You became a lawyer and sent the judge in

Chapter 133 Judgment found that the first-instance judgment was rejected.

soon.….
An hour has passed since the adjournment was announced.

All the clerks stood up.

The members of the collegial panel entered the courtroom again.

During the adjournment stage, Wang Jianjun had already sorted out the case.

And the trial and general judgment have been determined.

Sitting on the presiding judge's seat, Wang Jianjun looked around the courtroom and spoke slowly:
"At present, the trial of Lin Haoxue's second-instance judgment has been basically completed."

"The defendant, can you please provide the complete process of the original DNA test report...?"

Faced with Wang Jianjun's question, Yan Shang was silent for a few seconds, wondering whether he should submit it or not.

Because once submitted....
Then it may be questioned because of the submission process.

But if you don't submit it...then there is absolutely no possibility of overturning this case.

If the court finds that the law enforcement party was negligent...
Then the influence on them is too great...
Faced with this situation, Yan Xiang didn't know how to choose for a while.

After hesitating for tens of seconds.

At this time, Wang Jianjun saw Yan Shang's hesitation and continued to ask.

It's just that the tone of the inquiry this time is much more serious than the previous one.

"Respondent, please answer the question."

Faced with Wang Jianjun's inquiry, Yan Xiangxiang thought of a coup, throwing the pot away.

"presiding judge."

"As for the presiding judge's question, I didn't have an in-depth understanding of the DNA testing process, so I couldn't give an answer in court..."

"Presiding judge, we apply to hand over relevant materials and evidence after court."

Wang Jianjun:? ? ?

How did you say that...?

Submit evidence after court?

Don't you know that there is a certain time limit for submitting evidence in court?

Besides...
You little trick, I have served as the presiding judge for so many years, you think I can't see it, right...?

Wang Jianjun's expression was calm, knowing Yan Xiang's inner thoughts...
It is nothing more than that he intends to use this argument to explain that he has evidence and corresponding clues, so that he can take this into consideration when making a judgment.

but.….
Wang Jianjun still said the same sentence, how to judge, how to judge...
Evidence depends on the evidence in court. What is the point of not seeing other evidence?
Even if he knew, he couldn't judge the authenticity of the evidence, so it was equivalent to saying that Yan Shang was playing a trick.

Wang Jianjun didn't like this little cleverness very much.

After slightly frowning, he rang the gavel.

dong dong!

"Since the accused party could not provide evidence in court, according to the trial rules, the evidence from legal sources cannot be verified, that is, the original DNA test report is judged to be invalid evidence."

dong dong!

"Does the accused have any comments...?"

When he heard the verdict, Yan Xiang was taken aback for a moment.

This... is the verdict...?

"Presiding judge, we have objections... We think this judgment is unreasonable. Our DNA identification report is true, and we have already proposed to submit the corresponding process evidence after court. Why should we judge our test report? Is it invalid evidence...?"

Hearing Yan Shang's words, Wang Jianjun didn't want to lose face at all.

Don't you know why the DNA test report is judged to be invalid evidence?
However, Wang Jianjun, as the presiding judge, still gave an explanation.

"According to Article [-] of the Criminal Procedure Law, the understanding and application of collecting evidence in accordance with the law."

"The litigant questioned the source of your evidence, and it has factual basis. You cannot prove the legality of the source of evidence in court. Based on the above, your evidence is judged to be invalid evidence."

"If the accused party has any factual basis that does not match or thinks that the judgment does not conform to which law, he can raise it in court. The court thinks it is reasonable and can accept it."

"The accused party has objections to the above judgment, and now the accused party is asked to state its objections."

Yan Shang: ...
State counterarguments...?
How does this state...
Yan Shang rubbed the center of his brows, realizing that what he said just now was too impulsive and left a bad impression on the presiding judge.

It is judged that the DNA test report is invalid, how to say this judgment...
From the subjective point of view of the presiding judge, it can be judged to be invalid, and of course it can be judged to be valid.

after all.….
The DNA test report is true.

