Liu Gongzai ordered Ou Heng to block it, so Master Jiu immediately changed his method, and then assumed the existence of the second suspect!
　　Well, there is one more chapter, see you later.

　　
　
(End of this chapter)