Regardless of whether it is a forgery or not, the other party cannot produce strong evidence to prove it...
Although, the other party proved the source of the blood on his body.

But Lin Haoxue's DNA did remain in the victim's nails.

This point is beyond doubt, and it is also this point that the other party needs to refute.

This DNA can come from other sources. Of course, if it is determined based on this, then the fact that the bloodstains were identified in the first instance will not match.

But this is not the most important thing. The most important thing is that the DNA of Lin Haoxue left in the victim's nails is the factual basis.

If the other party cannot prove it with strong facts.

This depends on the presiding judge's tendency to identify the DNA report...
Therefore, he used a common method to avoid this problem.

But I didn't expect... I got myself into it...
Wang Jianjun: Don’t show off your small thoughts.
I have tried so many big cases, and I have seen many of your kind... Is there any problem in judging you?
Reasonable and legal, without any problems!

Wang Jianjun will severely punish this kind of cleverness!

on the bench.

Seeing that Yan Shang didn't speak, Wang Jianjun's expression was flat, and he continued to ask:
"Can the accused party provide factual basis to prove that the collegial panel has problems with this judgment?"

call.….
Yan Shang let out a long sigh: "Judge, we can't, we have no objection to the judgment of the collegial panel."

Boom boom boom!
Wang Jianjun rang the gavel and said:
"The defendant's lawyer didn't have any objection, so why did he raise a question just now...?"

dong dong!

"The defendant's lawyer disrupted and interfered with the progress of the trial process, give me a warning!"

"The defendant's lawyer, do you have any objection to this punishment?"

Yan Shang was in a state of distress, and it was obvious that he would be punished.

But there are reasons and evidence, is he angry?
Definitely angry.

But there is nothing to do with anger....
He nodded silently: "Judge, we have no objection to this punishment."

Boom!
After Wang Jianjun sounded the gavel, he nodded in satisfaction.

The next step is the court presentation stage...
Boom!
"Do the parties to the lawsuit have any objections to the decision that the DNA evidence is invalid?"

The prosecution was the first to answer: "No objection."

Su Bai: "No objection."

Yan Shang: "No objection."

dong dong!

"The parties to the lawsuit have no objection to this judgment. The collegial panel has roughly sorted out the case and confirmed the basic facts. Now, the parties to the lawsuit are invited to make court statements."

"The prosecution, please make a statement."

Kong Jiantu was hearing the court statement.

Take a long breath.

After the statement is over, you should be able to eat melons...
According to the content of this lawsuit, the influence of this case is not small...
Forging evidence, suing for the death penalty, and submitting an application for the death penalty, the public, prosecutors, and law parties have the responsibility to supervise, and yet such a big mistake has occurred.

If approved by the Supreme Court.

Well, the influence is... absolutely nothing.

In fact, before the trial, someone had already contacted him.

Let him complain about this court trial, and try his best to maintain the first-instance judgment. After the second trial is over, he will be rewarded.

Thinking of this, Kong Jiantu muttered silently. Fortunately, he stuck to his bottom line as a public prosecutor and didn't get involved... Otherwise...
Kong Jiantu shook his head slightly, then looked at the trial platform.

"Judge, we give up our statement."

Straightforward, no statement at all.

dong dong!

"The prosecution and public prosecutor gave up the statement, and the accused party is invited to make a statement."

Yan Shang knew in his heart that after the case reached the presentation stage, it was judged that the evidence of the DNA test report was invalid, and now he has lost the case.

The most important thing now is to mitigate the other party's accusation of their negligence.

After taking a deep breath.

Yan Shang began to make a statement:
"Presiding judge, our court statement is as follows:"

"In our view, the litigants allege that we were negligent .. with negligence, and in fact there is no strong evidence to support this view"

"When law enforcement parties exercise their responsibilities, they take into account various issues."

"It cannot be judged whether there is negligence or not on a single surface."

"Judge, we have finished our statement."

Yan Xiang's statement was simple and clear, without any unnecessary nonsense.

There is only one purpose for saying this.

That is--

Presiding judge, don't bother to judge that our law enforcement side is wrong, there are other parties too.

It cannot be dismissed just because the other party did not file a complaint.

Yan Shang set his eyes on Wang Jianjun's face, hoping to see the result of the judgment from his face.

It's a pity that Wang Jianjun didn't show the slightest emotional change on his face, which made Yan Shang unable to figure it out.

dong dong!

"The law enforcement party has finished its statement, and now the parties are invited to make a statement."

After Lin Haoxue heard the presiding judge's voice, he said:
"Judge, I have nothing to say."

"I just hope that...the law can give me a fair sentence"

"Judge, I'm done..."

Boom!
"After the party has made its statement, does the agent have anything to add?"

"There are presiding judges."

"Please ask the agent of the party to make a supplement."

"Good Judge"

Su Bai nodded and continued:
"My addition is to the law enforcement parties stating that they were not at fault. …"

"For this statement from the law enforcement party, I think it is inappropriate..."

"First, the law enforcement handed over Lin Haoxue to the prosecution without confirming the truth of the evidence. Secondly, the law enforcement seriously deviated from the procedures, and serious problems occurred."

"If Lin Haoxue's testimony and testimony were not investigated, how could Lin Haoxue be accused of assaulting women and committing murder...?"

"How could he be imprisoned for six years at the age of 18 and miss his life?"

"You know, the case was originally charged with the death penalty, and an application for approval was submitted to the Supreme Court."

"If the approval is passed, then for Lin Haoxue, it is not that he has missed six years of his life, but that he has lost his life directly."

"Every unjust, false and wrongly decided case is a huge blow to the credibility of the verdict."

"If the law enforcement party verifies the evidence, does not violate the regulations, and does not deviate from the procedure, then there will be no unjust, false or wrongly decided cases this time."

"Based on the above, we believe that the accused party has committed serious negligence and negligent behavior, and must make a public apology and compensation to us!"

.... ...

After Su Bai finished his statement, the comment section of the trial was broadcast live outside the courtroom.

"You're right, you're very good. If the law enforcement party hadn't been at fault, then this unjust, false and wrongly decided case would never have happened. Now that I've missed it, what's the point? Just admit your mistake and be done!"

"Be honest and admit your mistakes and it's over? Brother upstairs, have you forgotten what the crime you charged at the beginning? The crime you charged at the beginning was the death penalty! If it hadn't been rejected by the Supreme Court, then now... can this be confirmed? Was the accused murdering intentionally?"

"There are indeed intentional suspicions in this regard, but... there is one thing to say, isn't it the prosecution's responsibility for the death penalty charge? It doesn't seem to have much to do with the accused party, right?"

"That's right! So the prosecutor's lawyer is very smart. He didn't say a word during the whole process, and he didn't say a word of subjectivity. The whole scene was, right, right, right, right, right, right, right, right, right, right, right. It's completely different, with an attitude of listening to the judge's judgment."

"Hahaha! After you said that, I suddenly understood why the prosecution stopped talking. Is it because the speed is to point the finger at the prosecution?"

"Indeed! After hearing the explanations from the bosses, I realized that this is the reason why the public prosecutor didn't speak!"

"Hahaha! Absolutely amazing!!"

"..."

In the comment area, there was a heated discussion about Su Bai's court statement.

And at the same time.

In the courtroom.

After listening to the court statements of all parties, Wang Jianjun looked at Zhou Yun and Zhu Chaoyang.

Zhou Yun and Zhu Chaoyang nodded slightly and agreed.

Seeing this, Wang Jianjun sounded the gavel.

dong dong!

"The court statements of all parties have been understood by the members of the collegial panel."

"The verdict is now ready to be announced."

Boom!
Wang Jianjun sounded the gavel.

Clerk: "Everyone stand up! The presiding judge, please announce the verdict!"

Swish swish.

At the trial site, everyone stood up, and Wang Jianjun held the verdict and began to read the verdict.

"The cause of the case: the litigant refused to accept it, defended Lin Manhao's application to revoke the first-instance judgment for innocence, and found that the accused department was at fault in exercising responsibility, and applied for a public apology."

"This court has jurisdiction over this case, and the applicable laws are all in accordance with domestic laws."

"The verdict is announced below:"

"According to the research decision of the collegial panel, the parties to the lawsuit applied for revoking the first-instance judgment of the Lin Haoxue case and defended their innocence. The results of the judgment are as follows:"

"Aiming at revoking the judgment of Lin Haoxue's first-instance Jiangdu Intermediate Court."

"The Jiangdu Higher Court, the court of second instance, now finds that:"

"According to the Criminal Procedure Law, the understanding and scope of Article [-] and its applicable regulations, and the scope of application of the five Articles of Light Confession and Heavy Evidence:"

"In the first-instance judgment, the facts found did not match."

"The key points are as follows:"

"First: There is a major difference between Lin Haoxue's confession and the evidence submitted by law enforcement."

"Second: Lin Haoxue's repeated confessions have not yet been judged, and the judgment is made without confirming the facts, which does not conform to the corresponding judgment process."

"Third: The relevant departments did not listen to Lin Haoxue's testimony, which is a serious violation of regulations, and Lin Haoxue presented factual evidence to determine the main evidence of the first instance, and the DNA test report was invalid."

"Fourth: The litigant submitted evidence on the origin of the bloodstains on Lin Haoxue's chest identified in the first instance, thus refuting the source of the bloodstains identified in the first instance, and the determination was wrong in the first instance."

"fifth:.….…."

Wang Jianjun listed a number of matters that were found to be inconsistent with the facts.

After the enumeration was completed, Wei Wei raised her head and looked at the seats of the parties involved.

"Based on the above, it is determined that the first-instance judgment lacks factual basis, lacks legal basis, and lacks factual identification."

"The second-instance judgment revokes the first-instance judgment."

"Convict Lin Haoxue of innocence and release him in court!"

"At the same time, determine the amount of state compensation requested by the litigant!"

"Determined negligent conduct against the law enforcement party as alleged by the litigating party."

"The court judged that the law enforcement party did not determine the facts based on the conditions of the criminal facts, the purpose of the criminal facts and other factual basis to hand over to the prosecution. It is indeed negligent."

"It is judged that the relevant law enforcement agencies at that time made a public apology for Lin Haoxue!"

"According to the provisions of our country's procedural law, if the parties to the lawsuit have found that the facts are wrong or the ruling is wrong, they can submit it to the relevant department for review and supervision after the court session is closed, or file a request for retrial to the higher court."

"The verdict will be issued to all parties within [-] days after the court is closed."

Boom!
The muffled sound of the gavel echoed throughout the courtroom.

The silence of the trial just now was broken.

When the presiding judge announced the verdict just now.

The audience was silent, without a single sound, everyone wanted to know what the final verdict would be.

now.

At the moment when the verdict was announced.

Various litigants at the trial site, as well as parties or relatives have different reactions.

Lin Haoxue and Li Xiangfang, who was on the seat of his family members, wept with joy, because they were crying about the hardships of the past six years.

After six years of persistence, the court finally ushered in a just trial and was acquitted.

Kong Jiantu on the prosecutor's seat breathed a sigh of relief, the trial was over, and he didn't have to worry about anything else.

Yan Shang, who was on the accused's seat, frowned, not knowing what he was thinking.

However, it can be clearly seen that the eyes are full of worry about the result announced by the court judgment.

However, Su Bai and Li Xuezhen, who were on the litigant's seat, behaved differently.

Su Bai breathed a sigh of relief. After the verdict of this case came out, there was no big problem.

It was a troublesome case solved.

The decision is made, easy!

Li Xuezhen had a happy face and bright eyes.

call.
I won the case.

There is evidence to submit to the supervisory review.

+1+1+1+1+1+1.….
Beautiful...
PS: Ask for a monthly pass~

(End of this chapter)